Back-end-of-line integration of PCMs into commercial silicon photonics platform
Large-scale fabrication based on the CMOS platform without modifying the existing passive and active photonic component library is essential for realizing various practical applications of PCM-based nonvolatile electrically programmable photonic chips. However, PCM is a kind of material that is incompatible with standard CMOS processes. Therefore, a back-end-of-line integration of PCMs is coveted for commercial photonics platform-compatible nonvolatile devices. Here, we propose a trench etch process utilizing SiN as the etch stop layer to realize deep SiO2 cladding etching above the functional areas (where PCM would be deposited), which is suitable for developing CMOS back-end integration of multiple functional materials40.
The SiN-assisted silicon photonic process was conducted on a 200-mm wafer at the IMECAS foundry, including the low-loss SiO2 trench etching atop the functional areas. The integration of PCM was accomplished by a back-end-of-line process involving ultraviolet lithography and film deposition, which exhibits significant potential for facilitating large-scale integration. The customized silicon photonic process incorporating a layer of SiN serves as an etch stop layer to preserve the Si waveguide from damage during the etching of SiO2 trenches (see Fig. 1(a)). Firstly, the patterning of photonic devices, implantation, and ion activation was implemented on a 200-mm SOI wafer comprising a 220-nm silicon layer on top of a 2-µm buried oxide layer. Secondly, a sequential deposition of a 5-nm SiO2 and a 20-nm SiN was performed, followed by lithography and etching techniques to fabricate the etch stop layer. Following the deposition of SiO2 and subsequent metal interconnection, the silicon oxide above the waveguides in functional areas of the photonic devices was selectively etched. Due to the high etching selection ratio (> 50:1) between SiO2 and SiN, the etching process is effectively halted at the etch stop layer (SiN), thereby preventing damage to the silicon waveguide. Finally, a wet etch process was employed to remove the SiN layer above the functional areas.
Benefiting from the etch stop layer, waveguides with low-loss narrow SiO2 trenches were realized, with their measured transmission spectra shown in Fig. 1(b), where the numbers of cascaded trenches are 10, 20, and 30, respectively. The cut-back measurement suggested that the insertion loss introduced by a single trench is as low as 0.083 dB at 1550 nm, as shown in Fig. 1(c). The low-loss trenches provide a convenient approach for the back-end integration of PCMs, facilitating compatibility with available silicon photonic devices in commercially available PDKs. To prevent any performance degradation of the device, the post-processing temperature should be lower than 450 ℃41. Additionally, post-fabrication patterning was accomplished exclusively by ultraviolet lithography, thereby possessing the potential for large-scale integration with high throughput. The detailed fabrication process flowchart for the back-end integration of PCMs is illustrated in Fig. 1(a). The PCM thin film was deposited through magnetron sputtering followed by a lift-off process upon the SiO2 cladding trench window (process temperature < 150 ℃). Afterward, the chip was annealed at 200 ℃ and 300 ℃ in a nitrogen atmosphere for 15 minutes to facilitate the crystallization of Sb2Se3 and GeSbSe4Te1, respectively. A 30 nm-thick Al2O3 protective layer was then deposited by atomic layer deposition (process temperature < 150℃). Finally, the contact window above the metal electrode was etched to ensure electrical interconnection (process temperature < 110℃). Figure 1(d) illustrates the functional region's structure after fabrication. The electro-thermal control of the PCM induced by the PIN diode enables a nonvolatile response of the effective refractive index in the hybrid waveguides.
Back-end integrated SbSe enabled trimming of push-pull MZI switch
Silicon photonic devices inevitably suffer from fabrication errors and consequent deviation of performance from the intended design. Meanwhile, the device-to-device deviations could be significantly magnified in networks, leading to an increased complexity when configuring PICs. Post-fabrication trimming (PFT) enables the calibration of the photonic devices after their fabrication. Compared to other trimming methods, including femtosecond-laser annealing42 and Ge ion implant-and-annealing43,44, active and reversible trimming enabled by PCM manipulation30 possesses a significantly improved degree of freedom. In this section, we demonstrate the post-fabrication active trimming technique by electrically fine-tuning a low-loss Sb2Se3 patch integrated using back-end integration.
The schematic diagram in Fig. 2(a) illustrates the device structure and operational principle of low-loss PCM-based PFT, exemplified by a push-pull MZI switch. A section of p-i-n doped Si waveguide, covered with a patch of Sb2Se3, was employed as a trimming unit. An identical structure was set on another branch of the MZI to achieve optical loss equilibrium. During the PFT, a sequence of electrical pulses is applied to the trimming unit, thereby triggering the amorphization of Sb2Se3 and inducing a nonvolatile change of the refractive index in the Sb2Se3/Si hybrid waveguide. Therefore, the optical power between the two output ports gradually achieved equilibrium, accompanied by the balance of drive voltage.
The microscope image of the push-pull MZI is presented in Fig. 2(b). Before PFT, as shown in Fig. 2(c), the optical power-voltage (O-V) curve suggested that the optical power splitting ratio between two output ports was larger than 6 dB at 0 V, the drive voltage for the bar state(cross state) was − 1.03 V (0.93 V), corresponding to a power consumption of 4.55 mW (1.00 mW). Additionally, a significant optical power imbalance spanning the C-band was observed, as shown in Fig. 2(d). Therefore, the insertion loss of the bar and cross states exhibited significant disparities due to the inherent losses associated with carrier injection-based phase modulation. (> 0.4 dB at 1550 nm. The measured spectra can be found in Fig. S1(a) of SI.1).
After applying a series of electrical pulses with varying amplitudes (ranging from 3 V to 6 V with an interval of 0.01 V) and a fixed pulse duration of 500 ns, precisely control over the amorphous-and-crystalline-mixing state of Sb2Se3 was achieved, thereby enabling device trimming without impact on the electrical property of the device (see Fig. S1(b) in SI.1). The imbalance between the two ports was reduced to 0.110 dB at 0 V, as depicted by the O-V curve in Fig. 2(e). The bar and cross states' drive voltage was reduced to -0.98 V (yielding a power consumption of 2.33 mW) and 0.97 V (yielding a power consumption of 2.01 mW), respectively. This thereby reduced the voltage disparity from 0.1 V to 0.01 V, as well as improved total and peak power efficiency by > 20% and > 48%, respectively. Moreover, the trimming unit effectively equalized the splitting ratio of both output ports across the entire C-band (see Fig. 2(f)). The imbalance of insertion loss at the bar (2.69 dB) and cross (2.62 dB) states was effectively minimized to a mere 0.07 dB at 1550 nm while simultaneously ensuring an extinction ratio > 20 dB in both states (see Fig. 2(g)). The insertion loss of the trimming unit is 0.46 dB, estimated using the cut-back method, as detailed in SI.2. The characterization of the push-pull MZI without Sb2Se3 also confirms that the primary source of insertion loss does not originate from the trimming unit(see SI. 3), but primarily from the propagation loss of the Si waveguide and the mode mismatch between the straight and bend sections. The trimmed MZI exhibits a high switching speed with 10–90% rise and 90 − 10% fall times of 9.26 ns and 9.81 ns, respectively (see Fig. S1(c) in SI.1). Additionally, the on-off switching (> 107) and storage at room temperature (12 days) has no significant impact on the optical performance of the device, indicating that the Sb2Se3-based trimming unit is a reliable method for PFT (refer to SI.1 for detailed measurement results).
The Sb2Se3-based trimming unit provides a reliable PFT technique, which not only achieves a balance of the drive voltage and insertion loss but also significantly reduces both the total and peak power consumption of a push-pull MZI. The embedded trimming units are essential for simplifying the control and reducing the power consumption of very large-scale PICs.
Reconfigurable nonvolatile multi-level low-loss phase modulation
The compact nonvolatile multi-level phase modulation not only mitigates static power consumption but also enhances integration density, making it a promising candidate for constructing reconfigurable PICs such as microwave photonics45, quantum computing46, and coherent optical computing47. Here, we demonstrated a low-loss multi-level phase modulation using a back-end integrated SbSe/Si hybrid waveguide in a microring resonator(MRR).
The nonvolatile MRR switch, featuring an 8 µm-long SbSe/Si hybrid waveguide, is shown in Fig. 3(a). A ~ 25-nm SbSe patch was adopted to mitigate mode mismatch loss arising from the interface between the bare silicon waveguide and the SbSe/Si hybrid waveguide (see SI.4 for a detailed analysis of loss induced by mode mismatch). The reversible switching was achieved by applying a 7.15 V/500 ns pulse for amorphization and a 2.25 V/100 ms pulse for crystallization, resulting in an extinction ratio (ER) larger than 25 dB at 1551.513 nm (see Fig. 3(b)). The observed change in the measured spectra indicates that a phase shift of ~ 0.3π was achieved, accompanied by a crystallization-induced loss of 0.0223 dB/µm.
To achieve multi-level switching, two types of manipulating pulses were employed, including electrical pulses with varying amplitude and fixed duration (PVAFD) and pulses with varying duration and fixed amplitude (PVDFA). The change in transmittance (\({\Delta }T\)) at 1551.145 nm was utilized for monitoring the nonvolatile multi-level phase modulation exhibited by the MRR. As shown in Fig. 3(c), 36-level (> 5-bit) crystallization was realized by applying PVAFD with an interval of 0.01 V. However, achieving higher levels of nonvolatile switching using PVAFD with an amplitude interval smaller than 0.01 V poses a significant challenge. Hence, the PVDFA exhibits a potential for accommodating more distinguishable states during inducing multi-level crystallization due to the presence of numerous pulses (nearly 105 at a resolution of 1 µs) with durations < 100 ms. Here, a quasi-continuous switching was achieved by applying PVDFA with gradually increased duration (see Fig. 3(d)). The demonstration of 500 switching events was also presented (see Fig. 3(e)).
The back-end integrated SbSe/Si hybrid waveguide offers a reversible low-loss phase modulation, enabling fine multi-level switching by employing PVDFA, providing an attractive fine-phase tuning solution for large-scale PCM-driven photonic networks.
Reconfigurable nonvolatile multi-level intensity modulation
Intensity modulation has been widely used in optical computing48, optical communication49, and microwave photonics50. GSS4T1, a novel material possessing a low-loss amorphous state and a lossy crystalline state at telecom wavebands19 emerges as a promising candidate for nonvolatile intensity modulation when compared with traditional GST material. Here, we pioneered the demonstration of an electrically programmable waveguide-integrated broadband optical attenuator employing back-end integrated GSS4T1.
The back-end integrated photonic attenuator offers a high extinction ratio with a small footprint (16 µm), owing to the high extinction coefficient contrast (Δk = 0.549) between different states of our sputtered GSS4T1 films (see Fig. 4(a)). The microscope image of the fabricated device is shown in Fig. 4(b). The reversible multi-level switching of the photonic attenuator was achieved by applying PVAFD, as shown in Fig. 4(c) and Fig. 4(d). The insertion loss and extinction ratio were measured to be 2.91 dB and 39.5 dB, respectively. Furthermore, a multi-level intensity modulation exceeding 180-level (> 7 bits) was achieved by applying PVDFA (see Fig. 4(e)). After 1500 switching events, there is no obvious deterioration in the device’s performance (see Fig. 4(f)). Further switching events, both with and without an optimized coupling efficiency of the grating coupler after the cyclic measurement, suggest that the observed increase in optical loss can be attributed to a shift in the coupling state.
Although fine-tuning for any target state can always be accomplished via multiple fine-correction pulses akin to the trimming process, the arbitrary state configuration is essential in certain scenarios. The arbitrary state configuration is usually accomplished by applying an amorphization pulse followed by a crystallization pulse. Through this process, we were able to realize a > 3-bit arbitrary state configuration for the GSS4T1-based attenuator. By applying pulses with varying amplitude (varying duration), a total of 7 (13) distinguishable states were achieved (see Fig. 4(g) and (h)).
We have demonstrated a back-end integrated GSS4T1-based photonic attenuator with an ER > 39 dB and a multi-level switching > 7 bits, thereby forging a pathway for large-scale nonvolatile intensity-modulated PICs.