Eye diseases differ with age, gender and geographical locations from one region of the world to the other as reported in many works.14, 15. In children, eye diseases can cause visual impairment as well as potentially cause blindness if not treated early16.The family serves as a primary unit in health and medical care. Women report to health facilities more than men17.Sick role is culturally more compatible with women and this include the traditional role of care for their household especially children17. In this work, majority of the informants were mothers (79.5%). This underscores the role of mothers in child care and in seeking health for a vulnerable population that cannot seek health for themselves.
Allergic or vernal conjunctivitis more often occurs in warm, dry, climates with a decrease in inflammation and symptoms in the winter18. Zaria, the location of the study area, has a tropical wet and dry climate with warm weather all year-round- a wet season lasting from April to September and a drier season from October to March 19. Onset of the symptoms of allergic conjunctivitis especially vernal conjunctivitis begin from childhood and peaks in early teen around age 13 years18. This study also agrees with the description of early onset of allergic/ vernal eye disease which peaked around the age of 11 years (table 4) although there was no statistically significant association between age and disease P value > 0.05
Earlier works by researchers have shown that in Nigeria, refractive error is one of the common presentations to the eye clinic 20, 21. In this study, a total of 42 children (9.4%) were diagnosed to have refractive error, mainly hypermetropic-astigmatism (40.0%) followed by hypermetropia (26.2%). More female (73.8%) patients were observed to have refractive error compared to the males (26.2%) (P value > 0.05) this was similar with the findings of Isawumi et al21 in which males constituted 33.9%-although myopia was reported more in their study. Living in a rural area is associated with a higher risk of hypermetropia. The study area is located in an environment where it serves a predominantly rural population and this may explain the fact that hypermetropia was more common in the study. Children in a rural setting are also more likely to be engaged more in outdoor games and less of indoor games which may be a reason for lower percentage of children having myopia as noted. Most of the children with refractive error were between the ages of 10–15 years. The finding of more refractive error in older children compared to children of younger age reported in this study is similar to the report by Sandra22 in Germany as well as another study by Jaya et al in West Bengal, India23. The relatively higher percentage of the number of patients in the age range 10–15 years with refractive error may probably be due to the fact that it is around this age range that there is increased need for near vision because of school activities and children may be able to articulate their complaints better than younger children.
In a primary eye care clinic microbial conjunctivitis constitute about 1% of all consultations by general practitioner and could be as high as 40% of cases seen in paediatric eye care24, 25. The estimates of children with bacterial conjunctivitis vary with age. In this study 8.7%of the patients had microbial conjunctivitis (Table 2.0). Out of these the age group of 0–4 years range had the highest number of cases 66.7%, 5–9 age 10.3% and 10–15 years 23.7% respectively. In the United States26 it was estimated that bacterial conjunctivitis was 23% in the 0–2 year age range, 28% occurred in the 3–9 year range and 13% in the 10–19 year range. Furthermore, factors that have been associated with bacterial infection include age less than 6 years, onset of symptoms between December and March, and the absence of watery eyes26.The fact above is also supported by the bulk of the patients with infective conjunctivitis which were in children less than 6 years of age reported in this study. Besides, the study period also transited through the period of December and March which are characteristically dry and has low humidity. In the 1980s trachoma was an important cause of blindness and accounted for 12% of world blindness27. However, a downward trend to 3% has been recorded by the World Health Organization28. No case of trachoma was recorded in this study. The concerted efforts of the government and Non-Governmental Organization (NGOs) in the provision of portable water as part of the components of the SAFE strategy plus behavioural change may as well explain this development. Although a previous study29 opined that trachoma was more of a population- based problem rather than hospital based.Studies30, 31 in Calabar South-South Nigeria and Benin –City recorded ophthalmia neonatorum (neonatal conjunctivitis) as 1.1% and 1.7% respectively. No case of ophthalmia neonatorum was however, recorded in this study. Improved maternal education, antenatal and obstetric care and socioeconomic status may be responsible for this observation.
Congenital cataract was one of the most common congenital ocular abnormality - recorded with a proportion of 28 (6.3%). Studies32–34 done in Kaduna, Lagos and Ogun States also indicated that congenital cataract was a common ocular congenital anomaly operated /reported. One hundred and eighty one of 204 eyes (88.0%) had cataract surgery in Kaduna, n = 27 (39.1%) and n = 50 (47.6%) of congenital cataracts in Lagos and Ogun respectively. A similar pattern of congenital cataract as a common ocular congenital condition observed was also noted in Kolkota, India n = 16 (16.49%)35 and the United Kingdom n = 160 ( 66%)36.
Furthermore, the patients who had congenital glaucoma were 28(6.3%), lower than what was recorded in Ogun State34 Nigeria (14.3%) and in Lagos, Nigeria (8.7%)33 but higher than the report from a suburban region of Edo state37(1.7%) .In this study all the patients with congenital glaucoma presented within the first four (4) years of life. This is similar to the time presentation pattern reported in Edo37 of between 2 to 5 months and 12.31 (± 17.13) months in Ibadan38
Parents of children with birth defects have anxieties socially, emotionally, financially on how to manage a child with defect39. In this work, the patients who had multiple congenital anomalies n = 16 (3.6%) mainly had cleft lips and palates, microphthalmos, lids coloboma, microcephaly and polydactyly. Most of the cases of congenital anomalies reported between the ranges of 0–4 years of age. The concern and eagerness to find answers to the question of care for these children may explain the reason majority of the cases of congenital eye diseases were diagnosed at a younger age group –less than 4 years old.
Retinoblastoma was the only orbito-ocular tumour reported in this work n = 8 (1.8%) of all children less than four years of age. Over four decades ago in Kaduna, Nigeria Abiose et al40 reported retinoblastoma as n = 63 (60.5%) of all orbito-ocular tumours. Fifteen years later in the neighbouring town of Zaria, retinoblastoma recorded a lower percentage n = 50 (40.3%) amongst orbito-ocular tumours41. The relatively low percentage recorded in this work compared to the above perhaps may be due to the fact that their studies40,41 were solely on orbito-ocular tumours relative to retinoblastoma. Additionally, the fact that there are more tertiary health facilities now around the study area compared to the time when those studies were carried out may have reduced the concentration of patients only to the study area. Besides, the culture of consanguineous marriage, which is a risk factor for genetic diseases including retinoblastoma is likely to have reduced now due to civilization.
The proportion of blindness observed in in verbal children in the study population was 12 (3.1%) as shown in Table 4.0. Adegbehingbe42recorded a lower prevalence of blindness (1.4%) and so did Kemmanu43 et al (0.08%). In this study the leading causes of blindness were cortical visual impairment and congenital cataract (33.3% each n = 4). Although childhood cataract and cortical blindness were also reported as the leading causes of blindness by Adegbehingbe42, 17.9% of blindness was due to childhood cataract and 12.0% from cortical blindness, these proportions reported were dissimilar to this study. The different timelines between this study and Adegbehingbe’s42and the difference in the study area may explain the reason for the varying results.
Table 4.0
Type of refractive errors in 42 children by age groups
Type of error | Age group (Years) | |
---|
0–4 | 5–9 | 10–15 | Total |
---|
Myopia | 0 | 2 | 3 | 5 |
Hypermetropia | 0 | 0 | 11 | 11 |
Myopic-astigmatism | 0 | 2 | 3 | 5 |
Hypermetropic-astigmatism | 5 | 1 | 11 | 17 |
Mixed astigmatism | 0 | 0 | 4 | 4 |
Total | 5 | 5 | 32 | 42 |
Simple hypermetropia and hypermetropic-astigmatism were the commonest refractive error and were observed to be more in the age group 10–15 years |
Table 4.0
Causes of blindness in 12 eyes of verbal patients aged 5–15 years
Causes | Frequency | Percentage (%) |
---|
Cortical Visual disorder | 4 | 33.3 |
Congenital cataract | 4 | 33.3 |
Orbito-ocular tumour (Retinoblastoma) | 2 | 16.7 |
Penetrating globe Injury | 2 | 16.7 |
Total | 12 | 100 |
Bilateral cortical blindness and congenital cataracts were the most common causes of blindness in the patients, retinoblastoma and globe injury were unilateral |