Equine GI nematode infections are an increasing problem worldwide due to the rapid development of anthelmintic resistance in P. univalens and cyathostomins [27]. To find alternative treatments, a better understanding of the parasite interactions with the host intestinal barrier is needed. In that context, equine enteroids are attractive experimental models that can partially recapitulate the structure and function of the small intestinal epithelium [15, 28]. However, the large size of nematode larvae and the closed structure of traditional basal-out 3D enteroids complicate studies of the natural route of infection. To address this issue, equine enteroids were in the present study adapted into 2D monolayer cultures allowing easy administration of nematode larvae to the apical surface of the epithelium. These enteroid monolayers were functionally perturbed by basolateral stimulation with Th2 polarizing cytokines and/or apical exposure to the equine GI nematodes P. univalens, cyathostomins and S. vulgaris, and thereafter characterized for gene expression and morphology.
It was recently demonstrated that equine enteroids can be cultured in 3D conformation, as well as in open conformation as a 2D monolayer [15, 28–30]. One consequence of plating out enteroid cells on a flat surface is that the organizational hierarchy with crypt-like domains rich in stem cells and villus-like regions containing differentiated cells is lost. Although there seem to be some degree of crypt-like spatial organization in enteroid monolayers of murine origin under some conditions [13, 31, 32], such cultures primarily contain immature cells with high proliferative activity that do not differentiate without modification of the culture medium [3, 33]. By removing or reducing the growth factors that stimulate the Wnt pathway, enteroids and enteroid monolayers of man and mice can be transformed from a stem-cell like to a more differentiated state [33]. In such cultures, dual Wnt and notch inhibition is generally needed for expansion of goblet cells [33, 34]. With this background, it was unexpected to find that the equine enteroid monolayers expressed the goblet cell marker MUC2 after 5–6 days of culture despite being kept in the presence of Wnt-stimulating factors. This is in consistence with our previous study that showed similar gene expression levels of MUC2 after 2–3 days of monolayer culture [15]. Further in support of this finding, presumed goblet cell orifices appearing as ring-shaped (crater)-like features containing secretory vesicles were in the present study observed by SEM. The combined expression of CGA, DCLK1, EPCAM, MUC2, SOX9 and PCNA further suggests that the established culture conditions upholds a population of proliferative cells alongside the differentiation of secretory cell lineages. A similar heterogenous gene expression profile was recently demonstrated for bovine enteroid monolayers using an in-house composed medium [35], emphasizing the need to optimize the culture conditions for each animal species and experimental setup.
To verify the presence of goblet cells, transwell-grown equine enteroid monolayers were carefully recovered, sectioned and stained for acidic and neutral mucins. This procedure verified a single cell layer interspersed with occasional mucin-containing cells. In addition, AB-PAS staining revealed a thin layer of mucins situated at the apical brush border, likely representing the membrane-bound mucins that build up the intestinal glycocalyx [36]. Similar staining procedures have illustrated changes in goblet cell distribution and mucin content in various equine intestinal disorders [37] and following the inflammatory response to equine cyathostomins [38]. Therefore, it seemed vital to assess if functional goblet cells are present and can be flexibly induced in equine enteroid monolayers aimed for GI-nematode research.
Even though intestinal mucus production is essential for the “weep and sweep” response occurring at expulsion of worms from the intestinal lumen [10, 25, 26, 39], the mucin components and/or associated proteins are likely also important for initial protection against invading larvae [10, 11]. Since the differentiation of goblet cells and their mucus production is promoted by IL-4 and IL-13, these type 2 cytokines were added into the growth medium of 3D enteroids or to the lower chambers of transwell-grown enteroid monolayers during the last 48 hours of culture. Z-stack imaging of enteroid monolayers illustrated a marked increase in MUC2-positive staining after stimulation with eqIL-4/IL-13, compared to the weakly stained untreated control monolayers. In the 3D enteroids, intense staining of MUC2 was found in the lumen of both untreated and eqIL-4/IL-13-stimulated enteroids, likely reflecting the accumulation of mucus in these closed enteroid structures over time. Thus, mimicking the Th2 cytokine response typically evoked by GI nematode infection dramatically boosts mucin production by equine enteroid monolayers.
The production of IL-4 and IL-13 during nematode infection in vivo is mainly initiated by the alarmins IL-25, IL-33 and TSLP released by epithelial and stromal cells [40]. An important producer of IL-25 is the rather recently described chemosensory tuft cell [reviewed in 41] that respond to GI nematodes and other intestinal insults [42]. In this context, mouse intestinal organoids have been indispensable in improving our understanding of the role of epithelial tuft cells in the initiation and regulation of type 2 immune responses against nematodes [6, 25, 39, 43, 44]. In accordance, the expression of DCLK1 was increased in both equine enteroids and enteroid monolayers by basolateral eqIL-4/IL-13 stimulation, as shown by immunofluorescence microscopy and gene expression analysis, respectively. Furthermore, cells with a tuft cell-resembling morphology, as described for other species [6, 45], were observed by SEM. Taken together, the gene expression data, immunohistochemical staining, confocal and scanning electron microscopy imply that the equine enteroid monolayers contain tuft cells and mucus-producing goblet cells whose frequency and expression is affected by basolateral stimulation with Th2 cytokines linked to nematode infection.
We have previously shown that equine enteroid monolayers respond to apical stimulation with viral and bacterial pathogen-associated molecular patterns (PAMPs) by inducing gene expression for anti- and pro-inflammatory cytokines [15]. However, no differential expression of these cytokines was observed in transwell cultures of equine enteroid monolayers after 20 h exposure to GI nematode larvae, regardless of whether the monolayers had been primed with eqIL-4/IL-13 or not. The only significant effect of nematode larvae was on the expression of MUC2 in monolayers that had been eqIL-4/IL-13-primed before exposure to P. univalens larvae. Effects on MUC2 production was also indicated by z-stack confocal imaging after 48 h exposure to P. univalens or S. vulgaris larvae.
A current major limitation of the transwell culture system is its poor compatibility with live-cell imaging. To overcome this, a novel method for imaging pathogen interactions with human enteroid monolayers was recently demonstrated using Salmonella enterica Typhimurium and Giardia intestinalis as models for bacterial and protozoan infections, respectively [16]. This technology is built on custom imaging chambers that support monolayer growth while optimizing conditions for DIC microscopy to give sufficient optical contrast and resolution for tracing individual microbes atop the epithelium. To test if these AICs are also compatible to study the infection dynamics of equine nematodes, conditions for co-culturing equine enteroid monolayers with cyathostomins, P. univalens and S. vulgaris L3s on AICs were established. During the entire co-incubation time of 72 h, the larvae remained motile across the monolayer surface. Despite this, no signs of stable larval attachment or invasion of the monolayer was observed. Notably, however, the larvae frequently accumulated epithelial cell debris at their anterior end while probing the monolayers. If this behaviour is relevant to nematode foraging, attempts at damaging the epithelial cell layer integrity, or some other aspect of the nematode infection cycle remains an intriguing question for future studies.
Moreover, the live-cell imaging revealed that epithelial cells with an altered apical morphology reproducibly appeared after 48 h of larval exposure, suggesting that either transient larval attachments or excretory/secretory (ES) products released at sites of contact affect the single cell characteristics of the epithelium. While the important role of nematode ES products in establishing and maintaining infections has been known for decades [46, 47], the secretome of equine nematodes and the effects of released ES products on the equine intestinal mucosa remain to be resolved. Although additional experiments are needed to evaluate the putative role of ES products in the present study, the results indicate that equine enteroid monolayers could serve as useful model for studying direct effects of ES products on the equine intestinal epithelium. Future studies should also explore if conditions can be optimized to visualize successful nematode traversal of the epithelial cell layer. This may include testing different states of cellular differentiation and/or increasing the pliability of the infection model, e.g. by culturing the enteroid monolayers atop loose hydrogel scaffolds [48], or introducing an air-liquid interface [6, 49]. Regardless, the imaging technologies elaborated on here will provide a meaningful basis for future studies of nematode infection dynamics at the intestinal epithelial barrier.
In conclusion, an experimental model representative of the nematode-infected equine small intestine that can be analyzed by various imaging techniques was established. These equine enteroid monolayers contain tuft cells and mucus-producing goblet cells whose differentiation and relative abundance can be controlled by addition of Th2 polarizing cytokines. Co-incubation with nematode larvae enables detailed studies of parasite-induced effects on the intestinal epithelium, demonstrating the potential for using enteroid monolayers as an in vitro tool to study host-nematode interactions in the equine gut.