Small bowel volvulus (SBV) in Northcentral Ethiopia

doi:10.21203/rs.3.rs-33522/v2

Download PDF

Research article

Small bowel volvulus (SBV) in Northcentral Ethiopia

https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-33522/v2

This work is licensed under a CC BY 4.0 License

Journal Publication

published 02 Oct, 2020

Read the published version in BMC Surgery →

You are reading this latest preprint version

Background: Small bowel volvulus (SBV) is a benign gastrointestinal surgical condition in which there is a torsion of all or parts of a segment of small bowel on its mesenteric axis. It has been contributed significant burden of surgical emergency as cause of small bowel obstruction in developing countries. The main objective this study was to explore clinical and epidemiological profile of Small bowel volvulus in Northcentral Ethiopia

Method: The study was conducted at Debre Tabor General Hospital, South Gondar in Northcentral Ethiopia. The medical records of patients with a discharge diagnosis of small bowel volvulus were reviewed. The patients were seen for a 4-year period from Jan1, 2016-Dec31, 2019. The study was hospital-based retrospective cross-sectional and data were collected with a standardized structure questioner tool. The collected data checked for any inconsistency, code, and enter SPSS version 23 for data processing and analysis. Descriptive analyses were represented as frequency, percent, mean ± standard deviation for normal distribution, and Median ± Interquartile range for skewed data. Cross tabulation analysis was done for risk factors contributed for mortality and morbidity of SBV.

Result: There were 148 patients with Small bowel volvulus as a cause of small bowel obstruction was admitted within four years. The annual occurrence rate was 35cases per year. It represented 59% of small bowel obstruction and 36.3% of bowel obstruction. The majority were males (N=125, 84.5%) and females were (N=23, 15.5%). The age ranged from 15-78 years. The mean age was 41.14±(SD=15.4) .The most common clinical presentation was abdominal pain 98% and vomiting 91.2%. The median time of hospital stay was 5 days (± IQR=2).The mean duration of illness before hospital admission was 2 days (± SD=1.4) and median was 1 day (± IQR=2). The morbidity rate was 5.4% (N=8) and the mortality rate was 3.4 %( N=5)

Conclusion: Annual occurrence of SBV was 37 cases per year. The prevalence of SBV was 59% of small bowel obstruction and 36.3% of bowel obstruction respectively.

Surgery

General Surgery

Small bowel volvulus

Small bowel obstruction

Ethiopia

Debre Tabor

The origin of the word volvulus is derived from the Latin word “volvere” which means turn or roll [1]. Small bowel volvulus (SBV) is a benign gastrointestinal surgical condition in which there is a torsion of all or parts of a segment of small bowel on its mesenteric axis [2]. Small bowel volvulus is a rare cause of surgical emergency in the western and the USA while it is commonly found in Africa, India, and Iran [3]. Small bowel volvulus can be Neonatorm volvulus, primary or secondary according to the cause. The mechanism and underlying cause of primary SBV has not been well illustrated but the presumed factors include unusual mobility of small bowel, laxity of abdominal wall, physical exercise, absence of mesenteric fat, constipation or diarrhea, and the unusual length of small bowel segment[2-5]. Secondary SBV occurs in the presence of acquired underlying conditions such as post-op adhesion, tumors, pregnancy, diverticular disease, and bands [2] while Neonatorm volvulus is due to malrotation of bowel and defective fixation of mesentery [3]. Small bowel volvulus is a rare cause of mechanical small bowel obstruction. The incidence rate of SBV is high (24-60per 100,000populations) in Africa, Asia and Middle Eastern while low (1.7-5.7 per 100,000populations) in western [6].The overall mortality rate of SBV varies from 10-38%, viable bowel 3-13 % in western and 20-25% in Africa and Indian. The mortality rate of gangrenous bowel has been reported in a range of 20-100% [7]

Study area, period and Design

The study was conducted at Debre Tabor General Hospital, South Gondar in Northcentral Ethiopia. The medical records of patients with a discharge diagnosis of small bowel volvulus were reviewed. The patients were seen for a 4-year period from Jan1, 2016-Dec31, 2019. The study was hospital-based retrospective cross-sectional and data were collected with a standardized structure questioner tool. The Question tool contained demography, clinical presentation, and duration of illness, procedures and intraoperative findings, postoperative complications, and management outcome. All patients from age 15 years and above with clinical or/and radiological diagnosis of Small bowel volvulus which managed with conservatively and /or operatively or died due to confirmed Small bowel volvulus was included while paralytic Ileus (functional obstruction) and age below 15 years were excluded from the study. The hospital provides clinical service for approximately 900 inpatient and 80,000 outpatients in a year that comes from the catchment area of the population around 3.5 million.

Data collection and analysis

Data collected with a structured questionnaire that is developed by the English language and translated to the Amharic language. The tool was prepared after reviewed different literature and pretested before data collection. The collected data checked for any inconsistency, code, and enter SPSS version 23 for data processing and analysis. Normal distribution was evaluated with the Q-Q plot test and histogram diagram. Descriptive analyses were represented as frequency, percent; mean ± standard deviation for normal distribution, and median ± interquartile range for skewed data. Cross tabulation analysis was done for risk factors contributed for mortality and morbidity of SBV.

Ethical consideration

Ethical Review Committee of Debretabor University was approved and collection started after approval of the proposal. The confidentiality and privacy of patients maintained during data collection. The data collected retrospectively from the medical chart and consent from patients is not needed

There were 148 patients with small bowel volvulus as a cause of small bowel obstruction was admitted within four years. It represented 59% of small bowel obstruction and 36.3% of bowel obstruction. The majority of SBV were males (N=125, 84.5%) and females were (N=23, 15.5%). The majority of SBV patients were rural residents (N=121, 81.8%) and urban residents were (N=27, 18.2%).The age ranged from 15-78 years. The mean age was 41.14 years ± (SD=15.4) (Table2)

Table2. The Demographic and Characteristics of the Patients Small bowel volvulus in Debre Tabor Hospital, Northcentral Ethiopia, 2020

Item		Frequency(N)	Proportion (%)
Age N=148	15-25	28	18.9
	26-35	34	23.0
	36-45	33	22.3
	46-55	29	19.6
	56-65	15	10.1
	>66	9	6.1
Sex N=148	M	125	84.5
Sex N=148	Female	23	15.5
Residence N=148	Rural	121	81.8
Residence N=148	Urban	27	18.2

The most common clinical presentation was abdominal pain 98% and vomiting 91.2%. Most of the patients presented within 48hrs (67.6%) and 48-72hrs (19.6%). The mean of hospital stay was 5.3days (± SD=2.9) and ranged from1-18 days. The median time of hospital stay was 5 days (± IQR=2).The mean duration of illness before hospital admission was 2 days (± SD=1.4) and median was 1 day (± IQR=2). Majority of the patient respond for conservative treatment with NPO, NGT decompression and fluid resuscitation (43.2%). The most common procedure for non-respond for conservative measures were derotation and milking (DAM) for 39.9% and primary resection and anastomosis for 16.2 %( Table3). The overall morbidity rate was 5.4% (N=8) and the mortality rate was 3.4 %( N=5) (Table 3& 4). Wound infection was found as most complication. The morbidity rate for patients who had undergone surgery was 9.6% and the mortality rate was 6%.

Table3. The Clinical presentation of Patients with Small bowel volvulus in Debre Tabor Hospital, Northcentral Ethiopia, 2020

Item		Frequency(N)	Proportion(%)
Clinical Symptoms	Abdominal Pain	145	98
	Vomiting	135	91.2
	Abdominal Distention	91	61.5
	Constipation	100	67.6
Clinical Sign	Drainage Vital sign	19	12.8
	Abdominal Tenderness	126	85.1
	Hypo/Hyperactive bowel sound	71	48
	Visible peristalsis	96	64.9
	Hyper tympanic	123	83.1
Mode Treatment	Emergency	83	56.1
	Conservative	64	43.2
	Death before procedure	1	0.7
Procedure	Derotation and Milking	59	39.9
	Primary resection and anastomosis	24	16.2
	Conservative	64	43.2
	Death before procedure	1	0.7

Table4. The Pattern and outcomes of Patients with Small bowel volvulus in Debre Tabor Hospital, Northcentral Ethiopia, 2020

Item		Frequency(N)	Proportion(%)
SV	Simple SBV	123	83.1
SV	Gangrenous SBV	25	16.9
Type of SBV	Primary	148	100
Type of SBV	Secondary	0	0
Outcome	Improved	132	89.2
	Morbidity	8	5.4
	Leave against medical advice	2	1.4
	Mortality	5	3.4
Duration of illness before hospital visits	<48hr	100	67.6
	48-72hr	29	19.6
	72-96hr	8	5.4
	>96hr	11	7.4
Hospital stay N=148	<=7 days	123	83.1
Hospital stay N=148	>7 days	25	16.9
Morbidity N=8	Wound Infection	4	2.7
	Anastomosis Leak	1	0.7
	Fistula	1	0.7
	Paralytic illness	1	0.7
	others	1	0.7

Cross tabulation analysis showed morbidity rate of SBV was more likely female 8.7%vs4.8%, common in age >40 years 5.8%vs5.1 %, urban 7.4%vs. 5%, Hospital stay >7days 24%vs1.6

%, patients presented 72-96 hrs. 12.5% ,as compared less than 48hrs 5%, gangrenous SBV 20%vs.2.4% ,emergency procedure 9.6% vs0% conservative and primary resection and analysis16%vs derotation and milking(DAM)

Cross tabulation analysis showed mortality of SBV was more likely common in age <40 years 3.8%vs2.9%, urban 3.7%vs.3.3%, hospital stay >7days 4%vs3.3%, patients presented above 97hrs 18.2% as compared less than 48hr 2%, gangrenous SBV 8%vs.2.4% ,emergency procedure 6% vs0% conservative and derotation and milking (DAM)7%vs.4% in primary resection and analysis

Small bowel volvulus is a rare cause of small bowel obstruction in the western and the USA [1, 2, 8]. The incidence rate of SBV is high (24-60 per 100,000populations) in Africa, Asia and Middle Eastern while low (1.7-5.7 per 100,000populations) in western [6]. Annual occurrence in the USA and Europe is quite low compared with that in Africa, Middle East countries, and Asian [2-3, 7, 13-15] (Table1). A 57-years data review in the USA found that annual occurrences of SBV was 0.6case per year and SBV accounted for 6.9% of all bowel obstruction [7]. Welch CE 1958 reported that the prevalence reduction from 6.9% to 3.3% in the period of 1930-1958 in the USA [16] .A. Roggo and L. W. Ottinger (1992) at the Massachusetts General Hospital over 10 years reported those 35 small bowel volvulus were treated which represented 1.7% of bowel obstructions and 4% of small bowel obstructions [7]. Vaez-Zadeh et al (1969) reported the incidence of small bowel volvulus in Iran was 19.6% and 41% in bowel obstruction and small bowel obstruction respectively [2].

Table 1: Literature Review

Authors	Atalel F. Current study	M. Demssie	Roggo	Frazee	Welchi	Veaz-Zadah
Study Place	DGH, Ethiopia	Southern, Ethiopia	Bosten	Rochester MN	Glasgow UK	Iran
Study period	Jan1,2016-Dec31, 2019	June 1992toMay 1996	1980-1990	1975-1984	1965-1980	1962-1965
Duration Years	4	4	10	10	15	5
No of patients	148	98	35	57	53	41
Annual occurs	37	24.5	3.5	5.7	3.5	8.2
Male to Female	5.4:1	8.8:1	1:1.2	1:1	1:1.12	9.25:1
Mean age	41.14	34.1	67	59	54	42
Primary SBV(%	100	94.9	14	11	30	80
Secondary SBV(*%	0	5.1	86	89	70	20
Gangrenous SBV(%	16.9	28.7	46	49	43	-
Overall Mortality	3.4	13.3	9	12	28	15
Viable SBV	2.4	8.3	0	3	11	-
Gangrenous SBV	8	25.9	17	21	47	-

A series of research done in Ethiopia reported that small bowel volvulus accounted sizable portion of bowel obstruction; Tegegne A. 1992(18.3%) [9], Lintjorn B.1981et al (38.6%) [10], M. Demissie 2001(41.7%) [2], Gizaw TA.et al 2016, (36.4%) [11], Soressa U.et al 2016, (30.3%) [12]. I.O.McDonald et al. 1980 reported more than 50% of bowel obstruction due to Small bowel volvulus in Nepal [5]. This great discrepancy of the prevalence of small bowel volvulus may due to dietary factors that when a bulky bolus of food entered the proximal jejunum, that loop felt down into pelvis and causing empty distal bowel to rise into a right upper quadrant. Rapid emptying of the stomach and diaphragm makes the distal bowel spread across the left upper quadrant. As this distal loop themselves filed up would fall into left quadrat completing 360⁰twists [3]. Primary SBV is more common in developing countries while secondary SBV is more in developed countries. Frazee RC et.al 1988 (UK) and A.Roggo and L. W. Ottinger 1992(USA) noted that secondary SBV accounted for 89%&86% of SBV respectively [13, 7](Table1). A Research done by Vaez-Zadeh et al 1969(Iran), M.Demssie 2001(Ethiopia) and De Souza LJ1976 (Uganda) showed that primary SBV accounted 80%, 94.9% and 100% of SBV respectively [2, 3, 15] (Table1).We found that primary SBV accounted 100% of SBV. The presumed risk factors in different literature were hypermobility of bowel gut, hypermobility of mesentery, and bulky and poorly digestible diet taken at long intervals [2, 7, 13,17].

The speculation was some populations have long mesenteric and short roots of mesentery which would allow abnormal mobility of whole or segment of the small bowel. Diet and pattern of feeding is also the most relevant risk factor for occurrences of primary SBV. The Abrupt change of dietary habit of ingestion of a single large amount and bulky food after a long interval of fasting or empty of bowel may induce forceful bowel peristalsis, resulting in SBV [2, 7,13,17]. Secondary small bowel volvulus occurs in the presence of underlying identified predisposed conditions. It is mainly seen in bands, post-op adhesion, malrotation, or midgut nonrotation in newborn and young children and a gastrointestinal infestation of the parasite. The prevalence of secondary SBV is more common in western, constituting a 70-90 %of case [7].

The prevalence of primary SBV is more common in children and young while secondary SBV is dominantly in old age. A study conducted in the different areas stated that the mean age was 67 years in the USA ,34 years in Ethiopia, 42 years in Iran,59 years in the UK(2,3,7,13](Table1). We found that the mean age was 42 years. The incidence of SBV is a male predominance, particularly in developing countries. The research described that male to female proportion 1:1.2 in USA, 1:1.12 in UK, 9.25:1 in Iran, 8.8:1 in Ethiopia [2, 3, 7, 13]. We found similar results on the male to female proportion 5.4:1(Table 1). The exact cause of sex discrepancy is not well-illustrated but possible reasons suggested that spacious female pelvic area allowed a greater possibility of spontaneous reduction of volvulus, females have a lax abdominal wall due to childbearing, doing less heavy and prolonged exercise and more obese [2, 3, 7].Our finding noted that SBV was more common in rural resident due to more childbearing, doing less heavy, long time fasting and higher fiber diet.

The literature review summarized the common complaints of SBV abdominal pain 94-100%, vomiting 83-100%, and abdominal distention 55-100% [7]. Our result identified the common clinical complaints of SBV similar to the previous review; abdominal pain 98%, vomiting 92.1 % and distention 61.5% and frequent physical findings were abdominal tenderness 85.1% and visible peristalsis 64.9%.

SBV has been contributing a significant burden in mortality and morbidity especially when the bowel becomes gangrenous, ischemic, and develops peritonitis. The prevalence of gangrenous SBV depends on the health-seeking behavior of the community, access to a health facility, early diagnosis, and economy of the patients. The incidence of gangrenous SBV was 28.7 in Ethiopia, 46 % in the USA, and 43% in the UK [2, 7, 13].

Our study found that the incidence of gangrenous SBV 16.9%. This difference study conducted in the USA and UK was in the early 1950s and currently increases access to surgical investigation modality decreasing the incidence of gangrenous SBV.

SBV had a high mortality rate but currently mortality due to SBV decreasing due to the advance of surgical health, investigation, and early diagnosis. Overall mortality rate reported 26% in Nepal ,13.3% in Ethiopia,28% in UK,9 % in USA and 15% in Iran[2,3,5,7,13].Our finding was lowered compared with the previous study (3.4%).

Annual occurrence of SBV was 37 cases per year. The prevalence of SBV was 59% of small bowel obstruction and 36.3% of bowel obstruction respectively. It had low morbidity and mortality rate (5.4 &3.4% respectively). The majority of SBV were respond with conservative treatment with NPO, NGT decompression and resuscitation (43.2%).

COR: Crude Odd Ratio

DAM: Derotation and Milking

IQR: Inter Quartile Range

NGT: Nasogastric tube

NPO: Nill per os

OR: Odd Ratio

SBO: Small bowel obstruction

SBV: Small Bowel volvulus

SD: Standard deviation

SPSS: Statistical package for Social Science

UK: United Kingdom

USA: United States of America

Ethical approval and consent to participate

Ethical Review Committee of Debretabor University approved the ethical issue of this study and official permission to undertaken the study obtained from Debre Tabor General Hospital. The confidentiality and privacy of patients maintained during data collection. The data collected retrospectively from medical chart and consent from patients is not needed.

Consent to publication

Not applicable

Availability of data source

The datasets used and/or analyzed during the current study available from corresponding author on reasonable request.

Competing interest

Authors declare that they have no competing interests

Funding

No funding given for this study.

Authors’ contributions

Conceptualization: AF

Data collection and Methodology development: AF BT WB DZ

Software: AF BT

Data analysis: AF BT

Manuscript Draft: AF

Manuscript review and editing; AF BT WB DZ

All authors have read and approved the manuscript

Acknowledgments

Not applicable

Gingold, Z. Murrell. Management of Colonic Volvulus. Clin Colon Rectal Surg 2012;25:236–244
Demssie.Small Intestinal Volvulus in Southern Ethiopia. East Afr Med J 2001; 78 ( 4)
Vaez-Zadeh, W. Duirz, M. Nowrooz-Zadeh. Volvulus of the Small Intestine in Adults:A Study of Predisposing Factors. Ann Surg 1969;169(2)
W.Warambo . Acute volvulus of the small intestine. East Afr MedJ. 1971;48:209-12
O. McDonald, D. B. G. Hawker. Small Bowel Volvulus - The Commonest Abdominal Emergency in Nepal. Bristol Medico-Chirurgical J 1980
Iwuagwu O, Deans GT. Small bowel volvulus: a review. J R Coll Surg Edinb. 1999; 44:150–5.
Roggo, L. W. Ottinger. Acute Small Bowel Volvulus in Adults A Sporadic Form of Strangulating Intestinal Obstruction. Ann. Surg 1992;216( 2)
Li X, Zhang J, Li B, Yi D, Zhang C, Sun N, et al. Diagnosis, treatment and prognosis of small bowel volvulus in adults: A monocentric summary of a rare small intestinal obstruction. PLoS ONE 2017:12(4
Tegegne A. Small intestinal volvulus in adults of Gonder region, northwestern Ethiopia. Ethiop Med J. 1992; 30:211 1-7.
Lintjorn B., Breivik K. and Lendes. Intestinal volvulus in Sidamo, Southern Ethiopia. Easr Afr Med J 1981;58:208- 11
Ayenew Z, Gizaw AT, Workneh D, Fentahun N .Outcome of Non-Traumatic Surgical Acute Abdomen in Nekemte Referral Hospital Southwest Ethiopia: A Retrospective Cross-Sectional Study. Surgery Curr Res 2016; 7: 282. Doi: 10.4172/2161-1076.1000282
Soressa U, Mamo A, Hiko D, Fentahun N. Prevalence, causes and management outcome of intestinal obstruction in Adama Hospital, Ethiopia. BMC Surg 2016; 16:38
Frazee RC, Mucha P, Farnell MB, van Heerden JA. Volvulus of the small intestine. Ann Surg 1988; 208:565-568.
Welch GH, Anderson JR. Volvulus of the small intestine in adults. World J Surg 1986; 10:496-499.
De Souza LJ. Volvulus of the small bowel. Br Med J 1976; 1: 1055- 1056.
Welch CE. Intestinal obstruction. Chicago: Year Book Publishers, 1958, pp 14.
Barabde M, Tiwari S, Lavankar Small bowel volvulus: a rare twist in an adult. Int J
Sci Rep 2016;2(2):44-7

Download PDF

Journal Publication

published 02 Oct, 2020

Read the published version in BMC Surgery →

Editorial decision: Accept
25 Sep, 2020
Review #1 received at journal
21 Sep, 2020
Reviewer #1 agreed at journal
29 Aug, 2020
Reviewers invited by journal
26 Aug, 2020
Editor assigned by journal
31 Jul, 2020
Submission checks completed at journal
30 Jul, 2020
Editor invited by journal
30 Jul, 2020

You are reading this latest preprint version

Small bowel volvulus (SBV) in Northcentral Ethiopia

Status:

Journal Publication

Version 2

Abstract

Background

Methods

Results

Discussion

Conclusion

Abbreviations

Declarations

References

Status:

Journal Publication

Version 2