Purpose of an early diagnosis and DMT intervention service for AD
It was agreed that a new DMT service for AD should be fully embedded in existing or proposed RSMC units. As such, it would be an additional layer of service integrated into the pathway for diagnosis, disclosure and initial care planning process, and post-diagnostic interventions. Patients would retain close ties with their local MASS to access brain health support and the full range of post-diagnostic interventions and support, in parallel with the DMT provision. Table 1 outlines the specific purposes of the service providing the DMT.
Material resources and structures (‘system hardware’):
i. Surveillance to detect early disease
Early detection and monitoring of progression of cognitive decline in the earliest stages (prodromal or mild dementia stage) should be a key element of DMT preparedness because evidence supports the potential efficacy of disease modification approaches prior to moderate or advanced stage dementia. This requires early detection at the clinical level, but also greater public awareness and health literacy for timely help seeking.
Early clinical detection: Ideally, blood-based biomarkers, available at the primary care level, would be available to enable early detection. While such interventions are on the horizon, currently raising awareness amongst the public and primary care providers is the only alternative. Importantly, initiatives to introduce widespread cognitive screening for older people in the UK were not supported [14] due to the risk of over-diagnosis and the lack of meaningful interventions in the early stages. With the advent of the DMTs, this may need to be revisited.
Public awareness and health literacy needs: To enable successful implementation of the new DMTs, it is important to harness political willpower by presenting DMTs as a public health investment, rather than a cost, with a clear narrative around economic savings that could accrue from delaying conversion to or progression of dementia. Research at a national scale that captures public perception, expectations, and concerns about DMTs is required, and any public health literacy campaign should be designed in collaboration with stakeholders, including PPI contributors, capitalising on existing resources (e.g., Ireland’s ‘Understand Together’ dementia campaign). Finally, public health messaging should highlight the importance of an early diagnosis, while managing expectations regarding the efficacy and narrow eligibility criteria for DMTs.
ii. Infrastructure and provision for an early diagnosis and intervention service for AD
The working group debated the utility of a distributed versus centralised service model for DMT delivery. One commonly used model in Irish healthcare is a ‘hub-and-spoke’ model (e.g., in hyper-acute stroke care), which can provide a practical compromise, as shown in Fig 1. This entails one or more RSMC acting as a central hub, ideally in different regions of the country, and local MASS acting as spokes across the country. Rolling out DMT provision in one or two highly resourced pilot sites in the first instance, rather than starting with a fully distributed service, would ascertain eligibility rates and DMTs uptake, and develop experience around the administration and monitoring of DMTs. In the meantime, existing MASS services (spokes) will see relatively small numbers of people potentially eligible for DMTs. Thus, local referral pathways will be needed from these services to a nearby RSMC, or a MASS that has elected to provide DMTs in the first wave, so that the person can have detailed eligibility assessment and access to a DMT.
[Insert Fig 1 here]
Minimal service capacity to deliver DMT
The minimal service capacity requirements to deliver DMTs are detailed in Table 1, and include: (1) capacity to ascertain biomarker status for AD; (2) medication administration infrastructure (e.g. infusion facilities); (3) sufficient MRI neuroimaging capacity for both diagnosis and monitoring; and (4) links to brain health pathways and post-diagnostic support.
[Insert Table 1 here]
Patient referral criteria to the DMT service
It was agreed that the service providing access to anti-amyloid DMTs would identify its own pool of eligible patients within its MASS/RSMC remit, as well as accepting referrals from other MASS, diverting a patient directly to the MASS/RSMC or performing an initial assessment/full diagnosis and disclosure prior to referral. In addition, the DMT service might choose to accept referrals directly from primary care or triage such referrals to a local MASS for initial review. Suggested patient referral criteria to the DMT service are listed in Table 1. Patients would not be accepted into the service if they had non-degenerative cognitive impairment due to another identified cause at the point of referral (e.g. depression, alcohol or drug misuse). If cognitive complaints persisted after effective treatment of a primary illness, then referral could be considered.
Components of the DMT intervention pathway
The DMT arm of a memory service would have three main components: (1) assessment and diagnosis; (2) intervention administration; and (3) ongoing monitoring and care. These components would run parallel to a brain health clinic model offered by local MASS services and are also outlined in Table 1, along with a list of eligibility criteria for DMT, which align broadly with the inclusion criteria of the relevant clinical trials of these same DMT [1]. It is noted that at the point of referral to local MASS, it is expected that a basic medical and cognitive work-up will have been completed in primary care to rule out reversible causes for cognitive complaints (e.g. depression and thyroid dysfunction) and to establish that the patient is in the prodromal or mild dementia stage. Once a referral has been accepted, a detailed assessment including biomarkers would be undertaken, as summarized in Table 1 under the first component of the service, ‘Assessment domains’. This will ascertain diagnostic sub-type and prognosis of early-stage cognitive decline. The assessment would include clinical, lifestyle, behavioural, functional, and cognitive assessments as well as biomarker detection. Key biomarkers, as recommended under the International Working Group (IWG-2) criteria for AD [4] are briefly outlined in Table 1. The use of biomarkers in the diagnosis of AD in the prodromal stage has altered the characterization of AD from being a syndrome-based diagnosis to a biologically based diagnosis.
The outcome of the assessment will enable patients to be assigned to one of three risk-based 'streams': (1) begin the DMT care pathway; (2) refer to local MASS for brain health pathway or relevant care for non-AD neurodegenerative disorders; and/or (3) refer to research. Details of an approach to brain health management in preparation for use of the new DMTs has already been outlined in elsewhere and will thus not be repeated in full here. Under the ‘intervention administration’ domain, guidelines for medical rationalization, managing comorbidity, and pharmacological and non-pharmacological interventions are outlined, and under the ‘ongoing monitoring and care’ domain, guidelines for periodic MRI monitoring and possible cessation of therapy are listed.
iii. Workforce: Roles and education
Roles and expertise required: The availability of frontline healthcare workers in sufficient numbers and with appropriate training and expertise to administer and monitor DMTs is a key feature. Whilst the specialist assessments and initial interventions will be undertaken by members of the core MASS/RSMC team, they will link in with a range of services and providers, both internal and external, as per the model of care. The MASS/RSMC team will be meeting in person or virtually for multidisciplinary team (MDT) meetings. Additional to the roles of the MDT as outlined in the model of care, for DMT provision, there are additional roles specifically for DMT provision, described in Table 2.
[Insert Table 2 here]
Education and training of workforce: Delivery of an accurate diagnosis, identification of suitable treatment candidates, and monitoring of ongoing DMTs will require a standardised training program. Clinicians from multiple specialities (geriatric medicine, psychiatry, neurology, general practice) involved in the work-up and diagnosis of dementia will require training delivered via the Royal College of Physicians Ireland, Irish College of General Practitioners, and the Irish College of Psychiatry in the application of biomarker and therapeutic indications for a DMT trial. Radiologists will require training in the interpretation of evolving imaging modalities supporting the diagnosis of AD and other dementia subtypes. Training for clinicians on the identification of adverse drug reactions (e.g. ARIA) will be required and delivered as an ongoing iterative process as the field advances.
iv. Communication mechanisms
Considering the hub and spoke model across the geography of Ireland, robust, timely, and standardized communication between the hub and spokes is necessary for ensuring patient safety. Additionally, the use of visual representations of the health system structure, such as the one detailed in Fig 1, will facilitate decision-making and preparedness among users and policy makers.
Human and institutional relationships, values, and norms (i.e., system 'software'):
i. Governance: Need for a national AD DMT patient registry
Governance emphasizes the creation and monitoring of the rules that govern the supply and demand of health services. There should be a national Alzheimer DMT patient registry for accurate patient safety monitoring at national level and to support service planning. These data can be recorded along with other mandatory data from the developing MASS and RSMC (as an adjunct to the already proposed minimum dataset), but there may be additional drugs’ group monitoring requirements, dictated by Ireland Health Products Regulatory Agency.
ii. Trust
Trust is a fundamental component of health system preparedness, incorporating both interpersonal trust (between patient and provider) and institutional trust (between individuals and the health system or government) [15]. Furthermore, trust is a prerequisite for health system resilience, particularly as new paradigms of care are being introduced. Health systems that have the trust of the population and political leaders by providing quality services prior to a health urgency have greater resilience [16].
Current provision of services in Ireland that are ‘DMT ready’ and the projected need
If and when a DMT such as lecanemab gains approval for use Ireland, the additional demand on services would be significant, including additional diagnostic services for biomarker detection (i.e., lumbar puncture, ligand-based PET scans), drug administration (i.e., infusion facilities such as day hospitals), and treatment-related safety monitoring capacity (i.e. serial brain MRIs). Considering these minimum requirements to offer an infusion based DMT in Ireland, it is likely that it can only be offered in a limited number of centres in Ireland.
Projected neuroimaging requirements: Currently an MRI scan is the preferred imaging modality in a memory service to assist with early diagnosis and detection of subcortical vascular changes [11]. Since the amyloid-based DMTs are associated with ARIA, ongoing monitoring for those on treatment would be needed. Based on the estimated prevalence figures above, and an anticipated need of 3 routine monitoring scans per person, this would necessitate 10,140-65,640 scheduled MRIs.3 Additionally, about 40% of those on DMTs may require up to three additional MRIs due to the actual development of ARIA or neurological sequelae, equating to 4056-26,656 non-routine MRI scans, so that the total early roll-out need for additional MRI scans is 14,196-92,296 scans, required over the first 2-3 years post-licencing.3 Steady-state MRI demand by 2030 is estimated to be 5,720-30,879 scans per annum.
Challenges to delivery of DMT for Alzheimer’s in Ireland
Table 3 summaries several areas that may pose both structural and ethical challenges to these new treatments for AD in Ireland.