Vertical sleeve gastrectomy ameliorates MASH progression independent of weight loss
To study the mechanisms by which bariatric surgery ameliorates MASH, we used a validated mouse model of VSG in which approximately 80% of the lateral stomach of mice is clamped by a gastric clip and excised15. To induce MASH, we fed mice a high-fat high-carbohydrate (HFHC) diet that recapitulates aspects of human disease such as obesity, hepatic lipid accumulation, inflammation, and fibrosis27. Mice were fed the HFHC diet ad libitum for 12 weeks and then assigned to either sham (Sham AL) or VSG surgery (Fig. 1A) and remained on the HFHC diet for 5 weeks. Most mice survived the surgery, and we confirmed surgical anatomy by oral gavage of barium and imaging15. To determine weight-loss-independent effects, we included a sham group that was pair-fed to the VSG group (Sham PF) to match their caloric intake during the post-surgery period28. In addition, a group of mice were fed a normal chow diet (NCD) for the duration of the studies. Compared with Sham AL, both VSG and Sham PF mice resulted in a similar decrease in average daily food intake (Fig. 1B). Following the surgeries, body weight rapidly decreased in Sham AL, PF, and VSG groups due to the intervention, as previously reported29 (Fig. 1C). However, while the body weight in Sham AL mice recovered, Sham PF and VSG mice maintained their weight loss throughout the study (Fig. 1C). Five weeks after the surgeries, both Sham PF and VSG mice showed a similar decrease in liver weight (Fig. 1D). Compared with Sham AL controls, only the VSG group showed a reduction in hepatic lipid accumulation (Fig. 1E and 1F), ALT/AST (Fig. 1G), fibrosis (Fig. 1H and Extended Data Fig. 1B), and NAS score (Extended Data Fig. 1A), suggesting that the effects of VSG are partly independent of the reduced caloric intake induced by the surgery. As decreased intestinal lipid absorption has been proposed as a mechanism of VSG actions30, we measured fecal lipids and found that VSG mice had increased fecal lipids compared with Sham AL mice (Fig. 1I). We also determined the effects of VSG on MASH progression 10 weeks after surgeries and found that the VSG-induced reductions in body and liver weight, liver triglycerides, AST, and ALT were maintained at this later timepoint (Extended Data Fig. 1C-G). Overall, these findings indicate that VSG results in substantial improvements in MASH in a weight-loss-independent manner.
To determine if the VSG-induced improvements in MASH were associated with alterations in the gut microbiota and its metabolites, we analyzed the fecal microbial composition of NCD, Sham AL, Sham PF, and VSG mice 5 weeks after surgeries. Compared with NCD mice, HFHC feeding induced dramatic remodeling in gut microbial species, including increased abundances of Akkermansia, Erysipelotrichaceae, Parasutterella, Ruminococceae, Clostridium XVIII, and decreased abundances of Lactobacillus, and Alistipes (Fig. 1K and Supplemental Table 1). While HFHC feeding caused a substantial loss of Lactobacillus, regardless of surgical treatment, VSG resulted in a restoration of this genus towards levels found in NCD mice (Fig. 1J). In contrast, the HFHC diet increased the abundance of Clostridium XVIII whereas it was partially lowered following VSG (Fig. 1L). No differences in fecal microbiota composition between Sham AL and Sham PF mice were detected 5 weeks after the interventions (Supplemental Table 1). Intestinal products can translocate into the portal vein and reach the liver where they can regulate immune homeostasis and inhibit inflammation31. Thus, we measured the concentrations of bile acids (BA) and short-chain fatty acids (SCFA) in the portal vein blood. While HFHC feeding increased the total amount of BA, as observed in Sham AL mice, both Sham PF and VSG mice had decreased BA concentrations to levels similar to NCD controls (Fig. 1M). In particular, VSG and Sham PF mice had a similar decrease in taurine-conjugated cholic acid while VSG was more effective at reducing deoxycholic acid and taurodeoxycholic acid (Fig. 1N). Independent of surgical intervention, HFHC feeding decreased the levels of cholic acid, chenodeoxycholic acid, and hyodeoxycholic acid and increased several taurine-conjugated BA in all groups without any effects of Sham PF or VSG (Extended Data Fig. 1H). HFHC feeding also decreased the concentration of SCFAs in hepatic portal serum and neither VSG nor Sham PF had an impact on their concentration (Fig. 1O and Supplemental Table 2). Overall, these data suggest that the VSG-induced improvements in MASH are associated with a partial restoration of specific gut microbial species and BAs.
scRNA-seq reveals profound effects of VSG on hepatic LAMs
To explore the impact of VSG on hepatic macrophages, we first determined the abundance of macrophages and Kupffer cells (KCs) subsets by flow cytometry32. We did not detect any differences in the number of monocyte-derived macrophages (MoMF), embryonic KCs (emKC), monocyte-derived KCs (moKC), and VSIG4− macrophages between Sham and VSG groups at 5 or 10 weeks after surgeries (Extended Data Fig. 2A). To determine how VSG influences the function of hepatic macrophages, we profiled the gene expression of macrophages from Sham AL, Sham PF, and VSG mice using droplet-based single-cell RNA sequencing (scRNA-seq, Fig. 2A). Livers were perfused before immune cell isolation to remove circulatory cells33. We multiplexed samples using cell multiplexing oligos (CMOs) to track the sample of origin. Cells were loaded into the ports of a 10x-Genomics chip following a single-cell 3’ kit. The gene expression and CMO libraries were sequenced using a Novaseq S4 chip (2x150bp PE). After quality control, data were normalized and de-multiplexed. Monocytes and macrophages were identified using the cell ID function of Seurat and re-clustered for analysis. We profiled the gene expression of 58,904 single cells (avg. read depth 50,000, Fig. 2B). Unsupervised graph-based clustering was performed on the integrated dataset and cells were visualized using uniform manifold approximation and projection (UMAP). Independent of surgical groups, integrated UMAP analysis revealed 18 clusters of monocytes and macrophages, whose identity was determined based on the expression of established marker genes18, 34 (Fig. 2C, Extended Data Fig. 2B, and Supplemental Table 3).
Independent of surgical intervention, clusters 0, 2, 5, 6, 7, 8, 13, and 16 were identified as monocyte-like cells while clusters 1, 3, 4, 9, 10, 11, 12, and 14 were macrophages (Fig. 2C). Monocyte clusters had heterogeneous gene expression profiles indicative of their progressive stages of maturation and function. Clusters 0, 2, and 7 had dual monocyte and macrophage features, such as Ly6c2 and H2-Ab1, suggesting that they were transitioning monocytes on the trajectory of becoming macrophages. Cells in cluster 6 were identified as classical monocytes based on their high expression of Ly6c2 and Ccr2, which allows them to migrate in response to inflammation. Monocytes in cluster 8 were enriched in Spn and did not express Ccr2 and Ly6c2 indicating these cells were non-classical monocytes capable of patrolling. Clusters 13 and 16 corresponded to unidentifiable monocyte populations that expressed high levels of Il2rb and Cxcr2, respectively (Fig. 2C). We next analyzed the macrophage subsets which can broadly be divided into Kupffer cells (KCs) and MoMFs. Clusters 3, 9, and 10 were identified as KCs (KC1-3) based on their expression of Clec1b, Clec4f, Vsig4, and Folr2. These clusters of KCs had minimal expression of Timd4 suggesting that they are primarily moKCs32. Clusters 3 and 9 had a similar gene expression pattern, although cluster 3 was enriched in genes associated with efferocytosis such as Mertk and Wdfy3. Cluster 10 was enriched in Esam and Cd36 and resembles a recently identified subset of pathogenic KCs termed “KC2”35. Among MoMFs, cells in cluster 1 were enriched for LAM genes including Trem2, Spp1, Lipa, and Cd3636 (Fig. 2C, 2D and Supplemental Table 3). Pathway analysis showed that LAMs have enriched gene programs associated with lipid metabolism such as “Lipoprotein particle binding” and “Lipase activity” (Fig. 2E). Cluster 4 was composed of MoMFs and transitioning monocytes that could not be further characterized based on their differential gene expression. Cells in cluster 14 were enriched in hemoglobin genes Hba-a1 and Hba-a2 which are highly expressed by erythrophages. Cluster 12 had a high G2M score and was enriched with Top2a, typical of proliferating macrophages (Fig. 2C, 2D and Supplemental Table 3). To gain insight into the differentiation of macrophage subsets, we performed a slingshot trajectory analysis37 of our integrated dataset. Although the origin (ontogeny) and cellular turnover of hepatic LAMs is unknown, recent work suggests that recruited MoMFs give rise to hepatic LAMs22, 38. Using monocytes as the origin, we found three primary trajectories by which newly recruited monocytes differentiate into transitioning monocytes and then either differentiate into LAMs, KC1s, or Trans Mon2s (Fig. 2F and Extended Data Fig. 2C). These data suggest that LAMs are derived from classical monocytes and are consistent with recent studies that have used single cell transcriptomics to reveal a previously unappreciated heterogeneity in hepatic macrophages in the MASH liver18, 39.
Following cluster identification and trajectory analysis, we demultiplexed the samples based on their experimental group and determined the relative abundance of each cluster. There were no differences in the proportion and number of the major myeloid clusters 5 weeks post-VSG (Fig. 3A). To investigate the effects of VSG on the transcriptome of hepatic macrophages, we performed differential gene expression analysis between Sham AL, Sham PF, and VSG groups and found distinct expression patterns in macrophage clusters analyzed in bulk (Extended Data Fig. 3A) and per cluster (Supplemental Table 4). Given the reparative functions of LAMs in MASH, we focused our subsequent analysis on these cells. First, we quantified the average single-cell expression of the Trem2 gene in the LAM cluster and found no differences between groups (Fig. 3B). Despite no effect on the abundance of LAMs and Trem2 gene expression, VSG mice had a decreased serum level of sTREM2 (Fig. 3C), suggesting a reduced cleavage of membrane-bound TREM2 in macrophages due to improved inflammation21. Next, we performed differential gene expression analysis between LAMs from VSG, Sham AL, and Sham PF mice. Compared with LAMs from Sham AL (37 DEGs), and to a lesser extent Sham PF (24 DEGs), LAMs from VSG mice showed an increased expression of genes involved in lysosomal activity (Lyz2, Ctsl, Ctss, and H2-Eb1), antigen presentation (H2-Eb1), repression of inflammation (Egr1), and fatty acid metabolism (Lipa) (Supplemental Table 4 and Fig. 3D). In contrast, several genes associated with inflammation (Cd83, Nfkb1, Junb, and Mmp7) were downregulated in LAMs from VSG mice (Fig. 3D). Pathway analysis revealed an upregulation of pathways associated with immune activation and lysosomal activity such as “Chemokine signaling”, “Cytokine receptor interaction”, and “Phagosome” in LAMs from VSG mice (Fig. 3E). Similarly, gene set enrichment analysis showed that genes involved in “Chemokine signaling”, “Lysosome”, “Peroxisome” and “Fatty acid metabolism” had increased expression in VSG LAMs, compared with Sham PF controls (Fig. 3G). Overall, these data highlight lysosomal and metabolic regulatory mechanisms by which VSG may sustain the protective function of LAMs against MASH in response to VSG.
Hepatic TREM2+ LAMs mediate the reparative effects of VSG against MASH
Recent work has shown that systemic TREM2 deficiency worsens diet-induced MASH as TREM2 is required for LAM survival, the metabolic coordination between LAMs and hepatocytes, and the clearance of dying liver cells 21, 22, 23, 40. To determine if LAMs directly mediate the reparative process induced by VSG against MASH, we performed sham or VSG surgeries on WT and TREM2-deficient (TREM2 KO) mice fed an HFHC diet for 12 weeks. Expression of Trem2 was not detectable in bone marrow-derived macrophages (BMDM) from TREM2 KO mice (Extended Data Fig. 4A). Five weeks post-surgery, WT and TREM2 KO mice showed a similar degree of weight loss (Fig. 4A) and an increase in fecal lipid excretion (Fig. 4B) in response to VSG. In agreement with our previous experiments, we found that sTREM2 was reduced following VSG in the serum of WT mice but was not detectable in TREM2 KO mice (Extended Data Fig. 4B). Notably, while VSG ameliorated MASH progression in WT mice, this effect was blunted in TREM2 KO mice (Fig. 4C-G). Compared with their Sham controls, VSG failed to decrease the liver weight (Fig. 4C), hepatic steatosis (Fig. 4D and 4E), ALT (Fig. 4F), and AST (Fig. 4G) in TREM2 KO mice, suggesting that TREM2 is required for the VSG-induced reversal of MASH. To explore the underlying mechanisms, we first assessed whether TREM2 deficiency alters the hepatic macrophage populations in mice with MASH before and after VSG. We found no differences in the number of MoMFs, emKCs, moKCs, and VSIG4- macrophages between WT and TREM2 KO fed the HFHC diet for 12 weeks without any intervention (Extended Data Fig. 4C). Similarly, the blunted effect of VSG in TREM2 KO mice was not associated with alterations in the number of hepatic macrophage subsets (Fig. 4H and Extended Data Fig. 4D). To determine the potential mechanisms by which TREM2 KO mice are resistant to the beneficial effects of VSG, we magnetically sorted and performed bulk RNA sequencing on total macrophages from the livers of WT and TREM2 KO mice after sham or VSG surgeries. Unsupervised PCA showed a distinct separation between WT Sham and WT VSG, whereas there was no distinction between TREM2 KO Sham and TREM2 KO VSG macrophages (Fig. 4I). Differential gene expression analysis revealed a more robust response of WT macrophages to VSG (331 DEGs), compared with that of TREM2 KO cells (44 DEGs) (Fig. 4J and Extended Data Table 5). In agreement, unsupervised clustering of the top 500 most variable genes revealed substantial gene expression differences and clustering between WT Sham and VSG macrophages but not between TREM2 KO Sham and VSG cells (Extended Data Fig. 4E). We performed pathway and gene ontology (GO) analyses and found that TREM2 KO macrophages from VSG mice upregulated genes enriched in inflammatory and immune activation pathways such as “cytokine-cytokine receptor interaction” and the GO terms “inflammatory response” and “chemotaxis” (Fig. 4K), suggesting that TREM2 is required for preventing an inflammatory activation of macrophages. To test this possibility, we examined the response of BMDMs from WT and TREM2 KO mice with or without stimulation with palmitate (PA) in vitro to mimic the lipid-rich environment of the MASH liver. Compared with WT controls, TREM2 KO BMDMs showed a markedly increased expression of Il1b, Il6, and Tnf, regardless of stimulation (Fig. 4L). Next, to determine whether TREM2 facilitates the ability of macrophages to clear apoptotic cells, we induced apoptosis in AML12 hepatocytes by PA treatment (Extended Data Fig. 4F) and co-cultured them with either WT or TREM2 KO peritoneal macrophages. Consistent with its key role in efferocytosis, TREM2 was required for macrophages to perform effective efferocytosis of apoptotic hepatocytes (Fig. 4M). Together, these data suggest that hepatic LAMs mediate the VSG-induced reversal of MASH by repressing inflammation and facilitating efferocytosis in a TREM2-dependent manner.
VSG increases the content of inflammatory lipid species in hepatic macrophages
Our scRNA-seq data shows that hepatic LAMs are uniquely equipped with the enzymatic machinery to recognize, scavenge, and catabolize lipids20, 38. Because our data showed that total liver TGs decreased in response to VSG while hepatic LAMs upregulate lipid metabolism genes, we performed metabolic profiling of sorted F4/80+ macrophages from Sham AL and VSG livers to determine how bariatric surgery alters their lipid content. We performed metabolite profiling by liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry (MxP® Quant 500 kit, Biocrates), which revealed 317 unique detectable metabolites in macrophages. The majority of these were lipid species, predominantly TGs and phosphatidylcholines, although we also detected amino acids and bile acids (Fig. 5A). Unsupervised principal component analysis (PCA) of detected metabolites showed a moderate clustering of VSG samples with more separation among Sham AL specimens (Fig. 5B). We found no difference in the concentration of total TGs in the mcarophages from Sham AL and VSG mice (Fig. 5C). However, when we performed chain length enrichment analysis of all lipid species, we found that macrophages from Sham AL mice were enriched in species with longer chain lengths while those from VSG mice were enriched in species of shorter chain length (Fig. 5D). Quantification of the major lipid families showed that macrophages from VSG mice had increased total phosphatidylcholines and sphingolipids, but no changes in total, cholesterol esters, fatty acids, glycosylceramides, ceramides, sphingolipids, and diacylglycerols (Fig. 5E). To further assess the effects of VSG on the lipid profile of hepatic macrophages, we assessed the composition of the individual lipid species. VSG macrophages had increased levels of phosphatidylcholines particularly species containing 2 acyl-bound (aa), one acyl- and one alkyl-bound (ae), and monounsaturated fatty acids (Fig. 5F and Extended Data Fig. 5). The role of phosphatidylcholines in macrophages is unclear with studies reporting both pro-inflammatory41 and anti-inflammatory42 responses. VSG macrophages were also enriched in sphingolipids containing long, very long-chain fatty acids, and hydroxyl-free species (Fig. 5G), as well as ceramides rich in very long-chain fatty acids (Fig. 5H). Given that sphingolipids acylated with fatty acids give rise to ceramides43, and that excess ceramides have detrimental effects on the liver including steatosis44, insulin resistance45, inflammation, and oxidative stress46, it is possible that VSG macrophages protect the liver from their detrimental effects. Although there were trending increases in VSG macrophages, we were unable to detect significant differences in the content of mono- and poly-unsaturated fatty acids (Fig. 5I) and cholesterol esters (Fig. 5J), compared with Sham controls. As the liver has decreased steatosis after VSG, the increase of macrophage intracellular lipids suggests an improved ability to clear lipids after the surgery.
Spatial transcriptomic of MASH livers following bariatric surgery reveal an improved metabolic status in the macrophage microenvironment
Given that our scRNA-seq analysis revealed substantial changes in the gene expression profile of hepatic macrophages, we explored the effects of VSG on the hepatic areas surrounding these cells using spatial transcriptomic analysis of liver sections (Nanostring GeoMx). Tissues from NCD, Sham AL, Sham PF, and VSG mice were collected 5 weeks after surgery and stained with a fluorescently labeled antibody against the macrophage marker CD68 to capture gene expression changes in CD68− microanatomic areas (Fig. 6A). Following imaging and sequencing, the initial data was subjected to quality checks, filtering, and scaling, leading to a total of 7074 detectable genes and 32–36 regions of interest (ROI) per group (Fig. 6B) Unsupervised PCA of the normalized genes showed a substantial separation between CD68-expressing ROIs, and to a lesser extent between experimental groups (Fig. 6C). Due to the small size of their ROIs, we were unable to detect meaningful gene expression data from the CD68+ macrophage areas. However, differential expression gene analysis of the CD68− ROIs revealed 185, 103, and 139 DEGs (FDR < 0.05, FC > 1.5; Supplemental File 6) between NCD vs. Sham AL (Fig. 6D), Sham AL vs. and VSG (Fig. 6E), and Sham PF vs. VSG (Fig. 6F), respectively. To better understand the biological meaning of these changes, we performed enrichment and pathway analyses. Gene set enrichment analysis revealed that our analysis covered a wide range of cellular pathways including “metabolism”, “immune system”, “signal transduction” and “metabolism of proteins” (Extended Data Fig. 6A). Compared with the NCD group, pathway analysis showed that Sham AL mice had downregulated genes involved in the “metabolism of steroids” and “respiratory electron transport” and upregulation of “plasma lipoprotein remodeling” and “chemokine receptors bind chemokines” (Fig. 6G). Compared with Sham AL, VSG downregulated pathways involved in “biological oxidations”, “metabolism of amino acids”, and “metabolism of lipids” in agreement with the reduced lipid accumulation observed in VSG mice. On the other hand, VSG upregulated pathways such as “degranulation of neutrophils/platelets” and “complement cascade” indicative of an active immune and tissue remodeling response (Fig. 6H). Compared with the Sham PF group, we observed a downregulation of metabolic pathways and an upregulation of complement pathways in the VSG ROIs, similar to the VSG-induced changes relative to the Sham AL group (Fig. 6I). Overall, these findings highlight the VSG-induced transcriptomic changes in metabolic and immune pathways in the microenvironment surrounding hepatic macrophages that are associated with MASH reversal.
Finally, we determined whether our main findings could be relevant to human patients with MASH undergoing VSG. We performed spatial transcriptomics on needle biopsy specimens from a patient with MASH, collected before and one year after VSG (Extended Data Fig. 6B) as VSG resulted in the resolution of MASH (NAS 4 to NAS 0 after 12 months, Table 1). We also included a liver specimen from a donor patient with MASH without any surgical intervention. After staining with cytokeratin (green) and the macrophage marker CD68 (magenta), 32 ROIs were annotated to define hepatic zones I, II, and III (Extended Data Fig. 2C). Unsupervised PCA of detectable genes revealed a substantial separation between specimens but small differences between hepatic zones (Extended Data Fig. 2D). Pathway analysis of these comparisons revealed several downregulated pathways involved in the “metabolism of lipids”, “cholesterol biosynthesis”, and “metabolism of steroids” (Extended Data Fig. 2E), consistent with the MASH resolution observed in this patient. To explore if human LAMs are responsive to VSG as in our mouse studies, we assessed the expression of genes involved in the LAM differentiation program including Trem2, Plin2, Ctss, Cd36, and Lipa38, 40. LAM genes were primarily enriched in zone I of the liver (Extended Data Fig. 2F), in agreement with a recently published spatial transcriptomic study20. Furthermore, the LAM genes were upregulated in the Pre-VSG and MASH samples but were lower in the Post-VSG sample (Extended Data Fig. 2F). These data suggest that LAMs correlate with disease progression in human MASH.