The placenta is a complex organ with different structural subregions consisting of various cell types including syncytiotrophoblasts, cytotrophoblasts, mesenchymal cells, and fetal vascular cells (Wang and Zhao 2010). Different anatomic placental areas could play varying roles in normal fetal growth and development. Our previous study revealed that intrauterine injection of lipopolysaccharide resulted in different mTORC1 activities in different anatomic locations of the mouse placenta (Dong et al. 2019). These findings suggest that it is necessary to distinguish placental zones when analyzing molecular expressions and functional changes. In this study, we identified increased mTOR activity in fetal-side compared to maternal-side of human placentas. Similarly, in mouse placentas the key molecules of mTOR signaling exhibited different expression levels and phosphorylation activity in different anatomical zones (DJ layer vs L layer). A study by Napso et al. (Napso et al. 2022) reported that the change in respiratory capacity differed in different placental zones under the condition of maternal diet-induced obesity, suggesting that the junctional and labyrinth zones have different functionality and response abilities.
FGR is a common complication of pregnancy and can have significant effects on long term neonatal outcomes Although a growing number of studies support mTOR signaling inhibition as an underlying mechanism of FGR (Gupta and Jansson 2019; Larqué et al. 2013; Roos et al. 2009), there remains inconsistencies in the literature, likely owing to differences in study methodology (Dong et al. 2020). Therefore, our study aimed to clarify the precise mechanism of placental mTOR activity in FGR.
We investigated the placental mTOR signaling pathway in full-term human SGA and AGA pregnancies. In contrast to previously published studies (Hung et al. 2017; Roos et al. 2007; Zhang et al. 2017), we found lower levels of p-RPS6 and higher levels of p-4EBP1 in the fetal-side of human SGA placentas, while t-mTOR level was decreased in the maternal-side of SGA placentas. The variation in these results compared to previously published findings is thought to be due to optimization of detection methods in our study. For example, we tested mTOR-related molecules in the maternal- and fetal-side of placentas. In addition, we utilized Coomassie staining as the total protein reference used for calculating the relative values of protein bands in WB, which may be superior to the housekeeping proteins in terms of quantitative analysis (Welinder and Ekblad 2011).
Many different FGR models exist, including folate deficiency, maternal diet restriction, and hypoxia. As summarized in our review (Dong et al. 2020), studies of these models have identified the commonality of placental mTOR signaling pathway inhibition in FGR, indicating that it may be a key regulatory hub in the development of growth restriction. Based on this, we assume that inhibiting placental mTOR activity with rapamycin to induce FGR is a valid model to study the mechanism underlying FGR, especially the type without specific pathogenic factors. In 2021, Shao et al. (Shao et al. 2021) developed the rapamycin-induced FGR mouse model by intraperitoneally injecting rapamycin at the dose of 1 mg/kg/day (approximately 0.04 mg/day per dam) during E10.5 to E13.5, and found the phosphorylation activities of mTOR and S6k (an upstream of Rps6) were significantly reduced in the bulk placentas from FGR group. In this study, we utilized the FGR model induced by a low-dose rapamycin (0.01 mg/day), we observed that the decreased mTOR activity occurred in the DJ layer of mouse FGR placentas. Our data demonstrate that low-dose rapamycin is associated with decreased intrauterine fetal growth and that mTOR signaling is affected to a greater extent in the DJ layer than the L layer of mouse placentas.
To understand the potential mechanism responsible for FGR due to the decreased placental mTOR signaling, we analyzed the morphology of mouse placentas and found that rapamycin-induced FGR placentas demonstrated reduced placental size and thickness, decreased ratio of junctional zone, and decreased vascular density. These morphological changes may be associated with abnormal placental structure and function. By the methods of whole placenta transcriptomics, we characterized that lipid metabolism may be affected in FGR placentas based on the enrichment analysis and expression identification of the DE mRNAs (Enpp7, Acacb and Clps). In addition, lipidomic examination of the DJ and L layers of mouse placentas, identified the increased levels of multiple lipid components linked with energy supply (such as FFA and TAG) in rapamycin-induced FGR placentas. However, other lipids (such as CL, PE, and PS) involved in cellular structure assembly were significantly reduced in FGR placentas, which may explain their reduced placental size. When analyzing the expression of genes related to lipid metabolism, despite the differential expression between the DJ and L layers, most of the relevant genes demonstrated reduced expression levels in FGR placentas compared to controls. As mTOR signaling plays a fundamental role in regulating lipid biosynthesis and metabolism, the observed changes in lipid molecules and corresponding regulatory genes could be attributed to mTOR inhibition in these FGR placentas (Caron et al. 2015). With the exclusion of the potential effect of maternal blood lipids on placental lipid levels, we suppose that the increased major lipids (FFA, CE and TAG) are due to suppressed lipid metabolism (including lipid oxidation, synthesis, and transport) in rapamycin-induced FGR mouse placentas. Importantly, we observed that mitochondrial respiratory chain (MRC) complexes V (CV, also called ATP synthase) were significantly increased in the L layer of FGR placentas compared to controls. These findings indicate that, as a consequence of altered lipid metabolism, there may be a compensatory increase in energy supply in FGR placentas to maintain fetal growth.
Strategies to prevent unexplained FGR are critical but limited in obstetric management. At present, effective interventions to reduce the occurrence of FGR mainly emphasize maintaining a healthy lifestyle (ex. avoiding tobacco and alcohol) and routine ultrasound monitoring (Berghella 2007). There remains a significant need for effective preventive and therapeutic interventions. Since rapamycin-induced FGR placentas had increased lipid accumulation, and may have decreased utilization, we explored the effect of maternal exercise on fetal weight in the FGR model. Our data showed that maternal exercise in rapamycin-treated pregnancies, conducted during E0.5 to E16.5, increased fetal and placental weight. Maternal exercise was also associated with improved placental morphology in the FGR model and increased phosphorylation activity of Rps6 in the DJ and L layers of FGR placentas. Additionally, we observed that the FFA level in the DJ zone of FGR placentas returned to normal level with maternal exercise. These results suggest that maternal exercise improves placental insufficiency and promotes FFA metabolism in rapamycin-induced FGR. According to our findings, maternal exercise may be an effective method to mitigate the development of FGR. In fact, some researchers have reported that pregnant women who participate in moderate physical activity have a less risk of low-birth weight babies (Xi et al. 2020; Walasik et al. 2020; Gollenberg et al. 2011; Takito and Benício 2010). However, other studies found no effect of maternal physical activity in reducing the risk for SGA neonates (Pastorino et al. 2019; Beetham et al. 2019; Davenport et al. 2018), with some actually reporting that vigorous physical activity may increase the risk (Legesse et al. 2020; Ehrlich et al. 2020). These discrepancies may be related to differences in exercise definition and study design. Currently, there is no strong evidence that moderate exercise during pregnancy is detrimental. Further research on maternal exercise is important and may assist in the development of recommendations for clinical practice to improve pregnancy outcomes, including in cases of FGR.
Although we found that maternal exercise mitigated the abnormal findings in fetuses and placentas in the rapamycin-induced FGR mouse model, we cannot be certain that maternal activity directly regulates placental mTOR signaling or promotes lipid utilization and energy supply to the fetuses. The placenta has the ability to adapt to intrinsic and extrinsic environmental abnormalities in order to support fetal growth (Sandovici et al. 2012; Myatt 2006). We found that, compared to controls, p-mTOR level was decreased in the DJ layer of FGR placentas at E14.5, but restored to normal levels at E18.5. In the L layer, the levels of FFA, TAG, and Cho were no different at E18.5 between the FGR and control groups, despite an increase identified at E14.5. Additionally, the increased CV expression in the L layer of FGR placentas at E14.5 was found to further increase at E18.5 under the treatment of maternal exercise. Placental junctional and labyrinth zones support intrauterine fetal growth. The junctional zone provides the main endocrine function of the placenta by generating hormones, growth factors, and cytokines while labyrinth zone transports nutrients and gases from mother to fetus (Woods et al. 2018). Previous studies have identified the junctional zone structure as being particularly affected in cases of FGR, much more so than the labyrinth zone (Tao et al. 2022; Gualdoni et al. 2021; Roberts et al. 2021). We speculate that the junctional zone of the placenta may be more sensitive to insults associated with FGR compared to the labyrinth zone, and the labyrinth zone may primarily act as an adaptive regulator to sustain fetal growth.
It is important to note that there are also some limitations in this study. First, evidence reported by Tshering S et al.(Tshering et al. 2021) showed that rapamycin can transfer to the fetal body through the placenta, and it may simultaneously restrict placental and fetal growth despite the controversial findings(Chu et al. 2008; Tshering et al. 2021; Ebrahimi-Fakhari et al. 2021). Additionally, the inhibition of placental mTOR activity is common in FGR caused by specific (like maternal malnutrition, pre-eclampsia, chemical exposures, etc.) or unknown factors. Therefore, the rapamycin-reduced FGR model may be appropriate to simulate clinical FGR appeared in pregnant women who receive organ transplantation and take sirolimus, or mimic FGR with unknown pathogenic factors. Second, although we found that mTOR signaling were changed in different anatomic zones of human and mouse placentas, from a detailed perspective, the changed molecular markers were not fully consistent between human and mouse placentas. We speculated there may exist different adaptive responsive mechanisms in FGR placentas between the two species. Moreover, despite the benefit of maternal exercise in mitigating mouse FGR, the clinical significance of maternal exercise in preventing FGR is required to be further proven.