Laboratory findings can help to delimit the diagnosis in cases with unclear or atypical features, but they can also lead to misdiagnosis. For instance, absence of vaccine responses, considered as a major criterion, arises measurement and interpretation difficulties, making it challenging to be used alone2,4,18. The need to overcome these difficulties led us to analyze the individual performance versus combinations of biomarkers for CVID identification in our cohort of patients12.
The novelty of this exploratory works lies on the use of logistic regression to develop an accurate diagnostic model for CVID. Even today, CVID diagnosis is based on exclusion criteria without any findings considered pathognomonic of the disease. Timely diagnosis and prompt and effective treatment are extremely important for patients, reducing morbidity and mortality19,20. By comparing several classifiers, we were able to determine the optimal model for the data. Overall, the tree decision model was the most consistent, with specific antibody responses and sum κ + λ showing ideal diagnostic performance. Sum κ + λ was one of the two best CVID classifiers, highlighting its potential as a diagnostic criterium for the disease and its added value to current tests.
We first validated previous studies on the diagnostic value of sBCMA17 and sum κ + λ14–16 for CVID against other PID and SID patients. Interestingly, increase in any of sBCMA and/or sum κ + λ above cut-off levels might alert of inflammatory or lymphoproliferative complications during follow-up and personalize management.
Our results may extend the understanding of CVID pathophysiology and interdependencies by condensation of the information of the clustered biomarkers. Interestingly, a strong association was found between sBCMA and sum κ + λ, two apparently different biological events. Very low sum κ + λ suggest an alteration during early bone marrow B cell ontogeny at pro-B to pre-B cell stages, whose etiology remains unclear21. By contrast, sBCMA expression is restricted to advanced B cell maturation stages towards full plasma cell (PC) differentiation. Increased sBCMA values have been related to conditions where an expansion of these cell types occur, whereas its decrease may identify severe humoral immunodeficiencies22,23. This association might suggest that alterations at early maturation stages within the bone marrow have repercussions in ulterior activation and differentiation stages. In this context, CVID typically shows slow and progressive clinical and immunological onset, eventually from SIgAD, whereby these biomarkers may represent a real-time alert sign of progression24. Although sBCMA expression is weak in pre-PC maturation stages, we observed a significant correlation between sBCMA values and smB percentage, further supporting an alteration at germinal center.
Our results should be interpreted with caution due to the limited sample size and need to be validated in a wider prospective study. However, the results were quite uniform and the ideal cut-off levels validated those previously described by other authors.
In conclusion, our exploratory study suggests that combining the measurement of specific antibody responses to immunization with sum κ + λ enhances early CVID diagnosis. This integrated approach could generate patient-specific, personalized signatures for CVID diagnosis and prognosis.