During the growth and metabolism of lactic acid bacteria, a variety of bioactive metabolites, such as short-chain fatty acids, organic acids, diacetyl, peptides, hydrogen peroxide, extracellular polysaccharides, and bacteriocins, are produced and extracellularly secreted. They play import roles in cellular signaling, and they are the bioactive metabolites that confer probiotic effects on the host [35]. This study preliminarily purified and characterized the antibacterial AF in the CFS of L. paracasei Zhang. We also mined the genome of L. paracasei Zhang for genomic regions encoding putative bacteriocins.
Normally, the concentrations of some active metabolites are too low to be detected by traditional in vitro assays [36, 37]. Therefore, it is necessary to enrich the bioactive fraction for further experiments. Herein, a two-step purification was implemented by ultrafiltration and Sephadex G-25 gel filtration chromatography, which mainly desalted the CFS and concentrated the active metabolites based on size. By testing the antibacterial activity of the ultrafiltrates, we found that the bioactivity was concentration in the 1–3 kDa fraction, which was further purified by gel filtration chromatography and subsequent analysis. In the purification process, small size metabolites like lactic acid and acetic acid would be separated from the active metabolites, as most of these interfering molecules, ions, and acid salts had a molecular size of small than 200 Da. Moreover, we also ensure the osmotic pressure of the diluted AF was in a range not interfering bacterial growth in the agar antimicrobial assays.
Our further assay on the antimicrobial spectrum of AF revealed a broad antibacterial spectrum, inhibiting both members of the Gram-positive (Staphylococcus aureus, Listeria monocytogenes, Bacillus cereus) and Gram-negative (Pseudomonas fluorescens, Pseudomonas aeruginosa, and Actinobacillus actinomycetemcomitans) bacteria. The AF exhibited the strongest inhibitory activity against S. aureus compared with other tested bacteria. S. aureus is both a food and human pathogen. As a foodborne pathogen, S. aureus is widely distributed in air, water, and different kinds of food, and can cause food poisoning by secreting enterotoxin. On the other hand, S. aureus is also widely distributed on skin surface, larynx, nasal cavity and other mucosal surfaces; it does not only cause skin infection, but also induce infective endocarditis, fasciitis, osteomyelitis, and pneumonia occasionally, posing a great threat to human health and safety [37]. Thus, the strong inhibitory activity of AF against S. aureus is of interest for it to be applied in food preservation and products like cosmetics. Another feature of AF is that it exerted no inhibitory effect on lactic acid bacteria or probiotics, which is similar to the antibacterial spectrum of other lactic acid bacteria-originated bacteriocins [38, 39]. This makes AF a desirable food biopreservative, which would not alter the endogenous and beneficial gut microbiota when applied in food.
Apart from a wide antibacterial spectrum, a suitable bacteriocin should ideally have good tolerance to heat, acid-base fluctuation, and common enzymes like proteases [40]. We found that the antibacterial activity of AF has a high stability over a wide range of temperature (40℃ to 100℃) and pH (pH 2–3 and pH 6–10). The good thermal and acid-base stability makes it a suitable biopreservative for harsh and complex industrial production processes. Additionally, the bioactivity of AF was highly resistant to digestion by a variety of common industrial use enzymes and enzymes present in animal/human body (such as trypsin, pepsin, α-amylase and protease K), except for papain, which differs from the high susceptibility of many previously characterized bacteriocins and most antibacterial peptides or bacteriocins towards enzyme inactivation [23, 38, 39, 41, 42]. Trypsin and pepsin are two of the most important digestive proteases existing in the human gastrointestinal tract, and protease K and α-amylase are often used in the food industry. The time-based kinetic analysis of papain digestion of the AF in the current study revealed that papain inactivation was a gradual process, suggesting that the nature of the antibacterial metabolite is protein or peptide. In conclusion, the good stability and strong resistance to different kinds of enzymes make AF suitable for use in food preservation and as an oral supplement against gastrointestinal pathogens [43].
In this study, several putative bacteriocin-like genes were identified in L. paracasei genome with the BAGEL 4 web server, including LESI_2163 in AOI_1, and enterocin_X_chain_beta ( Evalue = 1.88e− 09, match = 64.000% ), carnocin_CP52 ( Evalue = 1.39e− 20, match = 31.818% ), ORF13, ORF30, ORF54 and ORF56 in AOI_2. Previous studies have shown that the mature peptide of LSEI_2163 was a class IId bacteriocin that exhibited antimicrobial activity against some lactobacilli and several Listeria species [44]. The sequence of LSEI_2163 was found to be 100% identical to those sequences present in several strains of L. paracasei, including ATCC 334 (accession number, CP000423.1), TD 062 (accession number, CP044361.1), and TCS (accession number, CP038153.1). Enterocin X_chain_beta, a class IIc bacteriocin, belongs to the Lactococcus protein-like family, and has 50.98% homology with Enterocin X from Enterococcus faecium KU-B5. Enterocin X is a heat-resistant dipeptide bacteriocin, contains non-thiopeptides and its full antibacterial activity requires the interaction of two complementary peptides [45]. BLASTN analysis showed that the amino acid sequence was 100% identical to that of L. paracasei (CP032637.1). Carnocin_CP52 is homologous to carnobacteriocin B2, which is the first bacteriocin identified from a strain of C. piscicola isolated from a dairy product and identified as class II bacteriocin [46]. Blast results by UniRef90 revealed that ORF13 belongs to Lactococcin-like family and contains ggmotif, and ORF30, ORF54 and ORF56 are class II bacteriocins containing double-glycine leader peptide. As is known to all, cell density-dependent gene expression in bacteria exists widely and is mediated by extracellular communication molecules. Previous studies have found that Gram-positive bacteria usually perceive population density through post-translational processing of peptide pheromones [47]. The Class II bacteriocins are usually produced as propeptides, which contain a characteristic amino-terminal leader sequence called a double-glycine leader sequence [48]. Three components involve in the regulation of class II bacteriocin production: an inducible peptide, also known as a pheromone, and a two-component regulatory system [49]. Similar to the bacteriocin peptides, the inducing peptide is cationic, synthesized as a propeptide with a double-glycine leader sequence, which is cleaved during transportation. The two-component system includes a membrane-bound histidine protein kinase that plays as an environmental sensor, and a cytoplasmic response regulator that is a DNA-binding protein responsible for the activation of the transcription of its target genes. After secretion, the inducing peptide is subsequently sensed by the dedicated two-component system, thereby inducing the transcription of the operons involved in bacteriocin production [47]. As we know, functional bacterial gene clusters for producing extracellular cationic peptide-bacteriocins are usually organized as operons that comprise a complete sets of genes for production until externalization of the bacteriocin, including at least four gene components: bacteriocin structural gene, specific immune protein gene, ABC transporter gene, and its accessory protein gene [50]. Therefore, based on the predicted gene function, it is likely that AOI_02 but AOI_01 was functional in biosynthesizing bacteriocins that are responsible for the seen antibacterial activity of L. paracasei Zhang subjected to the growth environment and quorum sensing activity. What’s more, amino acid sequence alignment results showed that all of ORF13, ORF30, ORF54, and ORF56 had lower similarity with the reported bacteriocins of other strains of L. paracasei, including L. paracasei ZFM54 [23], L. paracasei LS-6 [51], L. paracasei HD1-7 [52], indicating the most possibility of production of novel bacteriocins by L. paracasei Zhang.
Apart from the conventional use of bacteriocin as food preservative, it has been proposed to expand the applications of bacteriocins from food to health. For example, nisin has shown nisin a cytotoxic effect on SW480 cancer cell line, inducing apoptosis by increasing the ratio of bax/bcl-2 on both mRNA and protein levels [53]. Bacteriocins have also been proposed as potential anti-cancer agents due to their selective action against cancer cells based on distinctive cell membrance differences between healthy and cancer cells. Moreover, antibacterial metabolites, including extracellular polysaccharides, bacteriocins and antimicrobial peptides, have been found to exert beneficially regulate the gut microbiota composition, improve host immune response, and enhancing intestinal barrier function. For example, a study found that adding AMP Gal-13 to the diet of broilers could improve the intestinal digestive capacity, antioxidant activity, and immune function of broilers, ultimately promoting the growth of broilers [54]. These active metabolites can stimulate tissue development and affect the nutritional level and physiological function of the body. Another study found that adding nisin into the diet of broilers could reduce potential jejunal and cecal pathogens, such as Clostridium perfringens and Enterobacteriaceae, and substantially suppress jejunal bacterial fermentation [55]. The addition of nisin and Chinese gallnut to the diet of carp substantially remodulated the intestinal microbiota, suppressing amoeba and enhancing Bacteroides [56].
The L. paracasei Zhang strain has shown multiple probiotic functions in animal and human intervention trials, including the enhancement of antioxidation and anti-lipid peroxidation effects [26], stimulating cellular and humoral immunity and tumor immunity [27], improving blood lipids and liver lipid metabolism [28], preventing type Ⅱ diabetes, protecting liver and preventing liver injury [29], and regulate the gut microbiota via increasing the beneficial microbes, while reducing potential pathogens [26]. In this study, we only confirmed that the CFS of L. casei Zhang contained antibacterial metabolites, probably class II bacteriocins, speculated based on genomics prediction, the molecular size and physico-chemical properties (acid-base, thermos-, and enzyme tolerance) of the bioactivity. Whether these metabolite(s) and/or bacteriocin serve other biological functions in vitro and in vivo remain to be further explored. Future studies should also focus on large-scale purification and identification of the bioactive metabolites, exploring their effectiveness in food preservation and suppression of gastrointestinal infection by pathogens, and elucidating the mechanism of the bioactivity.
From these characteristics, it can be concluded that the active substance in AF is a novel antibacterial metabolite. It is believable that the two outstanding advantages will promote and broaden its application in foods preservation and pathogen infection.