In the present study, we investigated CRP with the underlying cascade of acute-phase cytokine levels of IL-1, IL-6 family and TNF-α cytokines with associated soluble receptors at time of diagnosis in relation to 5-year DSS in a cohort of 144 HNSCC patients. High levels of CRP predicted impaired prognosis. Regarding the IL-6 family, high values of IL-6 and IL-31, along with the associated receptors s-IL-6Rα and s-gp130, predicted worse DSS among HPV(─) patients. From the IL-1 family molecules, IL-1RA, but not IL-33Rα/ST2 also predicted DSS with adjustment by tumor HPV status. The IL-6/IL-31/IL-1RA predictions were primarily associated to tumor extent and smoking history. With tumor extent and smoking history adjustment the soluble receptors IL-6Rα, gp130 and IL-33Rα/ST2 still predicted survival.
High CRP and IL-6 levels [15, 22–29] are associated with an adverse prognosis in cancer, HNSCC included. We have currently confirmed this together with a dose-response relationship. IL-6 is a member of the IL-6 cytokine family; i.e. several cytokines with common receptor characteristics [7, 35]. IL-31, a member of the IL-6 family, also predicted 5-year DSS. The other investigated IL-6 family cytokines i.e. IL-27, OSM and CNTF, did not generally predict 5- year DSS. As IL-6Rα predicted survival among the HPV(─) tumor patients activation of both the classical and trans intracellular pathway seem to be associated with an increased HNSCC-caused mortality. On the other hand, gp130 is regarded as an inhibitory system [42], but also showed that increased concentrations were associated with decreased 5-year DSS.
Other cytokines beside IL-6 family members, are also viewed as secondary drivers of the APC [7], and for this reason we also included the IL-1 family mediators IL-1β, IL-1RA, IL-33Rα and TNF-α. IL-33 was not included because it is expressed by the cancer cells and we therefore regard local release as more important than distant release [43, 44]. Unfortunately, IL-1β was not measurable from plasma. We found that high IL-1RA predicted decreased 5-year DSS. We have also determined a trend towards survival prediction to the worse by increased TNF-α. Thus, we have shown that the pro-inflammatory cytokine cascade from CRP to TNF-α was associated with HNSCC prognosis.
Generally, we have demonstrated that examples of both stimulating and inhibiting factors of the inflammatory system, if elevated at diagnosis, predict worse prognosis. This aligns with the idea that the inflammatory system exhibits multifaceted interactions with HNSCC tumors, and it is probably the net effect that matters. To provide a clearer overview, we performed factor analyses, resulting in two factors, both of which predicted survival by primary Kaplan-Meier analyses. This suggest that two fundamentally different factors contribute to these predictions.
Levels of these inflammatory markers can also be influenced by inflamm-aging, i.e. a smoldering pro-inflammatory phenotype that can be a part of the aging process [45]. Therefore, we adjusted for the age of the patients. This adjustment did not alter the survival prediction. Disease extent, as measured by the TN stage, predict HNSCC survival [46]. Smoking is a part of HNSCC biology, as well as an inflammatory driver [47] and tied to worse survival [48]. We have therefore studied smoking level and TN stage as covariates in Cox regression analyses of the cytokine survival predictions. The 5-year DSS cytokine predictions were mostly statistically secondary to a combination of TNM stage and smoking history. On the other hand, higher levels of the studied soluble IL receptors also predicted survival even after adjusting for age, gender, TN stage and smoking history. These present findings furthermore underline the importance of trans IL-6R caused activation as an important part of HNSCC tumor biology.
The present study has included cancers with fundamentally different causes; i.e. tobacco and smoking versus HPV [6]. These diseases have many common properties, but differ fundamentally as to molecular biology [5] and prognosis [49]. The association between inflammation and HNSCC is closer regarding HPV(─) than HPV(+) tumor patients. Due to the excellent prognosis of HPV(+) patients, however, this study has a low sensitivity of investigations based on survival among such patients. This study supports that these phenotypic inflammation characteristics reflect different underlying drivers, as similarly observed in other comparable phenomena [7].
The present observations show that the HNSCC cytokine/cytokine receptor levels likely reflect separate aspects of the cancer-associated systemic acute-phase cytokine response with one dimension associated with IL-6, IL-31 and IL-1RA, whereas another dimension is associated to IL-6Rα, gp130 levels and IL-33Rα/ST2 levels. A potential explanation may be that malignant tumors have a higher overall cellular turnover compared to their more benign counterparts [50] with consequently more receptor shedding. Increased number of immune cells in to HNSCC blood have also been shown to signal worse DSS [51], and increased number of soluble cytokine receptors could be related to these findings.
IL-1RA is an acute-phase marker and high levels have previously been associated with aggressive disease and/or unfavorable prognosis in various malignancies, including T-cell lymphoma [52], sarcoma [53], colorectal cancer [54, 55] and thyroid cancer [56]. Our studies are the first, to our knowledge, suggesting that this is also true in HNSCC.
We have included only patients primarily treated with curative intent. Including newly diagnosed palliative patients would have moved especially the HPV(─) patient group to have included additional patients with substantial inflammation present at diagnosis. Our results thus apply more to the HNSCC disease before end-stage of the disease.
The DSS risk is tied to the IL-6 values dose-dependent. We have therefore studied the actual IL-6 values generated by ROC analysis. A cut-off at 2.5 pg/ml provide both and sensitivity and specificity of more than 70% of risk to succumb to disease-specific death. Such information could be used to personalize the treatment, particularly to maximize treatment for clinically limited disease cases. In addition, an individualized analysis, excluding patients with other explanatory causes for high IL-6 values, could improve this prognostic factor.
Another question is that only one blood sample has been drawn from each patient. The half-life of the studied cytokines in blood is unknown, and the blood cytokine concentration may vary substantially over time. However, we have previously conducted studies, with renal carcinoma as experimental system, that have demonstrated the cytokines levels in blood to be surprisingly stable [57] making this methodical problem less.
The fact that the immune system seems to be important for patient prognosis encourages further explorations of immune-modulating treatments for HNSCC patients [58]. The present results suggest targeting the general inflammatory dimension of the HNSCC disease. Additional research into the interactions between carcinomas and the immune system is needed.
To conclude, increased IL-6, IL-31, IL-1RA, IL-6Rα and gp130 blood levels predicted worse HNSCC 5-year DSS. We suggest that the cytokines reflect one HNSCC inflammatory dimension, whereas soluble IL-33Rα/ST2, IL-1RA, gp130 and IL-6Rα represent separate HNSCC inflammatory dimension. The soluble cytokine receptors we have studied in particular warrant further investigation in HNSCC patients. The strong association between IL-6 values and DSS invites clinical use of this relation.