Physical characterization of BPs
Bioplastics (BPs) with S. edule starch (SSE), P. vulgaris starch (SPV), and a combination of both starch sources (SSE-SPV) obtained by the plate casting method formed matrices with manageable, continuous, and uniform properties (Table 2). The BPs with SSE presented aspects of manageability, continuity, and uniformity from the 6% w/v concentration. In comparison, the BPs made with SPV and SSE-SPV combinations presented these attributes from concentrations of 5% w/v. The obtainment of BPs by the plate casting method depends on the composition of the filmogenic solution, which is made up of SSE and SPV starch in both individual and binary combinations. When it is in excess water and undergoes a heat treatment (90º C), this polymer gelatinizes to form BPs. In this process, the amylose and amylopectin chains form a colloidal network [29]. Another factor observed as determining was the concentration of glycerol, which interacts intermolecularly with starch and reduces hydrogen bonds between amylose and amylopectin. This action that reduces fragility and improves the flexibility and extension of BPs [30]. During pouring, the dispersion of the filmogenic solution acquires the shape of the mold. Likewise, the formation of BPs depends on the time and temperature of solvent evaporation; in this last stage, the intermolecular interactions between the polymer chains are improved and form an adequate microstructure of the BP. However, sufficient time must be considered to evaporate the solvent and prevent the adhesion of the BP to the mold [30].
As shown in Table 2, the opacity of the BPs made with SSE is in the range of 1.39 to 1.67, greater than that of SPV (0.38 to 0.78) and those generated with the SSE-SPV combinations (0.146 to 0.78). 0.44). Opacity is a key point in consumer acceptance. Low values of this parameter indicate the transparency of the BPs; therefore, the BPs generated with starch mixtures can be used in the development of packaging that allows the content of the product to be displayed. The opacity values reported in this work are similar to those found in BPs with potato, corn, wheat, and rice starch at concentrations of 5 and 1.5 wt% of glycerol, with 93.5 wt% of water [31]. Likewise, one of the advantages of starch-based BPs is their excellent barrier property against oxygen due to the formation of the ordered and compact matrix of starch molecules [32].
Regarding the swelling capacity of BPs, values between 4.26 and 10.98% are reported in this work. These values are related to the high hydrophilic capacity of starch and glycerol. This characteristic that allows the formation of hydrogen bonds and, therefore, increases water retention within the polymer matrix. This parameter increases the relative humidity of the BPs and favors ideal conditions for the development of microorganisms. Therefore, the swelling capacity of BPs is related to their biodegradability and potential application in food packaging.
In the BPs obtained with the binary combinations (SSE-SPV), the solubility values are between 25.96–37.89% w/v, with significant differences (p < 0.05). The highest solubility values were observed at concentrations higher than 6% w/v of starch. These values indicate their affinity they have for water, so they can dissolve quickly, causing an increase in the diffusion of the components and favoring the biodegradation of the material [32].
BPs with adequate mechanical properties are required to maintain the integrity of BPs during food transportation, handling, and storage. Dong et al. [22] define hardness as the force per unit area for fracture to occur. In this work, it was observed that BPs made with SSE present hardness values in a range of 41.50 and 59.25 gf without significant differences between the treatments (p > 0.05). In BPs made with SPV, this parameter ranges between 579.00 and 2102 gf and increases with the starch concentration. This trend is observed with the BPs made from the starch mixtures (SSE-SPV), which show hardness values between 455.20 and 1972.00 gf, similar to those obtained with SPV. In the same way, it is observed that the elasticity index in the BPs made with SSE starch is between 0.77 and 1.06 without significant differences between treatments (p > 0.05), while the BPs made with starch mixtures (SSE-SPV) show an elasticity index higher than 0.86. This value is greater than the value of SPV BPs (Table 3). The mechanical properties of starch-based BPs depend on the proportion of amylose and amylopectin [29]. In the starch of various varieties of P. vulgaris, a concentration of 44.97 to 51.11% of amylose has been reported [12], while in chayote starch, a concentration of 26.3% is reported [33]. Based on this information, it is inferred that the difference in the concentration of amylose could be related to the hardness of the films. According to a study carried out on BPs of sweet potato starch (Ipomoea batatas) with different amylose content (21.84–26.34%), starch granules with a more significant amount of amylose molecules form a more rigid polymer matrix per unit of area [32]. This statement coincides with the hardness values of the BPs developed from SPV, SSE, and the BPs formulated with the starch mixtures prepared in the present work.
Based on the accumulated evidence and to evaluate the effect of relative humidity (RH) on elongation, BPs made with the combination of SSE-SPV starch in the different concentrations studied in this work were chosen and stored under controlled conditions of 11.30, 57.60 and 90.30% RH.
In BPs stored at 11.30% RH, the percentage of elongation peaked in BPs coded as 6% SSE-SPV with significant differences between treatments (p < 0.05), and it is even higher in 7 and 9% SSE-SPV BPs (Fig. 1). These results coincide with what Lauer and Smith [34] reported, who indicate that a high percentage of amylose tends to form more rigid films and is reflected in reduced elongation of the BPs.
In the storage conditions of 57.60% RH, the maximum elongation value was reached from the concentration of 6% of SSE-SPV. This parameter is similar to that reported in BPs made with 4% w/w of chayotextle starch or potato starch, 0.5% w/w of cellulose, and 2% w/w of glycerol [35]. In Fig. 1, it is generally observed that the elongation percentage is reduced when RH is increased, which is attributed to the fact that an increase in RH around the BPs also increases their water content. In other words, when the BP is wet or absorbs too much moisture from the environment, molecular mobility is promoted in the polymer network, resulting in swelling of the film, which can spontaneously give way to the deformation and partial solubilization of the BP matrix, as well as the hydrolysis of unstable bonds of the polymer [31]. These characteristics could help explain the biodegradability of the BPs analyzed in this study.
Derived from the hydrophilic capacity of BPs made from SSE and SPV starch and the effect of RH on the elongation percentage, its application to produce primary packaging containing low-humidity foods stored in dry environments can be considered. Based on the physical characteristics of the BPs analyzed in this work and to study their biodegradation, the BPs made with the 6% SSE-SPV mixture were selected.
Biodegradability
Three different methodologies were used during the biodegradation tests of the selected BP: in vitro, over-soil, and soil burial, to compare the biodegradation capacity between two different materials: the BP proposed in the present work and a commercial sample of an oxyplastic. Figure 2 shows the images obtained during the evaluation of the biodegradation process at different times. In the in vitro systems (Fig. 2A), bacterial colonies were formed in the systems with BP from day 5 to day 55. However, the formation of bacterial colonies was not observed in the oxy-plastic samples. This may be due to the composition of BP, made up of starch, an important source of bioavailable carbon for microorganisms. Likewise, it was observed that the humidity of the soil extract agar contributed to the swelling of the BP, and, therefore, to its bioavailability to microbial attack. The cause of this, as mentioned above, is that when the BP absorbs too much water, molecular mobility is promoted in the polymeric network, generating its deformation. This meant that the bioplastic sample could not be removed from the petri dish because it was observed to have fractures. On the other hand, the oxo-plastic did not present apparent changes due to the effect of humidity.
During the evaluation of BP biodegradation in the over-soil systems (Fig. 2B), microbial colonization on the BP was observed from day 15 and with the passage of time it was more visible until day 90. This could be observed by the change in color from a light tone to a very dark one, where the microbial colonization was completely visible. Conversely, the oxo-plastic resisted the microbial attack because, in the first 30 days, microbial colonization was not visible. However, by day 45, microbial growth was observed on the surface of the oxo-plastic, which increased without covering its total surface. During biodegradation, the BP changed its initial shape until it formed a cylindrical structure. This was probably due to low humidity and the structural changes of the BP because of the microbial attack.
Finally, during biodegradation in soil burial systems (Fig. 2C), microbial colonization on the BP was observed from day 3. Starting on day 9, irregular edges and a change in color in the physical appearance of the BP were observed. On day 15, the partial degradation of the BP was visualized, and fragments of the BP were obtained during the recovery of the sample from the soil burial systems. For its part, the oxo-plastic did not present structural changes during the total time of the experiment; only microbial colonization was observed on its surface.
During a BP biodegradation process, the main factors that determine the speed of this process are temperature, humidity, the enzymatic activity of the microorganisms, and the composition of the soil, as has been reported in similar studies [36] [37].
Microscopic analysis of biodegradation
The samples obtained at different times of the biodegradation processes in the over-soil and soil burial systems were analyzed by scanning electron microscopy (Fig. 4) using 300 and 1000X. In the BP samples obtained from the over-soil biodegradation systems, hyphae and spores were observed during the first 15 days (OS-15). As time went by, the presence of spores (OS-60) increased, which colonized the surface of the BP. These observations are consistent with other works, where the same structures are observed and described, which were identified as fungal spores [38] [39].
On the other hand, during the biodegradation process of BP in the soil burial system, the presence of fractures was observed at the beginning of biodegradation (SB-03), while the presence of bacteria was observed on day 9 (SB-09), which increased until the bacteria colonized the entire surface (SB-18). The colonization of BP made mainly of starch has been previously observed by Ruggero et al.[40].
The difference in the colonization of the BP surface between the different biodegradation treatments could be associated with humidity, temperature, and enzymatic microorganism activity, as previously mentioned [36] [37].
In the over-soil systems, only one of the faces of the BP was in contact with the soil surface. Therefore, the relative humidity was lower than the soil burial system, so fungal growth was favored under these conditions. On the other hand, there was a greater effect on biodegradation in the soil burial systems, which is attributed to the fact that both surfaces of the BP remained in contact with the two layers of the soil and, therefore, the moisture content was larger, a factor that favored the biodegradation of BP mainly due to bacterial action. As observed in the images obtained by SEM (SB-09 and SB-18).
Evaluation of the Biodegradation of the BP
During the experiments, the change in the mass of the BP was an important parameter that allowed us to compare the biodegradation process in the different treatments used in this work. The weight variation allowed us to determine the percentage of biodegradation, the specific biodegradation rate for each system, and the biodegradation parameters for the first and second-order kinetic models (Table 4). According to the results obtained from the changes in weight of the BP, the highest percentage of biodegradation was observed in the soil burial system (91.02%), followed by the in vitro system (71.97%), and the lowest percentage (57.89%) was observed when over-soil biodegradation was simulated. The BP was degraded due to its starch-rich composition, with starch being a hydrophilic molecule that is completely biodegradable [9]. Consisting mainly of glucose, it is a monosaccharide easily metabolized by microorganisms as a carbon and energy source. It is to be oxidized until total mineralization, that is, to be transformed into CO2 and water.
In determining the calculation of the specific biodegradation rate, a relationship was observed with the percentage of biodegradation of BP. The highest rate was 7.6854 mg BP/day, with a biodegradation percentage of 91.02% in the burial systems; this indicated that the biodegradation rate was three times higher than the other evaluated systems. Therefore, it can be said that BP degraded in greater proportion and with greater speed in the soil burial system compared to the other two systems evaluated in the present work.
Determining the kinetic parameters for BP biodegradation was evaluated by applying of first- and second-order kinetic models previously reported by Santonja-Blasco [26]. The results of adjusting the experimental data of BP biodegradation in the different in vitro treatments, over-soil, and soil burial, demonstrated a greater adjustment to the first-order kinetic model according to the correlation coefficient obtained (Table 4). Considering the quality of the adjustment of the first-order model in the three systems, the biodegradation rate coefficients were 0.1143, 0.0905, and 0.6873 days− 1 for the in vitro, over-soil, and underground biodegradation systems, respectively. The results obtained in the present work are consistent with those reported by Gil-Castell et al. [41], where the experimental data of the biological degradation process of the biofilm based on polylactic acid obtained from corn were adjusted to a first-order kinetic model.
In a biodegradation study of polylactic acid-based BP presented by Santoja-Blasco et al. [26], a k with a value of 7.12x10-4 days− 1 was obtained. This value of k is lower than the results obtained in the different experiments carried out in the present work.