The Effect of Cessation of Drinking Water Fluoridation on Dental Restorations and Crowns in Children Aged 3-5 Years in Israel – A Retrospective Study

doi:10.21203/rs.3.rs-3801276/v1

Download PDF

Research Article

The Effect of Cessation of Drinking Water Fluoridation on Dental Restorations and Crowns in Children Aged 3-5 Years in Israel – A Retrospective Study

https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-3801276/v1

This work is licensed under a CC BY 4.0 License

Journal Publication

published 20 Sep, 2024

Read the published version in Israel Journal of Health Policy Research →

You are reading this latest preprint version

Background: Community water fluoridation (CWF) began in the 1945 as a public health measure to prevent and control caries and was implemented in Israel in 1981. CWF reduced caries significantly, but in 2014, the Ministry of Health decided to stop CWF in Israel.

The aim of our study was to examine the effect of fluoridation cessation on the dental health of children aged 3-5, treated in "Assuta Tel Aviv" dental clinics, under general anesthesia or deep sedation.

Methods: The computerized Maccabi-Dent database provided data for this retrospective study. Records from the years 2014-2019 including treatment codes for procedures relevant to the study, the number of stainless-steel crowns and restorations of all types were examined. Kruskal-Wallis test was performed to compare the results from before and after fluoridation cessation.

Results: A statistically significant increase in the mean number of treatments in the years after fluoridation cessation (P<0.05) was found. There was approximately a two-fold increase in the number of all treatments for all ages.

Conclusion: The results of the study emphasize the advantages of water fluoridation and are further proof of need to restore community water fluoridation in Israel.

Community Water Fluoridation

Public Health

General Anesthesia

Health Policy

Oral diseases:

Microbial diseases of the oral cavity affect the hard (caries) and soft tissues (periodontal diseases). Periodontitis is a progressive and chronic disease impacting the tooth supporting structures and may eventually lead to tooth loss [1].

Dental caries in permanent teeth is the most common health condition worldwide according to Global Burden of Disease 2019 [2]. Its earliest detectable stage is the appearance of a white spot on the tooth, which may later cavitate to the extent that the tooth is lost. It may cause pain, difficulty eating, a reduction in life quality, and in severe cases, hospitalization. This multifactorial disease, is due to an imbalance between dietary sugars, the dental biofilm, and the host, within the oral environment, causing de-mineralization of tooth enamel [3]. Some periods in life are more prone to this imbalance, such as the stage of primary and mixed dentition [4]. Prevention of the disease by using fluoride, removing dental biofilm and reducing sugar intake [3], is preferable but once a lesion is cavitated, the first stage of treatment is removal of the affected tooth material and placing a restoration. When too much tooth structure has been lost due to caries to retain a restoration a crown may be required [5], in pedodontics prefabricated stainless steel crowns are used [6].

Fluoride and its effect on enamel:

Fluoride is a naturally existing anion found in minerals, rocks, and soil. All water sources contain fluoride, and levels depend on the specific geographical conditions. Fluoride concentration in rivers, streams, or wells is usually below 0.5 mg/l [7].
There is a strong affinity between fluoride and biological apatite (the main mineral component of teeth). The hydroxyl component of calcium hydroxyapatite of tooth enamel is easily replaced by fluoride, becoming fluorapatite, which is stronger and more chemically stable. Fluoride in dental plaque and saliva, inhibits demineralization and promotes remineralization of initial caries lesions [8], interferes with bacterial glycolysis, and at higher concentrations fluoride is bacteriocidic.

Water fluoridation:

Fluoride can be used to prevent caries in 3 ways: (1) community-based – provision of fluoridated water, salt, and milk, (2) professional administration of fluoride varnish and gels in the dental clinic, (3) self-administered – using toothpastes and mouthwashes [7].
Community water fluoridation (CWF) has been used as a public health measure to prevent and control caries since 1945, following the epidemiological studies of H. Trendley Dean et al. (1942) [9], which found the optimal level of 1 mg/l of fluoride that provides maximum protection against caries, with minimal dental fluorosis.

CWF involves adjusting the amount of fluoride in water to achieve optimal prevention of dental caries. The CWF fluoride concentration typically ranges between 0.5-1.1 mg/l. In many countries CWF is a core component of oral health policy [10].

An English study on the effect of water fluoridation (Roberts et al. 2022) [11] found that in 5-year-old children, the prevalence of dental caries was 6% lower in areas with 0.7 m/l of water fluoride than areas where concentrations were below 0.1 mg/l. The study also showed a 59% decrease in hospitalizations due to dental caries in individuals aged 0-19 years when fluoride levels were higher.
A study across 10 countries performed by Rugg-Gunn and Do in 2012 [12] on individuals aged between 3-44 years, found a 30-59% reduction of caries in the primary dentition, and a 40-49% reduction in the permanent dentition in areas with fluoridated water.

Following the recommendation of WHO, CWF began in Israel in 1981, and the optimal fluoride concentration ranged between 0.7-1.2 PPM, depending on local temperature and water consumption. At this time, about 90% of the children suffered from tooth decay, and dental public services were limited [13]. From 2002 CWF became mandatory, and 75% of the population received fluoridated water [14]. Even though CWF in Israel significantly helped to reduce dental caries – 56.4% of children were free of caries in fluoridated areas and 40.6% were free of caries in non-fluoridated areas [15], the Israeli Ministry of Health stopped CWF in Israel in 2014 .

A 2022 study investigated the effect of fluoridation cessation in Israel (Tobias et al.)[13]. The study examined children aged 3-12 in geographical areas where water fluoridation ceased, and used the populations of areas that were never optimally fluoridated as a control group. The number of dental treatments in 2014-2015 did not change with age. However, between 2016 and 2019, the number of treatments increased with age (after fluoridation cessation) and almost doubled. Furthermore, the areas with optimal fluoride levels had less treatments than those with partial or no fluoridation.

Dental treatment coverage in Israel:

In 1994, the National Health Insurance Law made the State of Israel responsible for the provision of health care to all citizens. Healthcare is provided by four Health Maintenance Organizations (HMOs). However, dental treatments were not included in the initial government covered healthcare services [16]. Nowadays in Israel, dental care until age18 years old is given free of charge (preventative treatments such as dental examinations), or with minimal charge (restorative treatments such as restorations, stainless-steel crowns, and treatments under general anesthesia for children 5 years and younger), following the dental reform in 2010 which was initiated by Health Minister Yaakov Litzman [17].
From a study conducted in 2016 (Natapov et al.) [16], it seemed that the level of dental disease remained constant after the reform, yet an increase in the treatment component was observed, following the reform.

Dental treatments given under general anesthesia:

Most children can be treated adequately using behavioral techniques. However, some children require general anesthesia e.g., very young children, or those suffering from physical, mental, cognitive, or emotional immaturity or disability, or severe anxiety. General anesthesia is a controlled state of unconsciousness in which protective reflexes are lost. One of its greatest advantages is the fact that general anesthesia does not require cooperation [18].

"Maccabi-Dent":
"Maccabi" is the second largest HMO in Israel with 2.3 million patients. "Maccabi-Dent" is the HMO's dental clinic, and has 53 clinics and 1100 dentists [19]. In the specialist clinic "Assuta Tel Aviv", many treatments are performed under general anesthesia or deep sedation, due to complicated dental status, or the reasons mentioned above. Patients from all over the country are receiving dental treatment in "Assuta", and therefore represent a sample of the entire population.
Our study used data from treatments performed on children aged 3-5 at "Assuta Tel Aviv" between 2014-2019.

We hypothesized that after the cessation of water fluoridation, there would be a greater need for dental treatments due to an increase in the prevalence and severity of dental caries. We aimed to examine the effects of cessation of water fluoridation on the dental health of children aged 3-5.

The present study was approved by the Institutional Review Board (IRB) MHS 0157-20 The Helsinki committee of Macabi Healthcare services.
This retrospective study used data of children aged 3 to 5 years from the computerized data base of "Maccabi-Dent", between 2014-2019. The database included information regarding the number of treatments performed on children aged 3 to 12, from all over the country, treated at "Maccabi-Dent" clinics. Treatments included extractions, root canal treatments, prefabricated crowns, amalgam restorations, composite restorations and more. The data was recorded as codes, each code representing a different treatment, and we only extracted codes relevant to the current study - the number of stainless-steel crowns and the number of restorations of all types (amalgam and composite resin restorations on all surfaces), performed at "Assuta Tel Aviv" branch in Ramat Hayail. The rationale for selection of these particular treatments will be outlined in the discussion.

We compared the treatments by year - from 2014 to 2019 and by age 3 to 5. Additionally, a comparison between the years where fluoridated water was present (2014-2015) and the years without fluoridated water (2016-2019) was made.

Statistical methods:

In order to compare the number of treatments before and after CWF cessation for all age groups, a Kruskal-Wallis test (a non-parametric test which examines whether independent populations came from the same source) was performed. The Kruskal-Wallis test can only be performed when the variables between the two populations being compared are not significantly different, in this study there were relatively few parameters to compare. A two tailed test was also performed, alpha= 0.05. Python software version 3.7 was used.

Descriptive data:

The total number of treatments performed between 2014-2019 in children aged 3-5 was 34,606 crowns and 44,358 restorations, with means of 1922 ±1051 crowns and 2464 ±942 restorations over this time. The number of treatments per year increased between 2014 and 2019 (see table 1).

Figure 1 shows the number of treatments performed by age and by year. An upward trend in all age groups, especially regarding the number of crowns can be seen. Most treatments doubled over the years, and the increase in 4-year-olds was the greatest. More restorations than crowns were performed in 3-year-olds, whereas this trend was reversed in 4-year-olds. 5-year-olds had the lowest number of treatments.
In 2014-2015 the patients had been drinking fluoridated water whereas those treated between 2016-2019 were drinking un-fluoridated water. With fluoride 6709 crowns and 9677 restorations were performed with means of 1118 ±368, and 1612 ±414 respectively. Without fluoride, 27,897 crowns and 34,681 restorations were performed, with means of 2324 ±1057, 2890 ±837 respectively.
The number of restored surfaces per tooth was also compared. The number of treated surfaces is an indication of disease severity. As seen in figures 2-4, there were more treatments on more than one surface, and the rate of increase of multi-surface restorations was greater than the rate of increase of single surface treatments. The greatest increase was in 4-year-olds. Figure 3 shows the statistically significant difference between the number of restorations performed on one or more tooth surfaces. 3-year-olds had the most one surface restorations and 5-year-olds had the least.

Table 1: Total treatments per year

Year	Total number of crowns	Total number of restorations
2014	3121	4450
2015	3588	5227
2016	4585	7533
2017	5769	8274
2018	7536	9085
2019	10007	9789

Analytic data:
Dependent variables were the number of treatments i.e., crowns and restorations. Independent variables were age, fluoridated (2014-2015) vs. non fluoridated water (2016-2019) and year. Figure 5 shows the results of the Kruskal Wallis test, there were significantly more treatments in the years where the water was un-fluoridated that when there was fluoride in the water (p<0.05).
Figure 6 shows the mean number of treatments with and without fluoride by age. The greatest difference was in 3-year-olds before and after fluoridation cessation, especially in restorations. The Difference exists in all age groups, and the mean number of treatments almost doubled in all age groups.

The purpose of the current study was to examine the influence of water fluoridation cessation in Israel on the dental health of children aged 3-5. We collected computerized treatment records from 2014-2019 from "Assuta Tel Aviv", a specialist dental clinics, where treatments are performed under general anesthesia or deep sedation, belonging to "Maccabi" HMO. Young children usually require deep sedation or general anesthesia [20]. Due to the fact that the specialists at "Assuta Tel Aviv" receive patients from all over the country, our study included a sample of the entire population.

We examined standard treatment for teeth with carious lesions - Restorations for smaller lesions and stainless-steel crowns for situations when much of the tooth material was lost due to extensive caries [5]. An increase in the total number of treatments or in the proportion of crowns indicates whether there has been a decline in dental health and the severity of the decline.

We noted a correlation between the number of treatments performed and fluoridation cessation, which is reflected by an almost 2-fold increase in the number of treatments over the years, both restorations and crowns.
When comparing treatments performed in different age groups, there was an upward trend at all ages, and a statistically significant difference between the mean number of treatments performed before (2014-2015) and after the cessation of fluoridation (2016-2019). It is important to note that, when comparing the un-fluoridated and fluoridated fluoride years, we used the mean results per year because there were 2 years of fluoridation and 4 un-fluoridated years.
Canadian studies by Mclaren in 2017 and 2021 [21,22] support the findings of the current investigation. The 2021 study examined the effect of fluoridation cessation in children aged 7-8 years in Calgary, where fluoridation ceased in 2011 (i.e., the children were not exposed to fluoridated water), and used Edmonton, a fluoridated city, for comparison. The prevalence of caries was significantly higher without fluoride and worsened over time. The authors concluded that fluoridation cessation had a negative effect on the dental health of the children. The 2017 study showed a smaller increase in the prevalence of caries. It is important to note that initially, the proportion of the children in Calgary with caries was lower than in Edmonton. The amount of decay in primary teeth in Calgary began to rise by 2010, and accelerated after CWF cessation in 2011 [23].

Our data showed the lowest number of treatments in 5-year-olds. This may be due to children being treated in general clinics, without the need for general anesthesia or deep sedation. Initially, there were more restorations than crowns, which equalized in 2019. Considering when fluoridation was stopped, those aged 5 in 2019 were not exposed to CWF, whereas 5-year-olds born in 2015 were exposed to fluoridated water for at least 4 years. Similarly, 5-year-olds in 2018, had some exposure to fluoride, and the sharper increase in treatment numbers started here. Taken together it seems that the number of treatments equalized because the more severe caries lesions needed crowns, perhaps due to lack of exposure to fluoridated water from birth and before eruption.
Cohort studies (Singh and Spencer 2004, Singh et al. 2007) [24,25] found that the pre-eruptive effect of fluoridated water is important for the prevention of caries and is of great significance during the first years of life, especially in pits and fissures of permanent teeth – since topical fluoride does not reach these areas. The effect is maximal when the exposure continues post eruption.
A 9 year cross-sectional study (D.H. Levy et al. 2023) [26] conducted in Israel examined the association between water fluoridation cessation and the dental reform in Israel in young adults.
The dental needs between subjects born in and before 1994 were less than those born in and after 1996. The researchers assumed that these differences were due to complete development of the permanent dentition without fluoride exposure in those born in and before 1994. In contrast, subjects born in or after 1996 were exposed to fluoride at a critical age in teeth development (0-6 years). This emphasizes the pre and post eruptive effects of fluoride. The study concluded that water fluoridation was significantly associated with a decrease in the need for caries related treatment.

There were more restorations than crowns in 3-year-olds, similarly there were more one surface treatments than multi-surface in this age group. This may reflect the natural progression of caries, that younger individuals had less severe lesions. In those aged 4-5 years there was a greater increase in restorations performed on more than one tooth surface. This may be explained by the fact that less conservative treatments are performed under general anesthesia [27], or the increased severity of the lesions is due to the teeth being less resilient. Indeed, a Cochrane review found that with water fluoridation, the severity of dental caries (measured by an 26% reduction in DMFT) decreases [28].

In summary, there is a correlation between fluoridation cessation and the number of dental treatments performed. The difference is statistically significant when comparing the average number of treatments at all ages before and after the cessation.
Exposure to fluoride is important both before and after tooth eruption, which emphasizes the need for restoring water fluoridation in Israel, to help prevent the occurrence of dental caries and reduce its severity.

Limitations:

At "Assuta Tel Aviv", most treatments are performed following a referral based on a dental examination in another branch. Therefore, we could not calculate the number of treatments in relation to the number of examinations. However, considering that the number of patients and dentists has not changed over the years, the increase in the number of treatments does not depend on the number of patients treated in this case i.e., more treatments per patient.
As with all retrospective cross-sectional studies, only correlations can be drawn. There was no direct causal relationship that the removal of CWF was the fundamental reason that there were higher rates of caries and therefore more treatments. However, because many studies noted the same correlation, we can conclude that there are benefits to water fluoridation, which have been known for many years.
Other treatments such as extractions and root canal treatments, also indicate the severity of the dental disease. Therefore, we recommend that future research should include these treatments in addition to restorations and crowns in relation to fluoridation cessation to receive more information.

The results of this study emphasize the need to restore community water fluoridation and highlight the clear evidence to the decision makers regarding the necessity of water fluoridation.

Ethical approval and consent to participate:

The present study was approved by the Institutional Review Board (IRB) MHS‑ 0157‑20 The Helsinki committee of Maccabi Healthcare Services.

Consent for publication:
Not applicable

Availability of data and materials

The data that support the findings of this study are available from "Maccabi-Dent", but restrictions apply to the availability of these data, which were used under license for the current study, and so are not publicly available. Data are however available from the authors upon reasonable request and with permission of "Maccabi-Dent".

Competing Interests:
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.

Funding:
Self-funding.

Authors' contribution:
TG, SSN, MJ – Conception and design of the study, analysis of the data, writing, reviewing, and editing.

FM – Conception and design of the study, data curation

CT – supervision and methodology
HD – Conception and design of the study, data curation

Acknowledgements:
N/A

Egelberg J. Discussion: Design of clinical trials of traditional therapies of peridontitis. J Clin Periodontol. 1986;13:498–9. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1600-051X.1986.tb01496.x
World Health Organization: Oral Health. https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/oral-health (2023). acessed 20 Nov 2023.
Pitts NB, Zero DT, Marsh PD, Ekstrand K, Weintraub JA, Ramos-Gomez F, et al. Dental caries. Nat Rev Dis Prim. 2017;3. https://doi.org/10.1038/nrdp.2017.30
Buzalaf MAR. Review of Fluoride Intake and Appropriateness of Current Guidelines. Adv Dent Res. 2018;29:157–66. https://doi.org/10.1177/0022034517750850.
Cheng L, Zhang L, Yue L, Ling J, Fan M, Yang D, Huang Z, Niu Y, Liu J, Zhao J, Li Y, Guo B, Chen Z, Zhou X. Expert consensus on dental caries management. Int J Oral Sci. 2022;14(1):17. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41368-022-00167-3.
Leal SC, Takeshita EM. Pediatric restorative dentistry. Pediatr Restor Dent. 2018;1–221. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-93426-6.
O’mullane DM, Baez RJ, Jones S, Lennon MA, Petersen PE, Rugg-Gunn AJ, et al. Fluoride and Oral Health Sections. Community Dent Health. 2016;33:69–99. https://doi.org/10.1922/CDH.
Ten Cate JM, Featherstone JDB. Mechanistic aspects of the interactions between fluoride and dental enamel. Crit Rev Oral Biol Med. 1991;2:283–96. https://doi.org/10.1177/10454411910020030101.
Dean H. The investigation of physiological effects by the epidemiological method. In: Fluorine and dental health, Moulton, R.F. ed., pp23-31. Washington, DC: American As- sociation for the Advancement of Science. 1942.
Twetman KJTS, Parnell CSC, Lygidakis CVLNΑ. Guidelines on the use of fluoride for caries prevention in children : an updated EAPD policy document. Eur Arch Paediatr Dent. 2019;20:507–16. https://doi.org/10.1007/s40368-019-00464-2.
Roberts DJ, Massey V, Morris J, Verlander NQ, Saei A, Young N, et al. The effect of community water fluoridation on dental caries in children and young people in England : an ecological study. 2022;45:462–9. doi: 10.1093/pubmed/fdac066. PMID: 35754332.
Rugg-Gunn AJ, Do L. Effectiveness of water fluoridation in caries prevention. Community Dent Oral Epidemiol. 2012;40 Suppl 2:55–64. doi: 10.1111/j.1600-0528.2012.00721.x. PMID: 22998306.
Tobias G, Findler M, Chackartchi T, Bernstein Y, Greenberg B, Mann J,Sgan-Cohen H.D. The effect of community water fluoridation cessation on children’s dental health: a national experience. Isr J Health Policy Res. 2022;11:1–7. https://doi.org/10.1186/s13584-022-00514-z.
Zusman SP. Water Fluoridation in Israel : Ethical and Legal Aspects. Public Health Rev. 2012; 4:1–14. https://doi.org/10.1007/BF03391658 34:1–14.
Sgan-Cohen HD, Zini A, Vered Y. Survey of Levels of Dental Caries In Fluoridated Cities. State of Israel Ministry of Health. 2012. (in Hebrew). Minist. Heal. 2012. https://www.health.gov.il/publicationsfiles/flouridereport2015.pdf
Natapov L, Sasson A, Zusman SP. Does dental health of 6-year-olds reflect the reform of the Israeli dental care system? Isr J Health Policy Res. 2016;5:3–7. http://dx.doi.org/10.1186/s13584-016-0086-3
Ministry of Health, Dental Health Department: Dental treatments for children and youth. https://www.gov.il/he/service/dental-treatments-for-children (2023). Acessed 26 Sep 2023.
Ramazani N. Different aspects of general anesthesia in pediatric dentistry: A review. Iran J Pediatr. 2016;26. https://doi.org/10.5812/ijp.2613.
Clarfield AM, Manor O, Nun G Bin, Shvarts S, Azzam ZS, Afek A, et al. Health and health care in Israel: an introduction. Lancet. 2017;389:2503–13. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(17)30636-0
Del Machuca Portillo MC, Hanke Herrero R, del López Valle L, Machuca Portillo G, Bullón Fernández P. General anesthesia: as a challenge and treatment need option in pediatric dentistry. P. R. Health Sci. J. 2005. p. 291–6. PMID: 16570526.
Mclaren L, Patterson SK, Faris P, Chen G, Thawer S, Figueiredo R, et al. Fluoridation cessation and children’s dental caries : A 7-year follow-up evaluation of Grade 2 schoolchildren in Calgary and Edmonton, Canada. 2022;391–403. https://doi.org/10.1111/cdoe.12685.
Mclaren L, Patterson S, Thawer S, Faris P, Mcneil D. Exploring the short-term impact of community water fluoridation cessation on children’s dental caries : a natural experiment in Alberta , Canada. Public Health. 2017;146:56–64. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.puhe.2016.12.040.
Hearnshaw S, Cockcroft B, Rugg-Gunn A, Morris AJ, Lowry RJ, Beal J, et al. Comments on recent community water fluoridation studies. Br Dent J. 2023;235:639–41. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41415-023-6338-z.
Singh KA, Spencer AJ, Brennan DS. Effects of water fluoride exposure at crown completion and maturation on caries of permanent first molars. Caries Res. 2007;41:34–42. https://doi.org/10.1159/000096103.
Singh KA, Spencer AJ. Relative effects of pre- and post-eruption water fluoride on caries experience by surface type of permanent first molars. Community Dent Oral Epidemiol. 2004;32:435–46. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1600-0528.2004.00182.x.
Levy DH, Sgan-Cohen H, Solomonov M, Shemesh A, Ziv E, Glassberg E, et al. Association of Nationwide Water Fluoridation, changes in dental care legislation, and caries-related treatment needs: A 9-year record-based cross-sectional study. J Dent. 2023;134. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jdent.2023.104550.
Eshghi A, Samani MJ, Najafi NF, Hajiahmadi M. Evaluation of efficacy of restorative dental treatment provided under general anesthesia at hospitalized pediatric dental patients of Isfahan. Dent Res J. 2012; 4:478-82. PMID: 23162592.
Iheozor-Ejiofor Z, O’Malley LA, Glenny AM, Macey R, Alam R, Tugwell P, et al. Water fluoridation for the prevention of dental caries. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2013. https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858.CD010856.

Download PDF

Journal Publication

published 20 Sep, 2024

Read the published version in Israel Journal of Health Policy Research →

Editorial decision: Major revision
29 Apr, 2024
Reviewers agreed at journal
27 Dec, 2023
Reviewers invited by journal
27 Dec, 2023
Editor assigned by journal
26 Dec, 2023
First submitted to journal
25 Dec, 2023

You are reading this latest preprint version

The Effect of Cessation of Drinking Water Fluoridation on Dental Restorations and Crowns in Children Aged 3-5 Years in Israel – A Retrospective Study

Status:

Journal Publication

Version 1

Abstract

Figures

Background

Materials and methods

Results

Discussion

Conclusions

Declarations

References

Status:

Journal Publication

Version 1