Voltage-Gated Sodium Channels (VGSCs or Nav) are the intrinsic transmembrane proteins, which are implicated in regulating the influx of Na+ across the cell membrane of excitable and non-excitable cells in response to membrane potential. Nav generates action potential during neuronal synapses [43]. The mutation(s) in the SCN gene family results in hyperexcitability in the brain, i.e., epilepsy, and several other neurological disorders. Diverse population studies reported that mutations associated with Nav most commonly cause epilepsy [14,18,26,27]. Epilepsy is the most common and devastating neurological disorder characterized by unprovoked, recurrent seizures, arising from excessive synchronized neuronal discharging. SCN1A, SCN2A, SCN3A, SCN8A, and SCN1B are of huge significance due to their high expression in the nervous system. This retrospective study reports the SCN gene mutations found in our cohort of patients with epilepsy and other neurological disorders. Our study highlights the diverse genotype-phenotype association, identify potential pathogenic mutation by in silico approaches, and discusses the potential roles of personalized treatments.
The goals of this research were to study the genetic factors that regulate the expression of neuronal Nav, the underlying mechanism behind seizure generation in epilepsy, and the basis of variable severities in epilepsy patients. Next-generation sequencing technology was used to determine if mutation or variations in SCN1A, SCN1B, SCN2A, SCN3A, SCN8A, and SCN9A contribute to causing epilepsy. Moreover, bioinformatics and functional analysis were used to evaluate the significance of the SCN gene mutations and to identify putative pathogenic mutations. The medical records of patients were also reviewed to find the genotype-phenotype correlation.
4.1. SCN1A
SCN1A (OMIM# 182389) mutations are novel and primarily related to the different epilepsy-related phenotypes, including Dravet syndrome [44-46]. SCN1A mutations are considered common in epilepsy because of repeatedly reported [47]. Dravet syndrome (OMIM # 607208) was first discovered by Dravet [48], which is characterized by generalized, unilateral, tonic, clonic, or tonic-clonic seizures with febrile illness or fever. Dravet syndrome (DS) is an infantile-onset epileptic encephalopathy associated with developmental delay, intellectual disability, gait problems, and intractable epilepsy [45,49]. 80% of the Dravet syndrome cases have SCN1A mutation. [50,51]. Bjurulf, et al. [52] reported that 90% of children with DS have SCN1A variations. Missense or truncating mutations in the voltage sensor and pore domain of SCN1A are reported to be more common in DS patients, irrespective of differences in clinical presentation [53]. In line with this, we also found a c.3147del a frameshift mutation that create premature codon, producing a truncated protein in a 5-year-old female patient with Dravet syndrome and also other clinical presentations, including hemibody convulsion, frequent seizures with illness, and seizure, microcephaly. Frame-deletions in SCN1A disrupt protein residues and exert deleterious effects on Nav1.1 [54]. In our cohort, we have 3 pathogenic frameshift mutations (c.4554dup, c.2851del, and c.3147del). Also, mutations on the homology domains result in earlier onset rather than mutations occurring in the linker domain of SCN1A [55]. SCN1A variants may also be common in patients with co-occurring epilepsy and autism spectrum disorders [56]. In our cohort, we also found two patients with autism having SCN1A mutations, a missense mutation in the extracellular loop (c.812G>A) and a frameshift mutation in the pore-forming unit of domain II (c.2851del). Moreover, we also found two SCN1A mutations (p.Lys1049Asnfs*6, and p.Ala1429Pro) to be associated with microcephaly.
In a Turkish cohort of GEFS+ (n=6) and DS (n=12), 17 variations in SCN1A were reported with 7 novel variations in DS cases (E1916G, I767L, M1R, M147T, N1319I, R1886G, and R1933Q) [57]. Similarly, 19 mutations in SCN1A genes with 12 novel mutations were also reported in another Turkish cohort of DS spectrum phenotypes patients (n=46) [58]. A study on a Chinese cohort of pediatric epilepsy patients reported 8 variants in SCN1A, with 6 novel mutations and 2 inherited [59]. In this study, 2 inherited missense mutations in cytoplasmic loops (p.Arg500Trp and p.Ser1122Thr), 2 de novo missense mutations, 1 in the pore-forming loop (p.Ala1429Pro), and 1 in the extracellular loop (p.Gly271Asp) of SCN1A gene, were found in epilepsy patients (Figure 1). Novel mutations, i.e., c.812G>A, c.4285G>C, and, c.3147del have been found, which were not described in literature nor the population databases dbSNP or gnomAD. Also, c.4554dup and c.3364T>A were not described in literature nor in the population databases dbSNP but ClinVar and gnomAD, respectively. However, c.2851del and c.1498C>T were described in population databases, i.e., dbSNP (rs886042004, rs141188608), gnomAD (1498C>T: 0.00081%, including two heterozygotes) and ClinVar. Previously, R500Q (c.1499G>A) mutation was reported in patients with epilepsy febrile seizures plus (EFS+) [60], whereas we have found R500W (c.1498C>T).
4.2. SCN1B
The mutated human SCN1B (OMIM# 600235) gene is also associated with a spectrum of epileptic phenotypes with variable severity. The first pathogenic epilepsy-related mutation in SCN1B was reported in GEFS+ patients who inherited p.C121W mutation in an autosomal dominant pattern [61]. This shows that β subunits of SCN genes may influence the normal activity of Nav and contribute to the pathogenesis of epilepsy. Heterozygous SCN1B mutations have been reported in GEFS+ and temporal lobe epilepsy [61-63]. Also, a mutation in the SCN1B gene was reported in DS patients, but rarely [64]. Homozygous SCN1B mutations are uncommon [65]. However, homozygous Homozygous SCN1B mutation in three consanguineous families causes severe recessive developmental delay and epileptic encephalopathy [66]. A study from Taiwan reported the SCN1B variant (rs55742440) to be associated with not achieving seizure-free with sodium channel blockers [67]. A novel SCN1B mutation (N110S) was reported recently in a Chinese pediatric epilepsy patient [68]. However, we found 2 SCN1B mutations, p.Ala197Val (c.590C>T) and p.Cys211Tyr (c.632G>A), in the cytoplasmic domain of Navβ1. Both of these mutations were described in population databases, i.e., dbSNP (rs554201948, rs141188608), gnomAD (0.0016% and 0.039%) and ClinVar. One of the SCN1B mutations (c.1498C>T) occurred in comorbidity with SCN1A mutation (c.590C>T). Both of these mutations were considered pathogenic by the bioinformatics tools.
4.3. SCN2A
SCN2A (OMIM# 182390) mutations have been reported in several epileptic pathologies of different types, GEFS+, DS, epileptic encephalopathies, and benign familial neonatal infantile seizure [69]. SCN2A variants dependent epilepsies mostly onset in early childhood with a wide variety of phenotypic spectrums, which may also include intellectual disability, developmental delay, and epileptic encephalopathy [70]. SCN2A mutations are also considered a major cause of epilepsy in infancy with migrating focal seizures [71]. Melikishvili, et al. [72] reported three de novo mutations (D1487E, M136R, and M1545V) in the SCN2A gene in neonate patients with tonic spams, oculoclonic seizures, and epilepsy of infancy with migrating focal seizures [72]. SCN2A variations cause an early-infantile onset of seizures (up to 3 months of age) and infantile/childhood-onset (>3 months of age), with recognizable phenotypes (infantile spasms, partial migrating discharges, etc.) [58]. Zeng, et al. [73] also reported that half of the SCN2A mutated patients have seizures onset during the neonate period and 80% have seizures in the first 6 months of age. A novel mutation (A215T) in SCN2A also causes the onset of seizures immediately after birth [74]. Moreover, various SCN2A variations have also been reported, including A1316V, A1283D, N1393K, and G40T [75]. A1316V variant was also reported previously in patients with Ohtahara syndrome [76,77]. In this study, only one pathogenic missense heterozygous mutation, c.3457G>C (p.Glu1153Gln), was found in the SCN2A gene, which was located in the extracellular loop connecting domains II and III, causing refractory seizures and global.
4.4. SCN3A
Various missense and truncating variations have been reported in SCN3A (OMIM# 182391) gene, which could be associated with epilepsy and related epileptic encephalopathy. Homozygous SCN3A mutations could be associated with mild nonspecific forms of epilepsy. A heterozygous mutation K247P is reported to be associated with focal epilepsy and developmental delay. K247P variation in Nav1.3 causes loss of function with decreased cell surface expression and current density [78-80]. Pathogenic variations in SCN3A result in childhood-onset of epilepsy and cortical development malformation [81]. Zaman, et al. [82] reported I875T de novo mutation in SCN3A to be associated with developmental and epileptic encephalopathy as well diffuse polymicrogyria. Polymicrogyria is the disorder of progenitor cell proliferation and migration. Similarly, Miyatake, et al. [83] also reported the reported I875T mutation in SCN3A in patients with developmental and epileptic encephalopathy as well diffuse polymicrogyria. SCN3A mutations are associated with development delay, refractory epilepsy, polymicrogyria, intellectual disability, autism spectrum disorder, and pharmacoresponsive epilepsy [84]. In our cohort, we also found that SCN3A missense mutations, c.3486C>A and c.956T>C, cause speech delay and learning difficulties. Vanoye, et al. [80] reported M1323V mutation, the first reported mutation site in focal seizure-related genes, in children with focal seizures and epilepsy. The damaging SCN3A mutation D1688Y was reported in patients with focal seizures plus [85]. The SCN3A variant N302S causes depolarizing shifts in voltage-dependent activation and inactivation, as well as a slow recovery from inactivation; therefore indicates a decrease in sodium channel activity [86].
However, in our cohort mutations in the SCN3A were associated with different types of epilepsy or seizures. The c.44G>A mutation was associated with Generalized tonic-clonic and myoclonic seizures in a patient with a family history of febrile seizures. A patient also had attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) with learning difficulties and epilepsy due to c.956T>C mutation in SCN3A. Furthermore, mutations in the SCN3A gene also cause epilepsy with the absence of seizures, i.e., c.2350A>G in our cohort. Similarly, another study also found that SCN3A missense mutations (c.A1816G, p.Ser606Gly) were associated with childhood absence epilepsy [87]. Also, a female with epilepsy (absence of seizure), learning difficulties, and benign infantile familial seizures-5 had mutations in the SCN3A (c.928A>T) and SCN8A (c.5113G>C) genes. Also, the c.4594A>T (p.Ile1532Phe) mutation in SCN8A was found in a patient with Infantile epileptic encephalopathy-13, neonatal seizure, hypotonia, and regression in development. Zaman, et al. [88] reported the first association of SCN3B mutation (p.Ile875Thr) with the early infantile epileptic encephalopathy. In this study, we found the association of SCN8A mutation (Ile1532Phe) with infantile epileptic encephalopathy-13.
4.5. SCN8A
SCN8A gene (OMIM# 600702) is associated with a spectrum of epilepsy phenotypes with variable severity. Since the first epilepsy-causing mutation was reported in 2012 [89], hundreds of SCN8A variants have been reported to be associated with the pathogenesis and phenotypes of epilepsy and epileptic encephalopathies. SCN8 mutations are mostly associated with early-onset epilepsy and epileptic encephalopathies, early infantile epileptic encephalopathies, and sudden unexpected death in epilepsy [90]. In epilepsy, SCN8A mutations are typically heterogeneous and important in the pathogenesis of epileptic encephalopathies in the early first year. However, SCN8A was never reported to be mutated in neonatal-onset epileptic encephalopathies with suppression-burst. Approximately half of the SCN8A mutations in the neonatal period have myoclonic jerks [91]. The epilepsy-related SCN8A mutations are predominantly de novo mutations or inherited from unaffected parents. E1483K missense variation in the SCN8A gene causes benign infantile spasms and paroxysmal dyskinesia [92]. SCN8A mutations are also associated with co-occurrence of epilepsy and intellectual disability or autism spectrum disorder [93]. De novo and novel mutations (A890T, S1596, R850Q, L407F, and R1617Q) were reported in Chinese children with epilepsy and intellectual disability/developmental delay [94]. Various variations alter the structure of Nav1.8, causing channel inactivation, and hyperexcitability [95]. In our study, we found that patients with SCN8A mutations significantly had developmental delays. Previously, p.Leu267Ser mutation in SCN8A was reported in a 4-years girl presenting seizures and development delays [96]. Similarly, another study also reported that SCN3A variation (p. Arg223Gly) is associated with developmental and epileptic encephalopathy [97].
4.6. SCN9A
SCN9A gene (OMIM# 603415) mutations have been reported in epilepsy and autism-related disorders, which occurred alongside SCN1A mutations; therefore called “genes with modifying roles to SCN1A” [14,98]. Potentially pathogenic mutations (N641Y, Q10R, S490N, K655R, and I739V) in population allele frequencies are associated with monogenic seizure disorders [99]. Heterozygous rare variants in SCN9A were reported to be responsible for the epileptic syndrome [100]. R185H mutation in D I S2-S3 of Nav1.9 was reported to be associated with focal seizures plus, inherited in horizontal pattern [85]. SCN9A mutations are also considered susceptible to epilepsy with febrile seizures plus [101]. SCN9A mutations could be the genetic modifier of Dravet syndrome caused by SCN1A mutation [102]. Other than febrile seizures, the G327E variant in SCN9A is reported to cause idiopathic focal epilepsy with Rolandic spikes in EEG [103]. Our study reports 4 missense mutations in the cytoplasmic loops of Nav1.9 α-subunits, which are c.279A>C (Lys93Asn), c.1482G>T (p.Lys494Asn), c.1336G>A (p.Glu446Lys), and c.4702A>C (p.Asn1568His) (Figure 5). c.1482G>T mutation is reported in population databases, i.e gnomAD (0.00081%, 2 heterozygous individuals reported) and ClinVar (ID: 331990). c.279A>C mutation was not described in literature nor in the population databases dbSNP or gnomAD. However, c.1336G>A was not described in the literature but in the population database dbSNP (rs1175228324). Also, we found that 2 patients had the same SCN9A mutation, c.279A>C, and expressed similar clinical features, i.e., global development delay, infantile spasms, and microcephaly in one patient and global development delay, drug-resistant epilepsy, and mental retardation in another patient. 2 more same mutations, c.1482G>T, were also found in SCN9A and they were also associated with GDD, microcephaly, and epilepsy.