HIV-1 infection decreases Neurogranin (Nrgn) expression in human brain tissue both at the mRNA and protein levels.
Simplification of dendritic network and synaptic dysfunction are neuropathological hallmarks of early HAND [3, 27, 28]. Previous report from our group indicated that post-synaptic protein, Nrgn is dysregulated in HAND positive individuals [4]. We then sought to evaluate the correlation between Nrgn expression and HIV-1 infection in the human brain cortex. Using immunofluorescence, we observed a dramatic decrease in Nrgn expression in frontal cortex tissue of HIV-positive individuals compared to healthy control brain tissues (Fig. 1A-B). We further quantitated the Nrgn level in whole frontal cortex tissue lysates in PWH (HIV-1+) (N = 13 donors) and age-matched people without HIV (HIV-) (N = 15) by Nrgn ELISA. We observed an average of 20% reduction in Nrgn level in HIV-1-positive individuals (Fig. 1C), compared to HIV-1 negative controls. Next, we assessed the relative expression level of Nrgn mRNA in total RNA samples from frontal cortex of HIV-1-positive individuals (N = 22) and age-matched control uninfected brain samples (N = 49) by RT-qPCR. Our results indicate that relative Nrgn mRNA level is significantly lower (average of 2.5-fold) in PWH in 75.5% of cases (37 out of 49) (Fig. 1D). Further assessment of copy number of Nrgn mRNA in brain tissue indicate that Nrgn is significantly reduced by 2.1-fold in HIV-1 positive individuals compared to HIV-1 negative individuals (Fig. 1E) based on the curve (Fig. 1F), confirming that decreased level of Nrgn protein in frontal
cortex of PWH is associated with reduced amount of Nrgn mRNA.
The candidate Nrgn regulator, lncRNA RP11-677M14.2 transcript expression is elevated in brain of HIV-1 positive individuals.
To identify the putative lncRNAs and its potential role in neurogranin dysregulation, we utilized the University of California Santa Cruz (UCSC) Genome Browser (genome.ucsc.edu) to investigate the genomic landscape of human NRGN gene. We have identified a single transcript (RP11-677M14.2) of 1,704 base pair length, which is localized in the antisense strand in NRGN locus in chromosome 11 (-strand, hg38) that remains to be characterized (Additional file 1, Fig S1A, red arrow). Moreover, in Ensembl (http://www.ensembl.org) browser, this transcript corresponds to a 3 exons antisense RNA with no protein-coding potential, being classified as a long non-coding RNA. RP11-677M14.2 arises from independent promoter and its promoter region co-aligns to epigenetic markers of active transcription (Additional file 1, Fig S1B, red circle, H3K27Ac mark). Analysis of the promoter activity from the same cell lines (Additional file 1. Fig S1C, Regulatory build track, thick red blocks) corroborates to this analysis, showing that when the Nrgn promoter is inactive (grey boxes on left), the RP11-677M14.2 promoter is active (red blocks on right). Additionally, gene expression data in 53 tissues from GTEx RNA-seq track revealed that RP11-677M14.2 is particularly abundant in human brain regions where Nrgn is also abundant, such as hippocampus and frontal (Additional file 1, Fig S1D, yellow track)[29]. Together, these data suggest a potential functional role for RP11-677M14.2 in mediating Nrgn levels.
To investigate whether RP11-677M14.2 is dysregulated in HAND, we measured the lncRNA expression levels in frontal cortex tissues from age and sex-matched people with and without HIV by RT-qPCR assay. The levels of RP11-677M14.2 were aberrantly up-regulated (> 12.00 average fold-change, p = 0.0123) in 61.2% (30 of 49) of PWH compared with tissues without HIV-1 (Fig. 2A). Comparison between PWH without any degree of cognitive impairment (HIV+/HAND-) with PWH diagnosed with some level of cognitive impairment (HIV+/HAND+) also revealed a statistically significant increase in RP11-677M14.2 levels (Fig. 2B). Moreover, the relationship between RP11-677M14.2 expression and clinical stages of HAND was analyzed. Although not statistically significant, there is an upward trend of increased RP11-677M14.2 levels as HAND progresses from the less severe form (asymptomatic neurocognitive impairment, ANI) to the most severe form of disease (HIV-1- associated dementia, HAD) (Fig. 2C). To further confirm this expression pattern, next, we performed RNA-FISH HCR for RP11-677M14.2 transcript and co-stained with DAPI in 3 paired HIV-positive and HIV-negative FFPE autopsied human frontal cortex tissues. As shown in Figs. 2D and 2E, the lncRNA RP11-677M14.2 transcript is overexpressed in the brain tissue of PWH and the subcellular localization was predominantly in the cytoplasm. Calculation of total puncta counts (Fig. 2F) and the normalized puncta counts (Fig. 2G) further confirm that this lncRNA is globally upregulated in HIV-1 positive brains. Although no significant difference in puncta size and total area was observed between the two groups (Fig. 2H and 2I, respectively), we observed an increased lncRNA RP11-677M14.2 puncta area in brains of PWH (Fig. 2I). Further, the relationship between lncRNA RP11-677M14.2 expression level and Nrgn mRNA in 49 brain tissue samples of PWH was examined. Regression analysis showed that the overexpression of lncRNA RP11-677M14.2 was significantly correlated with lower levels of Nrgn in frontal cortex with a correlation coefficient of -0.3065 (p = 0.0322) as shown in Fig. 2J. Thus, we refer RP11-677M14.2 transcript as Nrgn antisense (Nrgn-AS).
LncRNA RP11-677M14.2 displays both nuclear and cytoplasmic distribution.
LncRNAs have been separated into several broad classes in terms of their mechanisms of regulation of mRNA transcription and translation: decoys, regulators of translation, enhancers and modular scaffolds that guide chromatin modifying enzymes to specific genomic loci[30, 31]. Those lncRNAs localized within the nucleus, have been previously linked to the epigenetic control of transcriptional regulation through different mechanisms, whereas cytoplasmic lncRNAs are
involved essentially in post-transcriptional mechanisms, subcellular localization and regulation of translation[32]. To dissect the function of Nrgn-AS in Nrgn regulation we first examined the distribution of this lncRNA (Fig. 3A) and Nrgn mRNA (Fig. 3B) in SH-SY5Y cells through RNA-FISH HCR co-stained with DAPI (Fig. 3C). Calculation of the puncta revealed that nearly 51% of the lncRNA transcripts reside in the nuclear compartment, whereas 48% of the Nrgn mRNA transcripts are localized within the nucleus (Fig. 3D)
Cell fractionation followed by RT-qPCR further confirmed that both RP11-677M14.2 transcript Nrgn mRNA are equally distributed between these two subcellular compartments (Fig. 3E). According to the distribution of glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate dehydrogenase (GAPDH) and Malat1, a lncRNA enriched in nucleus, the nucleus/cytoplasm separation was successful (Fig. 3E). Notably, minimal colocalization between the two transcripts was observed, suggesting that these transcripts do not physically interact (Fig. 3C)
Nrgn and lncRNA RP11-677M14.2 (Nrgn-AS) transcripts exhibit discordant expression pattern.
Antisense transcripts may regulate expression of its sense gene at the transcriptional level (via transcriptional interference) and/or at the post-transcriptional level[7, 8, 33]. To investigate the potential regulation of Nrgn by endogenous levels of RP11-677M14.2, we treated SH-SY5Y cells with all-trans retinoic acid (RA) for 7 days (Fig. 3F) and measured the Nrgn and RP11-677M14.2 transcript by RT-qPCR. These cells express low levels of endogenous RP11-677M14.2 and high levels of Nrgn under normal conditions. During the differentiation process with RA treatment, both Nrgn mRNA and protein increase (Fig. 3G). Interestingly, our data reveal that while the expression of Nrgn increased, RP11-677M14.2 level sharply declined by 3-fold upon differentiation (Fig. 3B). This observation suggests that Nrgn level may be regulated by its anti-sense lncRNA RP11-677M14.2 in a discordant manner upon certain stimuli, as shown for other sense-antisense pairs[19, 34]. Therefore, we speculate whether this antisense lncRNA exerts a silencing effect on the Nrgn mRNA or corresponding protein abundance.
Overexpression of Nrgn-AS, RP11-677M14.2 inhibits Neurogranin expression.
To test the prediction of a discordant regulation of Nrgn-AS and Nrgn mRNA, we have cloned full-length RP11-677M14.2 transcript into pCDNA3.1 expression vector to overexpress this lncRNA in HEK293T and SH-SY5Y cells (Additional file 1, Fig S2A). Firstly, Nrgn mRNA was assessed by RT-qPCR upon transiently transfecting the Nrgn-AS construct in HEK293T. Our results show that Nrgn mRNA was decreased by 90% in HEK293T cells in comparison to cells transfected with the empty vector (Fig. 4A). The effect seemed to be dose dependent as we observed concentration dependent decrease in Nrgn mRNA expression as we increase the quantity of pCDNA3.1 RP11-677M14.2 in transfection (Fig. 4B).
Next, we stably transfected SH-SY5Y cells with RP11-677M14.2 plasmid and observed a 50% reduction in Nrgn mRNA in these neuronal cells (Fig. 4C). To confirm these mRNA results, we next assessed Nrgn at the protein level by ELISA (Fig. 4D). Similar results were obtained when we measured the protein level of Nrgn, being observed an average decrease of 4.7-fold in neuronal cells overexpressing Nrgn-AS in comparison to cells transfected with empty vector as control. Finally, by employing FISH HCR co-stained with DAPI, we observed a diffuse distribution of the lncRNA in the stably transfected SHSY-5Y cells (Fig. 4F) similar to the endogenous distribution of this transcript observed in the empty vector control (Fig. 4E). These results suggest that the expression of Nrgn-AS directly or indirectly alters Nrgn mRNA expression resulting in lower protein levels.
To further investigate the effects of Nrgn-AS on the synaptodendritic damage, we also examined the expression level of selected synaptodendritic integrity markers: the dendritic marker MAP-2, the pre-synaptic markers GAP43, Synapsin and SNAP25, and the post-synaptic proteins Calmodulin, CAMK2, and calcineurin (PP3CA) in differentiated stably transfected SH-SY5Y (Additional file 1, Fig S2B). We observed a significant decreased expression of MAP-2 (p = 0.016377), SNAP25 (p = 0.0128) and CAMK2 (p = 0.003930) indicating that inhibition of Nrgn expression induced by overexpression of the lncRNA caused disruption of synaptodendritic integrity, which is implicated in cognitive decline.
Supernatant from HIV-1 infected macrophages or microglia alters Nrgn-AS expression in neurons:
We next investigated whether HIV-1 infection affects Nrgn-AS transcript levels as it affects Nrgn mRNA levels in vitro by exposing differentiated SH-SY5Y cells to conditioned medium from HIV-infected monocytes-derived macrophages (MDM) (Fig. 5A-B), microglia cells (Fig. 5C-D) or mock-infected, to mimic the impact of HIV-1 induced inflammatory factors, toxins and/or viral proteins as previously described [35–37]. The effect of these factors on sense and antisense transcripts levels was assessed by RT-qPCR. Results indicate that exposure of cells to supernatant of HIV-infected MDMs resulted in an average 1.8-fold decrease in Nrgn mRNA and a 6.8-fold increase of Nrgn-AS levels (Fig. 5B), although the increase in the lncRNA expression varied between monocytes donors, it is not statistically significant (p = 0.149). Interestingly, our results show that there is a pattern of both transcripts being altered at the same time (between 6 and 12h post-exposure) and these alterations seem to be reversible as the stress factors degrade in the culture media (~ 24h post-exposure). Similarly, we tested the conditioned media obtained from HIV-infected human microglia and observed that exposure of cells to supernatant of HIV-infected microglia resulted in a 1.86-fold decrease in Nrgn mRNA and a 4.6-fold increase in Nrgn-AS levels (Fig. 5D). Together, these results suggest that both viral proteins and/or inflammatory factors released by infected MDM or microglia affect antisense transcript level. The composition of products released from infected MDM or microglia is complex and not fully known, however previous studies by us and others have identified several cytokines/chemokines that are known to have a role in neuropathogenesis [25, 35, 36]. Thus, to identify the proinflammatory cytokines present in HIV-1 infected MDM and microglia supernatants that might contribute to loss of Nrgn in neurons, we selected and measured the levels of interleukin IL-1b, IL-6, tumor necrosis factor TNF-a, and IL-8 in the supernatants of HIV-1 and mock-infected MDM (Additional file 1, Fig S3A) and microglia (Additional file 1, Fig S3B) by ELISA. As expected, HIV-1 infection increased the production and release of proinflammatory cytokines in both cell types. Among the pro-inflammatory cytokines tested, only IL-1b significantly increased upon HIV-1 infection in both MDM (p = 0.0210) and microglia (p = 0.0356) compared to mock infected. Next, we tested the levels of IL-1b mRNA in the frontal cortex tissues and observed a significant increase in IL-1b expression level in HIV-positive group (p = 0.0174) (Fig. 5E), but not TNF-a (p = 0.7487) (Additional file 1, Fig S3C), corroborating with these in vitro findings. Collectively, our results suggest that IL-1b released by infected MDM or microglia might in part mediate Nrgn-Nrgn-AS dysregulation in neurons.
To further test this hypothesis in vitro, we exposed differentiated SH-SY5Y to recombinant IL-1b (1mg/mL) for 1hr and assessed the levels of Nrgn and Nrgn-AS through RT-qPCR. Results indicate similar dysregulation of the sense-antisense axis in which Nrgn-AS, RP11-677M14.2 levels aberrantly increased by 143-fold, whereas Nrgn-mRNA levels decreased by 1.4-fold (Fig. 5F). This suggests that activation of an intracellular cascade downstream to IL-1b leads to transcriptional activation of Nrgn-AS which in turn downregulates Nrgn mRNA.
Human brain organoids carrying HIV-1 infected microglia recapitulate the Nrgn-Nrgn-AS dysregulation.
To study Nrgn-Nrgn-AS dysregulation in a more physiologically relevant model, we leveraged 3D brain organoid technology by incorporating infected microglia to better represent the HIV-1 infected brain microenvironment. Having previously established that the triculture brain organoid system is amenable to HIV-1 infection resulting in increased glial activation and neuroinflammation [26, 38], we used our model to discern the contribution of Nrgn-AS dysregulation to Nrgn levels. As depicted in the schematic (Fig. 6A), we infected primary adult brain microglia with HIV-1 YU2-EGFP (MOI of 0.5) and 3 days post infection, microglia were incorporated into the fully mature brain organoids to generate an immunocompetent brain organoid as described[26]. These organoids were cultured for up to 30 days, harvesting RNA at days 5 and 20 for expression analysis. We found that incorporation of HIV-1 infected microglia caused substantial decrease in Nrgn expression (2.7-fold, p = 0.0056), whereas Nrgn-AS expression increased significantly (96-fold, p < 0.001) as early as 5 days in infected microglia containing organoids compared to uninfected control organoids (Fig. 6B). The same dysregulation continued up to day 20 p.i. where Nrgn mRNA and proteins levels are continuously suppressed (-2.5-fold, p = 0.0005) and Nrgn-AS level is elevated by 10-fold (p = 0.005) (Fig. 6B - C). In addition, the low expression of HIV-1 Gag at day 5 post incorporation suggests that the rapid Nrgn mRNA dysregulation occurred prior to active viral replication, and it was sustained thereafter corroborating with our hypothesis that the inflammatory environment is driving the Nrgn-Nrgn-AS axis dysregulation. Finally, we assessed the expression of Nrgn protein level by immunohistochemistry at day 30 post-microglia incorporation. As expected, HIV-1 infection led to a decrease of Nrgn immunostaining and accumulation of the remaining protein in the perinuclear region (Fig. 6C).