MODY cases are still often misdiagnosed now days. Traditional criteria of MODY, such as diabetes before 25 years old, non-insulin therapy and family history of diabetes, lack of T1D and T2D characters identifies only small part of MODY cases, is not sufficient in clinical practice (9). Such as, obesity was considered as evidence of T2D with polygenic background. However, the overweight and obesity rate of young people is increasing all over the world, causing a challenge to distinguish MODY from T2D, obesity alone should not preclude genetic testing in young persons with hyperglycemia and insulin therapy is in need for many MODYs (1). Some variants in HNF1A, HNF1B and HNF4A may also be associated with T2D and obesity (10, 11). In our study 6 patients were overweight or obese, including three patients with HNF1A and HNF4A mutations. But the BMI of two MODY 5 patients with HNF1B mutations were extremely different from each other. Andrew T, et al. (12) pointed out that lacks of clinical criterion, cost of genetic testing, and specialists’ emphasis on treatment rather than diagnosis were the major barriers for precision medication to MODY.
MODY 1 diabetes caused by HNF4A gene mutation is less common than HNF1A (MODY 3). These two types variants carriers tend to have hyperglycemia at the same age, and phenotypically familiar (3). The transcription factor HNF4A is expressed primarily in the liver, pancreas and kidney, where it regulates the expression of genes required for glucose transport and metabolism. About half of HNF4A gene variants carriers have macrosomia and 15% of variants carriers have transient neonatal hypoglycemia (13). Patient 1 was diagnosed MODY 1 diabetes at 11.5 years old with birth weight 4500g, but unclear of neonatal hypoglycemia or not. He was treated metformin and sulfonylureas after diagnosis. The mutation was inherited from his mother, who was treated with metformin and acarbose to control blood sugar.
MODY 3, the most common type MODY, is charactered by impaired insulin secretion after glucose stimulation due to mutation in HNF1A gene with autosomal dominant inheritance pattern. The transcription factor HNF1A is expressed in the liver, kidney, intestine and pancreatic β-cells. Fasting blood glucose is normal in the early stage, ketosis is rare because residual insulin secretion can last for many years, and glucose intolerance might be evident during adolescence or early adulthood (14). These patients present glycosuria from very beginning due to impaired renal tubular transport of glucose. 63% HNF1A mutation carriers develop diabetes before 25 years of age, 79% before 35 years-old and 96% before 55 years-old (15). In our study, a girl with MODY 3 (patient 5) was diagnosed diabetes at 9 years-old, her father was diagnosed at 15 years-old and her grandfather was diagnosed at 48 years-old. Patient 6 with MODY 3 was diagnosed diabetes at 11.7 years-old, her mother and grandmother were both found diabetes younger than 30 years-old. HNF1A mutations are associated with an increased frequency of cardiovascular disease and microvascular complications, careful glucose control is needed for MODY 3 patients (16).
MODY 3 and MODY 1 patients should be treated with diet control from beginning due to marked postprandial hyperglycemia after high carbohydrate food (14). Low-dose sulfonylureas is sufficient for MODY 3 and MODY 1 adult patients to control blood sugar and avoid hypoglycemia (17). But for patient 6 with MODY 3, blood sugar fluctuated severely and insulin secretion was extremely low, insulin supplement was needed to stabilize blood sugar. And patient 5 was young, insulin was also used to control blood sugar. Lipid metabolism disorder is also common for MODY 3 and MODY 1, which need appropriate diet control for these children.
MODY 2 is another common MODY, clinical manifestations are asymptomatic, mild, non-progressive fasting hyperglycemia and slight increase during OGTT. Genetic tests showed a high percentage of de novo variants (24%) in GCK genes, and negative family history of hyperglycemia should not be excluded from gene evaluation (18). GCK mutations altered the set-point of insulin secretion (19). HbA1c is usually 5.6–7.6%, and fasting glucose is always 5.5–8.5 mmol/L. 75.8% of patients had a level of 2h-postprandial blood sugar below 11.1 mmol/L, and the increments of blood glucose were 2.82 ± 2.03 mmol/L during OGTT (20). Multiple studies showed MODY 2 patients do not require antihyperglycemic medication except during pregnancy. And diet control can slightly reduce blood glucose levels and improve the glucose tolerance curve (21). Consistent with previous reports, patient 2, 3 and 4 with GCK gene mutations, showed slight increase in HbA1c, fasting glucose. Only patient 4 was treated with metformin for first two months due to hyperinsulinemia, and withdrawed after genetic diagnosis.
A diabetic child with multi-system extrapancreatic features is suspected to be monogenic disorder (22). Most MODY 5 patients with HNF1B mutations may have renal developmental disorders, like renal cysts, renal dysplasia and genital-tract malformations, hyperuricemia may also occur (23–25). Therefore, diabetic patient with HNF1B mutation were also described as renal cysts and diabetes (RCAD) syndrome, typically develops during adolescence and early adulthood. Patient 7 and patient 8 were both diagnosed MODY 5 in adolescence, patient 7 was found bilateral renal cysts, and patient 8 is found hydronephrosis. The variant of patient 8 had been reported previously (26). MODY 5 patients have variable phenotypes even within family with the same HNF1B variant, absence of the pancreatic body or tail is highly indicative in patient with renal cysts (27). Hepatic insulin resistance is another feature for MODY 5 patients (28, 29). Patient 7 had normal body size and normal insulin level, but patient 8 was severe obese with serious hyperinsulinemia and obvious acanthosis nigricans revealing insulin resistance. It is difficult to distinguish from T2D.
The paired homeodomain transcriptional factor, PAX4, function as a transcription repressor and plays a crucial role in pancreatic β cell function, development, regeneration (30), and represses the transcriptional activity of insulin and glucagon promoters (31, 32). Inactivation of PAX4 causes a lack of mature β and δ cells, resulting in impaired inability to produce sufficient insulin and growth inhibitory hormone, leading to diverse phenotypes (33). Missense mutation of PAX4 c.490C > A, p.Arg164Trp was identified from patient 5, which has been reported as MODY 9 before (34). But the patient in our study presented elevated blood glucose, polydipsia, polyuria with low insulin level, just like T1D. What is more important, autoimmune antibodies, glutamate decarboxylase antibody (GADA) and insulin antibody (IAA)were positive at diagnosis. Polymorphisms and mutations in PAX4 were also associated with T1D and T2D in various ethnic groups, like German, Swiss, Chinese, and Japanese (35, 36). There is overlap between T1D, T2D and PAX4-MODY.
ABCC8 gene mutations can cause dysfunction in ATP-sensitive potassium channels, resulting in MODY 12, which was first described by Bowman (37). Diverse clinical manifestations present with MODY 12, including overweight or obese, but always normal lipid metabolism. Activating mutations in the ABCC8 gene cause diabetes with decreased insulin secretion and inactivating mutations usually cause hyperinsulinemia and hypoglycemia in infancy. 4 patients with ABCC8 missense mutations were found hyperglycemia at adolescence. Patient 10 was macrosomia once but unaware of hypoglycemia or not in infancy, and she was also obese at diagnosis with dyslipidemia and nonalcoholic fatty liver disease. And she was found diabetic ketoacidosis at first, with high HbA1c levels 12.2%. Occasionally, all these mutations of ABCC8 gene were missense and inherited from their mothers.
Despite a missense mutation in ABCC8 gene, a mutation of BLK, c.C89A, p.Ala30Asp was also detected from patient 10. B-lymphocyte kinase (BLK) encodes a tyrosine receptor protein that stimulates β-cells to produce and secrete insulin and is essential for thymopoiesis in immature T cells, that may be responsible for MODY 11. But not all carriers of BLK pathogenic variants exhibit diabetes, there is still debates whether patients carrying BLK variants can be diagnosed MODY (38). And analysis of p.Ala30Asp used PolyPhen-2, SIFT and Mutation Taster tools showed it was benign, tolerated, and polymorphism. Thus, the patient was diagnosed MODY 12 finally.