The current study yielded three main findings. First, N100 amplitude was significantly reduced in male SCZspect compared to male HC and nominally reduced in the combined sample of SCZspect compared to the combined sample of HC. Second, T1w/T2w-ratio in AC1/AC2 did not differ between any groups. Finally, we did not find any significant association between N100 amplitude and T1w/T2w-ratio in the AC1 or in AC2.
To our knowledge, this is the first published report showing reduced N100 amplitude in male SCZspect compared to male HC 53. While we at this point can only speculate why N100 amplitude was reduced in males with SCZspect, but not in females with SCZspect, the neuroprotective abilities of estrogen may play a role 74.
Of interest, our supplementary analyses revealed reduced N100 amplitude in the combined sample of male patients and controls compared to the combined sample of female patients and controls (Supplementary Table 6). These findings are in accordance with previous reports of sex differences in auditory functioning in healthy individuals. Females have larger auditory brainstem response 75–77 and larger P300 amplitude, indicating enhanced auditory function, compared to males 49. Further, females are more sensitive to high frequency sounds 78 while males have a superior spatial auditory perception 79–81. In females the AC1 is more sensitive to noise compared to males 82. Together, these findings indicate sex differences in auditory function and estrogen may play a role. Estrogen is believed to protect the auditory system from noise and age-related damage and to optimize auditory processing 83. Sex differences in auditory function are already present in infants 84,85, indicating that exposure to sex steroids’ metabolites during prenatal development may lead to fundamental sex differences in auditory function 86. Further, auditory function changes during the menstrual cycle 87–89 and during pregnancy, a period when estrogen (and progesterone) levels rise continuously until giving birth 90,91. Peri- and postmenopausal women have diminished auditory function 92 and hormone-replacement therapy may reverse this decline 93,94. Further females with Turner´s syndrome, a disorder characterized by estrogen deficiency, have increased rate of hearing decline 83 and auditory pathology 95. Together, these findings indicate that estrogen has a neuroprotective role in auditory function 96. The neuroprotective effect of estrogen is believed to be partly mediated through its interaction with brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF), gamma-aminobutyric acid (GABA), norepinephrine 83,97 and through enhancing myelination 46,98,99. Women with MS have fewer MS relapses during pregnancy, suggesting a neuroprotective effect of estrogen through promoting myelination 100. More research is needed to fully understand the effect of sex steroids and myelination on auditory function in humans 83. In addition, the relationship between sex steroids and N100 amplitude remains elusive.
The effect of sex steroids on auditory function in SCZspect remain unknown. However, animal models of SCZspect show that estrogen plays a neuroprotective role in auditory function when interacting with BDNF, 101. Further, sex differences in dopamine 102 and GABA 103, neurotransmitters believed to have implications for generating post-synaptic potentials 104–106 which are important for auditory function, are reported in SCZspect.. Thus, sex differences in these neurotransmitters may also be involved in the current findings of reduced N100 amplitude in males with SCZspect. Understanding the relationship between sex steroids and N100 amplitude in SCZspect may provide insight into new treatment targets. Animal models of SCZspect show evidence suggesting that estrogen may be protective of the disorder through its interaction with BDNF and thus that estrogen–BDNF interactions may be new treatment targets 101.
The N100 amplitude may help us understand basic elemental mechanisms of brain function in SCZspect. In a previous study, we found positive associations between AC thickness and N100 amplitude in SCZspect, suggesting that a common neural substrate may underlie AC thickness and N100 amplitude alterations 61. Based on these previous findings, as well as on a growing literature indicating myelination abnormalities in SCZspect 107–114, we here aimed to examine whether myelination in AC may play a role in this association. Myelination plays an important role in spike synchrony 115. Thus, impaired myelination of pyramidal neurons in the AC could lead to abnormal neural synchrony and altered auditory processing, reflected by reduced N100 amplitude in SCZspect 16,116. Based on the assumption of altered myelination and altered synchronization of auditory pyramidal neurons in SCZspect, we expected to find reduced N100 amplitude and decreased T1w/T2w-ratio in AC in SCZspect and an association between reduced N100 amplitude and decreased T1w/T2w-ratio. However, in the current study N100 amplitude and T1w/T2w-ratio did not differ significantly between patients and controls and N100 amplitude was not associated with T1w/T2w-ratio in any groups. Thus, our findings did not support the hypothesis that altered myelination in the AC1/AC2, indexed by T1w/T2w-ratio, underlies N100 abnormalities in SCZspect. However, it has been questioned to what degree T1w/T2w-ratio measures myelin. In one combined MRI and post-mortem study of patients with MS, the T1w/T2w-ratio correlated with dendritic density rather than myelin density 42. Furthermore, while a high spatial correlation with cortical myelination was demonstrated by Glasser et al. (2014) 117, recent studies have reported lower correlations with indices of myelin in white matter 118,119, which shows that the T1w/T2w-ratio is a complex signal and not a quantitative marker of myelin content only. While the current findings point towards a lack of association between N100 amplitude and T1w/T2w-ratio in SCZspect, we cannot exclude altered myelination in the AC as a neural substrate for N100 amplitude reduction as previously reported in these disorders. To fully understand how myelination in the AC may relate to N100 amplitude in SCZspect, we need more precise measures of intracortical myelin. In theory, although speculative, another way to investigate the relationship between N100 amplitude and myelination in the AC may be combining intracortical EEG examinations with postmortem examination of myelin content in the AC. However, this method is hampered by ethical and technical challenges. Therefore, a combination of EEG and MRI measures acquired in vivo is more feasible.
Other factors than altered myelination, indexed by T1w/T2w-ratio, may explain reduced N100 amplitude in SCZspect. At this point we can only speculate what neural substrate may underly reduced N100 amplitude and thus altered function of AC pyramidal cells in SCZspect. Altered synaptic pruning 120,121 resulting in reduced dendritic spine density on cortical pyramidal neurons 122,123, is part of the pathogenesis of SCZspect. Reduced dendritic spine density on AC pyramidal cells (and interneurons) may result in desynchronized firing, a decreased summation of postsynaptic potentials and thus in reduced N100 amplitude in SCZspect 116,124. Further, excessive synaptic pruning in the AC in SCZspect may lead to impaired neural communication in cortical areas involved in auditory processing and may result in auditory hallucinations 125–127. Of note, these two alternative potential mechanisms are consistent with our previous finding of an association between AC cortical thickness and N100 amplitude in SCZspect 61. While the current study focused on cortical structures, deeper subcortical white matter may be associated with N100 amplitude.
Few studies have investigated the effect of APs on N100 amplitude and findings are inconclusive 128–130. APs commonly used to treat SCZspect have high affinity to the dopamine D2 receptor and to the 5-hydroxytryptamine 2 A receptor 131. Thus, APs may influence N100 amplitude either directly by having effect on neural generators of the N100 or indirectly by decreasing symptoms in SCZspect 128,132. Studies investigating correlations between the dose of APs and N100 amplitude are inconclusive 133,134. Further, one study has shown no effect of APs on the gray/white-matter contrast along the cortical surface 135. To conclude, longitudinal studies investigating N100 amplitude and myelination in individuals with SCZspect before and after starting on APs are needed to untangle the exact effect of APs on N100 amplitude and myelination.
Some limitations should be considered when interpreting the current findings. As mentioned above, while the T1w/T2w-ratio is spatially correlated with myelination of the cortex, it is not a direct measure of myelin content. Second, the small sample of SCZspect is an issue, although the study was hypothesis-driven and focusing on specific regions of interest, limiting the number of tests. Further, the way that we generated AEPs, using a small number of trials instead of what is typically recommended for AEPs is unusual. However, after visual inspection of AEPs, we found that the relatively strong stimulus intensity and the long ISI did elicit robust and large-amplitude AEPs as described by others 68. Strengths of this study include the use of multimodal imaging (EEG and MRI), a sample of clinically well characterized participants, rigorous quality control and assessment of sex differences.
In conclusion, our results are consistent with previous findings of reduced N100 amplitude in SCZspect although the finding was restricted to males only. We did not find altered T1w-T2w-ratio within AC in SCZspect compared to HC and found no associations between the N100 amplitude and T1w-T2w-ratio. More precise estimates of intracortical myelin in the AC and larger patient samples are needed to disentangle whether altered myelination explains N100 amplitude reduction in SCZspect.