Background and rationale
Trauma to the head is common in many contact sports, not least in boxing (1). If the trauma to the head, or to the body with energy transmitted to the head, is sufficient to inducea range of clinical symptoms and signs that may or may not involve loss of consciousness, a sport-related concussion (SRC) has occurred (2). In boxing, both participants receive, and deliver, numerous blows to the head during a typical bout. These repeated head impacts may not cause acute symptoms sufficient to reach the diagnostic criteria for an SRC, and are often named subconcussive impacts. These subconcussive head impacts may induce a brain injury and are considered a potential cause of impaired brain function at short- and long term (3). The neuropathological consequences of repeated SRC have been comprehensively investigated in previous studies, illustrating that repeated head impacts can cause structural and functional alterations to the brain (2)(4).
Similarly, repeated head impacts may lead to, e.g., cognitive impairment, mood disorders, and motor control problems as suggested not only in boxing but also in soccer heading (5)(6). The long-term consequences of SRC, which include, e.g., an increased risk of neurodegenerative disorders such as Alzheimer´s disease, are increasingly recognized (2). Several studies have shown that retired athletes who have sustained multiple SRC during their career may develop chronic traumatic encephalopathy (CTE), a progressive neurodegenerative disease associated with memory loss, depression, personality changes, and dementia (6)(7)(8)(1)(9)(10). At present, CTE can only be diagnosed post-mortem where key findings include irregular aggregation of phosphorylated tau protein at the depths of cortical sulci (6).
In sports, the strenuous exercise leads to elevated core body- and brain- temperature (11), which may exacerbate brain injury induced by head impacts. Recently, we showed that selective head-and-neck cooling, aiming to rapidly normalize the elevated brain temperature, applied acutely post-SRC in elite ice hockey players resulted in earlier return-to-play and a smaller proportion of players with prolonged symptoms following the SRC (12). However, there is a lack of objective outcome measures for assessing the effects of head-and-neck cooling in athletes.
There is a growing body of literature on the use of biomarkers of brain injury in athletes. In Olympic boxers, levels of cerebrospinal fluid biomarkers such as S100B, Tau, NFL and GFAP were collected at baseline, 1-6 days post-fight and after 14 days after repetitive head impacts attained in a boxing bout. The biomarkers showed both acute and cumulative effect of the impacts, with a lack of normalization of NFL and GFAP after the rest period, which may indicate an ongoing injury process (13). Inflammatory and muscle injury biomarkers were also increased in male elite boxers following a fight (14). When boxing and mixed martial art (MMA) were compared, retired boxers had a higher GFAP levels, and active boxers higher NFL than MMA fighters (15). In addition, serum NFL levels were elevated both at 7-10 days post bout and after 3 months of rest in boxers (16). These studies indicate that selected biomarkers may remain elevated during the 1st post-injury week. In this randomized trial, we hypothesized that biomarkers may be a surrogate yet objective marker for the efficacy of selective head-and-neck cooling on attenuating brain injury in elite boxers, assessed by blood biomarkers immediately prior to and during the first 6 days after a competitive boxing fight.
Objectives
Research hypothesis: Acute and selective head-and-neck cooling immediately after a boxing bout attenuated brain injury as evident by a reduced release of brain injury-related biomarker levels during the 1st post-fight week.
Study objectives.
Primary objective: To determine whether selective head-and-neck cooling attenuates the release of brain injury biomarkers.
Secondary objectives:
– To determine whether selective head-and-neck cooling improves symptom rating using the Sports Concussion Assessment tool- 5 (SCAT-5).
– To determine whether any biomarker increase post-fight, compared to baseline levels, is associated with the number of head impacts
- To determine any adverse event associated with the head-and-neck cooling
Trial design
The head-and-neck Cooling of Brain temperature In BOXing (COBIBOX) trial is designed as a randomized, controlled, open, single-center superiority trial with two parallel groups and a primary endpoint of biomarker changes during the first 6 post-fight days.
Clinical secondary outcome assessments of number of symptoms (NOS) and symptom severity score (SSS) using the symptom rating part of the of the SCAT-5 during the initial six post-injury days.
Randomization will be performed in blocks with 1:1 allocation.
Methods: participants, interventions, and outcomes
Study setting:
The study will take part predominately in southern parts of Sweden due to logistic reasons, aiming for feasibility of follow up with biomarkers at distinct post-fight time points. Blood samples will be collected at the site of the competitive boxing tournament or at the local boxing clubs and transferred to the biobank at Lund University Hospital. All data will be collected in Sweden.
The trial is academically driven by local funding. The trial will be conducted at
Lund University, Lund, Sweden.
Eligibility criteria
Inclusion criteria:
- Male and female elite boxers ≥18 years old
- Cleared for participation by the medical staff of the Swedish Boxing Association.
- Informed consent by each participant prior to the competitive event
- No boxing fights or match sparring during the initial 6 days after their last boxing fight
- Signed informed consent.
Exclusion criteria:
1.> 40 years old or < 18 years old
2. Participation in competitive fights, match-sparring or any training causing additional head impacts during the first six post-fight days after being included in the study.
3. History of autoimmune neurological diseases or a neurodegenerative disorder.
4. History of previous traumatic brain injury resulting in an intracranial haemorrhage.