29 patients met criteria for the study with mean age of 60 (± 14) years and median age of 61 years. 59% were men, 90% were white and 10% were Black. 83% were lower extremity ALI rather than upper extremity ALI. 8 (28%) were due to PAD, 7 (24%) were due to embolus from a cardiac source, 8 (28%) were iatrogenic from a procedure or surgery, and 6 (21%) were due to a hypercoagulable state. 18 (62%) patients had a threatened limb (Rutherford ALI 2a or 2b). Mean and median time to heparin drip was 17.5 hours (range 0.4-153.6 hours) and 8.6 hours, respectively. Mean and median time to definitive treatment was 23.8 hours (range 0.4-184.6 hours) and 8.6 hours, respectively. See Table 1.
Table 1
Summary of Demographics, Clinical Factors, and Outcome divided between the group with adverse outcome and the group with no adverse outcome.
|
Adverse Outcome
|
No Adverse Outcome
|
Total
|
P
|
Number of patients
|
19, 65.5%
|
10, 34.5%
|
29
|
N/A
|
Age years Mean (SD)
|
61 (13)
|
57 (20)
|
60 (14)
|
0.4789
|
Age years (Median)
|
66
|
57
|
63
|
|
Male
|
10, 52.6%
|
7, 70.0%
|
17, 58.6%
|
0.3743
|
White Race
|
16, 84.2%
|
10, 100.0%
|
26, 89.7%
|
0.1921
|
Black Race
|
3, 15.8%
|
0, 0.0%
|
3, 10.3%
|
0.1921
|
Genitourinary Cancer
|
3, 15.8%
|
3, 30.0%
|
6, 20.7%
|
0.3780
|
Gastrointestinal Cancer
|
5, 26.3%
|
4, 40.0%
|
9, 31.0%
|
0.4564
|
Gynecologic Cancer
|
1, 5.2%
|
0, 0.0%
|
1, 3.4%
|
0.4709
|
Breast Cancer
|
1, 5.2%
|
0, 0.0%
|
1, 3.4%
|
0.4709
|
Head and Neck Cancer
|
1, 5.2%
|
0, 0.0%
|
1, 3.4%
|
0.4709
|
Thoracic (lung, mesothelioma)
|
3, 15.8%
|
0, 0.0%
|
3, 10.3%
|
0.1921
|
Hematologic cancer
|
1, 5.2%
|
2, 20.0%
|
3, 10.3%
|
0.2208
|
Bone/soft tissue sarcoma
|
3, 15.8%
|
0, 0.0%
|
3, 10.3%
|
0.1921
|
Skin cancer
|
1, 5.2%
|
1, 10.0%
|
2, 6.9%
|
0.6328
|
Stage 1
|
3, 15.8%
|
4, 40.0%
|
7, 24.1%
|
0.1550
|
Stage 2
|
2, 10.5%
|
1, 10.0%
|
3, 10.3%
|
0.9670
|
Stage 3
|
3, 15.8%
|
0, 0.0%
|
3, 10.3%
|
0.1921
|
Stage 4
|
11, 57.9%
|
5, 50.0%
|
16, 55.2%
|
0.6895
|
Active chemotherapy
|
7, 36.8%
|
2, 20.0%
|
9, 31.0%
|
0.3610
|
Active prothrombotic chemotherapy
|
2, 10.5%
|
1, 10.0%
|
3, 10.3%
|
0.9670
|
Active immunotherapy
|
4, 21.1%
|
0, 0.0%
|
4, 13.8%
|
0.1242
|
Active radiation therapy
|
2, 10.5%
|
0, 0.0%
|
2, 6.9%
|
0.2968
|
Clonal Hematopoiesis of Indeterminate Potential
|
1, 5.2%
|
1, 10.0%
|
2, 6.9%
|
0.6328
|
Diabetes
|
6, 31.5%
|
4, 40.0%
|
10, 34.5%
|
0.6528
|
Hypertension
|
11, 57.9%
|
7, 70.0%
|
18, 62.1%
|
0.5305
|
Hyperlipidemia
|
6, 31.5%
|
4, 40.0%
|
10, 34.5%
|
0.6528
|
Chronic kidney disease
|
5, 26.3%
|
2, 20.0%
|
7, 24.1%
|
0.7111
|
Coronary artery disease
|
7, 36.8%
|
1, 10.0%
|
8, 27.6%
|
0.1314
|
Cerebrovascular disease
|
0, 0.0%
|
0, 0.0%
|
0, 0.0%
|
-----
|
Peripheral arterial disease
|
7, 36.8%
|
3, 30.0%
|
10, 34.5%
|
0.7189
|
Obesity
|
5, 26.3%
|
3, 30.0%
|
8, 27.6%
|
0.8350
|
Atrial fibrillation or other cardiac dysarrythmia
|
6, 31.5%
|
0, 0.0%
|
6, 20.7%
|
0.0503
|
Smoking
|
7, 36.8%
|
5, 50.0%
|
12, 41.4%
|
0.4803
|
Anti-platelet therapy
|
5, 26.3%
|
1, 10.0%
|
6, 20.7%
|
0.3114
|
Statin therapy
|
2, 10.5%
|
2, 20.0%
|
4, 13.8%
|
0.4881
|
Anticoagulation therapy
|
3, 15.8%
|
0, 0.0%
|
3, 10.3%
|
0.1921
|
Anticoagulation indicated but held/not taken leading up to ALI
|
7, 36.8%
|
0, 0.0%
|
7, 24.1%
|
0.0305
|
Lower extremity ALI (verses upper extremity) n, %
|
16, 84.2%
|
8, 80.0%
|
24, 82.8%
|
0.7798
|
Cause of ALI: Embolic n, %
|
6, 31.6%
|
1, 10.0%
|
7, 24.1%
|
0.2043
|
Cause of ALI: Hypercoaguable State n, %
|
5, 26.3%
|
1, 10.0%
|
6, 20.7%
|
0.3114
|
Cause of ALI: Iatrogenic n, %
|
3, 15.8%
|
5, 50.0%
|
8, 27.6%
|
0.0543
|
Cause of ALI: PAD n, %
|
5, 26.3%
|
3, 30.0%
|
8, 27.6%
|
0.8350
|
Threatened limb (Rutherford ALI 2a and 2b)
|
13, 68.4%
|
5, 50.0%
|
18, 62.1%
|
0.3402
|
Atypical or confounded presentation, n, %
|
9, 47.4%
|
4, 40.0%
|
13, 44.8%
|
0.7082
|
Pulses NOT documented
|
9, 47.4%
|
3, 30.0%
|
12, 41.4%
|
0.3743
|
Patients with services other than vascular specialist consulted
|
7, 36.8%
|
1, 10.0%
|
8, 27.6%
|
0.1314
|
Time to Heparin intravenous (initial treatment) Hours Mean (SD), range
|
23.6 (39.4), 1.0-153.6
|
5.9 (6.8),
0.4–20.4
|
17.5 (33.8), 0.4–153.6
|
0.1845
|
Time to Heparin intravenous (initial treatment) Hours Median
|
10.1
|
2.4
|
8.6
|
-----
|
Time to Definitive treatment Hours Mean (SD), range
|
23.0 (39.7), 1.0-153.6
|
25.1( 55.9), 0.4-184.6
|
23.8 (45.8), 0.4–184.6
|
0.9112
|
Time to Definitive treatment Hours Median
|
8.8
|
5.5
|
8.6
|
-----
|
Heparin initiated ≥ 6 hours from presentation
|
16, 84.2%
|
3, 30.0%
|
19, 65.5%
|
0.0041
|
NOT eligible for ALI Standard of Care n, %
|
12, 63.2%
|
0, 0.0%
|
12, 41.4%
|
0.0013
|
Death in follow up period n, %
|
12, 63.2%
|
1, 10.0%
|
13, 44.8%
|
0.0071
|
Death in 3 months n, %
|
12, 63.2%
|
0, 0.0%
|
12, 41.4%
|
0.0013
|
Death within 1 month n, %
|
9, 47.4%
|
N/A
|
9, 31.0%
|
N/A
|
ALI-related cause of death n, %
|
6, 31.6%
|
N/A
|
6, 46.1%
|
N/A
|
Cancer-related cause of death n, %
|
4, 21.1%
|
1, 10.0%
|
5, 38.4%
|
0.4602
|
Cardiac arrest from Myocardial Infarction as cause of death n, %
|
2, 10.5%
|
0, 0.0%
|
2, 15.4%
|
0.2968
|
Amputation n, %
|
2, 10.5%
|
N/A
|
2, 6.8%
|
N/A
|
Lifestyle-limiting claudication n, %
|
5, 26.3%
|
N/A
|
5, 17.2%
|
N/A
|
Critical limb ischemia, n, %
|
3, 15.8%
|
N/A
|
3, 10.3%
|
N/A
|
Mean (SD) Follow up, months
|
6 (14)
|
24 (15)
|
12 (17)
|
0.0075
|
Median Follow up, months
|
2
|
21
|
3
|
-----
|
Mean follow up for the entire cohort was 12 months ± 17 months, with median follow up of 3 months. In the follow up period 13 (45%) patients died, with 12 (41%) patients dying within 3 months of ALI diagnosis and 9 (31%) dying within 1 month of ALI diagnosis. Immediate causes of death were ALI-related (6, 46%), cancer-related (5, 38%), and cardiac arrest from a Myocardial Infarction (2, 15%). See Table 1.
Out of all 29 patients, only 9 (31%) were alive without adverse outcome in the follow up period. One patient died within the study period from cancer and did not have adverse ALI outcome. Those with classified adverse outcome (19, 65%) included – 9 (31%) dying within 30 days, 2 (7%) with an amputation, 5 (17%) with lifestyle-limiting claudication, and 3 (10%) with critical limb ischemia with wound ulceration or gangrene (Table 1).
Between the group with adverse outcome and the group with no adverse outcome, there were statistically significant differences in number of patients with anticoagulation being held/not taken leading up to ALI (adverse outcome group 36.8% vs no adverse outcome group 0.0%, p = 0.0305), heparin being administered ≥ 6 hours from presentation (adverse outcome group 84.2% vs no adverse outcome group 30.0%, p = 0.0041), number of patients not eligible for standard of care (adverse outcome group 63.2% vs. no adverse outcome group 0.0%, p = 0.0013), death in the follow up period (adverse outcome group 63.2% vs. no adverse outcome 10.0%, p = 0.0071), and death within 3 months (adverse outcome group 63.2% vs. no adverse outcome 0.0%, p = 0.0013). Follow up was shorter in the adverse outcome group compared to the no adverse outcome group (6 months vs. 24 months, p = 0.0075) consistent with the large amount of deaths in the adverse outcome group. All other factors (outside the definition of adverse outcome), including type of cancer, stage of cancer, cancer therapy, prothrombotic chemotherapy, comorbidities, the use of antiplatelet therapy, statin therapy, or anticoagulation were not statistically different between both groups. See Table 1.
Patients with hypercoagulable state were at increased risk of death within 1 month (RR 3.0667 95% CI [1.1743–8.0085], p = 0.0221). Patients NOT eligible for standard of care (RR 2.3333 95% CI [1.2743–4.2724], p = 0.0022) and heparin administration ≥ 6 hours (RR 2.8070 [1.0677–7.3795], p = 0.0364) from presentation were at increased risk of adverse outcome.
In univariate analysis, Heparin started ≥ 6 hours from presentation was a predictor for adverse outcome with 12 times greater odds for adverse outcome than patients with heparin administered < 6 hours (OR 12.4444 [95% CI 1.996–77.600], p = 0.0069) (Table 2). Atypical or confounded presentation (RR 1.8367 95% CI [1.0266–3.2862], p = 0.0405), pulse exam not documented (RR 1.9479 [95% CI [1.1439–3.3169], p = 0.0141), and services other than a vascular specialist consulted, (RR 1.9091 95% CI [1.2698–2.8703], p = 0.0019) were significant risk factors for heparin started ≥ 6 hours from presentation (Table 3).
Table 2
Prognostic variables for adverse outcome in a logistic regression model.
|
OR
|
95% CI
|
P (univariate)
|
P (multivariate)
|
Cause of ALI: Embolus
|
4.1538
|
0.4243–40.6627
|
0.2211
|
|
Cause of ALI: Hypercoaguable state
|
3.2143
|
0.3208–32.2076
|
0.3207
|
|
Cause of ALI: Iatrogenic
|
0.1875
|
0.0326–1.0774
|
0.0606
|
|
Cause of ALI: PAD
|
0.8333
|
0.1530–4.5376
|
0.8330
|
|
Threatened Limb
|
2.1667
|
0.4497–10.4393
|
0.3352
|
|
Not eligible for ALI standard of care
|
35.0000
|
1.7813-687.7111
|
0.9980
|
|
Heparin administration
≥ 6 hours
|
12.4444
|
1.996–77.600
|
0.0069
|
0.9984
|
Table 3
Risk and significance of variables leading to administration of heparin ≥ 6 hours from presentation.
|
Relative Risk
|
95% CI
|
P
|
Atypical or confounded presentation
|
1.8367
|
1.0266–3.2862
|
0.0405
|
Pulse not documented
|
1.9479
|
1.1439–3.3169
|
0.0141
|
Other services consulted
|
1.9091
|
1.2698–2.8703
|
0.0019
|
In the studied population, only 16 (55%) of patients had a typical presentation of ALI (Table 1). The other 13 (45%) patients presented with confounding signs and symptoms such as cancer-related pain such as back and radicular pain from retroperitoneal and spine metastatic involvement (4, one patient also with unrelated rash in the ipsilateral limb), post-surgical pain (2, one patient also with unrelated cellulitis in the ipsilateral limb), unrelated fever with pneumonia (1), unrelated severe shortness of breath from pulmonary embolus or CHF exacerbation (2), generalized weakness and dizziness due to advanced disease state/failure to thrive (1), unable to communicate symptoms due to unconsciousness (1), and small bowel obstruction with nausea/vomiting resulting in hypovolemia and arterial thrombosis in the setting of PAD (2).
12 (41%) patients did not have pulse exam documented at the time of presentation. In addition, 8 (28%) patients had referrals placed to other services such as Neurology, Pain, or Rheumatology Service before the diagnosis of ALI was considered and referral placed for a Vascular Specialist with the ability to treat ALI. See Table 1.