We develop a category of STMC for all-year-round building heating and cooling energy savings, as illustrated in Fig. 1a. STMC demonstrates reflection characteristic to minimizes solar heat gain in the solar radiation (SR) wavelength range (mainly 0.25 to 2.5 µm). In thermal infrared wavelength ranges, in winter, it is a low emissivity state, suppressing the thermal emissions from building out-surfaces. And in summer, it demonstrates a high emissivity state to boost the radiative cooling with outer environments.
We developed the STMC based on bilayer construction with pillar pore structure solar reflector as upper, the periodic columnar arrangement VO2 thermal emissivity modulation coating as lower. The solar reflectance and emissivity switching of STMC were investigated via FDTD. The micro- and nanopores in the solar reflector of STMC efficiently backscatter sunlight at any temperature (Fig. 1b). For the thermal emissivity modulation coating of STMC, when T is below TMIT, the VO2 columns are in the insulating state38, most of the IR radiation is reflected by the Al, resulting in a high reflectance. When T is above TMIT, VO2 switches to the metallic state, two neighboring VO2 columns will form an optical antenna39, giving rise to high absorptance in the mid-IR (Fig. 1c).
A phase separation process was developed for the production of STMC, as illustrated in Fig. 2a. In brief, VO2/PAN precursor (upper side of Fig. 2a), inorganic nanoparticles/PAN precursor (lower side of Fig. 2a) were formed by coating, and the precursors were immersed in deionized water to phase separation, transfer inorganic nanoparticles/PAN layer to VO2/PAN layer in water 40, dry naturally to obtain STMC. The optical photos and SEM morphology of the prepared STMCs are shown in Fig. 2b. Inorganic nanoparticle zinc oxide (ZnO), iron oxide (Fe2O3) and chromium oxide (Cr2O3) are utilized to generate primary colors (white, red, and green, respectively). The solar reflector is filled with pillar pore, as shown in the cross-sectional SEM. The pillar pore is 21 µm in height and 4 µm in diameter, as shown in Fig. 2c. The pores of the thermal emissivity modulation coating are blocked by the upper PAN, and the vanadium oxide in coating is still arranged in an isolated column, with 1.23 µm intervals, which is similar to the VO2 photonic structure 26. EDS elemental mappings of a cross section of the as-prepared ZnO-based STMC show that the Zinc oxide nanoparticles well dispersed in pillar hole wall (Fig. 2d), which effectively enhances the refractive index difference between air holes and hole walls, improving the scattering of solar light by STMC.
To investigate the influence of the pillar pore structure on the optical properties of the solar reflector, we further compared dense coatings (left column) obtained by directly solution coating with pillar pore structured coatings (right column) obtained by phase separation, as shown by the SEM images in Fig. 3a–c. Solar reflector with pillar pore presents the high average solar reflectance in UV-Vis-NIR wavelengths, while dense structure of the solar reflector shape drops to a low average solar reflectance in the near-to-short wavelength infrared range (0.25–2.5 µm) because only these inorganic nanoparticles are too small to effectively scatter such wavelengths. (Fig. 3d). The periodic structure with nano/microscale pillar pores is conducive to enhance the total scattering efficiency.
Figure 3e shows that the solar reflector with or without pillar pore show high transparency in the mid-IR region. Because PAN was composed of only aliphatic C-C and C-H bond and was IR transparent. The inorganic solids include chromium oxide (Cr2O3), iron oxide (Fe2O3), and zinc oxide (ZnO) with particle sizes of 100–300 nm, as shown in Figure S6a. This sub-microscale dimension is much smaller than the atmospheric transparent window 8–13 µm; almost no strongly scattering occurred for MIR infrared light. Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) spectroscopy (Figure S6b) illustrates that these inorganic solids have negligible absorbance in atmospheric transparent window. Compared with dense structure, the pillar hole structure slightly improves the transmittance of the solar reflector through the atmospheric transparent window. The presence of large holes permits direct transmission of partial MIR light, thereby mitigating the energy loss associated with light passing through the coating.
STMC efficiently reflects the incident solar radiation at any temperature. And STMC presents a low emission state at low temperature and a high emission state at high temperature, which is consistent with the working mechanism of the VO2 inter-pillar photonic resonance 26 (Fig. 4a). The VO2/PAN thermal emissivity modulation coating with pillar hole structure, achieved comparable modulation performance (Δεsky = 0.55) with a VO2 concentration of 10% (Fig. 4b). By using ZnO (white), Fe2O3 (red), and Cr2O3 (green), we are able to broadly tune the color and solar reflectance of a STMC (Fig. 4C). The mid-IR spectral emissivity of the colored STMCs at both low and high temperatures was measured by FTIR spectroscopy (Figure S8), showing an evident insensitivity to the solar reflector added. εsky and solar reflectance were calculated and shown in Fig. 4d. The VO2/PAN thermal emissivity modulation coating exhibits only 7.16% reflectance; the bilayer coatings (STMC) in white, red, and green colors show 85.92%, 44.30%, 36.52% reflectance in SR, respectively. The colorful coating not only maintains the aesthetic effect, but also provides additional thermal modulation.
Table 1
Comparison of representative radiative cooling technologies
Representative Materials | Working principle | Δε > 0.45 | %R > 85% | color | Low cost |
Pigment/VO2/Al (This Work) | Optical micro cavity | √ | √ | √ | √ |
Pigments/VO2/PE/Al 26 | Optical antenna array | √ | | √ | √ |
CaF2@VO225 | core − shell structured | | | | |
VO2/PMMA/ITO/glass 24 | F-P resonator | | | | |
VO2/BaF2/Ag 27 | F-P resonator | √ | | | |
P(VdF-HFP)HP 12 | porosity | | √ | | √ |
cellulose nanofibers 41 | regularly arranged fiber | | | | |
Pigment/PE/Al 30 | Dense layer | | √ | √ | √ |
Pigment/Al 29 | Dense layer | | √ | √ | √ |
Silica particles/PP, Ag/Cu Zn/Cu 42 | Temperature shape memory effect | | | | √ |
HfO2 / SiO243 | Multilayer structure | | √ | | |
TiO210 | Hierarchical porous | | √ | | √ |
The comprehensive performance of current state-of-the-art radiative cooling technologies is summarized in Table 1. The STMC prepared by phase separation process in this work exhibits very high solar reflectance and high modulation of thermal emittance, surpassing most of the reported results in Table 1.
Owing to the installation flexibility and versatility, our STMC are suitable to be used in warehouses for cold chain storage without adding extra weight and volume. As shown in Fig. 5a, two warehouse models with testing surface (upper) by commercial white wall coating (CWP) and ZnO based STMC were placed in cold environment (13.2°C) and an infrared baking lamp was used to radiate the CWP/STMC. Figure 5b shows the changes in ice mass during the testing process. It was observed that STMC can significantly slow down the ice melting speed. Storage of 50g of ice cubes in two warehouses, at the end of the test, the mass of ice cubes inside warehouse with STMC was 12.56g, while the mass of ice cubes inside CWP warehouse was 0g. Figure 5c exhibits the photographs of ice cubes before and after the 160 min testing period. It indicates that a great amount of cooling energy or phase change materials for temperature maintenance can be saved during storage. The experiment verifies that the high solar reflectance and emittance modulation of STMC can effectively alleviate radiative heat gain from the ambient.
The EnergyPlus software was used to calculate potential HVAC energy savings in midrise apartment buildings in cities along the Yangtze River, based on applying the STMC to walls, as shown in Fig. 5d. In cities with latitude 31, in terms of the HAVC, the use of STMC saves 1.12 tons of coal per year compared to TARC 27 (Fig. 5e). In cities with latitude 29, in terms of the HAVC, the use of STMC saves 2.28, 3.29, 3.42 tons of coal per year compared to PEAC 26, TARC 27, coloured low-emissivity films30, respectively (Fig. 5e). In cities with latitude 25, in terms of building cooling, the use of STMC saves 2.69 tons of coal per year compared to color low-emission radiation cooling coating29 (Figure S7a); in terms of the HAVC, the use of STMC saves 9.31, 6.74 tons of coal per year compared to TARC 27, PEAC 26, respectively (Fig. 5e). In cities with latitude between 19 and 22, in terms of building heating, the use of STMC saves 1.15 tons of coal per year compared to color low-emission radiation cooling coating29 (Figure S7b). Installation of STMC can achieve positive total HVAC energy savings penalties through high emittance modulation and solar reflectance, providing a comprehensive year-round energy-saving solution suitable for various regions.