The age range of 20 to 70 was chosen to focus on adults most susceptible to SD and ensure generalizability, excluding those under 20 due to lower SD prevalence and those over 70 due to increased comorbidities and polypharmacy, which could confound the result. Patients with mixed SD were also excluded to clearly define non-organic or organic SD and investigate specific TCM and cardiovascular associations.
This groundbreaking study explores whether TCM heightens the risk of MACE in SD patients. Initially, the risk of MACE rises with short-term TCM use (< 28 days, < 360 grams) but diminishes with continued use. Possible explanations include the body's adaptation and tolerance to the herbs, dosage adjustments, or discontinuation due to side effects. Furthermore, the bidirectional regulatory effects of TCM should be considered regarding cumulative dose and duration [11]. Common kidney-tonifying herbs for male SD, such as Epimedium Leaf (Yin-Yang-Huo, EPIMEDII FOLIUM) [12], Eucommia Bark (Du-Zhong, EUCOMMIAE CORTEX) [13], Morinda Root (Ba-Ji-Tian, MORINDAE OFFICINALIS RADIX) [14], and Desert-living Cistanche (Rou-Cong-Rong, CISTANCHIS HERBA) may temporarily affect blood pressure and vasoconstriction [15], potentially increasing the risk of ischemic stroke but not hemorrhagic stroke, as observed in this study. Similarly, Ginseng Root (Ren-Shen, GINSENG RADIX ET RHIZOME), when used as an aphrodisiac, may elevate blood pressure and cause palpitations; however, long-term use can alleviate hypertension [16, 17]. Nevertheless, prolonged usage of these herbs has shown cardiovascular and neuroprotective benefits, leading to reduced cardiovascular risk [18–21].
The influence of testosterone-like TCM on cardiovascular risk is another aspect to consider. Although the effect of testosterone replacement therapy on cardiovascular disease remains uncertain [22], some TCM herbs like Ginseng Root, Epimedium Leaf, Morinda Root, and Desert-living Cistanche are believed to have androgen-like properties, potentially boosting testosterone levels [14, 16, 23]. However, these herbs could elevate blood pressure, increasing cardiovascular risk [24]. This aligns with our finding that hypertensive patients face a higher risk of MACE when using TCM. Recent research also indicates a potential increase in intracranial bleeding and the risk of MACE associated with SSRIs [25, 26], contrary to previous beliefs about their cardioprotective benefits [27]. Table 3 illustrates a significant increase in the risk of MACE among patients using both TCM and SSRIs compared to those not using TCM (aHR: 1.24). Further investigation is needed to determine if TCM interacts with SSRIs, affecting blood pressure, heart rate, or coagulation function. In addition, patients in the TCM group might use Western medicine alongside or switch to TCM due to unsatisfactory results with Western treatment, potentially indicating more severe cardiovascular conditions and a higher initial risk of MACE.
This study has several strengths aimed at minimizing potential biases. A disparity in cardiovascular risk was observed between the non-TCM and TCM groups among the 2 million samples examined. For instance, Table 2 reveals that the TCM group had a 1.07 times higher risk of MACE than the non-TCM group, regardless of whether they had a SD diagnosis. Table 4 further shows that individuals without confirmed SD had a 1.06-fold increased risk of MACE when using TCM compared to non-TCM users. For those with SD, the TCM group had a 1.23 times higher risk of MACEs than the non-TCM group, particularly among those with organic SD (aHR: 1.24). These findings indicate an elevated cardiovascular risk in the TCM group. To address information bias, previous research indicates that NHIRD is highly accurate in identifying ischemic stroke, making it a valuable resource for cardiovascular disease research [28, 29]. Given that Taiwanese individuals tend to be cautious about discussing SD, a diagnosis should carry high diagnostic validity. To avoid research design bias, we carefully matched the cohorts to balance their demographics and conducted stratified analyses, ensuring no significant differences between groups and affirming our conclusions' robustness. We also applied strict criteria to exclude neurological or major psychiatric disorders related to SD and unmeasured confounders, such as pelvic surgery, prostate disease, cancer [30, 31], multiple sclerosis, spinal cord injury, schizophrenia [32], dementia, and Peyronie's disease, ensuring a rigorous screening process consistent with real-world epidemiological analyses.
The disparities in risk between non-organic SD and organic SD require clarification. Organic SD is closely associated with cardiovascular disease, increasing the risk of MACE. Potential cardiovascular risks from PDE5Is, amides, SSRIs, and TCM used to treat SD are not well-explored. Our study examined if these medications raise cardiovascular risk alone or in combination. Encouragingly, we found that TCM and nitrate medications did not increase the risk of MACE (aHR: 0.93, 95% CI: 0.88–0.99, P < 0.05). Previous research has suggested that combining SSRIs with TCM may be effective in treating PE, but its safety remains uncertain [33]. Our investigation revealed that combining SSRIs with TCM significantly raised the risk of MACE (aHR: 1.24, 95% CI: 1.02–1.5, P < 0.05), highlighting the need for further investigation.
This study has several limitations. Firstly, Taiwan's National Health Insurance does not cover variables such as illegal substance dependence/abuse, nicotine dependence, and medications like PDE5Is and amide sprays, which require out-of-pocket payments. Consequently, the limited number of cases makes it challenging to accurately represent the population, and it's impossible to determine the hazards of combining TCM with these pharmaceuticals. Secondly, Taiwan's NHIRD lacks laboratory data or medical records, including the International Index of Erectile Function-5 (IIEF-5) and testosterone levels, making it difficult to ascertain the severity of SD. It's hypothesized that the severity of ED in the TCM group, dissatisfied with Western medicine treatment within 28 days, may be more profound. SD severity correlates with the vascular endothelium, increasing cardiovascular risk. Thirdly, while our analysis goes beyond previous NHIRD studies by controlling for most potential confounders, especially drug interactions, the observational nature of this study hinders understanding the direct harmful consequences of TCM use based on medical records. Explicitly inferring a causal association between individual TCM and cardiovascular risk is challenging. Therefore, we explored alternative explanations for our findings, such as endothelial dysfunction and an initial increase in blood pressure following TCM treatment. People with SD often worry about their sexual performance, leading to over-the-counter pharmaceuticals and excessive use of TCM, which are identified as potential reasons for elevated cardiovascular risk.