Having epidemiological data on the frequency and spectrum of germline PV/LPVs associated with different hereditary cancers is of the utmost importance for every country aiming to organize an optimal cancer prevention programme and optimize cancer patients’ management. In the Slovene population, data on the occurrence of germline PV/LPVs in BRCA1 and BRCA2 genes and the clinicopathological characteristics of malignancies in those patients, have already been reported (20). Additionally, the spectrum of BRCA1 and BRCA2 PV/LPVs in male breast cancer patients, and characteristics of breast cancer patients with CHEK2 PV/LPVs have been studied (Besic et al. 2008; Krajc et al. 2014; Cvelbar et al. 2017; Nizic-Kos et al. 2021). PALB2 is one of the most common HBOC-related genes, found in approximately 1% of BRCA1/2 negative BC patients (Wu et al. 2020; Woodward et al. 2021) and is highly penetrant (Yang et al. 2020b). Nevertheless, very little is known about the characteristics of carriers of PALB2 PV/LPVs and the clinicopathological characteristics of tumors diagnosed in these patients. This gap in knowledge underscores the importance of further research into PALB2-associated cancers, not only for specialized institutions but also for primary care physicians.
Detection rate and spectrum of PALB2 PV/LPVs
Among all families tested with HBOC panel, we identified at least one germline PV/LPV in one of the genes in 19.1%. PALB2 was the fifth most commonly mutated HBOC-related gene (following BRCA1, BRCA2, CHEK2 and ATM). PV/LPVs in PALB2 represent 0.9% of all individuals tested, which was expected as it had previously been reported that 0.2–0.9% of women with breast cancer who undergo genetic testing will carry germline PV/LPV in PALB2 (Hu et al. 2021).
In our cohort the frequency of PV/LPVs in more than one gene from the HBOC panel in tested individuals is 2.6% (23/883) and is higher than the one reported in the literature, where we can find data ranging from 0.5 to 1% (Rosenthal et al. 2017; Shao et al. 2020). That may be due to the high prevalence of recurrent PV/LPVs in our population (Krajc et al. 2008; Stegel et al. 2011; Krajc et al. 2014).
In 41 families 14 different PALB2 PV/LPVs were detected. PALB2 c.912 del p.(Val305*) had not been reported previously and was found in one proband. Newly described PALB2 PV/LPVs in patients with BC are important since they can contribute to international databases and patients may benefit from prevention and treatment options.
Recurrent PV/LPVs in PALB2 in the Slovenian population
Five PV/LPVs in PALB2 were recurrent (diagnosed in at least two or more seemingly unrelated families) in our population, with PALB2 c.509_510del and PALB2 c.1451T > A being the two most frequent, detected in 10 different families each, and together encompassing almost half (20/41 or 48.8%) of all detected PV/LPVs in our population. Recurrent PALB2 PV/LPVs have been reported in other populations as well, such as those from Argentina (Gonzalez et al. 2022), Finland (Erkko et al. 2007) and Poland (Noskowicz et al. 2014). PALB2 c.509_510del has been described by Noskowitz et al. as being present in about 1 in 400 unselected breast cancer patients from Central Europe (Germany) and Eastern Europe (Belarus, Russia) (Noskowicz et al. 2014). PALB2 c.509_510del has also been described as a recurrent mutation in BC and OC patients from Poland (Kluska et al. 2017). We found no reports on the presence of PALB2 c.509_510del in Western European, Asian or American populations. While the Slovenian language does belong to the South Slavic language group, genetic studies have revealed close genetic affiliations with West Slavic populations, such as Poles, suggesting a common Slavic ancestor originating from the Dnieper basin (Zupan et al. 2013). We found no genotype-phenotype correlation studies for this specific PV. Of note, three patients from our cohort (33.3%) were diagnosed with a metachronous contralateral BC, one additional (11.1%) with a metachronous contralateral and ipsilateral BC. Additionally, we found two cases of ovarian cancer (10.5% of PALB2 c.509_510delGA carriers) with a median age at diagnosis 56.5 years (range 51 years – 62 years), one case of carcinoma of the papilla Vateri and one malignant melanoma. Based on our data BC patients harbouring PALB2 c.509_510del are at high risk of developing a second BC and OC, making them high-risk group among PALB2 PV carriers.
PALB2 c.1451T > A has not yet been described as a recurrent mutation in any population in the literature, however it has been found in nineteen individuals from ten different families in our cohort, which makes it a unique recurrent mutation in the Slovenian population. Among nineteen carriers of the above-mentioned PV, eight were diagnosed with breast cancer, with a median age at diagnosis 49 years. While it is challenging to establish genotype-phenotype correlation, this information could still be valuable in everyday clinical practice and may be included in the studies with bigger sample sizes.
Malignancies among PALB2 PV/LPV carriers
It has been known for more than a decade that PALB2 PV/LPVs increase BC risk (Hamdan and Nowak 2022). The risk is 2–30 times higher than in the general population, depending on the type of PV/LPV, age, and family history and PALB2 is considered a high-penetrance susceptibility gene for BC (Antoniou et al. 2014). As expected, the most common malignancy diagnosed in our cohort was BC in 36 patients, which confirms this association. Recent research has strengthened the correlation between PALB2 PV/LPVs and ovarian cancer. Yang et al. demonstrated a substantial association between germline PALB2 PV/LPVs and ovarian cancer with a risk ratio of around 3 and the lifetime risk of OC estimated to be around 3–5%(Yang et al. 2020a). In our cohort, four patients were diagnosed with a high-grade serous carcinoma of the ovary or the fallopian tube and one with a borderline ovarian carcinoma. There were no cases of primary peritoneal serous carcinoma. OC was the second most prevalent malignancy in our study. Two PALB2 PV/LPV carriers in our cohort (2/61, 3.3%) were diagnosed with PaC and additional carrier with carcinoma of Papilla Vateri. Indeed there is emerging evidence that PALB2 PV/LPVs predispose patients to pancreatic cancer. It is estimated that 3–4% of patients with famillial PaC are expected to harbour PALB2 PV/LPV. In the newest version of the National Comprehensive Cancer Network (NCCN) Guidelines enhanced screening not only for BC (with possible risk reducing surgeries), but also for OC (risk reducing surgery is offered as an option) and PaC is recommended (Clinical et al. 2024). Additionally, we have identified 3 cases of malignant melanoma, 1 NET and 1 gastric cancer in our cohort, there is, however, insufficient evidence to draw a conclusion about these types of malignancies.
Double heterozygotes
The increased use of multigene panels in the recent years has led to identification of individuals harbouring more than one PV/LPV in cancer susceptibility genes, although the data is still scarce. Double heterozygous PV in BRCA1/2 are identified in 0.3% of Ashkenazi and are very rare in other populations. Lavie et al. suggest that DH PV in BRCA1/2 in females of Ashkenazi Jewish heritage does not seem to cause a more severe phenotype than in cases where only one of the genes is implicated (Lavie et al. 2011). The results of the studies on DH VP in HBOC-related genes in other populations have been conflicting and inconclusive. To the best of our knowledge no research has been conducted on DH with one of the variants being PALB2 PV/LPV. A case report by Agiannitopoulos described a female patient, who was diagnosed at the age of 42 with endometrial cancer. DH in PALB2 and MSH explained the remarkable family history of ovarian, breast, kidney and colorectal cancer and consequently the surveillance of family members was adjusted (Agiannitopoulos et al. 2020). There is emerging evidence of multiplicative effect of presence of PV/LPVs in more than one cancer susceptibility gene. Heidemann et al. showed that Caucasian female DH for BRCA1/2 seem to develop BC at a younger age and have more severe disease than carriers of a single BRCA1/2 PV/LPV (Heidemann et al. 2012). Similarly, Sokolenko et al. pointed out that the presence of additional gene defect in female BRCA1 PV carriers may further increase their chances for cancer (Sokolenko et al. 2014). We have identified three DH carriers in our PALB2 cohort with additional PV/LPVs in ATM, CHEK2, and BRCA1. The clinical presentations varied. DH patients with PV/LPVs in PALB2 and ATM or CHEK2 were diagnosed with BC at 48 and 32 years, respectively. Patient who was found to harbour PALB2 and BRCA1 PV/LPV was diagnosed with 4 malignancies: two BC, OC and PaC, supporting the multiplying effect of DH. Genetic counselling for DH carriers is complex and further studies are required to elucidate its biological effect.
Strengths and limitations of our study
There are several limitations of our study. The expected population burden of PALB2 PV/LPVs in the Slovenian population is 0.13% (Kotnik et al. 2023). The absolute number of included PV/LPV carriers was small (61). 43 (70.5%) had a cancer diagnosis. However, our cohort represents 2% of the expected population of PALB2 PV/LPV carriers in Slovenia. Also, in comparison to the literature, where mostly case series are described, this is a large cohort of PALB2 PV/LPV carriers. The subgroups of patients with different PV/LPV were very small, therefore we were not able to analyse them separately. The retrospective collection of data is always unfavourable, since data can be missing or inappropriately understood, however as it can be seen from our data, the information regarding patients’ and tumours’ characteristics was complete for patients in our study.
Its strength lies in a reliable family history, with information obtained from the Slovenian National Cancer Registry. It is one of the oldest Registries in Europe, where the diagnoses are cross-checked with histopathological reports.
In cases of rare genetic diseases large multicentric studies are required to achieve a substantial number of patients and we hope these will be able to benefit from our cohort of PALB2 PV/LPV carriers.