The effect of inhaling mother’s breast milk odor on the behavioral responses to pain caused by hepatitis B vaccine in preterm infants: a randomized clinical trial

doi:10.21203/rs.3.rs-45921/v3

Download PDF

Research article

The effect of inhaling mother’s breast milk odor on the behavioral responses to pain caused by hepatitis B vaccine in preterm infants: a randomized clinical trial

https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-45921/v3

This work is licensed under a CC BY 4.0 License

Journal Publication

published 01 Feb, 2021

Read the published version in BMC Pediatrics →

You are reading this latest preprint version

Background: Nowadays, it is generally assumed that non-pharmacologic pain relief in preterm infants is an important measure to consider. Research findings suggest that familiar odors have soothing effects for neonates. The aim of this study was to compare the effect of maternal breast milk odor (MBMO) with that of another mother’s breast milk odor (BMO) on the behavioral responses to pain caused by hepatitis B (HB) vaccine injection in preterm infants.

Methods: This single-blind randomized clinical trial was performed over the period between February 2019 and March 2020 in the neonatal intensive care unit of Babol Rouhani Hospital, Iran. Ninety preterm infants, who were supposed to receive their HB vaccine, were randomly assigned into three groups: MBMO (A), another mother’s BMO (B), and control with distilled water(C). Oxygen saturation (SaO2), blood pressure (BP) and heart rate (HR) were recorded for all participants through electronic monitoring. In addition, premature infant pain profiles (PIPP) were determined through video recording for all three groups during intervention. The chi-square, ANOVA and ANCOVA were used for analyzing the data, and P<0.05 was considered significant in this study.

Results: No significant differences were found between the three groups in mean± SD of HR, BP, and Sao2 before the intervention (P>0.05). After the intervention, however, the means for heart rate in groups A, B, and C were 146±14.3, 153±17.5 and 155±17.7, respectively (P=0.012). Moreover, the means for PIPP scores in groups A, B and C were 6.6±1.3, 10 ±2, and 11.4±1.9, respectively (P<0.001). There was no significant difference found between groups in their means of SaO2, systolic and diastolic blood pressure after the intervention (P>0.05).

Conclusions: The results indicate that stimulation with MBMO is effective in reducing pain in preterm infants; therefore, it can be postulated that this technique can be considered in less invasive procedures such as needling.

Trial registration: IRCT, IRCT20190220042771N1. Registered 18 May 2019- Retrospectively registered, https://en.irct.ir/trial/37646

Pediatrics

Pain

Premature infant

Human milk

Odor

Hepatitis B vaccine

Many innovative measures to relieve pain in preterm infants are considered by various neonatal intensive care units (NICU) worldwide [1, 2]. It is assumed that neonatal pain in preterm infants can adversely affect their development in such multiple domains as nociceptive changes, altered brain development, stress systems, and functional abilities. Prolonged exposure to pain has also been associated with impaired brain development while preterm infants are in the NICU [3]. Pain assessment methods are currently performed through physiological (heart rate and respiratory rate) and behavioral criteria (crying time, changes in facial expression and limb movements) [4].

The premature infant pain profile (PIPP) is a set of measurable behavioral and physiological responses such as facial expression changes (squeezing eyes, raising eyebrows, wrinkling nasolabial groove) as well as changes in heart rate, SaO2, intrauterine age, and behavioral status of the infants, which are all definite reasons demonstrating pain in premature infants [5].

There is a strong tendency to use non-pharmacological interventions, as simple and secure techniques, for relieving pains in infants. Several methods have already been applied to relieve pain based on five senses[5]. Among them, the sense of smell is fully developed at birth [6] which can affect the neonate’s emotional relationship with his/her mother [7]. Familiar odors, maternal odor for instance, supposedly have soothing effects on newborn infants. It is widely known that infants have the ability to detect their mother's breast odor even without experiencing breastfeeding at birth [8]. The breast milk odor (BMO) can enhance infants’ sucking through the facial and trigeminal motor nerves in the brain, which, in turn, stabilizes the physiological state in infants [9]. In some cases, research findings has demonstrated that breastfeeding in human newborn infants can completely eliminates pain responses, and animal models have also depicted that the pain modulating effect of breastfeeding is likely mediated by opioid and non-opioid mechanisms [10]. Some studies have shown that Some other studies have also shown that fetal-maternal odors (mother’s breast milk, body and amniotic fluid odors) can decrease stress responses including crying and motor activities in infants, especially those separated from breast milk or the ones under painful interventions [11]. In a relevant study, it was suggested that the maternal breast milk odor (MBMO) had a soothing effect on preterm infants, and that their pain score was lower than that of those exposed to formula odor [12]. Nevertheless, the results of Küçük Alemdar et al. (2017) demonstrated that the BMO made no statistically significant difference in the physiological and behavioral responses of MBMO group compared to other groups (amniotic fluid odor, maternal body odor and control groups) [13].

Given all the contradictory results on the effect of MBMO and another mother’s BMO on preterm infants and the importance of pain relief for preterm infants, this study strove to investigate the effect of inhaling human milk on the behavioral responses of pain caused by HB vaccine in preterm infants.

Study Design and setting: This single-blind randomized clinical trial was done from February 2019 to March 2020 in a NICU of academic center (Rouhani Hospital, Babol, Iran).

Participant: Preterm infants 28-37 weeks of gestation, who have to be vaccinated for hepatitis B –zero turn the vaccine- were randomly assigned to three groups. The inclusion criteria were infants with no painful procedure and no feeding for up to one hour before the intervention, stability in vital signs, no head and skull abnormalities as well as no receiving painkillers, sedatives and anticonvulsants. The exclusion criteria were maternal withdrawal from the study and infant sever disease or death.

Sample size: Considering 80% power and 0.05 error probability in this study, the number of cases was determined to be at least 30 neonates in each group [2].

Data collection and processing: According to the ward's schedule during the first four days of life, injection of HB vaccine was done. Preterm neonate was placed on a warmer by servo control and skin temperature 36.5- 37◦C in quiet room. All conditions including room temperature (25◦C), light, injection device were the same for all three groups as well as the vaccine administration was done by one person. The researcher and nurse did not use any aromatic substances in vaccination room during the study. The probe of monitoring was placed on the right wrist of baby without applying additional pressure. Heart rate, blood pressure and SaO2 of all preterm infants were recorded before starting the intervention as the initial time and immediately after completing vaccination (using the standard pulse oximeter and ECG monitoring of Saadat Company, Iran).

In both groups of A and B, the breast milk samples taken in the early morning before eating breakfast were used to stimulate the smell sense of neonates. Pouring 2 ml of maternal breast milk and another mother’s breast milk on a cotton swab was done as an intervention, and 2 ml of distilled water as control group (group C). Next, these swabs were placed three centimeters away from the baby's nose. This process started 3 min before vaccination and continued until the vaccination was completed [2].

Pain measurement

The Premature Infant Pain Profile (PIPP) was used as the primary outcome variable. PIPP scores were recorded immediately before and after the vaccination for each infant. The PIPP is a behavioral measure of pain for premature infants. It includes seven indicators: 1) gestational age, 2) the behavioral state, 3) change in heart rate, 4) change in oxygen saturation, 5) brow bulge; 6) eyes squeeze and 7) nasolabial furrow. The total score is the summation of all seven indicators, with a minimum of 0 and maximum of 21; the higher the score, the greater the pain behavior [14]. If the overall PIPP score is between 0 and 6 points, the pain level is mild; if between 7 and 12 points, it is moderate; and if between 13 and 21 points, it is severe [15] The PIPP tool was revised and validated for use with preterm babies born at 26-37 weeks of gestation by Gibbins et al. in 2014 [16]

Video recording of behavioral responses was taken from the beginning to the end of the process by a trained nurse, and then PIPP scoring was performed through watching video by the first author. The scoring was done while the video viewer was unaware of the test group. Throughout the intervention, any actions on the neonates such as contact, movement and so on were avoided.

Data were collected by using the demographic questionnaire including: birth weight, current disease (respiratory distress syndrome, transient tachypnea of newborn, sepsis and very low birth weight) , sex, gestational age, postnatal age, Apgar score and PIPP score.

Data analysis: Statistics advisor performed the data analysis blindly by using SPSS Version 18. Descriptive information was shown as frequency, percentage, mean and standard deviation. Chi-square test for the relationship between two qualitative variables (demographic and PIPP qualitative variables with group variable), ANOVA test for comparing quantitative variables at the levels of more than two variables (quantitative demographic variables with group variable) and ANCOVA test for comparing research outcomes (SBP, DBP, SaO2 and heart rate) were used to remove the pretest effect and a P value< 0.05 were considered significant.

Ethical consideration

The study protocol was approved by the Ethics Committees of Babol University of Medical Sciences (IR.MUBABOL.REC.1397.253). The trial is registered in the IRCT20190220042771N1 Before participation in the study, written informed consent was obtained from each child’s primary guardian.

Study subjects

ALL 90 preterm infants, who included, were completed the study. The infants of the three groups were not significantly different in terms of sex, age, infant's current disease ( Spsis, Respiratory Distress Syndrome (RDS), Transient Tachypnea of Newborn (TTN), very low birth weight (VLBW), gestational age, weight and APGAR score (p>0.05) (table 1).

Table 2 shows variables including SBP, DBP, SaO2 and heart rate before and after the intervention by using ANCOVA test.

As shown in table 2, by eliminating the effect of the pretest variable and use of ANCOVA test, there is no significant difference between the means± SD of SBP (p=0.482), DBP (p=0.341) and SaO2 (p=0.193) in terms of group membership. ANCOVA test showed that change in heart rate was significantly lower in group A (p=0.012).

PIPP score

The mean± SD of pain score in group A was 6.6±1.3, and 10±2 and 11.4±1.9 in groups B and C, respectively. The ANOVA test showed that there is a significant difference between groups (P<0.001), and the results of post-hoc Tukey's test determined that this difference was between group A with groups B and C (fig.2).

This study showed that MBMO greatly affected heart rate as well as behavioral responses to pain scoring in preterm infants compared with another mother’s BMO and the control groups, but there were no significant differences found between the three groups in terms of SBP, DBP and SaO2.

Zhang et al. (2018) conducted a systematic review study to investigate the analgesic effects of BMO on infants. Their results demonstrated that there was a change in the heart rate of infants and that SaO2 pain scores were lower in MBMO group during and after blood sampling compared with those of the control group [17], It is worth noting that their result is consistent with the findings of the current study, except for SaO2. The stimulation with MBMO had a soothing effect on the behavioral responses to pain and reduced infant’s pain in our study.

In another relevant study, Sajjadi et al. (2016) reported that the mean scores of PIPP had a significant effect on MBMO group compared to control group [2]. Nonetheless, a significant difference was found in the heart rate as well as SaO2 after the intervention. Their results are in line with those of the present study, except for change in SaO2. Likewise, Küçük Alemdar et al. (2017) conducted a study through which they investigated the effect of mother’s BMO, amniotic fluid odor, and body odor on the physiological and behavioral responses to heel stick pain in preterm infants and found no statistically significant difference between groups in terms of physiological and behavioral responses to pain such as heart rate, duration of crying and pain scale. although the SaO2 was slightly different in the amniotic fluid odor group [13], As it can be seen, this finding is vividly inconsistent with the results of the present study. One possible reason for this discrepancy is the difference between both studies in terms of methodology and intervention process. In their study, 5cc of the mother’s breast milk was poured on a sponge and placed five centimeters away from the neonate's nose for fifteen minutes before and after the intervention, , while the cotton swab had been placed three centimeters away from the infant's nose in our study. This process started 3 min before vaccination in the current study and continued until the vaccination was completed. Attempts were also made to minimize the effect of accustoming to the sense of smell in our study. Aziznejad et al. (2013) evaluated the physiological indicators and concluded that there was a statistically significant difference in the respiratory rate only between the intervention group with sucrose and the other groups immediately after the intervention, but there was no significant difference between the four groups in other variables (duration of crying, heart rate and SaO2) [18].

In three above-mentioned studies (Zhang, Sajjadi and Küçük Alemdar) which were different with our study in terms of methodology, there were no significant changes found in SaO2 between the intervention group and the control group. Moreover, in a similar study by Aziznejad et al. (2013), which was performed under the same condition, there were no differences in SaO2, either. One possible reason could be the difference in the equipment used.

On the basis of this research, the MBMO can be used as a familiar smell to manage the preterm infant’s pain before performing any needling procedures such as vaccination.

Limitations

Due to the limited amount of equipment, the use of special probes for infants during the study was provided by several companies. The differences in the sensitivity of these probes may have caused the SaO2 changes not to be accurately determined.

ANOVA: Analysis of Variance; MBMO: Maternal Breast Milk Odor ; BMO: Another Mother’s Breast Milk Odor ; HBV: Hepatitis B Vaccine ; HR: Heart Rate ; NICU: Neonatal Intensive Care Unit; PIPP: Premature Infant Pain Profile ; SBP: Systolic Blood Pressure ; DBP: Diastolic Blood Pressure ; SaO2 : Arterial Oxygen Saturation ; RDS: Respiratory Distress Syndrome; VLBW: very low birth weight ; TTN: Transient Tachypnea of Newborn; ANCOVA: Analysis of Covariance; chi² :Chi-square; APGAR: Appearance, Pulse, Grimace, Activity, Respiration;

Ethics approval and consent to participate

The study protocol was approved by the Ethics Committees of the Babol University of Medical Sciences (IR.MUBABOL.REC.1397.253). The trial is registered in the Iranian Registry of Clinical Trial (IRCT20190220042771N1). Before participation in the study, written informed consent was obtained from each child’s primary guardian.

Consent for publication

The article does not contain any individual’ details and consent for publication is not applicable.

Availability of data and materials

The datasets analyzed in the current study are not publicly available due to an agreement with the participants upon the confidentiality of the data, but they are available from the corresponding author upon request.

Competing interests

The authors declare that they have no competing interests.

Funding

This research received a grant from Babol University of Medical Sciences (Grant number: 258-9706616). The Babol university of Medical Sciences did not have any role in the design of the study, data collection, analysis, interpretation of the data, and the writing of the manuscript.

Authors’ contributions

ASA studied the conception/design, carried out the analysis, interpreted the data, and helped drafting the manuscript. PA, the first supervisor of the study, studied the conception/design, analyzed the data, helped drafting the manuscript, did the critical revisions for important intellectual content, provided administrative/ technical/ material support, and did the final revision. ZAR critically revised the proposal, did the analysis, interpreted the data, and designed the article. The shares of the first and the third authors was equal. HGA performed the data analysis, and ZV contributed in the data collection. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.

Acknowledgements

The authors would like to thank the Research Deputy of Babol University of Medical Sciences, authorities, and colleagues in the Neonatal intensive care unit of Babol Rouhani Hospital as well as the infants’ parents, who helped us throughout this study.

Majidipour N, Nirouzad F, Sarrafzade S, Kalani L, Aghababaeian H, Haghighat Borujeni S. The effect of holy Quran recitation on the physiological responses of premature infants during phlebotomy: A randomized clinical trial. International Journal of Pediatrics. 2018;6(7):7869-81.
Sajjadi M, Basirimoghadam M, Amiri Shadmehri E. Effect of Breast Milk Odor on Physiological and Behavioral Pain Responses Caused by Hepatitis B Vaccine in Full-term Infants. The Horizon of Medical Sciences. 2017;23(3):169-73.
Grunau RE. Long term effects of pain-related stress on neurodevelopment and pain perception of infants born very prematurely. Enfance. 2013(1):15-31.
Stadtlander L. Understanding Infant Pain. International Journal of Childbirth Education. 2018;33(2):6-8.
Verklan MT, Walden M, Forest S. Core curriculum for neonatal intensive care nursing e-book: Elsevier Health Sciences; 2020.
Jebreili M, Rasouli AS, Hosseini MB, Gojazade M, Esfahlani HN. The Effect of Breast Milk Odor in Venipuncture Pain in Preterm Infants: Randomized Controlled Clinical Trial. Majallah-i pizishki-i Danishgah-i Ulum-i Pizishki va Khadamat-i Bihdashti-i Darmani-i Tabriz. 2016;38(3):42.
Seraji A, Vakilian K. The comparison between the effects of aromatherapy with lavender and reathing techniques on the reduction of labor pain. Complementary Medicine Journal. 2011;1(1):34-41.
Iranmanesh S, Shamsi A, pour Aboli B, Movahedi Z. The effect of breast milk odor on transition time from gavage to oral feeding and hospital stay in premature infants. ICAN: Infant, Child, & Adolescent Nutrition. 2015;7(1):5-11.
MAROFI M, NIKOBAKHT F, ALI MN, BADIEI Z. COMPARING THE EFFECT OF LISTENING TO MELODY VS. BREAST-FEEDING ON NEONATES’PAIN INTENSITY DURING HEEL-BLOOD SAMPLING IN NEONATAL INTENSIVE CARE UNIT. 2015.
Holsti L, Oberlander TF, Brant R. Does breastfeeding reduce acute procedural pain in preterm infants in the neonatal intensive care unit? A randomized clinical trial. Pain. 2011;152(11):2575-81.
Nishitani S, Miyamura T, Tagawa M, Sumi M, Takase R, Doi H, et al. The calming effect of a maternal breast milk odor on the human newborn infant. Neuroscience Research. 2009;63(1):66-71.
Badiee Z, Asghari M, Mohammadizadeh M. The calming effect of maternal breast milk odor on premature infants. Pediatrics & Neonatology. 2013;54(5):322-5.
Küçük Alemdar D, Kardaş Özdemir F. Effects of having preterm infants smell amniotic fluid, mother's milk, and mother's odor during heel stick procedure on pain, physiological parameters, and crying duration. Breastfeeding Medicine. 2017;12(5):297-304.
Ranjbar A, Bernstein C, Shariat M, Ranjbar H. Comparison of facilitated tucking and oral dextrose in reducing the pain of heel stick in preterm infants: a randomized clinical trial. BMC pediatrics. 2020;20:1-9.
Stevens BJ, Gibbins S, Yamada J, Dionne K, Lee G, Johnston C, et al. The premature infant pain profile-revised (PIPP-R): initial validation and feasibility. The Clinical journal of pain. 2014;30(3):238-43.
Gibbins S, Stevens BJ, Yamada J, Dionne K, Campbell-Yeo M, Lee G, et al. Validation of the premature infant pain profile-revised (PIPP-R). Early human development. 2014;90(4):189-93.
Zhang S, Su F, Li J, Chen W. The analgesic effects of maternal milk odor on newborns: a meta-analysis. Breastfeeding Medicine. 2018;13(5):327-34.
Aziznejad P, Zahed Pasha Y, Ahmadpour Kacho M, Haji Ahmadi M, Mohammadzadeh I, Arzani A, et al. Comparing the effect of oral sucrose, breast milk and EMLA cream on acute pain during venipuncture in full term neonates. Journal of babol university of medical sciences. 2013;15(3):16-23.

CONSORT2010Checklist.doc

Download PDF

Journal Publication

published 01 Feb, 2021

Read the published version in BMC Pediatrics →

Editorial decision: Minor revision
12 Jan, 2021
Editor assigned by journal
11 Jan, 2021
Submission checks completed at journal
11 Jan, 2021
Editor invited by journal
11 Jan, 2021

You are reading this latest preprint version

The effect of inhaling mother’s breast milk odor on the behavioral responses to pain caused by hepatitis B vaccine in preterm infants: a randomized clinical trial

Status:

Journal Publication

Version 3

Abstract

Figures

Background

Methods

Results

Discussion

Conclusion

Abbreviations

Declarations

References

Supplementary Files

Status:

Journal Publication

Version 3