In previous work, we showed increases in mental health problems over the course of the COVID-19 pandemic (April 2020 – April 2023) in children in psychiatric care (van Oers et al., 2023). In the current study, we assessed within the same sample to what extent mental health differed between diagnostic categories, and whether these outcomes were differently affected by the COVID pandemic across these diagnostic categories. As expected, we found that overall problems varied substantially between diagnostic categories with internalizing problems most prevalent in Anxiety/Depressive disorders, and externalizing problems most prevalent in ADHD and Autism. Crucially, we found no evidence for different trajectories of diagnostic groups over time, suggesting that on average children with different psychiatric classifications were equally negatively impacted by the COVID-19 pandemic and related measures.
The lack of differences in trajectories for different diagnostic categories mirrors the lack of evidence for differences in trajectories for other moderators such as age, sex, or educational attainment (Kiviruusu et al., 2023; van Oers et al., 2023). These findings suggest the pandemic had an overall negative effect on the mental health of children and adolescents, rather than on specific subgroups. Of course, the pandemic has impacted people in different ways, and it may be the case that putative differences exist on a more individual level, or depend on broader factors such as family, neighborhood, or school. For example, early in the pandemic, economic concerns of the parents were found to be related to differences in pandemic impact on child mental health (Cost et al., 2022). Likewise, parental stress and mental health may mediate or moderate pandemic effects on child mental health (Babore et al., 2023). Alternatively, the impact of the pandemic may have been substantial in specific subgroups, but the coping response by caregivers, clinicians, and children themselves may have been effective in mitigating the negative impact.
Another important factor that influences the interpretation of our findings concerns the changes in mental health care itself due to the pandemic. A substantial portion of mental health care transitioned to telehealth during the pandemic, which impacted intakes, procedures, and treatments (Folk et al., 2022). In addition, the workload, stress, and mental health problems of mental health care workers increased (Van Doesum et al., 2023). Such factors may have affected the accessibility of care and possibly have influenced the patient population we studied. Although we controlled for background variables and the proportion of different diagnoses did not substantially change over time, we cannot rule out that this may have contributed to our results.
This study benefits from data from a large sample of children in psychiatric care in the Netherlands and relies on both child-reported and parent-reported data. The findings of parent ratings and self-reports are congruent, suggesting that different sources of information converge towards similar outcomes. Our findings are limited by the fact that not all diagnostic categories were represented in this study since sample sizes would become too low to perform meaningful analyses, hence, our findings cannot be generalized to other specific mental disorders. Likewise, our sample consists of children in specialized psychiatric care and findings may not generalize to broader child populations with mental health problems. In addition, for our analyses we used only three time points to retain sufficient power, but thereby also increased the time spans of measurements, and therefore we cannot rule out differences between and within smaller time scales. Finally, no pre-pandemic data was available and thus we cannot rule out that the acute impact of the pandemic may have been different for children with different diagnoses.
In sum, we found no differences between diagnostic categories in mental health changes over time from the start to a year after the COVID-19 pandemic. Our data suggest that having a specific psychiatric diagnosis did not pose a risk factor for worse outcomes during and after the pandemic compared to other diagnoses. We stress the need for regular, high-quality monitoring of child mental health to better understand changes that occur and to be able to better adapt to crisis situations.