Here, we carried out extensive malacological surveillance along the southern shoreline of Lake Malawi, Mangochi District, Malawi, to measure the distribution and diversity of Biomphalaria freshwater snail intermediate hosts of S. mansoni. We then used a range of molecular approaches to genotype a subset of collected Biomphalaria to species level and to screen all collected Biomphalaria for infection with S. mansoni to identify intestinal schistosomiasis transmission sites in this area. This was done to gain a more thorough understanding of Biomphalaria associated transmission of intestinal schistosomiasis in Mangochi District five years post-outbreak to better inform and strengthen future disease control efforts.
Biomphalaria were collected at multiple surveillance sites and all genotyped specimens were identified as Bi. pfefferi, which is the most widely distributed and commonly implicated intermediate host and vector of S. mansoni across sub-Saharan Africa (24). No cox1 variation was found between all genotyped Mangochi District Bi. pfeifferi, suggesting a potential single and recent colonisation event of Bi. pfeifferi in this area. According to cox1 analysis, all Bi. pfeifferi genotyped here were most closely related to Bi. pfeifferi collected in Zimbabwe, with two Zimbabwean isolates from different locations sharing identical cox1 sequence data to Mangochi District Bi. pfeifferi, and so perhaps these Bi. pfeifferi identified in Mangochi District originated from Zimbabwe, as suggested previously (22). Interestingly, enough genetic variation was found between the unique Malawi, Chikwawa District haplotype and the Malawi, Mangochi District haplotype to suggest that the Chikwawa District Bi. pfeifferi population may have in fact invaded from populations outside of Malawi, rather than migrated south along the Shire River from Mangochi District and diverged, as might have been initially assumed. Further analysis to confirm this, however, is needed, particularly as the cox1 phylogenetic tree generated here suggests that all Malawian Bi. pfeifferi (inclusive of Mangochi and Chikwawa Districts) and all Zimbabwean Bi. pfeifferi share a common ancestor. It is worth noting that no other species of Biomphalaria, such as Bi. sudanica or Bi. choanomphala, was identified, although limited deep water (> 1 metre) surveillance took place, which is the preferred microhabitat of Bi. choanomphala (24).
This recent introduction of Biomphalaria into Mangochi District can likely be, in part, attributed to environmental changes caused by ongoing climate change (40, 41). In recent years, Mangochi District, and Malawi more broadly, have been severely impacted by atypical and extreme weather conditions such as tropical cyclones and remarkably heavy rainfall with subsequent flooding, particularly in low-altitude areas such as the upper Shire River margins (42). Whilst flooding can transport and introduce Biomphalaria into new habitats from surrounding areas, such extreme weather events can also dramatically alter freshwater environments more generally, and thus more favourable Biomphalaria habitats can arise (40, 41). As an example, temporal freshwater pools, which would typically evaporate during dry seasons, may instead remain as permanent waterbodies in which Bi. pfeifferi can propagate. Such waterbodies may therefore quickly become active sites of intestinal schistosomiasis transmission. As different Biomphalaria species, which can differ in their ability to transmit S. mansoni, have different habitat preferences, a clear understanding of how climate change can alter the environment with respect to current and potential Biomphalaria habitats is needed to better understand ongoing and future transmission of intestinal schistosomiasis. Molecular approaches to identify Biomphalaria species, such as those used here, will be crucial in these investigations.
As found previously in this area (22), just one (0.17%) of all 589 collected Biomphalaria was found to be actively shedding S. mansoni cercariae. Through molecular xenomonitoring, however, a total of 20 (3.4%) Biomphalaria, were found to be infected with S. mansoni; 12 of which were collected from malacological surveillance sites that were not deemed intestinal schistosomiasis transmission sites through cercarial shedding analysis. The prevalence of Biomphalaria infection with S. mansoni was therefore increased from 0.17–3.4%, and the number of identified intestinal schistosomiasis transmission sites was increased from one to four, through use of molecular xenomonitoring. Interestingly, at one such site (site 21; see Additional file 1, Table S1), not only was a relatively high number of Biomphalaria collected (n = 80), but a high proportion (11.25%) of Biomphalaria were found to be infected with S. mansoni using molecular xenomonitoring despite none of these actively shedding S. mansoni cercariae during cercarial shedding analysis. Furthermore, of note, this site is a short distance (~ 1.5 Km) from Samama School, at which 55% of school-aged children in attendance were found to be infected with S. mansoni during recent parasitological surveillance in November of 2021 [Archer et al., under review].
In addition, through molecular xenomonitoring, six unique S. mansoni mitochondrial ND5 haplotypes were identified, which clustered into two distinct groups. A similar degree of mitochondrial DNA genetic diversity was found amongst S. mansoni miracidia cox1 haplotypes (infecting school-aged children) also recently identified in this area [Archer et al., under review]. Furthermore, during these previous cox1 analyses, two genetically distinct S. mansoni cox1 linage groups (II and IV), (43), were identified within the miracidia population, which may be reflected here in these ND5 haplotypes. Interestingly, it should also be noted that just one unique S. mansoni ND5 haplotype was identified at site 13, which is far removed (~ 12–15 Km) from the remaining three surveillance sites where S. mansoni transmission was found (all of which are within ~ 3 Km of each other), suggesting a focal population of S. mansoni at site 13 that is genetically distinct from S. mansoni populations further south along the lake’s shoreline. At the remaining three intestinal schistosomiasis transmission sites (sites 18, 21 and 27), multiple S. mansoni haplotypes were identified and found to be present at multiple sites, suggesting mixing of S. mansoni populations in this area, likely by human hosts visiting multiple different lake water contact points but also potentially through movement of Biomphalaria between surveyed sites.
Infection with non-Schistosoma trematodes was also detected in 12 Biomphalaria collected at multiple malacological surveillance sites. Six of these were identified as Uvulifer spp., which were all present at site 13. This diplostomid trematode has a three-host life cycle: specific genera of freshwater snails including Biomphalaria (44), freshwater sunfish, and piscivorous birds such as kingfisher (highly prevalent along this shoreline of Lake Malawi (45)). The remaining six were identified as Petasiger spp., which were present at sites 18, 20, 21 and 27. Petasiger spp. trematodes also utilise a three-host life cycle: a range of genera of freshwater snails including Biomphalaria and Bulinus, freshwater fish and tadpoles, and piscivorous birds such as cormorants (again, highly prevalent along this shoreline of Lake Malawi) (46). Whilst there appears to be no available studies investigating whether established Uvulifer spp. or Petasiger spp. infections within Biomphalaria impact S. mansoni development and transmission, other trematode species have been found to influence S. mansoni development within Biomphalaria (47), and so this may also be the case for these infecting Trematoda. This, however, requires further investigation to clarify.
Study limitations and future work
Given the limited diversity found across Bi. pfeifferi cox1hapolotypes analysed in this study, more thorough analysis of additional Bi. pfeifferi DNA loci, e.g., mitochondrial 16S or nuclear ITS regions, or even whole mitochondrial genome analysis, would likely provide further insights into Mangochi District Bi. pfeifferi phylogenies, population structuring, and origins (10). In addition, whilst molecular xenomonitoring can be used to detect Schistosoma infections in freshwater snail hosts that have been missed by cercarial shedding, this approach does have limitations. PCR-based molecular approaches such as end-point PCR used here, or real-time/quantitative PCR, are expensive and require specialised laboratory personnel. In addition, PCR also requires sophisticated laboratory infrastructure seldom available in schistosomiasis-endemic areas. As such, the continued development of more portable, rapid, and easy-to-use nucleic acid amplification technologies that can be carried out at the point-of-need, such as loop-mediated isothermal amplification (LAMP) and recombinase polymerase/aided amplification (RPA/RAA), for molecular xenomonitoring purposes is encouraged here (48, 49). Furthermore, the continued development of DNA extraction technologies capable of isolating DNA from freshwater snail tissues in resource-poor settings is also encouraged (49).