Our cohort study demonstrated that vaccinated patients were more likely to experience acute TRAEs during induction chemotherapy and radiotherapy compared with matched non-vaccinated patients, and we observed a possible interaction effect on grade-3–4 neutropenia in the subgroups of age ≥ 50 years and stage–II–III. As for oncologic outcomes, patients within the vaccinated group had similar 2-year oncologic outcomes compared with those of the non-vaccinated group.
Our observations of acute TRAEs are consistent with some previous studies, despite variations in treatment protocols. A multicenter observational study revealed that COVID-19 vaccination increased the prevalence of mild immune system-related adverse events (grade 1 or 2; 33.8% vs 19.8%, P < 0.001) in patients with cancer who received camrelizumab[20]. Another study indicated that COVID-19 vaccination could improve the response to treatment against programmed cell death protein-1 combined with chemotherapy in patients with recurrent metastatic NPC, but vaccinated patients were more likely to experience mild IRAEs (73.6% vs. 60.1%; P < 0.001)[21].
COVID-19 vaccines have been shown to be effective and safe, but numerous adverse events have been reported. As early study reported fatigue and nausea to be the common adverse events resulting from use of COVID-19 vaccines[22]. In the VOICE study, fatigue of grade 1–2 occurred in up to 44% in patients with cancer[23]. The protection induced by vaccination is mediated through a complex interplay between innate, humoral, and cell-mediated immunity[24, 25]. After vaccination, neutrophils are recruited, activated, and interact functionally with B cells by binding immunoglobulin (Ig)G and IgA and inducing antibody production directly by activating B cells[26–28]. Thus, neutrophils are recruited in immunization sites and are redistributed after vaccination. A recent study reported a small and transient drop in neutrophil after COVID-19 vaccination[29], which supports our results. Malignancy can cause a systemic immunosuppressive state[30]. The myelosuppression caused by chemotherapy can lead to neutropenia. The above might explain (at least in part) our finding of a higher prevalence of severe neutropenia in the vaccinated group in comparison with matched non-vaccinated group.
Multiple times (two or more times) COVID-19 vaccination had been shown to be effective in increasing vaccine-derived immunity[31–33], theoretically, the prevalence of adverse events of chemoradiotherapy could be influenced. However, our subgroup of analyses acute TRAEs according to number of vaccinations (once vs. two or more times) demonstrated that patients who vaccinated two or more times did not show significant difference in the prevalence of grade-3–4-specific TRAEs compared with those who vaccinated once. Possible reasons were vaccine effectiveness wanes over time and receiving chemotherapy from within 28 days to within 6 months of vaccination impaired vaccine-derived immunity[34, 35].
With regard to oncologic outcomes, two-year PFS in the vaccinated group was significantly higher than that for the unmatched non-vaccinated group. A possible reason for this result is that patients in the vaccinated group were more likely to received concurrent chemotherapy and nimotuzumab during radiotherapy, because this group of patients who had previous host immune dysregulation conditions. Accumulating evidence has demonstrated that nimotuzumab plus CCRT or intensity-modulated radiotherapy shows promising efficacy without increasing toxicity for patients[36–38]. Additionally, the addition of concurrent chemotherapy or nimotuzumab to radiotherapy can improve PFS in patients with NPC[39, 40]. After adjustment of the bias between the two groups using PSM, we noticed that the 2-year values for OS, PFS, DMFS, and LRRFS were comparable between the two groups. Multivariable analyses indicated that COVID-19 vaccination was not an independent predictor of OS, PFS, DMFS, or LRRFS. Our data excluded an unfavorable influence of COVID-19 vaccination on the oncologic outcomes of patients with NPC treated with chemoradiotherapy. Vaccines stimulate T cells and B cells, and leads to protection against a specific pathogen. However, recent chemotherapy (defined variably as receiving chemotherapy from within 28 days to within 6 months of vaccination) impairs vaccine-induced immune responses[41]. Moreover, immunosuppressive pathways are activated in the tumor microenvironment after irradiation[42, 43]. These phenomena might be why we noticed similar oncologic outcomes between the vaccinated and matched non-vaccinated group.
It is important to mention that this study has strengths and limitations. Our study is the first to investigate association between COVID-19 vaccination and oncologic outcomes in patients with cancer. Additionally, we integrated data from the national vaccination system of China, which enabled us to obtain specific information regarding COVID-19 vaccine types and vaccination timing and could effectively eliminate the recall bias. Other advantages include the large number of patients and the completeness of the follow-up of patients with NPC. One limitation of our study is that this study is a retrospective study, we tried to address potential selection biases with PSM, but our study remained vulnerable to unmeasured confounding. Another limitation is that the follow-up duration is short because large-scale vaccination of COVID-19 in China started from 2021. Evaluation of oncologic outcomes merits a longer duration of follow-up. In addition, more than one type of COVID-19 vaccine was used.
In conclusion, our study supports that COVID-19 vaccination was associated with higher prevalence of acute TRAEs in patients with non-metastasis NPC treated with radiotherapy alone or in conjunction with chemotherapy, and vaccinated patients had a higher prevalence of grade-3–4 neutropenia than non-vaccinated patients for those aged ≥ 50 years and those with stage–II–III disease. The number of vaccinations and window for vaccination had no influence on the prevalence of severe specific TRAEs. Nevertheless, oncologic outcomes at 2 years were similar between the two groups, COVID-19 vaccination was not associated with worse oncologic outcomes.