Proline is a non-essential amino acid found predominantly in collagen. A deficiency in PRODH or P5C dehydrogenase activity (both enzymes belonging to its degradation cascade) results in defective proline metabolism and elevated plasma and/or urine proline concentrations. In 1962, Schafer et al. [8] were the first to document the direct involvement of an error in proline metabolism. The affected family members exhibited hyperprolinemia, cerebral dysfunction, renal anomalies, hereditary nephropathy, and deafness [8].
Since then, there have been only a few reported cases of patients with hyperprolinemia worldwide. The presentation of this condition varies widely, with some individuals remaining asymptomatic [9, 10], while others presenting a diverse range of neurological and/or psychiatric manifestations, as outlined in Table 3. Patients with hyperprolinemia have also been reported to exhibit autism, ADHD, vitamin B6 deficiency [11], preference for carbohydrate-rich foods and nystagmus. The present case is the first report of a pediatric patient with the co-existence of two rare disorders, HPII and PSIS. The boy was diagnosed with HPII at the age of 2 years, with frequent seizure episodes being the principal manifestation. The manifestation of seizures in HPII may be linked to the neuromodulatory effects of proline and the pro-oxidizing results of P5C [12], as shown in vitro. No specific treatment is advocated due to the benign nature of the condition. However, in patients with associated clinical symptoms, attempts have been made to reduce the endogenous concentration of proline by dietary restriction [13]. More recently, attempts to minimize the pro-oxidant effect of P5C have been recorded, with the provision of per os antioxidant supplementation. In animals [14, 15], hyperprolinemia induces significant oxidative damage to the DNA and antioxidant defense proteins and lipoperoxidation. This result can be controlled by adjuvant antioxidant therapy with vitamins E and C. Furthermore, van de Ven [16] and Walker [11] revealed low vitamin B6 concentrations in patients with HPII, suggesting mitochondrial dysfunction and the need for supplementary vitamin B6 intake. This fact indicates that the elevated P5C concentrations in HPII deactivate pyridoxal phosphate (vitamin B6), a co-factor for several enzymes [11]. For this reason, the present boy was on daily vitamin B6 supplementation. Even though several dietary manipulations have been applied for hyperprolinemia (Table 4), these are based on individual case reports. The results appear conflicting, as the exact degree of proline and/or protein restriction has not been reported.
Table 3
Clinical characteristics of patients with hyperprolinemia reported in the literature.
First author | Origin | Study design | Sample | Clinical characteristics |
Applegarth [24] | Canada | Case report | N = 1, boy with HPII (5-year-old) | Seizures, abnormal EEG |
Shivananda [25] | India | Case report | N = 1, infant girl with HPI (2.5-month-old) | Cluster attacks of myoclonic jerks |
Di Rosa [26] | Italy | Case series | N = 4, unrelated children with HPI (2–14 years old) | Epilepsy, mental retardation, and behavioral disturbances |
Flynn [12] | Ireland | Cross-sectional | N = 312, subjects from 71 families including patients with HPII (N = 63) | Seizures were reported in 17 patients 10 exhibited mental handicap (IQ < 70) |
Hama [17] | Japan | Case report | N = 1, boy with HPI (8-year-old) | Preference for carbohydrate-rich foods and tendency toward neurodevelopmental disorders, including autism, ADHD, and learning disorders |
Harries [27] | UK | Case report | N = 1, infant with HPI (7-month-old) | Delayed neurological development, abnormalities of the renal tract, EEG and bones, as well as malabsorption |
Humbertcalude [28] | France | Case report | N = 1, infant boy with HPI (9-months-old) | Generalized tonic-clonic seizures with fever |
Kaur [29] | India | Case report | N = 1, infant girl with HPII (11-months-old) | Recurrent seizures, lethargy, and regression of milestones |
Navamar [30] | Netherlands | Systematic review | NR | High prevalence of developmental delay, intellectual disability, autism and psychosis spectrum disorders |
Oyanagi [13] | Japan | Case report | N = 1, infant girl with HPI (11-month-old) | Mental and motor retardation |
Pavone [31] | Italy | Case series | N = 3, siblings with HPII | Marked hyperprolinemia and hyperglycemia; otherwise asymptomatic |
Raux [32] | France | Cross-sectional | N = 92, patients with VCFS, including children (N = 8) with HPI (2–14-year-old) | Mental retardation generalized tonic-clonic seizures and autistic features Higher serum proline concentrations were associated with lower IQ in patients harboring the 22q11 deletion |
Steinlin [33] | Switzerland | Case report | N = 1, boy with HPI (10-year-old) | Mental retardation, cerebral palsy, epilepsy, nystagmus |
Wajner [34] | Brazil | Case report | N = 1, boy with HPII (5-year-old) | Mild developmental delay, recurrent seizures of the grand mal type |
Walker [11] | UK | Case report | N = 1, girl with HPII (18-month-old) | Vitamin B6 deficiency and convulsions |
ADHD: attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder; EEG: electroencephalogram; IQ: intelligence quotient; HPI: hyperprolinemia type I; HPII: hyperprolinemia type II; NR: not reported; SR: systematic review; VCFS: velo-cardio-facial syndrome. |
Table 4
Dietary interventions for hyperprolinemia.
First author | Origin | Study design | Population | Intervention type | Intervention duration | Results |
Ersoy [35] | Turkey | Case report | N = 1, girl with HPI (4-year-old) | Antioxidant therapy with 100 mg/d co-enzyme Q10 and B complex (B1 + B2 + B6 + B12 vitamins), 500 mg/day of vitamin C, and 500 mg/day L-carnitine | 6-month intervention, followed by 1-month wash-out and then revision of intervention | During intervention proline concentrations fell within the reference range. During wash-out, proline concentrations gradually increased, speech impairment increased and fine motor skills were impaired. At 69 months of treatment, IQ and speech disturbance improved significantly. |
Goyer [36] | Japan | Case report | N = 1, young girl | Low-proline and low-protein diet NOD, with a mixture of essential amino acids as the sole protein source | 1 month | Plasma urea and proline were reduced almost to normal concentrations, and prolinuria lessened. Addition of proline to the diet resulted in an increase in plasma proline. The diet was palatable and well-tolerated. |
Harries [27] | UK | Case report | N = 1, infant with HPI (7-month-old) | Restriction of dietary proline NOD | 18 months | Fall of plasma proline concentrations within the reference range, satisfactory growth, improved mental development, and the EEG, renal, skeletal, and intestinal abnormalities disappeared. |
Ishikawa [37] | Japan | Case report | N = 1, girl with HPI (9-year-old) | Restriction of proline and protein intake NOD | | Growth was satisfactory but mental development failed to improve (progressive speech and motor retardation). |
Oyanagi [13] | Japan | Case report | N = 1, infant girl with HPI (11-month-old) | Low proline dietary therapy NOD | Since 12-months of age | Serum proline concentrations were decreased reaching the reference range, growth was satisfactory, but mental development did not improve. |
EEG: electroencephalogram; HPI: hyperprolinemia type I; IQ: intelligence quotient; NOD, not-other-defined. |
Interestingly, the 5-year-old boy displayed a reduction in growth velocity and ADHD symptoms. Despite regular monitoring with anthropometric measurements falling within normal ranges, the abnormal growth velocity was not adequately assessed, resulting in a delayed diagnosis. However, it is important to recognize that children undergo seasonal increases in height, which can further complicate clinical interpretation, so meticulous attention during the clinical evaluation is warranted. Subsequent evaluation involving dynamic GH testing revealed GHD, with normal cortisol secretion. A severe episode of hypoglycemia followed, and then a subsequent brain MRI ultimately led to the diagnosis of PSIS. This raised the concern of whether the hypoglycemia was solely attributed to GHD or was the result of combined factors involving PSIS and hyperprolinemia. In our patient, the absence of subsequent hypoglycemic episodes following treatment with rhGH led to the belief that the primary factor precipitating severe hypoglycemia was GHD. A study by Hama et al. [17] documented an uncommon case of an 8-year-old boy characterized by short stature and suspected hypoglycemia. In this case, hyperprolinemia was identified, and due to normal hypothalamic-pituitary function, short stature was recognized as a clinical manifestation of HPI. It is worth noting that our patient exhibited remarkable growth during his early years. The only clinical indicator prompting investigation for GHD was the lower growth velocity in the absence of overt anomalies in anthropometric parameters relative to the boy’s age.
PSIS consists of an orphan syndrome involving the congenital abnormality of the pituitary gland, with three main characteristics: i) the hypoplastic or inexistent anterior pituitary gland, ii) absent or thin infundibulum, and iii) ectopic posterior pituitary location. PSIS is presented during the first decade of life [18]. Several studies have attempted to explain the mechanisms that induce the triad of anomalies in PSIS. Two primary hypotheses posited for these abnormalities involve traumatic birth injuries (breech delivery, cesarean section, perinatal hypoxemia) and disturbances in the embryonic development of the hypothalamic-pituitary axis [19–21], none of which was applicable in the present case. Identifying familial instances of PSIS and the co-occurrence of central nervous system (CNS) malformations suggest a potential genetic origin, prompting molecular studies aimed at identifying responsible gene mutations [19–21]. However, the family history was unremarkable. Midline CNS malformations infrequently associated with PSIS involve optic nerve hypoplasia, absent septum pellucidum, and Chiari malformation [19–22]. Additional anomalies include micropenis and cryptorchidism [10], the latter observed and being surgically corrected in our case.
Clinically, PSIS manifests as an insufficiency of pituitary hormones, with GHD being universally present at the time of diagnosis [23], as in the case herein. The onset and progression of pituitary hormone deficiencies vary, with common clinical features including delayed growth in childhood and signs of hormonal deficiency at birth being apparent in 30% of cases [23]. The treatment approach involves hormone replacement therapy with GH, thyroxine (T4), cortisol, estrogen/testosterone, and antidiuretic hormone, according to the needs [14], with long-term follow-up being essential.
In summary, we present the case of a boy with HPII coexisting with PSIS manifesting as GHD, diagnosed due to low growth velocity. The coexistence of these two rare conditions presents a unique medical scenario and poses significant diagnostic challenges. The cause and prevention of severe hypoglycemic episodes in a child with two coexisting conditions before rhGH administration was a diagnostic dilemma. The excellent response to rhGH therapy and the absence of hypoglycemia during further follow-up led to the conclusion that the most decisive factor in the occurrence of the severe hypoglycemic episode was GHD. The value of accurate and regular recording of the anthropometric parameters is emphasized for identifying subtle pathological issues that may require intervention. In that case, they led to further investigations, ultimately revealing the presence of both conditions. This presentation underscores the importance of meticulous clinical evaluation and comprehensive investigative approaches in unraveling complex medical presentations. By shedding light on the complex interplay between rare genetic disorders and their clinical manifestations, this case contributes to the expanding body of knowledge in pediatric endocrinology and it underscores the importance of individualized patient care guided by precise diagnostic approaches.