We present a protocol of standard histologic preparation, that ultimately enables the virtual reconstruction and analysis of fetal cardiac structures at the time of first trimester anomaly scan, 11-13 gestational weeks. This is important, because the size of the fetal heart at the time of first trimester anomaly scan generates an important dilemma regarding the best method to audit the heart structures normalcy in pregnancy termination cases. At this age, the fetal heart is too small for standard pathology investigation methods [24] and conventional MRI [11–13], too big for alternate imaging methods, as the photonic confocal microscopy [20, 25–27], ultrasound backscatter microscopy [28,29], and optical coherence tomography [30–32], while non-invasive high-resolution imaging techniques as 7 - 9.4 T MRI [6–8] and micro-CT [9,10] are still performed only in research settings due to the low availability and limited data regarding the reliability of first trimester heart anomalies detection. The principle of 3D reconstructions of embryonic organs based on computer aided techniques is not new [16, 19] and in our opinion, should not remain a historical one, but improved for the first trimester autopsy purposes. In our experience, the use of the technical advances in histological preparation and computer-imaging software overcome the previous highlighted disadvantages of the method. Thus, we developed a protocol that involves basic resources for general settings, to obtain an accurate and reproducible histo-pathological imaging of the first trimester fetal heart.
The results of our pilot study showed that the main features of the fetal heart anatomy, including atria and ventricles features, septum, and ventricle outflow tracts emergence and branching were achievable in all cases using low resources in terms of equipment and medical personnel. It was much harder to highlight left atrium venous inflows, but the need to confirm abnormalities of these structures is negligible in the first trimester, as the veins identification is not part of the routinely ultrasound scan protocol.
Non-invasive imaging tools were proposed to serve as audit for first trimester anomaly, especially in the context of alarmingly decreasing rates of fetal conventional autopsy. In our view, it is questionable to audit an imaging in vivo technique (ultrasound) with another one (IRM, CT) performed post-mortem. Poor image resolution of conventional IRM account for significant errors regarding heart malformations detection in fetuses less than 24 weeks’ of gestation [7, 11, 13]. This problem of image resolution in small-sized fetuses could be addressed by carrying out postmortem MRI at high field strength or CT angiography [7, 9]. Using high-field postmortem MRI at 9.4 T, the four-chamber view and outflow tracts can be visualized in all fetuses irrespective of gestational age (8), while micro-CT improved resolution for imaging small objects down to micrometers. Still, the human and technical resources for such investigation are lacking in general settings. This is also the main disadvantage of advanced pathology techniques, such as episcopic microscopy.
The literature and our studies as well highlighted the need for an accurate early diagnosis in pregnancy [33-38]. Therefore, the main objective of our research was to develop a feasible method to imagine the fetal heart in the first trimester. As various techniques were proposed, we aimed to use an optimal technique in terms of resources involved, such as medical equipment requirements, software, personnel and time. Three-dimensional (3D) reconstructions of histological sections based on computeraided manual tracing appears the optimal alternative for the conventional autopsy for several reasons. First, the requirements for the protocol are very lenient. Then, the use of histology offers the possibility to reanalyze the original heart block and correctly identify the tissue characteristics. It is also important that any sectional planes may be reconstructed to imagine various heart structures that may be considered important for the respective case.
Regarding the resources we used, no custom-made hardware is necessary: stained sections were digitized using an ordinary scanner and computer. The other methods we mentioned as a replacement for conventional autopsy require highly specialized, dedicated and expensive equipment and software. The software used for the reconstruction protocol does not require programming skills and was designed for end users and can be purchased at a reasonable amount of money. To further decrease the time involved by the protocol, many steps may be automated: cutting, coloring and scanning.
Our work represents a pilot study that confirms the feasibility of reconstructing cardiac structures from histologic sections in first trimester fetuses. The results demonstrate that this method can be applied to routine clinical practice. The method we used has several advantages. The image reconstruction resolution from histologic sections is higher than conventional imaging techniques, while the heart volume information can be reexplored using two-dimensional and three-dimensional imaging.
Study limitation
We recognize the preliminary nature of this pilot study, limited to the reconstruction of several normal hearts. The objective of our research was to demonstrate the applicability of the method in nowadays settings. However, the quality of the images we have obtained leaves little doubt that the method will be feasible for the study of abnormal hearts.
Histological investigation requires a conventional autopsy, that has a much lower acceptance by parents than non-invasive virtuopsy, which is accepted by nearly all mothers. Thus, the high acceptance of virtuopsy makes it a more acceptable alternative, as the rate of refusal of conventional autopsy is rising and usually depends on factors over which we have no control [39].
A lower resolution of the “reconstructed” planes was noted compared with the other imaging methods. This morphological deformation, inherent during heart block sectioning and preparation could be corrected using external marker-based automatic congruency [40], although this approach was previously challenged because of the difficulties to place external markers close enough to the fetal heart [20]. This field may benefit from implementation of image processing solutions that improve modelling of distortions. Such correction software solutions are used in other imaging techniques, as ultrasound or micro-MRI.