This study is the first to identify transcriptional changes reflective of reduced trophic support in the schizophrenia midbrain, and these changes are more robust in the presence of neuroinflammation. We find that reductions in trophic support proximal to midbrain dopamine neurons in schizophrenia include reduced BDNF and TrkBTK+ gene expression. We predict that these would also be present at the protein level, as is found in other brain regions in schizophrenia [23, 36]. Our finding of reduced NURR1 mRNA, especially in high inflammation schizophrenia cases, supports our hypothesis that these altered gene expression levels could impact the health and maintenance of dopamine neurons. In contrast, we find increases in “negative regulators” for both TrkBTK− and p75 receptor mRNA. While these mRNAs are likely to be localised to astrocytes and oligodendrocytes respectively, and therefore may not directly impact BDNF signalling on midbrain dopamine neuronal cell membranes. We posit that these putative changes in mRNA may impede neurotrophic signalling and could impact neurons, including dopamine neurons, of the substantia nigra.
Overall downregulation of BDNF mRNA in the schizophrenia group compared to controls in this study appears to be mostly found in cases in the high inflammatory subgroup, as corresponding reductions in BDNF mRNA are not present in schizophrenia cases with low inflammation. Pro-inflammatory cytokines compromise the capacity of BDNF to provide trophic support to neurons by interfering with signal transduction from the TrkBTK+ receptor to PI3K/Akt and Ras/ERK pathways, which are responsible for the neuroprotective effects of BDNF [53–55]. SnRNAseq confirmed a primarily neuronal profile of BDNF expression in the post-mortem human midbrain in both low and high inflammation schizophrenia cases, as well as controls. However, further investigation into the specific subtypes of neurons where reductions in BDNF mRNA are localised in schizophrenia midbrain is warranted.
Dysregulated transcription of BDNF in schizophrenia may be directly related to NURR1 as NURR1 is a transcription factor for BDNF and NURR1 mRNA is also decreased in the midbrain in schizophrenia cases with high inflammation. NURR1 is critical for dopamine neuron survival as NURR1 deficiency and rare variants of the NURR1 gene contribute to neurodegeneration of dopamine neurons in Parkinson’s disease [56, 57]. Decreased NURR1 expression can precede downregulation of BDNF mRNA and is paralleled by reductions in TH in cultured mesencephalic neurons [77], which are less resilient to neurotoxicity with NURR1 deficiency [58], reflecting specific impediments to dopamine neuron survival mechanisms [59]. Hence, the observed reductions in NURR1 mRNA in the midbrain of high inflammation schizophrenia cases supports another feature of impaired trophic support for midbrain dopamine neurons and suggests compromised health of dopamine neurons in schizophrenia.
Further evidence for disrupted BDNF-mediated trophic signalling in the midbrain are reductions in TrkBTK+ mRNA in both of the inflammatory schizophrenia subgroups compared to controls, demonstrating that reduced TrkBTK+ mRNA may be detected in the absence of overt tissue inflammation in schizophrenia. Using snRNAseq, we detected pan-TrkB (both TK + and TK- splice variants) across multiple subtypes of neurons and astrocytes. This is consistent with the TrkBTK− splice variant being principally localised to glial cells in the human DLPFC [32] and also supports that alterations in full-length TrkB mRNA can affect both dopaminergic and non-dopaminergic neurons in the midbrain. Indeed, BDNF and TrkB reductions are correlated with deficits in inhibitory neuron transcripts in the cortex of people with schizophrenia [21]. We have found evidence of GABA neuron dysfunction, marked by reductions in glutamate decarboxylase mRNA and protein, as well as reduced parvalbumin mRNA, in schizophrenia midbrain [60], suggesting these deficits could also be correlated with neurotrophin reductions in subcortical regions. This reduction in TrkBTK+ mRNA could also impact dopamine neurons as TrkB hypomorphic mice with approximately 25–30% of normal levels of TrkB receptors display dopamine neuron loss in the nigrostriatal pathway [61], with accompanying gliosis [62]. We find levels of TrkBTK+ mRNA in schizophrenia are not as profoundly changed as in hypomorphic mice (~ 75% that of controls), yet this deficit could have a detrimental impact on midbrain dopamine neurons; however, a more extensive analysis of dopamine neurons in schizophrenia is needed.
In contrast to the full-length TrkB receptor, mRNA levels of the truncated receptor, TrkBTK−, were elevated in the midbrain of schizophrenia cases compared to controls, primarily in cases with high inflammation. BDNF binding to TrkBTK− receptors on glia can promote the release of pro-inflammatory cytokines, including IL1β and TNFα, consistent with the increase of these cytokines at the mRNA and protein level we have found in the schizophrenia midbrain [54, 63–65]. We also find increased reactive astrocytes (GFAP) and microglia (IBA1) mRNAs in schizophrenia midbrain, and these cells are proposed mediators of the neuroinflammatory state in schizophrenia [5, 66]. Inflammatory activity of resident immune cells of the brain can also regulate neurotransmission as cytokines can evoke dopamine release and further perpetuate the hyperdopaminergic state of nigrostriatal dopamine neurons, and thereby may contribute to psychotic symptoms in schizophrenia [67, 68].
Interestingly, increases in p75 receptor mRNA in schizophrenia midbrain appear to transcend inflammatory state and are found in both high and low immune subgroups. This was an unexpected finding since p75 is upregulated in neurons and astrocytes in response to inflammation and oxidative stress in vitro [69, 70]. Also, in contrast to our expectations, snRNAseq of midbrain nuclei demonstrated that p75 receptor gene expression appears to be found mostly in oligodendrocytes in schizophrenia cases and controls. This observation was confirmed with immunohistochemistry; we found p75 receptor protein in oligodendrocyte-like cells and white matter tracts in many of the low and high inflammation schizophrenia cases, as well as some control cases. As p75 receptor expression in oligodendrocytes has a dual role, mediating both regenerative potential of these cells, but also promoting cell death [71, 72], these changes are difficult to interpret. While it is possible that increased p75 may be beneficial to oligodendrocytes in schizophrenia midbrain in the absence of neuroinflammation, we speculate that oligodendrocytes may be vulnerable to cell damage/death in high inflammation schizophrenia as mRNA for the cell-death ligand, TNFα, which is known to bind to p75, is increased. Indeed, myelin dysfunction, together with reductions in subcortical and cortical oligodendrocytes and associated transcripts, is found in schizophrenia in association with neuroinflammation [73–78]. Altogether, p75 receptor upregulation in the schizophrenia midbrain appears primarily localised in oligodendrocytes, indicating a role for the p75 receptor in contributing to white matter pathology in schizophrenia, rather than directly interfering with BDNF-mediated trophic support on the cell membrane of midbrain neurons.
We have evidence that the transcriptional changes evident in midbrain BDNF, TrkB, p75 and NURR1 may not result from long-term antipsychotic exposure as we do not find any changes in these mRNAs in healthy adult rats chronically treated with either first- (haloperidol) or second-generation (risperidone) antipsychotic drugs. However, animal studies assessing the effects of chronic antipsychotic exposure with a shorter duration of treatment report reductions in BDNF in multiple brain regions [79–83]. In humans, we find that midbrain p75 mRNA positively correlated with daily antipsychotic dose, supporting a potential contribution of antipsychotics to p75 receptor upregulation. However, midbrain BDNF mRNA did not correlate with antipsychotic exposure, consistent with previous post-mortem studies which also report no significant correlations with lifetime antipsychotic doses [23, 24, 26]. Reductions in TrkBTK+ mRNA levels in the post-mortem human DLPFC in schizophrenia are found and correlate with higher lifetime antipsychotic dose [11], so the potential impact of antipsychotics cannot be entirely ruled out. Gene expression of BDNF and NURR1 mRNA in the midbrain was found to negatively correlate with duration of illness in schizophrenia cases, and this may reflect that both mRNAs are known to decrease with age [84, 85], and the effect of increasing age on the brain may be more accelerated in schizophrenia [86, 87]
Limitations
Nuclei selected for snRNAseq analysis were Olig2- and NeuN+, suggesting that many cells that may express BDNF, TrkB and p75 were not selected for analysis, including subpopulations of dopaminergic neurons that are NeuN- in mammals [88] and oligodendrocytes. Future snRNAseq analysis may instead select for cells that express a marker for dopamine neurons to specifically characterise the transcriptional landscape in midbrain dopamine neurons in schizophrenia. Additionally, this study assessed the effects of chronic antipsychotic treatment on midbrain trophic transcripts in healthy adult rats; however, antipsychotics may differentially regulate trophic support molecules in the schizophrenia disease state, particularly when neuroinflammation is present.