4.1. Moderate supplement nano iron improved the growth performance and enhanced its intestinal physical barrier.
Iron (Fe) has been recognized as an essential mineral element crucial for fish health and growth [5]. This experiment demonstrated that supplementing juvenile Largemouth Bass with 60 mg/kg nano iron resulted in improved growth performance, as evidenced by significant increases in their Weight Gain Ratio (WGR) and Specific Growth Rate (SGR). Consistently, previous studies have demonstrated that supplementing fish diets with nano iron significantly enhances growth performance. This effect has been observed in various species including Hybrid Tilapia [22], Yellow Catfish [23], and juvenile Cobia [24]. However, excessive supplementation of nano iron did not yield further improvement in the Specific Growth Rate (SGR). Indeed, the group supplemented with 480 mg/kg of nano iron had a negative impact on the fish growth, in contrast to the group supplemented with 60 mg/kg. Similar declines in growth performance have been noted in other fish species. For example, hybrid tilapia demonstrated substantial reductions in feed efficiency and growth when their diet was supplemented with 400 mg/kg of iron citrate [22]. Moreover, juvenile Grass Carp exhibited reduced feed intake and Specific Growth Rate (SGR) when fed a diet containing 120 mg/kg of iron, in contrast to those fed a diet containing 52.8 mg/kg [25]. Research has demonstrated that heightened concentrations of nano iron can diminish embryonic hatching rates and induce apoptotic cell death in zebrafish [26]. Therefore, the adverse effects of excessive supplementation of nano iron on largemouth bass may stem from iron toxicity, which disrupts the balance of physiological functions, thereby impairing their ability to achieve optimal growth potential.
Intestinal villi are one of the important structures in the fish intestine, and their ability to increase the intestinal absorption area and absorption efficiency has an important impact on the growth and immunity of fish[27]. The addition of iron in the feed in appropriate amounts can improve the absorption efficiency of iron in fish, thus promoting the growth and development of intestinal villi and improving the growth and immunity of fish[28]. The findings of this experiment revealed that the length, width, density and absorption area of intestinal villi could be increased by proper addition of nano-iron. However, both insufficient and excessive iron supplementation had adverse effects on these parameters. Excessive iron levels can elevate free radical production in the fish intestine, potentially damaging the structure and function of intestinal villi and impeding fish growth and immunity. Conversely, inadequate iron levels can result in iron deficiency in fish, hindering the growth and development of intestinal villi. Thus, maintaining optimal iron levels is crucial for promoting healthy intestinal morphology and overall fish health [29].
The intestinal epithelial barrier primarily comprises tight junctions between adjacent cells, which are composed of several tight junctional proteins such as Claudins, Occludin, and ZOs. These proteins modulate intestinal permeability, facilitate selective nutrient absorption, and act as barriers against the entry of harmful substances into the human body through the intestine [30]. The current study demonstrated that supplementing with nano iron did not lead to a significant increase in the relative expression levels of intestinal tight junction-related genes MUC2, Claudin1, Claudin7, and ZO-1. However, higher levels of nano iron supplementation suppressed the relative expression levels of MUC2, ZO-1, and Claudin1. Electron microscopic observations further revealed that the tight junctions of cells in groups E and F exhibited compromised integrity, with blurred gaps, revealing that excessive supplementation of nano-iron adversely affect intestinal tight junctions. Excessive supplementation of nano iron may result in an accumulation of iron ions within intestinal cells, triggering a significant production of free radicals via the Fenton reaction. This oxidative stress can induce an inflammatory response within the intestine, ultimately damaging the physical barrier in juvenile largemouth bass [31].
4.2. Nano iron improved the intestinal antioxidant status and enhanced the immune ability.
Antioxidant capacity refers to an organism's ability to combat free radicals, which are major contributors to numerous diseases and significant agents of oxidative damage to cells [32]. In fish, the intestine plays pivotal roles in the digestion and absorption of nutrients. Furthermore, it serves as a critical defense barrier against potentially harmful external substances for the organism. [33]. Therefore, investigating the impact of nano iron on the intestinal antioxidant capacity of largemouth bass is crucial for understanding its effects on fish health. The study results revealed that increasing dietary nano iron supplementation led to a pattern where activities of antioxidant enzymes T-SOD and CAT initially increased and then decreased, whereas MDA content exhibited the opposite trend. Additionally, nano iron supplementation significantly influenced the expression of antioxidant-related genes in Largemouth bass. Specifically, the expressions of SOD1, CAT and Nrf-2 genes were increased in the 60 mg/kg group and decreased in the 480 mg/kg group. These findings align with previous research showing that dietary supplementation with a certain level of nano-iron enhanced activities of glutathione peroxidase (GPx) and superoxide dismutase (SOD) in the intestinal tissues of snowy salmon, thereby improving their ability to scavenge free radicals [12]. This suggested that supplementing nano iron about 60 mg/kg enhanced the fish's ability to scavenge free radicals and protects the intestine from oxidative damage. However, excessive nano iron can disrupt the antioxidant system of the fish gut, resulting in oxidative damage and potentially contributing to the development of intestinal diseases [34].
Compared to the 0 mg/kg group, the relative expression levels of intestinal pro-inflammatory genes TNF-α and COX-2 showed a tendency to decrease in the 60 mg/kg and 120 mg/kg groups. These findings suggest that moderate amounts of nano iron have the potential to attenuate the inflammatory response of the intestine, thereby offering protection against inflammatory damage. At moderate concentrations of nano iron, modulating oxidative stress levels through activation of the intracellular antioxidant defense system may be advantageous for mitigating inflammatory responses [35]. In contrast, Conversely, supplementation with excessive nano iron (480 mg/kg) significantly reduced the expression of anti-inflammatory genes such as TGF-β1 and IL-10. Excessive iron may influence the Fenton reaction, leading to heightened production of free radicals in the body and increased oxidative stress. Consequently, this oxidative stress may be responsible for the low expression of anti-inflammatory genes, which further increases inflammation in the body [29].
In the present study, the intestine of largemouth bass in the 60 mg/kg supplemented group exhibited relatively low expression levels of Caspase3 and Bax (pro-apoptosis-related genes). Concurrently, the relative expression levels of the anti-apoptotic gene Bcl-2 initially increased to the highest level with nano iron supplementation, but then reduced gradually with higher concentrations of nano iron. These findings suggested that moderate levels of nano iron may mitigate intestinal cell apoptosis. This effect could be attributed to the enhancement of the body's antioxidant capacity by moderate nano iron, which helps scavenge excessive free radicals within cells, thereby reducing oxidative damage. Ultimately, this protective mechanism may contribute to maintaining the integrity and stability of intestinal cells and decreasing apoptosis levels. However, excessive supplementation of nano iron may lead to an elevated rate of apoptosis in intestinal cells. This is likely due to the toxic effects of high nano iron levels, which intensify intracellular oxidative damage and subsequently induce apoptosis in intestinal cells. Overall, supplementing with nano iron at appropriate concentrations has the potential to bolster the immunity of the intestinal tract in juvenile largemouth bass and reduce intestinal apoptosis, thereby promoting and maintaining intestinal health.
4.3 Nano iron can improve the disease resistance, but high concentration of nano iron had negative effects.
With the rapid development of aquaculture, the scale of intensive farming is also increasing. However, the increase in culture density has led to an increase in the instability of environmental factors in the culture water, which can easily lead to a decrease in the immunity of the fish and is highly susceptible to large-scale diseases and mortality. Nocardia amberjack is a pathogenic bacterium frequently suffered by largemouth bass, and the main symptom is the appearance of white nodules on the body surface and internal organs, which is highly pathogenic to largemouth bass[36]. In order to reduce fish mortality and economic losses due to diseases and to improve the survival rate and economic efficiency of culture, it is now crucial to enhance the immunity of cultured fish through the addition of nutrients in feeds under the strict restriction of the use of antibiotics[37]. Iron plays a dual role in fish physiology: it not only promotes fish growth but also plays a crucial role in enhancing their immune function.
After Nocardia amberjack attack, the survival rate of largemouth bass was highest in the group supplemented with 60 mg/kg iron nanoparticles, lowest in the group without iron nanoparticles (0 mg/kg), and second lowest in the group supplemented with 480 mg/kg iron nanoparticles. This deficiency could potentially reduce the activity of iron-containing enzymes in the body, thereby impacting the function of immune cells and the bactericidal ability of leukocytes, ultimately compromising the overall immunity of the fish [38]. The resistance of fish to Nocardia amberjack was diminished, as evidenced by the lower survival rate of juvenile Largemouth bass in the 480 mg/kg group following the attack. This outcome is likely attributed to an excess of iron triggering the Fenton reaction, resulting in the generation of excessive free radicals. Consequently, oxidative stress ensued, causing damage to tissues and organs through oxidative mechanisms [39], further compromising the organism's immune capacity [40]. In addition, high concentrations of iron may promote bacterial growth and reproduction, causing more widespread infections and accelerating morbidity and mortality in the animal body[41]. The findings of this experiment align with Sealey et al.'s study, which observed that iron deficiency in feed increased the susceptibility of spotted forked catfish to Edwardsiella infection. Additionally, supplementing with appropriate amounts of iron reversed the decreased immunity resulting from iron deficiency in the fish. However, high iron levels (180 mg/kg) in Sealey et al.'s study also suppressed the immune response and elevated mortality among spotted forked catfish following E. edwardsi attack [42]. Therefore, supplementing the feed with nano iron can enhance the antibacterial capacity of juvenile Largemouth Bass by bolstering immune system function. However, excessive doses could potentially induce oxidative damage and compromise the organism's immunity [43].