3.1 Material characterization
The crystal structure of the samples was evaluated via XRD. Figures 2a and 2b show the XRD patterns for the samples calcinated at temperatures ranging from 600 to 1000°C. For the sample calcined at 1000°C, the diffraction peaks were between those of cubic TiN (JCPDS 38–1420) and TiO (JCPDS 8–117), suggesting the formation of a cubic titanium oxynitride phase in this sample. As the calcination temperature decreased, the peaks corresponding to titanium oxynitride broadened and shifted to larger angles. Additionally, a new peak appeared at approximately 2θ = 25.7° at 600 and 700°C, which may have been due to an abundant carbonaceous product from the precursor.
Figure 2c presents the change in the lattice constant of the cubic titanium oxynitride phase. The lattice constants were approximately 0.422 nm for temperatures between 1000 and 800°C. At 700°C, the lattice constant was clearly reduced to 0.418 nm. Referring to the database, the lattice constants of cubic TiO and TiN are 0.417 nm and 0.424 nm, respectively. The lattice-constant variation of the samples indicated the decreasing TiN composition in the titanium oxynitride phase at lower calcination temperatures. The crystalline phase composition of the catalysts was calculated by applying Vegard’s law to TiO and TiN (see Figure S2) (Djaoued et al. 2002).
Figure 2 Crystalline phase states for catalysts calcinated at different temperatures. Powder XRD patterns for catalysts (a), an enlarged view of the XRD pattern around 42.8° (b), the lattice constant (c), and the crystallite size calculated using Scherrer’s equation (d). The two dotted lines in (c) represent the lattice constants of TiN (JCPDS 38–1420) and TiO (JCPDS 8–117), respectively. The black dashed line in (d) represents the curve fittied to the data. The crystallite size and lattice constant were determined using the strongest diffraction peak at approximately 42.8°, which corresponds to the (200) plane of cubic titanium oxynitride.
To investigate the local structure and electronic state of the prepared catalysts, XAS experiments were conducted. Ti K-edge X-ray absorption near edge structure (XANES) of the series of catalysts and references are shown in Figs. 3a and S1. The spectrum of the sample calcined at 1000°C was similar to that of TiN. Meanwhile, the XAS spectra of the catalysts calcinated at lower temperatures ranging from 600 to 900°C did not correspond to any of the reference materials, and a remarkable pre-edge peak was observed at 4966 eV, as shown in Fig. 3b, which was also detected in the XANES spectrum of the titanium polyacrylate precursor. Farge et al. reported that the pre-edge peak increases in intensity and shifts to a lower energy as the coordination number of the titanium compound decreases (Farges et al. 1997). Accordingly, it is assumed that complete thermal decomposition of the precursor did not occur at these temperatures, yielding a mixture of titanium intermediates with a lower coordination number. In addition, this titanium intermediates phase was a non-crystalline phase, as no corresponding diffraction peak is observed in the XRD patterns in Fig. 2(a).
Figure 3 XANES spectra for the catalysts and reference materials (a), enlarged view of the pre-edge region in the XANES spectra (b), and the edge position shift with respect to the calcination temperature (c). All the XANES spectra were normalized. The black dotted line in (b) represents a pre-edge peak position at 600°C. The three dotted lines in (c) represent the edge positions of anatase TiO2, Ti4O7, and TiN respectively.
In this section, we discuss the electroconductivity of the deposited carbon in the samples. Figure 4 illustrates the variation in specific electrical resistivity with respect to the calcination temperature. Increasing the calcination temperature significantly reduced the resistivity, with the value decreasing by five orders of magnitude between 600 and 1000°C. The specific electrical resistivity decreased sharply at 800°C, and in response, the CV current increased rapidly (see Figure S3). The reduction in resistivity at 800°C is attributed to the promotion of deposited-carbon graphitization. Barbela et al. reported that graphitization of organic compounds progressed, yielding deposited carbon, over 750°C (Barbera et al. 2014). The electroconductivity measurements and CV measurements confirmed that an electron conduction path was formed through calcination of titanium polyacrylate.
To assess the change in catalyst morphology, TEM was conducted. Figures 5 and S4 show TEM images of the samples. Titanium compound grains and deposited carbon were observed under all the calcination conditions. As the calcination temperature increased, the particle size increased to several tens of nanometers, and the amount of deposited carbon covering the catalyst particle surface decreased.
3.3 Effect of calcination temperature on catalyst structure
Details regarding the catalyst structure for each calcination temperature are presented as Table 1 and Fig. 7. At 1000°C, the crystalline titanium oxynitride phase dominated in most of the catalyst particles. The chemical state of the particles was close to TiN. Although the specific resistance of the deposited carbon was the lowest among all the samples, the CV current was low, indicating that the electron conduction path formation was insufficient. At 900 and 800°C, the chemical state of the crystalline phase was hardly changed from that at 1000°C, whereas the proportion of the non-crystalline oxide-like phase in the catalyst particles was increased, as indicated by the XANES spectra. The resistivity of the deposited carbon was on the order of 10–100 Ω cm, and the CV current was relatively high, suggesting that there was a sufficient electron conduction path. At 700 and 600°C, most of the catalyst particles consisted of non-crystalline oxide-like phase. The resistivity of the deposited carbon was on the order of 104–105 Ω cm, and the CV currents were poor, suggesting that the electron conduction path formation was insufficient.
Chisaka et al. reported that the ORR activity decreased when the crystal structure transformed into cubic TiN because of excess nitrogen doping (Chisaka et al. 2013). In our study, a similar trend was observed. At 900 and 1000°C, the crystal structures were almost cubic TiN, and the Erest values were poor. Our results suggested that the decline in activity under high calcination temperatures was due to the excess nitrogen doping. Notably, Erest exhibited a strong correlation with the absorption edge position of the XANES spectra (see Figure S6). The absorption edge position located on the higher-energy side was recognized as the result of slight nitrogen doping in the oxides. While a detailed discussion of the mechanism underlying the activity is beyond the scope of this study, this trend suggests that the slight nitrogen doping of the non-crystalline titanium oxide-like phase may induce active-site formation. Although the samples calcinated at 600 and 700°C had high Erest values, their iORR values were poor. This is attributed to the insufficient electron conduction path formation. While there were catalytic particles capable of functioning as active sites, the poor electrical effective surface area resulted in a low current. According to the findings of this study, forming sufficient electroconductive deposited carbon and maintaining an appropriate nitrogen doping level of the oxynitride phase are important for achieving high Erest and iORR values. In future research, calcination conditions that allow precise manipulation of both the deposited carbon and the catalyst particle structure should be investigated.
Table 1
Material characterization and catalytic activity.
Calcination temperature /°C | Crystallite size /nm | Crystalline TiOxN1−x phase composition | Specific resistance /Ωcm | Erest /V | iORR at 0.60 V vs. RHE /mA g–1 |
/- |
600 | n/a | n/a | 34\(\times\)104 | 0.865 | 0.091 |
700 | 1.9 | TiO0.85N0.15 | 35\(\times\)103 | 0.884 | 8.9 |
800 | 15 | TiO0.35N0.65 | 51 | 0.861 | 4.9\(\times\)102 |
900 | 39 | TiO0.33N0.67 | 14 | 0.784 | 3.5\(\times\)102 |
1000 | 77 | TiO0.29N0.71 | 4.5 | 0.631 | 31 |