Stenotic group was compared to non-stenotic group in 4 subgroups of stenosese over 50%, 70%, 80% and 90% respectively.
The first group with stenosis over 50% included all 39 eye artery pairs. In 70% group there were 27 pairs, 80% 13 pairs and 90% 6 artery-eye pairs.
The AV difference was statistically significantly higher in the 80% stenosis vessels than the non-stenotic blood vessels (36.5% vs 39.0%; p-value 0.008)
It remained significant even in the control group formed of 47 eye artery pairs of any stenosis under 79% (35,9% vs 39,0%; p-value 0,028).
On the other hand, no statistically significant difference in any of the parameters of retinal oximetry was found for the threshold stenoses of 50%, 70% and 90%. There was a trend of increased AV difference, arterial saturation, decreased venular saturation and increased venular diameter in all stenotic subgroups compared to the control group.
Possible reasons are discussed below.
All groups showed significant difference in PSV and EDV values showing reliability of the ultrasonographic examination and stenosis evaluation.
A logistic regression analysis was used to test the reliability of the AV difference as the most sensitive parameter for predicting the odds ratio for the carotid stenosis in the same stenosis threshold groups.
For the stenosis of 50%, the cut-off value of AV difference of 38,96% was used with low sensitivity and medium specificity (44% vs. 85%). This value showed odds ratio of stenosis over 50% 4,379 (95% CI: 1,101–17,42; p = 0,036).
For the stenosis of 70%, a cut-off value for an AV difference of 38,9% was used, with sensitivity 48% and specificity 85%. Odds ratio for the 70% stenosis was 5,262; 95% CI: 1,246–22,23; p = 0,024.
For the stenosis of 80%, AV diff. was statistically significant, p-value 0.008. The cut-off value for the AV difference 38.712% was used with a sensitivity 69% and specificity 80%. Odds ratio for the 80% stenosis was 9,000; 95%CI: 1,801–44,96; p = 0,007
For the same severity threshold using the control group consisting of both non-stenotic and under 79% stenosis patients, the AV difference remained statistically significant with p-value 0.0028. 36.34% was chosen as a cutoff value with a sensitivity of 92% and specificity 52%. Odds ratio for the 80% stenosis with this broadened control group was 14.3; 1.713– 119; p = 0.014.
For the stenosis of 90%, no significant values were measured. The sample consisted of 6 patients in the stenotic group.
Results for each group are summarized in graphs 1–5 and Tables 2–6
Table 2
Analysis of measured values in stenosis over 50% vs. control group
| Control group (n = 21) | Stenosis over 50% (n = 39) | Mann-Whitney U test p-value |
Median | Min | Max | Median | Min | Max |
ACI PSV | 78,5 | 42 | 150 | 258 | 129 | 661 | < 0,0001 |
ACI EDV | 24 | 4 | 56 | 63 | 13 | 396 | < 0,0001 |
A SatO2 (%) | 97,7 | 90,7 | 102,4 | 97,7 | 91,6 | 103,2 | 0,968 |
V SatO2 (%) | 62,4 | 52,2 | 75,1 | 61,3 | 41,3 | 70,8 | 0,239 |
A Diameter (approx. µm) | 113,3 | 86,0 | 132,3 | 108,8 | 90,3 | 137,3 | 0,548 |
V diameter | 160,5 | 119,7 | 204,3 | 160,8 | 112,0 | 191,7 | 0,866 |
A-V diff. | 36,5 | 26,9 | 42,4 | 37,1 | 23,6 | 53,6 | 0,096 |
Table 3
Analysis of measured values in stenosis over 70% vs. control group
| Control group (n = 21) | Stenosis over 70% (n = 27) | Mann-Whitney U test p-value |
Median | Min | Max | Median | Min | Max |
ACI PSV | 78,5 | 42,0 | 150,0 | 285,0 | 200,0 | 661,0 | < 0,0001 |
ACI EDV | 24,0 | 4,0 | 56,0 | 80,0 | 32,0 | 396,0 | < 0,0001 |
A SatO2 (%) | 97,7 | 90,7 | 102,4 | 97,7 | 91,6 | 101,9 | 0,983 |
V SatO2 (%) | 62,3 | 52,2 | 75,1 | 60,8 | 44,4 | 70,8 | 0,268 |
A Diameter (approx. µm) | 113,3 | 86,0 | 132,3 | 109,0 | 90,3 | 137,3 | 0,628 |
V diameter | 160,5 | 119,7 | 204,3 | 162,8 | 112,0 | 191,7 | 0,923 |
A-V diff. | 36,5 | 26,9 | 42,4 | 38,9 | 23,6 | 53,6 | 0,098 |
Table 4
Analysis of measured values in stenosis over 80% vs. control group
| Control group (n = 21) | Stenosis over 80% (n = 13) | Mann-Whitney U test p-value |
Median | Min | Max | Median | Min | Max |
ACI PSV | 78,5 | 42 | 150 | 400 | 252 | 661 | < 0,0001 |
ACI EDV | 24 | 4 | 56 | 132 | 34 | 396 | < 0,0001 |
A SatO2 (%) | 97,7 | 90,7 | 102,4 | 97,7 | 94,0 | 101,4 | 0,713 |
V SatO2 (%) | 62,4 | 52,2 | 75,1 | 57,6 | 52,6 | 68,2 | 0,113 |
A Diameter (approx. µm) | 113,3 | 86,0 | 132,3 | 110,5 | 90,3 | 133,0 | 0,985 |
V diameter | 160,5 | 119,7 | 204,3 | 168,3 | 130,0 | 191,7 | 0,699 |
A-V diff. | 36,5 | 26,9 | 42,4 | 39,0 | 32,6 | 42,6 | 0,008 |
Table 5
Analysis of measured values in stenosis over 90% vs. control group
| Control group (n = 21) | Stenosis over 90% (n = 6) | Mann-Whitney U test p-value |
Median | Min | Max | Median | Min | Max |
ACI PSV | 78,5 | 42 | 150 | 509 | 265 | 661 | < 0,0001 |
ACI EDV | 24 | 4 | 56 | 188,5 | 132 | 396 | < 0,0001 |
A SatO2 (%) | 97,7 | 90,7 | 102,4 | 98,6 | 95,8 | 101,4 | 0,543 |
V SatO2 (%) | 62,4 | 52,2 | 75,1 | 59,2 | 56,3 | 63,2 | 0,273 |
A Diameter (approx. µm) | 113,3 | 86,0 | 132,3 | 113,0 | 105,0 | 133,0 | 0,447 |
V diameter | 160,5 | 119,7 | 204,3 | 171,6 | 130,0 | 191,7 | 0,855 |
A-V diff. | 36,5 | 26,9 | 42,4 | 38,9 | 36,8 | 41,9 | 0,051 |
Table 6
– Analysis of measured values in stenosis over 80% vs. control group of stenosis under 80% and nonstenotic vessels
| Control group under 80% (n = 47) | Stenosis over 80% (n = 13) | Mann-Whitney U test p-value |
Median | Min | Max | Median | Min | Max |
ACI PSV | 171,5 | 42 | 357 | 400 | 252 | 661 | < 0,0001 |
ACI EDV | 34 | 4 | 164 | 132 | 34 | 396 | < 0,0001 |
A SatO2 (%) | 97,7 | 90,7 | 103,2 | 97,7 | 94,0 | 101,4 | 0,499 |
V SatO2 (%) | 62,6 | 41,3 | 75,1 | 57,6 | 52,6 | 68,2 | 0,143 |
A Diameter (approx. µm) | 108,9 | 86,0 | 137,3 | 110,5 | 90,3 | 133,0 | 0,628 |
V diameter | 159,1 | 112,0 | 204,3 | 168,3 | 130,0 | 191,7 | 0,337 |
A-V diff. | 35,9 | 23,6 | 53,6 | 39,0 | 32,6 | 42,6 | 0,028 |