The immunomodulatory and anti-inflammatory functions of MSC, including ADSC, are strongly expected to exert therapeutic effects on a wide variety of age-related diseases 2. However, it has been found that when they are exposed to an inflammatory environment for a prolonged period, MSC actually become pro-inflammatory instead 2. SASP of MSC under an inflammatory environment is a serious challenge in clinical applications of MSC-based cell therapy, since affected tissues and organs are basically inflamed, which could be one of the reasons for insufficient efficacy of MSC-based cell therapies 18. In fact, non-quiescent ADSC cultured on plastic tissue culture plates exhibited stress-induced SASP (Figs. 2B and 3). However, inducing quiescence in those once non-quiescent cells successfully eliminated SASP even in the presence of stimuli that cause oxidative stress in ADSC. Therefore, regardless of preexisting SASP due to premature senescence, ADSC may be able to exert therapeutic effects for age-related diseases, including diabetes, once they become quiescent. Our results suggest that even ADSC isolated from patients, which are supposedly inflamed and showing SASP, could serve to treat inflammatory conditions, once they are converted to a quiescent state.
Conditioned medium from quiescent ADSC, which contains secretome and extracellular vesicles originated from these cells, effectively promoted fibroblast migration in vitro (Fig. 3), and transplanted quiescent ADSC in gel away from a wound accelerated diabetic wound healing (Fig. 4). It has been considered that the beneficial effects of MSC are attributable to their secretome and extracellular vesicles 9. Thus, therapeutic effects of quiescent ADSC can be expected, both by transplanting them in patients, and by administering the culture medium or its extracts to patients. It is also noteworthy that quiescent ADSC exhibited beneficial effects even under a diabetic condition (Figs. 2B, 3 and 4). Thus, quiescent ADSC-based cell therapies may provide solutions for diabetic complications even without the necessity of appropriate glycemic control, which may be sometimes difficult to achieve 19. Further in vivo and clinical research is necessary to explore these possibilities.
ADSC have been administered without a scaffold intravenously or locally (e.g. intramuscularly or intratracheally) in clinical studies to date. Our data suggest that quiescence may eliminate SASP from ADSC. Thus, if quiescent ADSC were to be used for disease treatment, ADSC might be administered with hydrogel as their scaffold in order to make ADSC quiescent. There are apparent advantages of using a scaffold; rapid disappearance of cells is one of the major challenges for present MSC-based cell therapies in which cells are administered without a scaffold 3–5. To overcome this issue, a large amount of MSC has been used for each treatment, which necessitates vast ex vivo expansion of MSC. Furthermore, most intravenously injected MSC are trapped in lung capillaries, instead of targeting inflamed tissues/organs, which raises the concern of pulmonary embolism due to administration of a large amount of MSC. ADSC embedded in gel can be injected as shown in Fig. 4, which shows that ADSC persist in gel for a prolonged period. In fact, a substantial amount of ADSC in gel persisted locally for at least 7 days after transplantation when compared with ADSC without gel (Fig. 4B), which may explain accelerated wound healing in mice with quiescent ADSC in gel. Thus, loss of cells is not a concern, and administration of a large amount of ADSC may not be necessary, which should make ADSC-based cell therapies safer and easier to access for patients. One potential drawback of administering ADSC in hydrogel is that the inflamed tissues and organs in patients may not necessarily be in close proximity to the administered ADSC. Inflammation could even be systemic. Nevertheless, as shown in Fig. 4A, transplanting quiescent ADSC in hydrogel away from the wound site still exhibited beneficial effects, suggesting that ADSC embedded in hydrogel may be able to control inflammation in remote tissues and organs. However, further research is necessary to establish such a remote effect of quiescent ADSC.
In our previous study we demonstrated that bone marrow-derived mesenchymal stem cells became quiescent on the surface of 250 Pa polyacrylamide gel 7. In this study we investigated whether quiescent MSC have clinical relevance. To this end, we adopted 3D biocompatible commercially available soft gel as a substrate for ADSC. ADSC in 3D-NanoFibGrow-I gel, whose stiffness is similar to that of 250 Pa polyacrylamide gel 8, also exhibited reversible cell cycle arrest (Fig. 1) and apparently eliminated SASP due to premature senescence, which cells encountered before being embedded in 3D-NanoFibGrow-I gel (Figs. 2B and 3). Thus, it is safe to say that quiescent MSC on 2D soft polyacrylamide gel were successfully reproduced in ADSC cultured in 3-D biocompatible gel, which will make possible future studies to investigate whether quiescent ADSC have clinical relevance.
High glucose treatment causes both oxidative stress and hyperosmotic stress, both of which have been reported to induce cellular responses in MSC 20. Thus, cellular responses caused by high glucose treatment could be attributable to either oxidative stress or hyperosmotic stress. However, non-quiescent ADSC exhibited attenuated IL-6 secretion, whereas quiescent ADSC showed resistance to high glucose treatment, which was reproduced in response to hydrogen peroxide treatment (Fig. 2B). Therefore, it is reasonable to consider that oxidative stress inhibits IL-6 secretion by non-quiescent ADSC, but quiescence markedly upregulates IL-6 secretion and makes ADSC resistant to oxidative stress in terms of IL-6 secretion.
Immune cell infiltration, as well as fibrotic changes, was not apparent at least up to 7 days after transplanting human ADSC into mice with a normal immune system (Fig. 4B), which was also true for the mice approximately 2 months after transplantation (data not shown). Thus, it is safe to say that the immunomodulatory functions of ADSC are maintained under quiescence. Also, 3D-NanoFibGrow-Ⅰ gel might be able to serve as a scaffold for ADSC for cell therapies in clinical settings. However, it is apparent that further studies are required to address these safety issues.
Although accelerated wound healing in STZ mice by quiescent ADSC in gel was apparent 3 days after transplantation, all mice including non-diabetic mice exhibited a similar level of wound healing 10 days after transplantation (Fig. 4A). Previous studies by others have also reported that STZ mice show completion of wound healing at the same time as non-diabetic control mice 15. Therefore, completion of wound healing eventually should be considered a limitation of using STZ mice, and initial acceleration during the healing process should be the endpoint in this diabetic wound model.
Non-quiescent ADSC on plastic tissue culture plates exhibited ROS accumulation, even when they were cultured with low glucose DMEM (5.5 mM glucose). However, these cells lost accumulated ROS despite being in a non-quiescent state, if they were once subjected to quiescence (Fig. 5). Thus, quiescence may be associated with elimination of accumulated ROS, which might explain the beneficial effects of quiescent ADSC. However, a causal relationship between quiescence and enhanced anti-inflammatory functions or elimination of SASP is not clear at this time and further research is required.
In conclusion, inducing quiescence in ADSC by embedding them in 3-D biocompatible gel accelerated diabetic wound healing presumably by eliminating SASP due to oxidative stress and by extending the dwell time of ADSC in vivo. Thus, application of quiescent ADSC in hydrogel may contribute to increasing the efficacy without compromising the safety of ADSC-based cell therapies.