Whipple’s disease (WD) is a rare infectious disease with an incidence of one in a million individuals. It can affect multiple organs, leading to highly heterogeneous clinical manifestations. Although it was first described over a hundred years, but due to the low positive rate of traditional detection methods and a lack of understanding of the disease, a considerable such disease has been overlooked. With the advancement of molecular biological diagnostic technology, it has greatly improved the detection of T. whipplei in various samples and enlarged the spectrum of TW infections[10]. NGS is a new technology that uses High-Throughput Sequencing to sequence all the DNA in samples. This new technology has improved the detection of rare pathogens, a retrospective study reported that the total positive rate detected by NGS method (91.1%) was significantly higher than that detected by the culture method (62.2%) in acute respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS) patients[11]. In recent years, many pneumonia caused by T. whipplei have been diagnosed by the use of NGS in BALF [12, 13, 14, 15, 16], this also confirms that T. whipplei can cause respiratory infections, but few study have explored the significance of the detection of T. whipplei in BALF. So, we performed a retrospective study in 43 patients with T. whipplei positive in 848 BALF samples. To the best of our knowledge, the present study is the first in a Hunan region, the second largest sample size in the epidemiological study of T. whipplei detected in BALF in China followed the study performed by Lin et al[12], and may provide valuable initial data for future epidemiological studies.
Our study showed that the disease was more likely to occur in middle-aged males rather than females, consistent with the study performed by Biagi F et al [17], and some scholars suggested that hormonal or genetic sex chromosome-associated factors influence the course of the infection or susceptibility[18]. However, a newer study in the United States suggested that the prevalence of Whipple’s disease was similar between males and females[19]. We found T. whipplei detected in the BALF is not related to smoking history, and the number of T. whipplei sequences was not related to the patient's immune status(Fig. 4). Besides, most patients in our study were non-immunodeficient status, we did not detect a higher prevalence of T. whipplei infection in immunocompromised patients which unlike the recent study performed by Lozupone et al[20], and a large study has also shown that T. whipplei infection had nothing to do with the patient’s immune status[9]. In our study, there were 22 patients diagnosed with pneumonia, accounting for half of the samples, this also supports that T. whipplei can causes acute lung infections, but the number of T. whipplei sequences was not related to the occurrence of pneumonia, so it indicates that only a limited number of carriers may develop to lung infection, so it supports that the host, bacterial, and environmental factors may all contribute to the pathogenesis[21], and some study suggested the host immunity appears to play a crucial role in developing the disease. Therefore, the mechanism of T. whipplei leading to pulmonary infection still needs further research.
The most common symptoms among these 43 patients were cough, expectoration, shortness of breath, and fever. Digestive and neurological symptoms were rare, this may be related to the fact that the gastrointestinal and nervous systems of these patients are not affected, which suggests that the respiratory tract can be an independent infected system, and if we can conduct pathological examinations on the intestines of these patients, it may better explain this phenomenon.
A previous study shown that routine laboratory tests for WD patients has no specific results, including elevated ESR or CRP levels (84%), and anemia in 50 patients (60%) [22], our study found the white blood cell count(WBC) can be elevated or normal, the PCT often increased slightly, but anemia is uncommon. In a recent study showed T. whipplei infection often led to increased serum lactate dehydrogenase (LDH) levels, and this might be used to predict the prognosis[23]. But, as far as we know, LDH can increased in many cases, the role of LDH in WD requires further research.
Chest CT image of the those patients exhibited a diverse range of findings, the most common imaging manifestation is lung nodules(18/43, 41.9%), including eleven solid nodules and seven ground-glass nodules, which could be solitary or diffuse, this is consistent with some other research findings[24], but the relationship between T. whipplei and lung nodules is not yet clear, and further exploration and research are needed in the future. Patchy infiltration (16/43, 37.2%) was the second most common imaging manifestation. Besides, five cases (5/43, 11.6%) had pleural effusion, two had interstitial changes, and only one case had cavity.
T. whipplei as the sole pathogen only in 6 BALF samples, and more often it co-exists with other pathogens. Among them, the most common co-exists is Epstein-Barr virus EBV(n = 13), followed by Haemophilus influenzae (n = 10), there is no research report on similar results currently. In addition, it is also common to have fungal co-exists, with a total number of 19 cases(including Pneumocystis jirovecii, Candida albicans, Aspergillus fumigatus and Penicillium marneffei), the most common detected fungi was Pneumocystis jirovecii, consistent with the research findings of Ying Li et al[25]. As for why there is such a high probability of co-exists between them, larger prospective studies are needed. However, unlike the results reported by Lin et al[12], none of our patients were found to have Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex, although one case was ultimately diagnosed with pulmonary tuberculosis and improved after anti-tuberculosis treatment.