Despite a marked decrease in weapon-carrying among high school-aged boys across all racial, ethnic, and age groups from 1993 to 2019,1–3 the issue of risky weapon-carrying behaviors (WCB) among Black youth in the US remains a complex public health concern with significant consequences for these young men, their families, and communities. This study examines weapon-carrying behaviors, which refers to the act of carrying different types of weapons in situations with a heightened potential for harm, aggression, or legal repercussions. WCB typically involves carrying firearms, knives, or other weapons in public spaces, schools, or other locations where the possession of weapons poses a significant risk. Firearm-related violence and WCB are notably higher among Black youth,4 who face disproportionate rates of firearm injuries, homicides, and severe punishments for weapon possession.3–5 Racially biased stereotypes exacerbate this issue by criminalizing firearm ownership among Black males compared to White males of the same age.3 Research must consider the unique experiences and rationale for WCB among Black adolescents in high-violence cities—with a paradoxical constellation of evidence-based violence prevention programs.6
Recent research has primarily focused on individual risk factors for WCB but has not adequately explored the unique set of interpersonal, community, and societal risk factors that directly influence WCB or the specific motivations underlying it among young Black males (YBM). This study aims to address these gaps by examining the prevalence of WCB and its associations with other types of interpersonal and peer violence, including youth violence, community violence, and partner abuse, as well as substance use among YBM. The ultimate goal is to comprehensively identify and analyze the contributing and interacting factors associated with weapon carrying among YBM to inform intervention and policy design and implementation.
The Prevalence of Firearm Violence Among US Youth
Firearm-related injuries and fatalities, commonly the result of risky WCB, pose a persistent public health issue, particularly among YBM. In the United States, significant disparities based on race/ethnicity and gender are observed in firearm homicides and violent injuries among adolescents and young adults. Data from 2019 to 2020 reveals a noticeable 39% increase in firearm-related homicides among youths aged 10-24, coinciding with an approximately 15% rise in firearm-related suicides within the same age group.4 Where firearm homicides were reported, the origin of the firearm remained unknown for up to a third of decedents, suggesting we may be underestimating youth firearm access, especially outside the home.7 Other studies indicate that even after controlling for sociodemographic factors, past violence victimization, witnessing firearm-involved violence, and witnessing non-firearm-involved violence were both associated with teen firearm carriage (OR: 3.55 [1.86, 6.79] and 4.51 [1.75, 11.6]).8
Research that considers gender differences reveals that gun carrying is more common among males (6.8%) than females (1.9%) 9. In a study of US students in grades 9-12, non-Hispanic Black male students (10.6%) had the highest rates of gun carrying, followed by Hispanic males (7.2%) and non-Hispanic White males (6.1%).9 Among females, Hispanic students (3.5%) had higher rates than Black (2.0%) and White students (1.1%).9 Of those carrying firearms, 46.8% of males and 69.8% of females did so on 1-3 days in the past year, while 42.0% of males and 21.6% of females carried firearms on six or more days during the same period.9
Longitudinal studies show a decrease in weapon carrying among all boys in schools without any significant variations in weapon carrying based on race and/or ethnicity.10 However, male students who reported experiencing violence or feeling unsafe in school were at least twice as likely to bring a weapon to school (Jewett et al., 2021). The same study by Jewett et al. (2021) also found that these negative experiences were more prevalent among boys of color, with rates ranging from 8% to 12%, compared to non-Hispanic white boys, whose rates were between 4% and 5%.3 New data suggests that non-Hispanic White boys attending schools perceived as safer exhibit a greater propensity to carry guns onto school grounds compared to their non-Hispanic Black/African American or Hispanic peers.10 In contrast, findings suggest that the incidence of handgun carrying among girls almost doubled from 0.9% to 1.7% between 2002 and 2015 (a figure substantially higher than the increase reported by boys during the same time frame), with the majority of this increase being observed among non-Hispanic White and Hispanic girls.11 According to a recent measure, approximately one out of every 15 male and one out of every 50 female high school students have reported carrying a gun for non-recreational purposes at least once in the past 12 months.12
The existing literature on weapon-carrying among different racial and ethnic groups shows inconsistent findings. Certain studies indicate that Black youth are more likely to carry firearms, whereas non-Black youth tend to carry knives.13 Conversely, other studies suggest that Black youth are less likely to carry weapons.14 Some studies indicate that White youth in rural areas are more likely to carry weapons than Black youth in the same settings.15 Additionally, other studies show that rural American Indian/Alaskan Native youth, lower-income youth, male youth, and older adolescents are more likely to carry handguns.14 Although the circumstances surrounding WCB may vary by settings, motives, weapon types, and contexts, Black youth are disproportionately affected and bear a significantly higher risk of firearm-related homicides and injuries compared to their White counterparts. This disparity encompasses the broader social and structural determinants of risk factors that influence WCB among Black youth. Examining WCB among YBM requires an intersectional understanding that acknowledges the unique individual, interpersonal, and structural challenges Black youth face in under-resourced communities.
Risk Factors for Weapon-Carrying Behaviors
Several risk factors are associated with WCB. Studies have shown that gang membership, psychological distress in male adolescents, and exposure to violence, either directly or indirectly, are predictors of gun carrying.13,16 Earlier research uncovered significant associations between carrying weapons and being male, residing separately from both parents, having a strained relationship with parents, participating in physical fights, vandalizing school property, and the belief that peers are also armed at school.17 Conversely, ensuing studies identified female gender as a distinguishing factor for students carrying weapons on school grounds versus off school grounds.18 Moreover, young adolescents who initiated substance use early and engaged in it frequently were more likely to carry guns and other weapons to school after controlling for age, sex, and ethnicity.19 Importantly, recent findings suggest that risky WCB is also connected to indirect experiences of youth violence, such as observing community violence, regardless of other violence exposures.8 Risk factors that strengthened in the aftermath of the COVID-19 pandemic are worth noting, as the pandemic intensified risky behaviors and firearm violence. For example, firearm-related homicides among YBM aged 10–24 were 20.6 times higher than among White males of the same age in 2019 but increased to 21.6 in 2020.2 In 2019, 11.5% to 13.2% of high school students reported carrying a weapon in the past year.7,20
At present, our knowledge of the association between these risk factors and various types of youth violence, as well as the distinguishing features of youth who carry weapons compared to those who do not, is limited. Few studies have investigated the association between WCB, various forms of peer and interpersonal violence (youth violence, dating, and partner abuse), vicarious violence (witnessing community violence), and substance use among YBM. Fewer studies have done this utilizing incident rate ratios (IRR) – a statistical metric in epidemiology for comparing rare event rates between two groups (or populations at risk) over time when data are structured to count occurrences and exposure times.
The Current Study
This cross-sectional study aims to assess the prevalence of risky WCB among YBM and investigates their association with different types of direct and vicarious violence, including youth violence, community violence, and partner abuse, as well as substance use and aggression related to substance use. We examine these factors in a high-violence but program-rich city (i.e., Chicago). Using univariate, bivariate, and multivariable negative binomial regression analysis, we hypothesize a high prevalence of risky WCB among YBM in Chicago due to the likelihood of high levels of exposure to multi-form violence and predict significant links between sociodemographic factors and WCB in this sample. Chicago presents a distinct context for this study due to its high prevalence of firearm-related violence and the numerous intervention programs implemented in response. A cross-sectional study conducted in Chicago between 2013 and 2017, before the pandemic, revealed a rise in firearm homicides among teenagers aged 15-19, with the highest number of cases recorded in 2016.2 This study found that YBM accounted for 75.6% of all adolescent homicides, increasing to 87.8% during the same period. The rate ratio for YBM compared to other adolescents peaked in 2015 at 19.4 (95% CI, 10.9-34.6).2