The principal findings of this study were that 1) articular incongruency significantly predicted valgization of the affected knee joint (β = -0.96, p < 0.001), particularly as articular depression exceeded 2 mm (β = -3.77, p < 0.001), and that 2) the articular incongruency in middle one-third portion of the lateral tibial plateau in the sagittal plane showed a significant correlation with HKA valgization (β = -0.775, p < 0.001).
The tibial plateau fracture impacts the knee joint’s weight-bearing area. Restoring alignment, length, stability, and joint congruity is crucial for better outcomes. Residual step-offs > 2 mm occur in up to 32% of all complex tibial plateau fractures.6) The current literature did not reach a consensus on the degree of articular congruity required for optimal outcomes. Some studies have suggested that articular incongruity can be tolerated up to 10 mm in the case of tibial plateau fractures,6,7) whereas several biomechanical studies showed that impressions of 1–2 mm resulted in decreased contact areas and increased contact pressure.8,9,18) However, these studies are cadaveric studies, and in vivo studies remain lacking. Bai et al. reported that articular step-offs resulted in valgus angulation, resulting in increased average and maximum contact pressures in the knee joint.8) Furthermore, Singleton et al. showed that articular depression after tibial plateau fracture treatment resulted in the valgization of the mechanical axis; however, this effect was clinically insignificant.7) Maquet et al. suggested that malalignment after tibial condylar fractures changes the load distribution and results in post-traumatic arthritis of the knee joint. Furthermore, 13 of 24 malreduced fractures (54%) in our study were in zone 2. Fracture location did not clearly indicate the incidence of postoperative articular step-offs; however, the articular incongruency in zone 2 showed a significant correlation with HKA valgization. The importance of the reduction of the posterolateral fragment has been well highlighted in the literature.6,16,18–21) However, our study suggests that achieving articular congruency in the middle one-third of the lateral plateau tibial fragment may also be important.
The relationship between valgus malalignment and tibiofemoral disease remains unclear; however, several studies on meniscectomy, tibial osteotomy, and fixation of tibial plateau fractures have suggested that increased contact pressure and accumulated load of pressure precipitate posttraumatic arthritis.10–12) Surgically managed tibial plateau fractures have an increased likelihood of developing osteoarthritis (OA) and requiring a subsequent total knee arthroplasty compared with a matched group from the general population.22) Moreover, tibial plateau fractures commonly result from high-energy injuries and are associated with complications such as meniscal tears, ligamentous injury, and compartment syndrome.23,24) Meniscal tears are present in 55% of patients with tibial plateau fractures.23) A few authors suggested that valgic overcorrection does not affect the lateral compartment of the knee joint after high tibial osteotomy, whereas Bick et al. provided evidence of progressive overall meniscal degeneration in the lateral compartment via follow-up MRI examinations.25–27) Torn meniscus knee joints have a smaller stressed contract area than healthy knee joints under any flexion angle and have larger contact pressures.28)
Traditional methods of surgical fixation involve an open approach to the proximal tibia, followed by reduction of the fracture fragments under fluoroscopic guidance. Depressed fragments are reduced, and the subchondral region is filled with bone graft or a bone graft substitute, such as polymethylmethacrylate (PMMA) or calcium phosphate bone cement, followed by rigid internal fixation with plates and screws. However, malreduction is reported to reach up to 32.3% in the literature.6) The incidence of malreduction in our study was 36% (24 of 67). Lateral tibial fractures account for two-thirds of all tibial plateau fractures, and malreductions were found to predominate in the posterior quadrants.6) This poses a major challenge to surgeons regarding the restoration of articular congruity since visualization of the posterolateral segment is difficult.6,18) The lack of intraoperative visualization is one of the main reasons for inadequate reduction after complex tibial plateau fractures.29) A fluoroscopic-guided reduction technique without submeniscal arthrotomy was found to be a statistically significant risk factor for malreduction.6)
Numerous techniques have been introduced to access the posterolateral quadrant fragment: the posterior approach; the posterolateral approach, with or without fibular osteotomy; the posteromedial approach; and the modified anterolateral approach.19) In our institution, posterolateral tibial plateau fracture fixation was individualized utilizing the three-column subdivision system based on the fibular head position.16) The posterolateral compartment of the tibial plateau was segmented into three zones based on the fibular position and an individualized surgical approach was proposed for each zone: 1) in anterior zone I, an extended anterolateral approach with the patient in the supine position; 2) in middle zone II, a transfibular approach with the patient in the supine position; and 3) in posterior zone III, a posteromedial approach with the patient in the prone position.
Despite the introduction of numerous techniques, current evidence suggests that restoration of articular congruency in tibial plateau fractures remains difficult, particularly with progressive subsidence of the articular fragment even after rigid fixation. We evaluated articular incongruency one year postoperatively, considering the possibility of gradual postoperative subsidence. Despite the dedicated effort to directly visualize and manipulate the articular fracture site for rigid fixation, a median articular step-off of 0.75 (0–2.08) mm remained one year postoperatively. An anatomic articular reduction in the posterolateral compartment of the tibial plateau is technically demanding. A biomechanical study demonstrated that posterior impressions of the posterolateral compartment with a step-off > 1 mm resulted in a large decrease in contact area and an increase in contact pressure.18) However, in this study, the degree of articular step-off in the posterolateral compartment did not show a significant correlation with the coronal alignment change in the full weight-bearing orthoradiogram. This is self-explanatory because the tibiofemoral contact point on the lateral tibial plateau is positioned slightly anteromedial to the center of the lateral articular surface in the standing position with a fully extended knee.13) Post-traumatic arthritis is diagnosed by assessing joint space narrowing using a full weight-bearing orthoradiogram and is characterized by pain aggravated by weight-bearing activities. The knee joint is a dynamic joint, in which the tibiofemoral contact point continuously changes throughout the whole range of motion. In this study, the articular incongruency in zone 2 showed a significant linear correlation with HKA valgization, and the majority of malreduced fractures (n = 13/24; 54%) were located in zone 2. Therefore, surgeons should address articular reduction in the center of the lateral compartment, which affects the coronal alignment of the whole lower limb, rather than primarily focusing on the posterolateral compartment, which has an accompanied risk of peroneal nerve injury during surgical manipulation via the posterolateral approach with fibular head osteotomy after common peroneal nerve dissection.
This study had some inherent limitations owing to the retrospective design and the small number of study participants. Furthermore, this study did not assess clinical outcomes and their correlations with malreduction and malalignment. Regardless, this study may serve as a reference for discussing the impact of malreduction on whole lower limb malalignment, in addition to the optimal quality of reduction in the surgical treatment of lateral tibial plateau fractures.