Nasopharyngeal carcinoma (NPC) is a malignant tumor originating from the epithelial cells of the nasopharynx mucosa, predominantly found in southern China and Southeast Asia. Due to its high sensitivity to radiotherapy, radiotherapy is the preferred treatment for NPC. However, approximately 10.0–36.0% of patients experience disease recurrence after initial treatment[4]. For these recurrent NPC patients, second-course radiotherapy and salvage surgery are the available treatment strategies. Despite second-course radiotherapy offering treatment opportunities for some patients, it is associated with numerous complications and significantly reduced efficacy compared to initial radiotherapy[5]. According to the NCCN guidelines, endoscopic salvage surgery has become the preferred treatment option for all locally recurrent resectable NPC (rNPC) patients[6].
Due to the proximity of the nasopharyngeal lesions to the skull base and the surrounding major blood vessels such as the internal carotid artery, the repair of the surgical wound post-endoscopic salvage surgery for recurrent NPC is crucial to promote healing and protect the surrounding vital vessels. The nasal septal flap (NSF), based on the posterior septal artery branch of the sphenopalatine artery, has been considered an effective and reliable method for repairing postoperative nasopharyngeal wounds [7] and radiation necrosis wounds [8][9]. However, necrosis of the NSF is a significant complication during surgery. This study conducted a detailed analysis of patients with recurrent NPC undergoing endoscopic tumor resection and NSF (alone or in combination with nasal floor mucosal flap) repair, finding an 86.13% survival rate for the NSF, consistent with other studies[10][11]. Additionally, we found that second-course radiotherapy, tumor T stage, and nasal packing time are independent risk factors for NSF necrosis.
Patients undergoing second-course radiotherapy exhibited a significantly higher risk of flap necrosis. Our study found that the probability of NSF necrosis in patients who had undergone second-course radiotherapy was 8.338 times higher than in those who had not. Radiation therapy-induced nasopharyngeal tissue necrosis progresses in three stages: the early stage mainly involves the mucosa, presenting with local degeneration and necrosis; the second stage affects the mucosa and muscles, extending to the nasopharyngeal muscles and causing significant defects in the parapharyngeal space; the third stage manifests as skull base radiation osteonecrosis[12]. Most recurrent NPC patients who undergo radiation therapy experience at least the early stage of nasopharyngeal necrosis, affecting blood perfusion in the nasopharyngeal area. Second-course radiotherapy exacerbates this condition. After flap transplantation, in addition to the blood supply from the pedicle vessels, the flap also requires the establishment of new capillary networks with the surrounding tissue or base for nourishment, increasing the complexity of this process in the presence of nasopharyngeal disease. The nasal septal flap (NSF) based on the posterior septal artery, located in the radiation target area for NPC, may suffer from radiation-induced changes in blood flow and tissue degeneration, reducing flap survival. Studies indicate that second-course radiotherapy is an independent risk factor for post-radiation nasopharyngeal necrosis (PRNN) in recurrent NPC patients [13] and an independent risk factor for the non-epithelialization of the nasopharyngeal area after NSF repair[14]. Therefore, stricter evaluations are warranted when using NSF for repair in patients who have undergone second-course radiotherapy.
Our study indicates an association between later T stage recurrence and flap necrosis. Advanced T stage tumors usually involve more extensive local invasion, necessitating wider tissue resection and flap repair. As the flap size increases, the distance between the distal part of the flap and the pedicle vessels lengthens, challenging blood supply to the distal flap. Researchers have found that advanced T stage is a risk factor for poor healing of the nasal septal flap[15], and flap size is an independent risk factor for complications after reconstructive surgery[16]. Therefore, tumor staging must be considered when planning surgery and selecting flaps. While the NSF can provide blood supply within the range of the nasal septum and nasal floor mucosa, its coverage area is limited, which may be insufficient for large defects, especially when distal blood supply is compromised. For advanced T stage patients, NSF might not be the best choice for postoperative defects. Instead, the temporalis muscle flap, offering a larger tissue volume and located outside the radiation target area for NPC, could provide better coverage and blood supply for large defects after advanced T stage tumor surgery[17] .
Our study reveals that the time of NPC recurrence is a high-risk factor affecting flap survival. Patients with longer recurrence times have a higher risk of NSF necrosis compared to those with shorter recurrence times. This could be related to the effects of radiotherapy. Radiotherapy causes both acute and late toxic reactions, with late toxic reactions including radiation-induced oral mucositis, xerostomia, dysphagia, radiation caries, radiation-induced osteonecrosis of the jaw, cranial nerve damage, temporal lobe necrosis, hypothyroidism, carotid atherosclerosis, muscle fibrosis, and radiation skin reactions. Although symptoms like xerostomia may gradually alleviate over time, issues such as hearing loss, nutritional deficiencies, tissue fibrosis, and neurological damage may worsen with time[18]. Therefore, radiotherapy may cause vascular and microcirculatory damage to the nasopharynx and nasal septum mucosa in recurrent NPC patients, which could gradually worsen over time. Surgical intervention may further reduce tissue tolerance and healing ability, leading to insufficient blood supply to the nasopharynx and NSF, increasing the risk of necrosis. Studies show that a short interval between radiotherapy and salvage pharyngolaryngeal surgery may increase the risk of complications in microvascular free tissue transfer[19]. Therefore, in patients with long-term NPC recurrence, special attention should be paid to evaluating the long-term effects of radiotherapy and taking measures to reduce the risk of necrosis during flap repair surgery.
The duration of nasal packing affects flap survival. Nasal packing for less than 5 days presents a higher risk of NSF necrosis compared to packing for 5 days or more. The fit between the NSF and the nasopharyngeal defect is a crucial factor affecting NSF survival [20]. Shorter nasal packing times may result in poor NSF adherence, leading to NSF necrosis. While longer packing times may improve NSF adherence, they could also cause poor local blood circulation, adversely affecting flap blood supply and healing. Therefore, reasonable control of nasal packing time during surgery is essential to improve flap survival and reduce the risk of complications, finding a balance between ensuring good flap adherence and maintaining adequate local blood circulation. Our experience suggests that 8 days is an ideal nasal packing time for NSF post-surgery.
This study developed a predictive model to assess the risk of NSF necrosis in recurrent NPC patients undergoing endoscopic resection and flap repair surgery. This model integrates factors such as radiotherapy history, recurrence T stage, recurrence time, and postoperative packing time to minimize the complications of flap necrosis. However, the study has some limitations. First, it is a retrospective analysis, which is less robust than a prospective analysis. Second, the sample size is small. NPC is mainly prevalent in southern China and Southeast Asia, limiting the study's geographic scope. The complex anatomy of the skull base and the high technical threshold for salvage surgery in recurrent NPC further limit the patient sample size. Additionally, the lack of external validation limits the generalizability and strength of the study's conclusions.
In conclusion, second-course radiotherapy, recurrence T stage, recurrence time, and postoperative packing time are identified as independent risk factors for NSF necrosis following salvage surgery for recurrent NPC. The risk assessment system based on these factors demonstrates good predictive ability, helping clinicians make more precise decisions in planning and implementing salvage surgery for recurrent NPC patients. This assessment system aids in identifying high-risk patients, enabling targeted treatment strategies and monitoring plans to reduce the risk of flap necrosis, improve surgical success rates, and enhance patient quality of life.