Few previous studies have investigated demoralization in renal populations, and this study is one of the first to investigate demoralization and related factors in patients with CKD. We found that one-third of patients had high levels of demoralization, the DS-MV score was 24.55 and the average itemized score was 1.02. This was higher than those in a previous study among patients with chronic illnesses [29]. A possible reason for this is that most patients in our sample have been ill for more than 6 months and experience long-term symptom burden and psychological distress. The mean total DS-MV score was similar to a study of cancer patients in Taiwan [30]. This may be due to the vulnerability of patients with CKD to the loss of social roles, vulnerability, and dependence on caregivers, which are also common themes associated with demoralization in oncology patients.
In the four DS-MV dimensions, loss of meaning scored the highest, followed by helplessness. When patients' physical symptoms become challenging to treat and they face persistent emotional distress during treatment, they may start to feel a loss of meaning and a sense of helplessness. Besides, in the case of chronic conditions, patients may feel that their health is at risk and integrity is compromised, which can challenge their sense of control and purpose in life. As a result, it is important to develop psychological interventions to address feelings of meaninglessness and helplessness in patients with CKD.
Duration since CKD diagnosis was found positively associated with demoralization among patients with CKD. This is consistent with the findings of a previous study in cancer patients [31]. Over time, patients may be exposed to lack of resources and reduced ability to cope abilities while facing an increased risk of demoralization [29]. Patients with a longer time since diagnosis might encounter a heavier symptom burden, reduced self-efficacy, and a sense of helplessness in managing their disease. Healthcare professionals should prioritize addressing the demoralization experienced by patients who have been diagnosed with CKD for a longer period of time. Conducting psychological assessments of these patients can help in offering tailored treatment and care.
Our results showed that spiritual coping was negatively associated with demoralization; this indicates that spiritual coping could protect patients with CKD against high levels of demoralization. Demoralization may result from the loss of resources experienced by the patient and the inability to self-manage the disease. For patients with serious illness, spiritual coping as a recovery-related resource that can facilitate meaning-making and self-growth [32]. Positive spiritual coping can help patients with CKD accept difficulties in life, re-establish trust and hope in life, and enhance self-awareness and self-development. Moreover, when individuals face stressful events, actively using spiritual resources can help them find the meaning of life and regain their ability to control life [33]. Therefore, encouraging patients with CKD to adopt spiritual coping strategies can help effectively cope with stressors and reduce discouragement.
Consistent with previous research in cancer patients [18], we found a strong association between demoralization and sleep quality in patients with CKD. Poor sleep quality is common in patients with CKD due to factors such as medication side effects, high daytime melatonin levels, tyrosine deficiency, stress, and anxiety symptoms [34]. Sleep difficulty is related to repetitive negative thinking and worrying about the future [35]. Individuals experiencing long-term sleep difficulties may easily lead to the accumulation of negative emotions, threatening physical health, and damaging overall well-being. Moreover, studies have shown significant correlations between poor sleep quality and related phenomena including hopelessness and suicidal behavior [36–37], which may promote the occurrence of demoralization in patients with CKD. Hence, Routine assessment and appropriate management of sleep quality in patients with CKD may reduce the risk of demoralization.
Higher levels of resilience was associated with lower levels of demoralization in our sample. This finding confirms that resilience is an important contributor to maintaining mental health in patients with CKD [38]. Individuals with high resilience have psychological resources such as optimism, calmness, and openness that help them find positive meaning in challenging situations [39]. These characteristics may help patients with CKD reduce the risk of demoralization by gain a sense of control over their lives. Considering incorporating resilience-building interventions into care plans to help patients with CKD controll or mitigate demoralization, this ultimately benefits their mental health.
Limitations
First, the cross-sectional nature of the study design cannot demonstrate a causal relationship between demoralization and other factors in patients with CKD. Second, all variables were assessed using self-report methods, which may be at risk of social desirability bias or recall bias. Third, the study did not evaluate changes in levels of demoralization over time. Longitudinal studies are needed to determine changes in demoralization over time and to determine causal relationships between demoralization and stage of disease, spiritual coping, resilience, and sleep quality. Finally, most patients with CKD recruited in our study were in stage 3b (35.8%) and stage 4 (23.15%), which may limits the generalizability of our findings.
Clinical implications
Previous research has demonstrated that interventions that enhance cancer patients’ sense of meaning can improve their demoralization [5, 40], but there are no intervention studies targeting demoralization in patients with CKD. This study identified some factors (spiritual coping, sleep quality, and resilience) associated with demoralization; our findings indicate that interventions for improving sleep quality, enhancing spiritual coping and resilience may may help reduce the risk of demoralization in patients with CKD.
Considering mindfulness-based interventions (such as the compassionate mindful resilience programme) [41] or life review-based interventions (such as the dignity therapy) [40] as the main strategy to help patients find the purpose and meaning of life and activate individual resources to reduce demoralization. In addition, regular assessment of demoralization and the provision of appropriate psychological intervention may prevent suicidal ideation in patients with CKD.