Fifteen media items that discussed the introduction of NHS funding for the swallowable intragastric balloon were identified. Eight mainstream news articles did not have comment facilities or had zero comments at the time of data collection. No items about this topic were found on searching Facebook, TikTok or Reddit.
Out of the remaining seven items, 2,364 comments were present on the search date. The majority (n = 2208) were in response to a BBC West’s Instagram Reel article that had over 11 million views and had been shared over 1,200 times. For comparison, the 20 BBC news reels before and after the intragastric balloon post received an average of 27,000 views (range 5069 − 224,000 views) and 9 shares (range 0–61 shares). The corresponding online article had no option for comments but was shared on the BBC West’s X account. Other media coverage included an Instagram Reel and YouTube video by ‘Talk TV’ (a ‘free-to-air’ British television and radio channel), articles by the ‘Daily Mail’, ‘Daily Mirror’ and ‘Welsh Guardian’ newspapers, and a YouTube video on ‘Channel 5 News’, a British news broadcaster.
After discrepancies between raters were resolved, sentiment analysis of comments found that 393 (16.6%) were ‘positive’, 1156 (48.9%) were ‘neutral’, and 815 (34.8%) were ‘negative’. The distribution of comments based on source media is shown (Fig. 1). The BBC West Instagram story had almost twice as many negative comments as positive comments.
Themes identified and supporting quotations summarized in Table 1 from ‘positive’ comments included: acceptance of being overweight, acknowledgement of obesity as a multifactorial disease (contradicting ideas of obesity as purely a function of overeating and lack of exercise), saving resources for the NHS in comparison to surgical methods of weight management, helping to address obesity-related diseases (e.g. type 2 diabetes, hypertension) and praising the advancement in technology within the field of bariatric surgery.
Table 1
Emergent themes for each sentiment and supporting quotations. Note, though prevalent during in the search, comments with vulgar language or strong abusive themes are excluded.
Sentiment | Theme | Supporting quotation |
Positive | Acknowledgement of obesity as multifactorial process | ‘All the hate here is disappointing. Many people have medical conditions that make it very difficult to lose weight. PCOS, thyroid issues are just some examples.’ |
‘As someone who at one time had lost over 100lbs/45kg, people that have not been significantly overweight don’t understand how hard it is to lose weight...I can’t imagine doing it with financial restrictions, stress or any other health problems.’ |
Positive alternative to surgical management of obesity | ‘I’m having gastric sleeve surgery soon. But by this short video I think I would much rather do this as a discipline than do the sleeve which I won’t ever be able to maybe eat a little more than normal and worry about damaging it.’ |
Positive examples of the intra-gastric balloon | ‘I’ve lost 32kg and kept the weight off. It’s been 2 yrs with this, I must say best decision ever’ |
Addressing obesity-related diseases | ‘If we could get people’s weight down we could save a fortune in treating the kinds of illnesses obesity brings. Well done!’ |
Advancement in technology | ‘how incredible. life changing technology for so many patients’ |
Neutral | | ‘What is it made of???’ |
‘Being overweight is a nightmare for me. If I could ‘just stop’ don’t you think I would?’ |
‘If it doesn't have a mother or grow from the ground, don't eat it.’ |
‘It looks like a breast implant’ |
‘That's some size to pass after!’ |
Negative | NHS funding better spent elsewhere | ‘The NHS should not fund any such treatment...weight gain is psychological and weight loss should also be’ |
‘people who have self control should not be forced to pay for those who do not.’ |
Negative weight stigmatization | ‘No not on the nhs.,.no way, join a gym, walk a friends dog...smaller portions on your plate, use your brain, they all want a quick fix’ |
‘stop eating or sew your mouth up is the best option’ |
‘how little determination must someone have to get this fitted, just eat less and exercise’ |
Solution to obesity is diet/exercise alone | ‘Stop swallowing this crap and learn to diet and exercise’ |
‘Anything to avoid gym’ |
Personal attacks on obese patients | ‘they'll just get fat again...they have zero morals, they refuse to control their flesh or physical urges. absolutely gross...the fact that anybody actually has to make science to help these cretens [sic] is ridiculous’ |
Thematic analysis of neutral comments was not performed but comments largely centered around misconceptions that the device would not deflate and be passed whole, that the balloon bore similarity to a breast implant, questions about the process or device, posts seeking personal help/advice, neutral emojis or alerting other users to content (tagging).
Themes identified from ‘negative’ comments included that NHS funding would be better spent on alternatives, including ear wax treatment, medical research, reducing waiting lists for secondary care treatment and staff retention. Negative weight stigmatization was identified such as comments on a person’s appearance and negative characterization of obesity (laziness, gluttony, shamelessness). Responsibility for obesity on an individual level was common, and there were many comments asserting that diet and exercise alone are the causes and solutions to obesity. There were also personal attacks on the patients featured in the news article and abusive, derogatory, and threatening messages directed towards PLWO. Two of the most engaged negative comments were “How about controlling what you put in your mouth?” (3712 likes) and “Or they could just stop feeding their face” (1994 likes). There were also more extreme comments unsuitable for publication.
There were significantly more negative than positive comments on the Daily Mail article when compared with the BBC Instagram story (p < 0.001). There was no statistical difference identified when the BBC Instagram story comments were compared with those on Talk TV, Daily Mirror, Welsh Guardian, or YouTube (Table 2).
Table 2
Summary of public response across social media, mainstream news articles and YouTube videos. Data is presented as a number of comments (% of total comments) per platform. P values indicate significance, ns = not significant.
| BBC West Instagram Post | Talk TV Instagram Post | BBC 'X' Post | Daily Mail Articles | Mirror Article | Welsh Guardian | Youtube videos |
Positive | 384 (17.3%) | 1 (7%) | 0 | 6 (6.4%) | 0 | 0 | 2 (5.7%) |
Neutral | 1083 (49%) | 11 (73%) | 0 | 35 (37.2%) | 1 (16.7%) | 2 (40%) | 24 (68.6%) |
Negative | 741 (33.6%) | 3 (20%) | 1 (100%) | 53 (56.4%) | 5 (83.3%) | 3 (60%) | 9 (25.7%) |
P value | n/a | ns | n/a | < 0.0001 | ns | ns | ns |