1. Cognitive Impairment Screening in Community Pharmacy. Systematic review
Data sources and searches
A systematic review of CD screening in community pharmacy was conducted in PubMed, Web of Science (WOS) and Scopus databases, following PRISMA guideline [13]. This review was carried out between 10 and 15 August 2023. The keywords used were: “community pharmacy” AND “cognitive impairment” AND/OR “subjective cognitive decline”. A flow sheet of the search is presented as Fig. 1. Manuscripts published during the last 10 years (2013–2023) with a screening intervention in Primary Care were included. Papers with no community pharmacist present in the study or not written in English or Spanish were excluded. A total of 103 records were first identified: 15 in PubMed, 57 in WOS and 31 in Scopus. Besides, 1 handsearching full-text article was included. After removing any duplicates, 64 records were selected. For the tittle-based screening, those in which an early detection was not developed were eliminated. Of the remaining 24 records, only those that considered community pharmacy as the service provider were selected. Thus, 17 full-text articles were assessed for eligibility. From them, 6 manuscripts proposing a screening design but with no study results, no community pharmacy participation or with cognitive screening results from a previous study were excluded.
2. Implementation of the Pharmaceutical Care Service for Subjective Cognitive Decline Screening
Data sources and searches
The project was initiated in February of 2020 in conjunction with 18 community pharmacies. Within a 16-month timeframe, the participating pharmacists screened patients with SMC during their working day.
Study selection
Inclusion criteria were age 50 years or older, SMC referred by themselves or by a family member/caregiver and willingness to participate. Conversely, exclusion criteria were diagnosis of dementia, severe sensory deficits such as blindness or deafness and physical disability interfering with the performance of the tests.
Patient description
The service was offered to regular patients of the pharmacy who met the selection criteria. Likewise, patients directly referred by physicians who had been previously informed of the project were also included [14].
Referrals for SMC and age of 50 years or older were used as inclusion criteria, aiming to detect early CD stages.
Principio del formulario
Community pharmacists’ participation and training
Community pharmacies in the region of Valencia were invited to participate voluntarily through a call made by the Official Illustrious College of Pharmacists in Valencia (MICOF).
Participating pharmacists underwent a 3-hour live webinar by MICOF, covering project introduction, dementia detection, and a standardized work protocol explanation.
Principio del formulario
Study design
A cross-sectional observational study was conducted. The study was reviewed and approved by the Institutional Review Board (IRB) of Universidad CEU Cardenal Herrera (CEEI21/198). All subjects gave written informed consent in accordance with the Declaration of Helsinki.
To encourage patient participation, posters and brochures announced CD screening service availability in pharmacies and pharmacists offered the service from the counter during daily practice to interested patients.
Pharmacists informed patients about the study and service using the Patient Information Sheet, addressing any concerns before obtaining their consent, and conducted MCI screening tests during a 30-minute interview in the pharmacy's Pharmaceutical Care Custom Zone, followed by referral to primary care physicians for further evaluation and diagnosis confirmation.
Assessment tools for cognitive impairment screening
To assess whether there is any suspicion of MCI, the following screening tests were carried out: Memory Impairment Screening (MIS), Semantic Verbal Fluency (SVF) and Short Portable Mental State Questionnaire (SPMSQ).
MIS validated into Spanish by Böhm [15]. Maximum score: 8. Cut off point: 4 or less. Sensitivity: 74%. Specificity: 96%. In a first phase, participants must read aloud four related words that belong to four different categories. After an unstructured distraction a free recall is made, and semantic keys can be given for those words or categories that cannot remember. Freely remembered items receive 2 points and those remembered after the key, 1 point, so that it comprises a path from 0 to 8 points.
SVF validated into Spanish by López Pérez-Díaz [16]. Cut off point: 10. Sensitivity: 74%. Specificity: 80%. It measures the number of items of a category that the subject can recall in one minute [17].
SPMSQ validated into Spanish by Martínez de la Iglesia [18]. Maximum score: 10. Cut-off point: 3 errors (4 errors for illiterate). Sensitivity: 85.7%. Specificity: 79.3%. It assesses different aspects of intellectual functioning, including short-term memory, long-term memory, information about current events, orientation, and the ability to perform a serial mathematical work [19].
The rationale for using three tests was to detect as many true positives as possible. Subjects with at least one positive result in these tests were classified as suspected MCI patients. An assessment of key attributes of brief cognitive tests and their suitability for clinical application was also conducted before selecting those to be incorporated into the project [20] (Table 1).
Furthermore, the interview encompassed additional lifestyle variables (physical exercise, reading, cognitive stimulation games, playing a musical instrument, dietary habits, social relationships, smoking, alcohol consumption, use of internet and social media) and dietary habits to gather information on factors associated with dementia.
In addition, 14 Point Mediterranean Diet Adherence Screen (MEDAS-14) and 5 Point Geriatric Depression Scale (GDS-5) were performed to obtain objective data on nutrition and depression factors, respectively.
MEDAS-14 validated into Spanish by Schröder [21]. It is the 14-point scale of adherence to the Mediterranean diet, designed in the PREDIMED study [22].
GDS-5 validated into Spanish by Ortega [23]. Maximum score: 5. Cut-off point: 2. Sensitivity: 82%. Specificity: 98%. It is the short version of GDS-30 and quantifies depressive symptoms in older adults through 5 questions.
In our study, CD screening targets patients with SCD by referring SMC. Those who test positive are identified as having suspected MCI, indicating results compatible with OCD.
Data Synthesis and Analysis
To ensure a proper registration of information, data collection was carried out through ATENFARMA®, a computer platform designed by MICOF for the development of Pharmaceutical Healthcare Services.
For the collected variables, a description of the effect sizes of the collected variables is calculated and the data are shown depending on the CD condition and the p-value of the appropriate test. Due to the lack of normality for most of the quantitative variables, the rank biserial correlation was reported as effect size. Depending on Shapiro-Wilk’s normality test, an appropriate hypothesis testing is performed. The t-test of independent samples is carried out for those variables whose p-value with Shapiro-Wilk’s test is not lower than 0.05; otherwise, the nonparametric test Mann-Whitney U test is performed. For qualitative variables, the chi-squared test or Fisher’s exact test are performed depending on meeting the conditions of the chi-squared test or not and as an effect size is used the odds ratio.
To determine the profile of patients with suspected MCI, we selected the ranger package to assess the importance of these variables. One of the measures is based on the mean decreased accuracy after a random reordering of the variable as it is described by Breiman [24] and the other one is an improved version of the Gini index [25] unbiased with respect to the number of categories and the range of quantitative variables. With that purpose, a random forest with 50000 trees was trained with all the data. The parameter controlling the number of variables used to decide a split at each point was set to the default value, which is the square root of the number of variables. After train the random forest, the mentioned indices of importance were calculated.