Hairy roots induction
Effect of A. rhizogenes strains on hairy roots transformation
The in vitro cultured plantlets of G. glabra were inoculated with strains MSU, A7, and A4-N of A. rhizogenes. The first hairy roots appeared at the site of the wounds on the explants 20 days after the inoculation. In the subsequent stages, the hairy roots obtained continued to grow in free-hormones liquid 1/2 MS cultures medium.
After one month, the percentage of explants that developed hairy roots was examined (Table 1). The results showed that the MSU strain had the highest effect on hairy root induction, with 80% of the three-week-old leaf explants showing root formation. Following that, the A7 and A4-N strains had effects on hairy root induction from the three-week-old leaf explants with percentages of 50% and 13%, respectively (Fig. 1, A).
Table 1
variance analysis of the effects of strain type and plant explant type on hairy roots induction.
Sources of changes | df | MS |
Strain type | 2 | 3344/44** |
Error test | 6 | 177/78 |
Sample type | 2 | 4433/33** |
Error test | 6 | 222/22 |
In the variance analysis table above, the symbol ** indicates significance level of P < 0.01. |
Table 2
Dry weight (D.W) produced glycyrrhizin contents (µg/g DW) by non- treatment hairy root and hairy root lines of G. glabra.
Line | DW (g) | Glycyrrhizin (µg/g) |
L1 | 6/7 | 397 |
L1 T | 5/1 | 191 |
L2 | 6 | 282 |
L2 T | 5 | 177 |
L3 | 6/8 | 382 |
L3 T | 5/3 | 197 |
L4 | 5/8 | 256 |
L4 T | 4/7 | 174 |
L5 | 6/4 | 116 |
L5 T | 7 | 382 |
Different strains of A. rhizogenes have varying potential in transferring T-DNA to host plant explants and subsequently inducing hairy roots (Porter and Flores 1991; Sharafi et al. 2013). That is because the number of T-DNA copies transferred from the Ri plasmid of A. rhizogenes, the integration site of T-DNA within the host genome, and the complete or partial transfer of T-DNA to the host cell genome all contribute to this variation. Therefore, it can be concluded that different strains of A. rhizogenes have varying abilities to induce hairy roots, and this is dependent on their pathogenicity. It is possible for a plant species to not be sensitive to one strain of bacteria and show a different response to another strain. Ionkova et al. (1997) demonstrated that different strains of A. rhizogenes had varying effects on the induction of hairy roots in Astragalus mongolicus. Furthermore, the results of this study are consistent with the findings of the study conducted by Dobigny et al. (1995), which investigated the induction of hairy roots by different strains of A. rhizogenes in two potato cultivars.
Effect of type and age of explants on hairy roots transformation
The comparison of means between the types of explants used, including leaf, stem, and petiole, indicated that leaf explants had the highest impact on the production of hairy roots (80% root induction) following inoculation with the MSU strain of A. rhizogenes. Following that, stem and petiole explants showed lower hairy root induction percentages, with 23% and 6%, respectively, in response to inoculation with the MSU strain of A. rhizogenes (Fig. 1, B).
Additionally, in some leaf explants inoculated with the MSU strain, both root induction and callus formation were observed. Most of the hairy roots obtained from the petiole explants also underwent necrosis and destroyed after five days. According to the observations, the site of hairy root initiation in the leaf explants of G. glabra was at the location of the wound created during the experiment.
According to the results of this study, the plant species and the type of plant explant are important factors that influence the success of transformation and induction of hairy roots. In studies conducted on the species Withania somnifera and Solanum surattense, leaves have been identified as the best plant explants for inducing hairy roots (Pawar and Maheshwari 2004).
A comparison was made between leaf explants of two, three, and four-week-old plants to assess the percentage of hairy root induction during the experiment. The results of the experiment showed that the age of the leaf explants had the greatest impact on hairy root induction, with the three-week-old leaf explants exhibiting the highest percentage of root induction (76.66%) (Fig. 1, C). The study conducted by Mehrotra et al. (2008) on the induction of hairy roots in G. glabra by Agrobacterium demonstrated that the age and type of explant, as well as the composition of the culture medium, have a significant influence on hairy root induction. This is because the age of the explant is the main factor in altering the physiological properties of the cells.
Effect of light conditions and carbohydrate source on hairy roots transformation
The results of the T-test showed that the application of 3% sucrose in 1/2 MS medium (86.66% root induction) and the maintenance of explants in complete darkness (86.66% root induction) had a more favorable response in terms of hairy root induction percentage (Fig. 1, D), compared to 1/2 MS medium containing 3% glucose (36.66% root induction) and 16 h light conditions (Fig. 1, E). Studies have shown that sucrose is the most suitable carbon source for cell cultures and the production of secondary metabolites. In addition, sucrose has been found to have stimulatory effects on the biomass accumulation of hairy roots (Hirasuna et al. 1996). The results of this research indicate that the explants placed in complete darkness exhibited better hairy root induction compared to the explants subjected to a 16 h light and 8 h dark photoperiod.
Molecular identification of hairy roots by PCR analysis
In order to provide definitive evidence of the transgenic nature of hairy roots in G. glabra, DNA extraction was initially performed from hairy roots, non-transgenic roots, and A. rhizogenes strains (MSU, A7, and A4-N). To confirm the presence of the rolC gene in the genomic DNA of hairy roots and verify the presence of the rolC and virD genes in the plasmid DNA of A. rhizogenes, as well as the absence of both genes in non-transgenic roots, a polymerase chain reaction (PCR) assay was conducted. The presence of the rolC gene was confirmed in the genomic DNA of hairy roots through the amplification of a fragment approximately 534 bp in length. The observation of bands indicates the transfer of the T-DNA fragment from the A. rhizogenes plasmid to the genome of hairy roots, thereby confirming their transgenic nature. The amplification of DNA fragments was observed in the extracted plasmid DNA, confirming the presence of a gene region called virD with an approximate length of 438 bp. However, the absence of any bands in both transgenic and non-transgenic hairy roots indicates the lack of bacterial gene remnants within the transgenic hairy roots. Furthermore, the absence of a band on the gel in non-transgenic roots (negative control sample) indicates their non-transgenic nature (Fig. 2).
The bacterial T-DNA region consists of two parts, TL-DNA and TR-DNA, which are transferred and integrated into the host plant genome separately. However, for inducing hairy root formation, the presence of TL-DNA containing the rolA, rolB, rolC, and rolD genes is essential (Georgiev et al. 2007).
After confirming the transgenic nature of the hairy roots, they were transferred to flasks containing liquid culture medium, and a growth curve of G. glabra hairy roots was obtained to monitor their growth pattern. This growth curve indicates that during the first week after transferring the hairy roots from solid medium to liquid medium, the hairy roots entered a lag phase. The average weight of the hairy roots at the end of the first week is 0.5 g. From the beginning of the second week until the end of the ninth week, the growth of the hairy roots followed a logarithmic pattern. By the start of the tenth week, the hairy roots entered a stationary phase, indicating a stable growth pattern. The late logarithmic phase (ninth week) was chosen as the appropriate time to add elicitor (methyl jasmonate) to the desired hairy roots samples (Fig. 3). The growth pattern of G. inflata hairy roots showed that the ninth week of the transfer hairy roots to the flask is the best time to add elicitor (Wongwichaa et al. 2011).
Methyl jasmonate treatment and HPLC analysis
The fresh weight of the hairy roots was measured at the appropriate time for adding methyl jasmonate elicitor, which showed that the L5 hairy root line had the highest weight (8/6 g). Following that, the L1, L2, L3 and L4 hairy roots lines have root weights of 8g, 7.8 g, 6.6 g, and 6.3 g, respectively.
Methyl jasmonate, as a biotic elicitor, induces a plant defense response (Eder and Cosio 1994). On the other hand, secondary metabolites are often produced in the plant's defense response to environmental stresses (Palazón et al. 2003). To determine the amount of glycyrrhizin in G. glabra hairy roots for four selected lines, HPLC was used after 48 h of adding methyl jasmonate. The results indicate that in line 5 (302 \(\:{\mu\:}\text{g}/\text{g}\)), compared to its own control line (116 \(\:{\mu\:}\text{g}/\text{g}\)), the addition of the elicitor methyl jasmonate led to an increase in glycyrrhizin production in the hairy roots. However, in contrast, in the other four lines where cutting was performed on the roots, the glycyrrhizin production in the hairy roots decreased compared to their respective control line. After 24 hours of cutting in the hairy a pink color with varying shades was observed in the medium (Fig. 4). Analysis of two culture medium samples from L5 and L3 showed the presence of glycyrrhizin in the culture medium of line 3 hairy roots and its absence in the culture medium of line 5. In addition, among the control treatments, L1 hairy roots line had the highest amount of glycyrrhizin (397 \(\:{\mu\:}\text{g}/\text{g}\)). Following that, the L3, L2, L4 and L5 hairy roots lines had glycyrrhizin contents of 382, 281, 256 and 116\(\:\:{\mu\:}\text{g}/\text{g}\), respectively (Table. 2). In continuation, with the addition of methyl jasmonate elicitor at a concentration of 100\(\:\:{\mu\:}\text{M}\), the results indicate a decrease in the produced amount of glycyrrhizin in the G. glabra hairy roots compared to the control treatment. Furthermore, among the cut roots and treated with the elicitor, the L3 hairy roots line had the highest amount of glycyrrhizin (197\(\:\:{\mu\:}\text{g}/\text{g}\)). Following that, the L1, L2, and L4 hairy roots lines had glycyrrhizin contents of 191, 177, and 174 \(\:{\mu\:}\text{g}/\text{g}\), respectively (Fig. 5).
The hairy root morphology is very sensitive as the roots respond to the little changes in the local environmental conditions like temperature and shear stress. Any change in the morphology of hairy root such as density, thickness and root length, significantly affect the production of secondary metabolite (Srivastava and Srivastava 2012). In a study, after producing hairy roots from the G. glabra plant, the highest amount of glycyrrhizin was measured 45.68 \(\:{\mu\:}\text{g}/\text{g}\) of dry weight, (6 times higher than the non-hairy root) (Shirazi et al. 2012). In the study by Wongwichaa et al. (2011), the use of methyl jasmonate elicitor at a concentration of 100 \(\:{\mu\:}\text{M}\) on G. inflata hairy roots after five days resulted in an increase in glycyrrhizin production to 109 \(\:{\mu\:}\text{g}/\text{g}\) (five times higher than the control sample). In the study by Shabani et al. (2008), the use of methyl jasmonate elicitor at a concentration of 100 \(\:{\mu\:}\text{M}\) did not significantly affect the level of glycyrrhizin present in the hairy root samples or the expression of the bAS gene compared to the control sample. However, when a concentration of 1\(\:\:\text{m}\text{M}\) of methyl jasmonate was applied, it resulted in an increase in the expression of the bAS gene. In this study, the amount of glycyrrhizin in L1, L2, L3, and L4 hairy roots lines decreased significantly compared to the control lines after cutting the hairy roots. This indicates that despite the addition of the elicitor, the production of glycyrrhizin in the cut lines decreased due to the change in the morphology of the hairy roots during shear stress. However, in line 5, where the roots were not cut, after 48 hours of adding methyl jasmonate elicitor at a concentration of 100 \(\:{\mu\:}\text{M}\) resulted in an increase in glycyrrhizin production in the hairy roots. Indeed, the use of G. glabra hairy root culture in this research has been effective in achieving a significant production of glycyrrhizin compared to other studies, considering the low production of glycyrrhizin in previous research. The hairy root culture system offers advantages such as genetic stability, rapid growth, and the potential for enhanced secondary metabolite production, making it a suitable platform for achieving high glycyrrhizin yields.