The management of cardiopulmonary bypass temperature during pediatric cardiac surgery has been a subject of ongoing debate, with varying practices across institutions [19–21]. Our study aimed to compare the outcomes of normothermic with hypothermic CPB in pediatric patients undergoing the arterial switch operation, with and without VSD closure. Both CPB and XCLMP durations were longer and maximal lactate and troponin-I were higher in the HT-CPB group. Maximal VIS and duration of MV were also higher in this group but without statistical significance. All that in the light of indifferent cardiomyocyte damage as evident by the level of cfDNA.
Intra-operative Parameters
The observation that normothermia during CPB resulted in shorter CPB and XCLMP compared to hypothermia invites a nuanced discussion about the potential mechanisms as well as implications of these findings. While surgeon differences may contribute to the duration of the surgery, the time needed to safely cool and subsequently rewarm the patient must be factored into the total CPB time. The traditional rationale for hypothermia in CPB has been its neuroprotective effects through reduced metabolic demand (7,20,21). However, if normothermia can achieve shorter operative times without compromising patient safety or outcome, it may prompt a reevaluation of temperature management practices during CPB.
Hemodynamic Stability and Recovery [9, 22–24].
Normothermia was associated with improved hemodynamic stability, as evidenced by lower maximal lactate levels and a trend towards lower VIS in the NT-CPB group [25]. This suggests better myocardial function and less dependence on inotropic support, potentially translating to a quicker recovery. In addition, our findings indicate that troponin levels, while elevated post-operatively in both groups, suggest a nuanced interplay between CPB temperature and myocardial preservation [15]. The comparative analysis revealed lower troponin release in the normothermic group. This pattern may suggest that normothermia, by maintaining closer alignment with physiological body temperatures, potentially aids in preserving myocardial integrity during the stress of cardiac surgery which leads to favorable hemodynamics post-surgery. This is in line with the observation of shorter MV time for normothermic patients, indicating not just a faster recovery trajectory but also an implication of cost-effectiveness and reduced healthcare resource utilization.
Higher KDIGO Scores in Normothermia
The higher incidence of AKI in patients undergoing normothermic CPB, as indicated by KDIGO scores, contrasts with the otherwise compelling advantages of normothermia, including reduced oxidative stress, improved myocardial protection, and enhanced clinical outcomes [23, 24]. This discrepancy underscores the complex interplay between CPB temperature management and renal outcomes. AKI in the context of CPB is multifactorial, influenced by factors such as hemodynamic instability, inflammatory responses, and oxidative stress, all of which can affect renal perfusion and function [26]. The higher KDIGO scores in the normothermia group suggest a potential vulnerability of the kidneys under normothermic conditions that merits further investigation.
The Novelty of cfDNA Dynamics in temperature management.
The novel investigation into cfDNA as a marker for cellular damage during CPB represents a significant leap in understanding the physiological underpinnings of temperature management strategies in pediatric cardiac surgery [27–29]. cfDNA levels, which rise in response to cellular injury, offer a unique window into the systemic impact of surgical interventions. The comparative analysis of cfDNA levels between NT-CPB and HT-CPB groups underscores a critical insight: normothermia maintains cellular integrity to a degree previously underestimated. By demonstrating the non-inferiority of normothermia in preventing cell death, this research may support the narrative shift towards a broader appreciation of physiological resilience under normothermic conditions. This pioneering perspective encourages a rethinking and reevaluation of clinical practices, advocating for further research of normothermic approach as not only a viable but an advantageous strategy for managing patients undergoing CPB.
Future Research Directions
The potential superiority or at least non-inferiority of normothermia in neonatal arterial switch operations invites further exploration. Future research should endeavor to include larger, multi-center datasets to affirm these findings' generalizability and investigate long-term outcomes beyond the immediate postoperative period, including central nervous system function and neurodevelopmental outcome which have not been addressed at out study. Additionally, a more granular analysis of the mechanisms underpinning normothermia's effects could uncover actionable insights for refining surgical protocols and enhancing patient care.