The aim of this study was to investigate whether mental fatigue, induced by a protocol consisting of 3 minutes of the Stroop Color and Word Test and 5 minutes of the Arithmetic Test, followed by execution of the benchmark workout (Angie) with 50 repetitions each of pull-up, push-up, sit-up, and air-squat exercises in a timed setting, had the potential to affect the performance of CrossFit® practitioners.
The results indicated that mental fatigue led to a significant increase in the perception of effort among the Stroop Group participants. This effect was not observed in the Neutral Group. Significant differences in VAS were only observed after implementation of the proposed protocol, demonstrating that there was a substantial impact of mental fatigue on the performance of the participants during the training session.
The present findings were consistent with the work of Staiano et al. (2019), who identified a deterioration in the performance of kayakers after the application of mental tests that induced psychological stress, such as the Stroop Color and Word Test, when compared to a group that engaged in cognitively neutral activities.
Other studies investigated the effects of mental fatigue in the sports activities of running, swimming, and kayaking, with 2%, 5%, and 1.2% slower times achieved by participants, respectively, when compared to control groups that were not subjected to cognitive stress (MacMahon et al., 2014; Pageaux & Lepers, 2018; Penna et al., 2018). These findings reinforce the hypothesis that the psychological component plays an important role in the performance of athletes. In this study, performance (measured in seconds) in the air-squat exercise was nearly 20% poorer for the Stroop Group.
In studies that were able to assess the physiological response of individuals during activities following a period of mental fatigue, variations in biochemical and physiological parameters of the body were identified in response to mental stress. Mental fatigue impairs performance in activities that require endurance, motor skills, and decision-making, but it should be emphasized that muscular strength is not affected in the presence of mental fatigue (Pageaux & Lepers, 2018). Further experimental evidence to support this effect was reported by Marcora et al. (2009), who concluded that mental fatigue limits exercise tolerance, mainly due to an increased perception of effort.
Since the noradrenergic system plays a role in accelerating central fatigue during prolonged exercise, there are changes in perceived effort that are related to alterations in the concentrations of neurotransmitters such as dopamine and adenosine (Meeusen et al., 2021). These changes occur in various brain regions, including the prefrontal cortex and the anterior cingulate cortex.
Stress, whether physical or mental, can significantly affect the physiological systems of athletes, in some cases resulting in injuries and the inability to continue training. A recent study investigated the prevalence of injuries in CrossFit® practitioners by applying the Musculoskeletal Injury-Focused Sports Readiness Questionnaire (Neto et al., 2022). Evaluation of 368 practitioners of this sport found an injury rate of 48.91%, with higher prevalence of injuries in the shoulder girdle, lumbar spine, and knees. These injuries were associated with training duration and joint overload (Neto et al., 2022).
It has also been shown that a single session of a CrossFit® protocol was sufficient to induce changes in jump height, mean power, and maximum speed (Maté-Muñoz et al., 2017), as well as alterations in overhead squat mechanics (Neto et al., 2023), regardless of whether the participants were exposed to a mental fatigue protocol.
The aim of the present work was to fill a gap in the literature by seeking to improve knowledge of the physical and mental processes involved in extreme conditioning programs (ECPs). The results highlight the importance of better understanding individuals who practice this sports modality, since this can be crucial for instructors responsible for designing progressive training programs, especially for beginners. This aligns with the need for musculoskeletal preparation for physical effort, as there is evidence that mental stress can lead to muscular pain (Brown et al., 2021; Mehta & Agnew, 2012; Mehta & Parasuraman, 2014; Salvagioni et al., 2017).
ECPs require athletes to perform both physical and mental actions. The activity requires strength, power, muscle flexibility, and agility. Additionally, athletes must manage time and the number of repetitions in each exercise, according to the goals set for the day's training, known as the Workout of the Day (WOD). Competition among athletes often extends beyond external competition; it also involves internal competition, where individuals seek to surpass their own limits each day. Therefore, any interference during training can have a significant impact on performance.
This study identified a decrease in exercise performance after the application of a mental stress protocol, suggesting the need for further investigations to address other related questions. It would be important to undertake assessments of physiological, biochemical, and biomechanical parameters, which were limitations of this study, to confirm and expand on the results obtained regarding performance and the subjective perception of effort. Such assessments could contribute to a better understanding of the effects of mental fatigue in the context of ECPs.