Mantle plumes are active for long periods of time1,2, however dating the onset of their activity is difficult. The magmatic products of the Galápagos plume, for example, have been subducted and fragmentarily accreted to the Caribbean and South American plates3,4. Based on submarine and terrestrial exposures it is inferred that the plume has been operating for ~90 Myrs5 or perhaps even longer (e.g., ~139 Myrs6). Here we show that the activity of the plume dates back to ~170 Ma. Evidence for this comes from 0 to 168 Ma zircon with isotopic plume signature (Galápagos Plume Array; GPA) recovered from lavas and sediments from ten islands of the archipelago. Given lithospheric plate motion, this result implies that GPA zircon predating the Galápagos lithosphere (i.e., >14 Ma) formed at asthenospheric depths. Thermo-mechanical numerical experiments of plume-lithosphere interaction show that old zircon grains can be stored within local astenospheric stable domains to be later captured by subsequent rising plume magmas. These results open new avenues for research on mantle plume dynamics in similar tectonic settings.