We report a new syndrome in twin boys manifesting as GHD, thin basement membrane nephropathy (TBMN) and intellectual disability, with interstitial 1q25.2q25.3 deletion and microduplication of 4q35.2. They were followed-up and treated with rhGH for more than 3 years. During the treatment, the twins showed significant catch-up growth, with great increase in IGF-1 and IGFBP3. Until the last visit, we found no endocrine side-effects or deterioration of the nephropathy.
Their overlapping regions in deletions and duplications were a 6.557-Mb region at 1q25.2q25.3 and a 141-Kb segment at 4q35.2 respectively. It’s reasonable to associate the phenotypes of the twins with the two CNVs. However, the causative relationships between the phenotypes and CNVs needed to be further discussed.
Deletions of the long arm of chromosome 1 are rare. Based on the location of the deletion of Chromosome 1q, the patients were classified into three groups: proximal (1q21-22→q25), interstitial (1q24-25→q32), and distal (1q42-43→qter) deletion(3). The 6.557-Mb deleted region of our patients located at 1q25.2q25.3, categorized into the interstitial deletion of Chromosome 1q. Up to date, there are only about 40 previously reported cases with molecular characterization of the deletion size(9–13). Among them, majority cases were large deletions encompassing multiple cytogenetic bands. There were about 6 cases reported with deleted regions encompassed 1q25.2q25.3, and only 4 cases with deletions within 1q25(13,14). The deletion regions and phenotypes of these reported patients were summarized in Table 5.
Major abnormalities of interstitial 1q deletions were growth retardation and developmental delay(3,14). Chatron et al. reported patients with growth retardation and intellectual disability. They suggested that a 2.7-Mb region (chr1:178,514,910–181,269,71) in 1q25.2q25.3 was the shortest region of overlap (SRO) responsible for the phenotypic features, and proposed the genes FAM20B and LHX4 may be candidate for the phenotypes(14). Not surprisingly, the vast majority of reported SRO was comprised in the deleted region of our cases, including FAM20B and LHX4 genes.Thus, the 6.557-Mb deletion region in 1q25.2q25.3 could be associate with growth retardation and developmental delay in our patients.
LHX4 is critical in the proliferation and differentiation of pituitary progenitor cells. The haploinsufficiency of LHX4 isassociated withcombined pituitary hormone deficiency, as well as brain abnormalities (PSIS, poorly developed sella turcica, Chiari syndrome, ect.)(15,16). As reported, the phenotypes related with LHX4 mutations are variable from isolated growth hormone deficiency to complete panhypopituitarism(17). In our cases, the twins showed isolated growth hormone deficiency, without the defects in other pituitary hormones throughout the 3-year follow-up. However, corticotrophin deficiency has been observed in at least half of the reported patients with LHX4 mutations, and can occur later in life(17,18). Moreover, the function of pituitary LH/FSH secretion needs to be evaluated later, since the twins in present study were still in prepubertal stage. Therefore, careful follow-up monitoring of the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal and gonadal function in the patients will be necessary.
TBMN was another feature of our cases. We reviewed all the entries from the DECIPHER database and the reported cases in publications, with overlapping deletions of 1q25.2q25.3 or duplications at 4q35.2. None of them reported hematuria or nephropathy. We noticed NPHS2, the gene associated with steroid-resistant nephrotic syndrome (SRNS), was included in the deletion region in our cases. To see whether there were compound heterozygous alteration in NPHS2 and to elucidate the cause of TBMN, we conducted additional exon sequencing of the reported genes associated with glomerular disease. Unfortunately, we didn’t find any pathogenic alteration.
Besides the deletion at 1q25.2q25.3, our patients had the 141-Kb microduplication at 4q35.2, including only one gene named FAT atypical cadherin 1 (FAT1). FAT1 is highly expressed in a number of fetal epithelia, facilitates cell to cell adhesion and is likely essential in developmental processes and cell communication(19). It was recognized as putative tumor suppressor or oncogene, and mutations in FAT1 are found in a variety of tumors(20). Recently, recessive loss-of-function mutations in FAT1 were found to cause a distinct renal disease entity in four families with a combination of steroid-resistant nephrotic syndrome, tubular ectasia, and hematuria(21). However, we retrieved far fewer reports of FAT1 or 4q35.2 duplications. Until now, no exactly pathological effects were report about FAT1 duplication. There was only one case presented as isolated posterior urethral valves (Boghossian et al., Subject 6), was found to have similar duplication with our cases, involving both FAT1 and MTNR1A genes(22). However, the phenotype was not consistent with our cases. Thus, the pathogenicity of the 141-Kb microduplication at 4q35.2 still needs further investigations.
In conclusion, we reported a new syndrome in twin boys manifesting as GHD, thin basement membrane nephropathy (TBMN) and intellectual disability, with interstitial 1q25.2q25.3 deletion and microduplication of 4q35.2. The rhGH was beneficial for their growth without obvious side-effects, and careful follow-up will be necessary for the HPA and HPG functions in the patients.