Thiostrepton treatment induces apoptosis in C. elegans germline
Thiostrepton has been reported to have an anti-cancer effect on various cancer cell lines by blocking the transcriptional activity of FoxM1 and reducing its expression, leading to apoptosis induction [12]. To evaluate the effect of Thio in an in vivo setting, we used C. elegans to better understand the effect of Thio at an organismal level on cell death induction. To this end, we treated the larval L4 stage worms with various dosages of Thio (from 100 mM to 180 mM) for 24 hours and investigated the effect of this treatment on germline apoptosis induction. To score the apoptotic cells upon Thio treatment, we used the ced-1::gfp-expressing C. elegans line. CED-1 is a transmembrane protein that mediates apoptotic corpse engulfment, and its accumulation around the dying cells is a canonical marker to detect apoptotic corpses [18]. Treating ced-1::gfp worms with 150-mM and 180-mM doses of Thio resulted in a significant increase in apoptotic cell death in the germline of the developing C. elegans, confirmed by the accumulation of CED-1 protein around the dying cells (Fig.1a). Analyzing the pachytene region of the Thio-treated germline using DIC optics highlighted the morphological features of apoptotic cell death that differentiate the corpses from healthy non-dying cells. These features include a button-like appearance under the DIC microscope due to their engulfment by the germline sheath cells and changes in the refractive index of the dying cells (Fig.1b). Notably, the 180-μM concentration exhibited the highest number of apoptotic cells compared to the control (Fig.1a and 1b). Our result shows that 24-hour treatment with 180-mM Thio induced apoptosis in the C. elegans germline, while exposure of the developing worms for 24 hours to various concentrations of Thio (5–180 mM) did not result in developmental arrest nor changes in the gross anatomy (Suppl Fig.1).
Thiostrepton -induced germ cell apoptosis depends on the core apoptotic machinery
During C. elegans development, a total of 131 cells is eliminated by apoptosis as part of the worm’s normal development. Nearly all apoptotic cell deaths in C. elegans are indispensable to the core apoptotic machinery consisting of the BH3-only domain protein EGL-1, the BCL2-related protein CED-9, the worm’s ortholog of mammalian Apaf1 CED-4, and the sole C. elegans Caspase CED-3. The executive CED-3 Caspase is the most downstream component of the core apoptotic machinery in worms and is activated by its physical interaction with CED-4/Apaf1 [19-23]. To functionally characterize the molecular mechanism of Thio-induced apoptosis, we aimed to measure the effect of 180-mM Thio on germ cells in various apoptotic-deficient mutants. To this end, we treated ced-3(n2452) and ced-4(n1162) mutants carrying the CED-1::GFP marker with 180-mM Thio for 24-hours. ced-3(n2452) contains a deletion in ced-3, and ced-4(n1162) carries a point mutation that abolishes their proapoptotic function. As expected, in both mutants, Thio treatment failed to induce apoptosis in the pachytene-stage germ cells (Fig.2 a, b, and c). To test if Thio-induced apoptosis is dependent on CED-9/ BCL-2 protein, we measure apoptotic cell death in the germline of the ced-9 gain of function (GoF) strain upon exposure to Thio. Surprisingly, the apoptotic phenotype impost by Thio treatment was abolished in the ced-9 gain of function mutants (Fig.2 d and e).
Thiostrepton-induced germ cell apoptosis is independent of P53 function and the DNA damage response
In C. elegans, germ cell apoptosis occurs either as part of normal oogenesis and tissue hemostasis or upon the activation of the conserved DNA damage pathways mediated by the tumor suppressor protein P53 [24, 25]. C. elegans CEP-1, the ancestral homolog of the mammalian P53, transcriptionally induces the BH3-only protein egl-1 in response to genotoxic insult [26, 27]. To test if germ cell apoptosis induction upon Thio treatment was mediated by the activation of the conserved DNA damage pathway and CEP-1/P53, we scored the apoptotic germ cells upon treatment with 180-mM Thio in both cep-1(Ig12501), ced-1::gfp and egl-1(n1084n3082) mutants. cep-1(Ig12501) contains a loss-of-function mutation that hinders CEP-1 capacity to trigger apoptosis upon DNA damage, while egl-1 is a loss-of-function mutant that abolishes most DNA damage-induced cell death in the C. elegans germline. Interestingly, the cep-1 and egl-1 mutants exhibited apoptosis induction comparable to the wild-type strain, indicating that Thio induces apoptosis in the absence of functional cep-1/p53 (Fig.3 a, b, c, and d).
Although the apoptotic phenotype mediated by Thio treatment was independent of the P53 function, we aimed to further confirm that this treatment did not induce DNA damage response (DDR) nor genomic instability. To this end, we assessed the formation of RPA-1 foci in the germ cells upon Thio treatment. The RPA-1 protein is involved in various DNA metabolism, including DNA duplication, DNA damage repair, and the activation of the DNA repair pathway. The accumulation of RPA-1 foci on the chromatin is the canonical marker of the DNA breaks that trigger the activation of ATM/ATR protein kinases, leading to the activation of the canonical DNA damage checkpoint pathway [28]. To test if treating germline with Thio induces genomic instability, we exposed the SSM473 C. elegans transgenic strain carrying rpa-1::gfp with 180-mM Thio and measured the RPA-1 foci formation in the germ cells. As expected, we observed no significant differences in the number of RPA-1 foci upon treatment with Thio, confirming that Thio does not induce genomic instability (Suppl Fig 2a). To further confirm that Thio treatment did not activate the canonical DNA damage response pathway, we investigated the activity of Checkpoint Kinase 1 (CHK-1). Upon genotoxic stress, CHK-1 is phosphorylated on ser 345 through the activity of the ATM protein kinase. We therefore stained the germline of the Thio-treated worms with the antibody against CHK-1 pser 345. In line with our previous data, we observed no increase in CHK-1 phosphorylation upon Thio treatment (Suppl Fig. 2b). Altogether, our data indicate that the apoptotic phenotype induced by Thio is independent of P53 and unrelated to the genomic instability.
Thiostrepton induces apoptosis in the somatic cells of C. elegans
To test if Thio also induces somatic cell death and its effect is not limited to germ cells, we measured apoptosis induction in the developing worms. To this end, we took advantage of ced-1(e1735), a loss-of-function mutant strain that is defective in the elimination of apoptotic cells, making the apoptotic cells persist throughout the development. Interestingly, the Thio-treated L1 staged worms showed a significantly increased number of apoptotic cells in the pharyngeal region compared to the control (Suppl. Fig. 3a and b). These findings suggest that Thio treatment also induces somatic apoptosis and generally exerts its effect at the level of the core apoptotic machinery.
Thiostrepton treatment does not increase the level of radical oxygen species
It has previously been reported that Thio is capable of elevating intracellular radical oxygen species (ROS) levels invarious cell lines, and this elevation in ROS is believed to be linked to apoptotic induction [11, 29]. To test if Thio treatment induced ROS production in C. elegans and if an increase in ROS could be potentially linked to apoptosis induction, we quantified ROS levels in the wild-type worms with and without Thio treatment. Surprisingly, we observed no significant changes in ROS production upon Thio treatment (Fig. 4a and b). Our results demonstrate that a 24-hour Thio treatment does not increase intracellular ROS. To our surprise, Thio treatment reduced ROS elevation in the DMSO control sample to some degree. Several studies have shown that DMSO treatment leads to increased ROS production in cell cultures [30]. Additionally, we evaluated the expression level of the member of the Glutathione S Transferase GST-4, a key protein involved in the cellular response to oxidative stress, upon Thio treatment across multiple time points (6–24 hours). Previous reports have shown that gst-4::GFP is a robust reporter to measure cellular oxidative stress [31]. Although a slight increase in the GST-4::GFP signal was observed between 10 and 18 hours compared to the control, the overall elevation of the GFP signal was minimal and fluctuated stochastically across most of the time points. Altogether, there were no significant differences in intensities across the conditions and time points (Fig. 4c and d).
Thiostrepton -induced apoptosis is independent of FOXO/DAF-16
FoxM1 is an oncogenic transcriptional factor associated with various types of cancer [32-34] . There are over 100 members of forkhead transcriptional factors that are evolutionary and highly conserved from C. elegans to humans. Thio has been reported to inhibit FoxM1 transcriptional factor in a p53-dependent manner. To test if Thio-induced apoptosis was related to the C. elegans Foxo transcription factor, daf-16, we counted the number of apoptotic cells in the daf-16 mutant. To our surprise, treating daf-16 mutants with Thio induced apoptosis similar to the wild-type control (Fig. 4e and f), indicating that the apoptosis induction is independent of the daf-16/Foxo axis.