In this study, we found that the SHH signaling inhibitor cyclopamine prevented pulmonary arterial remodeling by regulating the BMP4/BMPR2/ID1 pathway in both rats with MCT-induced PAH and hPASMCs. Consistent with previous work demonstrating that activation of SHH protein levels control proliferation of hPASMCs in response to hypoxia 10, our present findings indicate that SHH protein is activated in rats with MCT-induced PAH and in hPASMCs with impaired BMPR2. Furthermore, we found that regulation of the SHH protein level by cyclopamine had a protective effect on apoptosis and proliferation of hPASMCs via modulation of the BMP pathway and on expression of osteopontin protein in hPASMCs with impaired BMPR2.
Based on loss-of-function and gain-of-function studies, the BMP pathway has been proposed to function downstream of SHH signaling but at the same time inhibit SHH signaling in the limb bud mesenchyme, the oral-aboral axis of the mandibular arch, and the stem cells from the apical papilla, suggesting strong crosstalk between BMP and SHH signaling 3,16,21. Disassembly of SHH signaling in mesenchyme results in spontaneous development of pulmonary hypertension with increased RVSP and RV wall thickness in rats 12. Importantly, consistent with an in vitro study by Wang et al 10, we observed upregulation of SHH protein in both the lung vessels of rats with MCT-induced PAH and in BMPR2 knockdown hPASMCs. Increased SHH protein controlled apoptosis of hPASMCs and their proliferation in response to hypoxia and injury to the BMP pathway both in our study and in studies by others 10. The evidence presented above confirms that SHH cascade proteins are activated during the pathogenesis of PAH via the BMP pathway. Therefore, it is necessary in our subsequent research to determine whether inactivation of SHH can improve the aberrant vascular remodeling in PAH.
The BMPR2 gene provides instructions for making a protein called bone morphogenetic protein receptor type 2, which spans the cell membrane, so that one end of the protein is on the outer surface of the cell and the other end remains inside the cell 4,5. About 70% of heritable PAH and 15–40% of idiopathic PAH develops in the BMPR2 gene, making BMPR2 mutations the main genetic risk. Consistent with a previous report 22, we found that BMPR2 protein levels were downregulated in the pulmonary arteries of rats with MCT-induced PAH when compared with controls that had received saline. Targeted adenoviral BMPR2 gene delivery, the transcriptional regulator SIN3a, the protease inhibitor elafin, exogenous BMP9, and specific agents such as FK506 and rapamycin, have recently been recognized to have novel therapeutic mechanisms in PAH 5. However, continued interest in the interaction between BMPR2 signaling and the process of vascular remodeling should expand our understanding of this presently incurable pulmonary vascular disorder.
Use of cyclopamine as an SHH pathway inhibitor has already been established in many disorders, including cancer, blood-brain barrier defects, benign prostatic hyperplasia, and osteoarthritis 13,20,23,24, and the cyclopamine dosage usually used in rats is 10 mg/kg. We selected rats with MCT-induced PAH and a BMPR2-downregulated hPASMC model to explore the functional activities of cyclopamine that are potentially involved in the progression of PAH. In this study, we found that BMPR2 protein expression was decreased in the lung tissue of MCT-induced PAH rats, and cyclopamine treatment could increase BMPR2 expression. It is possible this occurs because cyclopamine can improve pulmonary vessel remodeling and decrease RVSP in vivo, leading to an improvement in hypoxia that increases BMPR2 protein expression through multiple pathways, including the microRNA, hypoxia-inducible factor and so on.5 Several groups have treated SMCs, such as hPASMCs, SMC-like cells in atherosclerosis, and vascular SMCs, with cyclopamine in vitro 10,25,26. However, there is a lack of information about what happens when cyclopamine is administered in animal models. In this study, we demonstrated for the first time that treatment with cyclopamine 10 mg/kg decreased the RVSP and RV/LV + S ratio in a rat model of MCT-induced PAH without affecting heart rate in comparison with controls that received saline. Cyclopamine also addressed pulmonary vessel wall remodeling involving muscularization of the vessel wall, in that thickening of the small pulmonary arteries in rats with MCT-induced PAH was repaired by cyclopamine. Furthermore, cyclopamine has been found to attenuate intimal thickening and neointima formation in the common carotid arteries in a mouse model, especially in vascular lesions 26,27. Overall, our results suggest that cyclopamine has a beneficial effect on pulmonary vascular dysfunction.
The inhibitor of DNA binding family of proteins (ID) 1 and 3, which are critical downstream effectors of BMP signaling in PASMCs 28, are increased by administration of BMP4. As in previous studies 29, we found that downregulation of BMPR2 reduced the BMP-stimulated induction of ID1 and ID3 in hPASMCs. ID1 regulates stemness and BMPR-mediated differentiation in various cells and tissues 30,31, and inhibition of ID1 improves SHH-induced neuron survival. However, in our study, exogenous SHH-N could not increase mRNA expression of ID1 and ID3 in vitro. Therefore, we hypothesized that this phenomenon may be explained as follows: the SHH protein may promote translocation of ID1 and ID3 and result in acceleration of these proteins in the nucleus 32 and the SHH protein is located downstream of ID1, as demonstrated in rodent cortical neurons by Hung et al 30. However, more intensive methods, such as co-immunoprecipitation and western blot analysis of nuclear proteins, are needed to confirm the above-mentioned hypotheses. There is some evidence that SHH signaling inhibitors, such as GANT61 and cyclopamine, diminish proliferation of carcinoma cells via ID1 31,33; however, before the present study, nothing was known about the effect of inhibition of SHH signaling on BMP-related proliferation of hPASMCs. Our finding that cyclopamine improved BMPR2 knockdown-induced hPASMC dysfunction probably through ID1 but not ID3 may ultimately lead to a new diagnostic or therapeutic target for remodeling in PAH.
Apoptosis, proliferation, and senescence of PASMCs are the main causes of pulmonary vascular remodeling 10,34,35. The mechanisms via which cyclopamine regulates PASMCs are far from being understood. By generating BMPR2 knockdown hPASMCs, which simulate patients with mutant BMPR2, we found that an impaired BMP pathway could induce apoptosis and proliferation of dysfunctional PASMCs, which has also been documented in previous studies 5,22,36. In our research, we found that cyclopamine improved the function of hPASMCs by enhancing apoptosis, which eventually led to proliferation of these cells and vascular thickening. Moreover, we found that changes in the ratio of BAX to BCL-2 may contribute to activation of caspase-3 and modulation of apoptosis during treatment with cyclopamine.
For the first time, we also found that overexpression of SHH protein led to disordered expression of osteopontin and α-SMA protein, which are either a key mediator of the SMC lineage and senescence or a marker of disease severity in PAH 34. Given that osteopontin participates in cell proliferation in multiple tissues, activation/inhibition of osteopontin is a promising therapeutic target 37. In this study, we also showed that the BMP4/BMPR2 signaling pathway mediated SHH-induced upregulation of osteopontin in PASMCs and that inhibition of SHH/Gli signaling by cyclopamine ameliorates BMPR2 deficiency-induced upregulation of osteopontin in vitro.
This study has several limitations. First, our studies used commercially available hPASMCs that are isolated from main pulmonary artery segments. Confidence in our results could be increased if we performed a larger study and obtained samples of lung tissue from patients with BMPR2 mutation to assess SHH signaling. Second, even though we used different concentrations of cyclopamine based on previous literature, treatment with this agent still cannot fully reduce pulmonary artery pressure to normal levels or reverse the pulmonary arterial remodeling completely. A different type of SHH signaling inhibitor can be used to induce remodeling of PASMCs 9. Based on numerous chemical compounds and drug delivery methods in tumor therapy with SHH signaling inhibition38, our research in the future will focus on multi-drug combination therapy in the treatment of pulmonary remodeling 31. Third, in cultured renal fibroblasts, recombinant SHH-N activated Gli1 and induced α-SMA expression39. Wang et al10demonstrated that hPASMCs contain SHH, and they further showed that hypoxia augmented SHH expression and secretion into the culture medium. However, the relationship between SHH and α-SMA in PASMCs is still unknown. In future work, we will try to investigate the interaction between SHH and α-SMA, as well as their role in influencing PAH.
In conclusion, our data indicate that expression of SHH protein is increased in rats with MCT-induced PAH, resulting in an increase in the number of viable hPASMCs contributing to remodeling of the pulmonary vessels, and that this effect on SHH signaling is via the BMPR2/p-SMAD pathway. We have shown that the SHH signaling inhibitor cyclopamine attenuates MCT-induced changes in RVSP and RV wall thickness in Sprague–Dawley rats and that it may play a role in preventing BMPR2 mutant-induced apoptosis of hPASMCs by restoration of caspase-3 and the Bax/BCL2 ratio and proliferation of hPASMCs by improvement of osteopontin and α-SMA levels. Furthermore, we provide evidence that targeting the BMPR2-SAMD-ID1 signaling pathway with cyclopamine may provide novel therapies for the prevention of PAH.