Investigation of reaction conditions
Initial experiment of aza-[4 + 2]-cycloaddition was performed between 3,4-dihydroisoquinoline B1 and benzocyclobutenone A1. The mixture in Et2O was irradiated under 365 nm light at 10 oC (see SI for detailed optimization), directly delivering the product tetrahydroisoquinolinone C1 with nearly quantitative yield (99%). BCB derivatives bearing substituents at C3, C4, C5-positions and 8,8-difluoro substitutions, or cyclobuta[a]naphthalenone underwent successful cyclization upon light irradiation, forming the corresponding products C2-C8 in 75–99% yields (Fig. 2). Variation of 3,4-dihydroisoquinolines (C9-C17) also proved effective in this catalyst-free system, especially 7,8-dihydro-[1, 3]dioxolo[4,5-g]isoquinoline, which enabled one-step formation of protoberberine alkaloids86,87 gusanlung B, D, and oxotetrahydroplamatine (C11-C12 and C16, 62–99% yields). Moreover, several other alkaloids, such as gusanlung A, tetrahydropalmatine, tetrahydrothalifendine, and xylopinine, could be precisely synthesized upon straightforward deprotection or reduction of the photoinduced cyclization products C13, C15-C17.
Encouraged by the success of this photoactivation strategy, we turned attention to the asymmetric photo-driven cycloaddition between benzocyclobutenone A1 and benzosulfonimide D1 using chiral N,N'-dioxide/metal complexes88–94 as Lewis acid catalysts to control the enantioselectivity (Table 1). The racemic product E1 could be observed under irradiation (365 nm) in CH2Cl2 with a yield of 76% without any catalyst (Table 1, entry 1), indicating a strong background reaction and a high challenge for enantiocontrol. Delightedly, N,N'-dioxides, a type of promising chiral ligands, exhibited a pronounced impact on enantioselectivity upon coordination with Ni(OTf)2 (entries 2–6). The aromatic amine-derived N,N'-dioxide L3-PiMe2Br displayed lower enantioselectivity compared to the aliphatic counterparts (entry 2 vs entries 3–6). L3-PisEPh derived from S-pipecolic acid and S-phenylethylamine, provided a moderate yield and the highest enantioselectivity (entry 6, 62% yield, 91% ee). Other metal ions,
Table 1
Optimization of the asymmetric photo-driven aza-[4 + 2] cycloadditiona
Entry
|
Variation
|
Yield (%)
|
ee (%)
|
1
|
without a catalyst
|
76
|
-
|
2
|
L3-PiMe2Br instead of L3-PisEPh
|
86
|
45
|
3
|
L3-PitBu instead of L3-PisEPh
|
99
|
55
|
4
|
L3-PiBn instead of L3-PisEPh
|
99
|
72
|
5
|
L3-PiAd instead of L3-PisEPh
|
92
|
83
|
6
|
-
|
62
|
91
|
7
|
La(OTf)3 instead of Ni(OTf)2
|
63
|
0
|
8
|
Mg(OTf)2 instead of Ni(OTf)2
|
77
|
0
|
9
|
Zn(OTf)2 instead of Ni(OTf)2
|
83
|
5
|
10
|
385 nm LED
|
74
|
90
|
11
|
400 nm LED, 24 h
|
13
|
74
|
12
|
Ni(NTf2)2 instead of Ni(OTf)2
|
37
|
92
|
13
|
Ni(NTf2)2 (12 mol%), 12 h
|
96
|
93
|
14b
|
Ni(NTf2)2 (12 mol%), 3 Å MS, 10 °C
|
95
|
95 (S)
|
a Unless otherwise noted, all reactions were carried out with A1 (2.0 equiv.), D1 (0.1 mmol), and metal salt/ligand (1:1, 10 mol%) in CH2Cl2 (2.0 mL) at room temperature under N2 atmosphere and irradiation (20 W UV LED, λmax = 365 nm) for 5 h. The yield was determined by 1H NMR with 1,1,2,2-tetrachloroethane as the internal standard. The ee was determined by UPC2 analysis on a chiral stationary phase. b Ni(NTf2)2/L3-PisEPh (1.2:1, 10 mol%), 3 Å MS (25 mg) in CH2Cl2 (3.0 mL) at 10 °C for 24 h.
including LaIII, MgII, and ZnII, yielded E1 with no more than 5% ee (entries 7–9). Further exploration of wavelength revealed UV light dependence in the C−C bond cleavage of BCB. Specifically, a slightly higher yield (74%) was obtained with 90% ee under 385 nm light (entry 10). However, visible light (400 nm) resulted in sharply diminished reactivity, providing only 13% yield and 74% ee (entry 11). When the counter ion of nickel salt was changed to NTf2¯, higher enantioselectivity was achieved with a lower yield (entry 12, 37% yield, 92% ee). Delightfully, a slightly excessive Ni(NTf2)2 enabled up to 96% yield with enhanced enantioselectivity (93% ee, entry 13), which is likely to accelerate the dissociation of chiral catalyst from the product. Given the existence of photo-mediated hydrolysis and reduction of the imine95–97, the inclusion of 3 Å MS in this system, along with adjustment of concentration and temperature, is expected to further improve enantioselectivity to 95% ee with 95% yield (entry 14). The absolute configuration of E1 was determined to be S through X-ray crystallographic analysis98.
Subsequently, we conducted a comprehensive examination of benzosulfonimides (Fig. 3). Modifying the ester substituent of D led to efficient yields and enantioselectivities (E1-E4, 90–96% yields, 94–95% ee). Regardless of the position and electronic nature of substituents on the phenyl ring, benzosulfonimides underwent the desired cycloaddition to afford the products E5-E16 with yields ranging from moderate to excellent (40–93%) and high enantioselectivities (84–96% ee). The lower yield of some substrates was primarily due to the photohydrolysis and photoreduction of imines95–97. Generally, imines bearing an electron-donating group exhibited lower reactivity and higher enantioselectivities than those with electron-deficient imines. An imine with a fused naphthyl could also be transformed into the desired product (E17), albeit with 55% yield and 86% ee.
A detailed examination of the BCB scope was also undertaken. A series of substituted BCBs reacted smoothly with D1 to afford the corresponding products E18-E25 with 54–99% yields and efficient enantioselectivities (92–97% ee) except for those bearing an electron-donating group at the C5 position (E22-E23, 31–78% yields, 73–85% ee). BCB with a fused ring was tolerated well in this reaction, giving the target product E26 with a 94% yield and 93% ee. The 8-methyl or 8-cyclopropyl substituted BCBs also underwent exclusively C1-C8 bond cleavage using this photoinduced strategy, giving the product E27-E28 in 86–98% yields and 90–98% ee, albeit with lower diastereoselectivity (1:1.6-3:1 dr). 8,8-Disubstituted BCBs were also compatible with this reaction system. For instance, a dimethyl substituted substrate exhibited moderate enantioselectivity probably due to its larger steric hindrance (E29, 64% yield, 73% ee), while the BCB containing a spiro framework generated E30 with 99% yield and 87% ee. The 8,8-difluoro substituted BCB provided an efficient result as well (E31, 92% yield, 96% ee).
Mechanistic studies
To elucidate the mechanism of C−C bond activation of BCBs, radical capture experiments were performed to verify the homolysis of the C−C bond of BCBs. When TEMPO was used as a radical scavenger, the coupling product G1 was isolated with 54% yield in the absence of D1 through C1−C8 bond cleavage (Fig. 5a). This compelling evidence strongly supports the occurrence of C1−C8 bond homolysis. However, when TEMPO (3.0 equiv.) was added to the standard reaction, the desired cycloaddition product E1 could be obtained with maintained yield (95%), and G1 was detected with only 1% yield. The negligible influence of TEMPO on this reaction may be attributed to the quick ISC of 1,4-diradical species Int-1. To further validate the intermediary of ortho-quinoid ketene methide, two sets of in situ preparation experiments were carried out (Fig. 5b). Remarkably, heating led to the successful production of ortho-quinoid ketene methide, yielding the target product with a 64% yield and 27% ee, emphasizing the superiority of the photoactivation strategy. Additionally, a mixture of Aa1 with CsF for desilylation99 to generate the ortho-quinoid ketene methide was also feasible which reacted with D1 to give racemic E1 with 63% yield.
Based on the aforementioned experimental results, the absolute configuration of E1 and our previous work82, a possible reaction pathway was proposed (Fig. 5c). Upon excitation of A1 with UV light, it reaches the excited singlet state S1 and subsequently undergoes ISC to reach the excited triplet state T1, enabling the homolysis of the C1−C8 bond and generating the diradical Int-1. The following fast ISC yields the ortho-quinoid ketene methide Int-2, which approaches the N,N'-dioxide/Ni(II) complex-activated D1 from its Re face, ultimately affording the product E1 with S configuration.