Heterotrophy dominates sulfur oxidation in the Bohai Sea sediments
Sulfur-oxidizing genes were prevalent in these 5,233 MAGs. Over 85.8% recovered MAGs (4,490 of 5,233), occupying 87.2% abundance of the recovered community, contain at least one gene related to inorganic sulfur oxidation (sulfide, zerovalent sulfur, thiosulfate, and sulfite) (Fig. 2 and Supplementary Fig. 2). Specifically, 43.2% recovered MAGs (2,263 MAGs) contained sqr and fccAB for sulfide oxidation; 38.8% had pdo (1,818 MAGs), rdsrAB (365 MAGs), hdrABC (329 MAGs), and sor (39 MAGs) for the oxidation of zerovalent sulfur; 45.4% carried the sox (473 MAGs), tsdA (1,229 MAGs), and doxD (786 MAGs) for thiosulfate metabolism, and 24.7% possessed sat-aprAB (1,284 MAGs), sorA (37 MAGs), and SOUX (32 MAGs) for potential sulfite oxidation. These data suggest that biological sulfur oxidation is prevalent in marine sediments[6]. These 4,490 MAGs were assigned into 48 bacterial and 6 archaeal phyla, dominated by Proteobacteria, Desulfobacterota, Gemmatimonadota, Myxococcota, and Thermoproteota (Fig. 2).
Heterotrophic and mixotrophic metabolisms dominate the microbial community in the Bohai Sea sediments. We identified 755 MAGs with autotrophic metabolisms. They mostly belong to Proteobacteria (264 MAGs), Desulfobacterota (125 MAGs), and Nitrospirota (72 MAGs). The remaining 4,478 MAGs, occupying 85.57% of the entire community, likely rely on heterotrophic and mixotrophic metabolisms. They mainly belong to Proteobacteria (1,108 MAGs), Desulfobacterota (432 MAGs), Gemmatimonadota (425 MAGs), and Myxococcota (378 MAGs). 3,807 of the 4,478 MAGs with heterotrophic/mixotrophic metabolism are capable of oxidizing different types of sulfur as evidenced by possessing different sulfur oxidation genes. For example, 1,581 MAGs contain SQR (1,220 MAGs) or FCSD (655 MAGs). 1,702 MAGs encode different enzymes, including PDO (1,571 MAGs), rDsrB (253 MAGs), HDR (259 MAGs), and SOR (15 MAGs) that oxidize zerovalent sulfur. Among 1,785 MAGs which oxidize thiosulfate, 1,005 and 740 MAGs oxidize thiosulfate to tetrathionate with TsdA and DoxD, respectively, and 436 MAGs oxidize thiosulfate to sulfate and zerovalent sulfur with the Sox system lacking SoxD. 943 MAGs carry Sat-AprAB that oxidize sulfite to sulfate.
Sulfide oxidation
2,594 of 3,474 SQR homologous sequences, annotated by the combination of IMG/JGI MAP and diamond search, were confirmed as SQR, and the remaining 880 SQR homologues were confirmed as the catalytic subunit of FCSD (FccB) by their phylogeny[35] (Supplementary Fig. 3). Phylogenetic analyses suggest that most of these SQR sequences belong to the membrane-bound type III (1,814), type II (379), and type I (296) SQRs, and few of them belong to type IV (9) and type VI (83) SQRs[35]. Over half of SQRs (1,707/2,594) were assigned in 1,507 MAGs, most of which belong to Proteobacteria (288 MAGs), Gemmatimonadota (239 MAGs), Desulfobacterota (190 MAGs), Chloroflexota (154 MAGs), and Bacteroidota (151 MAGs). FCSDs were mainly distributed in Proteobacteria (304 MAGs), Gemmatimonadota (99 MAGs), Chloroflexota (99 MAGs), and Thermoproteota (58 MAGs). The significantly higher abundance of SQR than FccB in middle and bottom layers (p < 0.001, t-test) suggests that SQR was the dominant enzyme oxidizing sulfide in Bohai Sea sediments (Supplementary Fig. 1).
Zerovalent sulfur oxidation
PDOs were the most abundant, followed by HDRs and rDsrABs for zerovalent sulfur oxidation in the sediments. 3,055 PDO sequences were identified from 15 assemblies. A maximum likelihood phylogenetic tree showed that 1,091, 1,150, and 814 PDO sequences were classified as type I, type II, and type III[36, 37], respectively (Supplementary Fig. 4). 2,047 of 3,055 identified PDO sequences were binned in 1,818 MAGs. Type I PDOs were mainly identified in Proteobacteria (469 MAGs; 295 Gammaproteobacteria MAGs and 174 Alphaproteobacteria MAGs) and Myxococcota (178 MAGs). Few type I PDOs were annotated in Acidobacteriota (36 MAGs), Planctomycetota (3 MAGs), Desulfobacterota (2 MAGs), SAR324 (2 MAGs), Gemmatimonadota (1 MAG), DSWW01 (1 MAG), and Cyanobacteria (1 MAG). Type II PDOs were identified mainly in Proteobacteria (653 MAGs), mostly Gammaproteobacteria (579 MAGs) and Alphaproteobacteria (74 MAGs). Few type II PDOs were annotated in Myxococcota (54 MAGs), Acidobacteriota (22 MAGs), Desulfobacterota (5 MAGs), and Gemmatimonadota (2 MAGs). Type III PDOs were distributed in more phyla (19 phyla) than Type I and TypeII PDOs, mainly in Gemmatimonadota (191 MAGs), Bacteroidota (114 MAGs), Chloroflexota (32 MAGs), Nitrospirota (28 MAGs), Planctomycetota (23 MAGs), and Actinobacteriota (17 MAGs). Types I and II PDOs are present only in Gram-negative bacteria, while type III PDOs were identified in both Gram- negative and positive bacteria but mainly in Gram positive bacteria[36–38]. Type II PDOs were commonly distributed in the surface, while types I and III PDOs were often identified in the bottom layer (Supplementary Fig. 4).
We identified 2,621 α subunit (DsrA) and 2,543 β subunit (DsrB) sequences of dissimilatory sulfite reductase (Dsr), which could be assigned in 1,514 MAGs, in the Bohai Sea sediment samples. The phylogenetic tree showed that 601 DsrAB sequences are the oxidative bacterial type (rDsrAB) oxidizing zerovalent sulfur[9] (Supplementary Fig. 5). rDsrAB sequences were mainly distributed in Gammaproteobacteria (291 MAGs) and Alphaproteobacteria (59 MAGs). Bacterial phyla CG2-30-53-67 (9 MAGs) and Desulfobacterota (6 MAGs), which are mostly considered as sulfate reducers, also have rDsrAB. The rDsrAB sequences were mainly identified in the surface, while the reductive bacterial type DsrAB sequences were mostly distributed in the bottom layer in the Bohai Sea sediment (Supplementary Fig. 5).
HDR is encoded by a hdrC1B1A-hyp-hdrC2B2 cluster acting as a sulfur-oxidizing entity[11, 12]. In total, 406 HDRs were annotated, and 334 of them were assigned in 329 Proteobacteria MAGs (Supplementary Fig. 6), belonging to Gammaproteobacteria (296 MAGs) and Alphaproteobacteria (33 MAGs). Several orders, including Woeseiales, Kilonielales, UBA8366, and SMXQ01, could oxidize zerovalent sulfur by using HDR. Gammaproteobacteria with HDR were mainly identified in the surface sediment, while Alphaproteobacteria with HDR were mostly distributed in the bottom layer (Supplementary Fig. 6).
Only 105 SOR sequences were identified, and 50 of them were assigned in 39 MAGs from 14 samples. 33 of 39 MAGs were classified as Desulfobacterota, which is known for dissimilatory sulfate reduction[39]. The narrow distribution of SOR suggests that it is a conserved gene within a small community with rare horizontal gene transfer across different phyla, and its rare presence suggests that it is probably not a key enzyme for zerovalent sulfur oxidation in Bohai Sea sediments.
Thiosulfate oxidation
SoxABCXYZ, TsdA, and DoxD[21] were annotated for thiosulfate oxidation in all sediment samples. However, the absence of subunits SoxD in the Sox system suggests the incomplete thiosulfate oxidation to sulfate and zerovalent sulfur[34]. 473 SoxABXYZ complexes were exclusively distributed in Alphaproteobacteria (93 MAGs) and Gammaproteobacteria (380 MAGs), mainly in the orders Woeseiales (137 MAGs), GCA-001735895 (56 MAGs), Thiohalobacterales (43 MAGs), Xanthomonadales (40 MAGs), Kiloniellales (37 MAGs), and UBA8366 (33 MAGs). Among 473 MAGs containing Sox complex, 460 MAGs also have at least one pathway for zerovalent sulfur oxidation (Supplementary Fig. 7), suggesting a potential high turnover rate of zerovalent sulfur and low chance of accumulating zerovalent sulfur during the incomplete oxidation of thiosulfate. 1,017 catalytic subunits of Sox complex (SoxB) were annotated, and 695 were assigned in 608 MAGs mainly belonging to Proteobacteria (607 MAGs). Gammaproteobacteria with SoxB were mostly distributed in the surface, and Alphaproteobacteria with SoxB were mainly identified in the bottom layer (Supplementary Fig. 8). 2,606 TsdA and 1,514 DoxD sequences were identified for thiosulfate oxidation to tetrathionate. TsdAs were mainly distributed in Proteobacteria (436 MAGs), Chloroflexota (156 MAGs), Nitrospirota (143 MAGs), and Desulfobacterota (134 MAGs). DoxDs were mainly identified in Gemmatimonadota (252 MAGs), Proteobacteria (167 MAGs), Chloroflexota (159 MAGs) and Bacteroidota (62 MAGs).
Sulfite oxidation
SAT and AprAB catalyzing both sulfite oxidation and sulfate reduction are abundant in the sediments (Fig. 2), suggesting the sediments are an active site for sulfate reduction or sulfite oxidation[40]. We identified 7,916 SAT and 2,918 AprAB sequences. 1,464 of 1,737 MAGs encode AprAB, which are mainly Proteobacteria (567 MAGs), Desulfobacterota (315 MAGs), and Nitrospirota (157 MAGs). 3,282 of 4,655 MAGs encode SAT, which are mainly Proteobacteria (1,081 MAGs), Desulfobacterota (426 MAGs), Myxococcota (258 MAGs), Acidobacteriota (247 MAGs), and Gemmatimonadota (236 MAGs). 151 MAGs classified into 15 phyla, such as Thermoplasmatota (53 MAGs) and Actinobacteriota (30 MAGs), only encode SAT without AprAB. The high abundance of AprAB and SAT in surface sediment suggests the SAT-AprAB pathway oxidizes sulfite and sulfate reducers are tolerant to oxygen in surface sediment[41, 42]. We further identified 56 SorA sequences oxidizing sulfite, and 37 SorAs were assigned exclusively in 37 Myxococcota MAGs. Among 66 identified SOUX sequences, 34 sequences were assigned in 32 MAGs, mainly Gemmatimonadota (18 MAGs), which may involve sulfite oxidation.
Metatranscripts during the incubation with sulfide
With the supplements of NaHS, the transcripts mapped to genes for sulfur oxidation were mostly enriched in the whole community (Fig. 4j). The sqr transcripts were enriched with supplements of NaHS (Fig. 4j). The abundance of fccB (catalytic subunit of FCSD) and sqr genes were similar in the surface sediment at station BHB10 (Supplementary Fig. 1); however, the transcripts of sqr were much more abundant than fccB under both control and experimental samples, suggesting the important role of SQR for sulfide oxidation in surface sediments. The upregulated sqr transcripts were mainly from Proteobacteria, Actinobacteriota, Acidobacteriota, Myxococcota, Bacteroidota, and Verrucomicrobiota (Fig. 4k).
The expression of all genes responsible for zerovalent sulfur oxidation, including rdsrAB, pdo, hdr, and sor, were highly upregulated during the incubation (Fig. 4j). The upregulated expression of rdsrAB was in a candidate phylum CG2-30-53-67 that consists of known sulfate reducers[9] and different orders belonging to the classes Alphaproteobacteria and Gammaproteobacteria (Supplementary Fig. 12), including GCA-001735895, Thiohalobacterales, SZUA-229, etc. (Supplementary Fig. 13). The abundance of pdo transcripts increased over 76 times in Planctomycetota after adding NaHS (Fig. 4k), suggesting the key role of pdo for sulfur oxidation. Twenty phyla, including Proteobacteria (Alphaproteobacteria and Gammaproteobacteria), Nitrospirota, Gemmatimonadota, Bacteroidota, etc. (Fig. 4k and Supplementary Fig. 12), increased the gene expression of pdo with the supplements of NaHS, suggesting the oxidation of zerovalent sulfur is a common function in microbial communities.
The transcripts of the genes encoding the SOX system were slightly enriched during the incubation, mainly due to their expression in Proteobacteria and Campylobacterota (Supplementary Fig. 14), a chemolithoautotrophic phylum for disproportionation of sulfur previously reported in deep-sea environments[49, 50]. Transcripts for sulfite oxidation did not increase, except for sat transcripts. The total transcripts of aprA or aprB did not change with the supplements of NaHS. However, their proportion in different phyla changed, such as the transcripts in Acidobacteria, Planctomycetota, Verrucomicrobiota, Desulfobacterota, and Gemmatimonadota decreased, while increased in Proteobacteria in experimental samples (Supplementary Fig. 14). The shifts of aprAB transcripts among different phyla suggests different responses to NaHS for sulfite oxidation in sediments.