Lake Sibaya is the largest nearshore freshwater lake in South Africa; it was formerly an estuary that was completely separated from the sea by the gradual formation of forested coastal dunes (Allanson 1979) on the northeast coast of KwaZulu-Natal Province. The lake is part of the iSimangaliso Wetland Park (Obura 2012), the country's first proclaimed World Heritage Site, with various wetlands comprising its biodiversity. Therefore, like many inland waters, Lake Sibaya provides a variety of ecosystem goods and services and has essential functions in the natural environment. It is an attractive tourist destination, and its hydrological features are impacted by developments in its catchment area (Nsubuga et al. 2019). The lake is an essential source of fresh water for domestic water supply, performs ecological functions, and is often the only water source for certain animals during drought (Weitz and Demlie 2014). In addition to Lake Sibaya’s global and national significance (CEPF 2010) is that it is crucial for major scientific study, with six locations across the nation chosen by the Expanded Freshwater and Terrestrial Environmental Observation Network (EFTEON) for host ecosystem research projects (Feig 2018).
There is growing concern about the deterioration of Lake Sibaya, and the recent publication titled "The Slow Death of Lake Sibaya" by Carnie (2020) has reinforced this impression. The lake is increasingly exposed to the negative impacts of increased rural and forestry development (Everson et al. 2019) and increasingly dry climate conditions (Nsubuga et al. 2019). Smithers et al. (2017) reported an approximately 35% decrease in the water level of Lake Sibaya since 2001, which can be attributed to the impact of commercial forestry plantations. However, some uncertainty regarding the exact history, magnitude, and effects of these plantations on the catchment was noted. Smithers also stated that the ten years of significantly lower-than-average rainfall from 2001 to 2011 was believed to be the primary cause of the decrease in Lake Sibaya's level since 2001. These dynamics add significant complexity to managing lakes and other inland water systems. Over the past two decades, lake water levels have decreased significantly, exposing large areas that were once flooded (Mpungose et al. 2022). While surrounding systems such as Lake St. Lucia and local dams have gradually improved since the drought, Lake Sibaya has not and continues to deteriorate (Carnie 2020)—a severe cause for concern! The results of the present study are unique because they shed light on the changes in the shoreline of Lake Sibaya.
As part of the sustainable management of water resources, regularly monitoring lakes and marking shoreline changes are essential (Dereli and Tercan 2020). This approach is necessary in much of Africa, where the difficulty of monitoring lakes poses a challenge even with best-funded monitoring programs (Ballatore et al. 2014). This task is even more critical in a water-scarce country such as South Africa, where water resources must be managed sustainably (Snaddon et al. 1998). The commonly used procedure for assessing the dynamics of coastal areas and inland waterbodies is shoreline change analysis, a sensitive indicator of the vulnerability of these systems to naturally and human-induced forces (Genz et al. 2007).
A shoreline is an interface between a waterbody and land, the movement of which is a complex process associated with changes in precipitation, evaporation, runoff, and human land-use activities and their interactions (Temiz and Durduran 2016). Therefore, shoreline change detection is crucial for providing a spatiotemporal analysis of freshwater resources (Duru 2017) to aid in formulating protection strategies. Therefore, many tools are utilized for shoreline change analysis. Prior shoreline change evaluations were straightforward and based on direct comparisons with preexisting maps (Burningham and Fernandez-Nunez 2020). However, estimates of precision and uncertainty were only possible during this time. Thus, the 1970s saw a complete transformation of this shoreline change study technique due to advances in computer technology and the associated Geographic Information System (GIS). Hitherto, concerted research efforts have been reflected in the growing number of shoreline change studies, most of which use remote sensing (Ankrah et al. 2022) to understand the dynamics of inland waters against various natural and anthropogenic pressures.
Remote sensing, particularly Landsat products, are indispensable data sources for shoreline extraction due to their longevity, free access, and good coverage with a 30-m ground sampling distance. Several studies have exploited Landsat data to characterize inland waterbodies (Hovsepyan et al. 2019; Yue et al. 2021). The basis for determining the shoreline using remote sensing is the spectral difference between the waterbody and the surrounding land area (McFeeters 1996), and its accuracy depends on the sensor's native resolution and how the position is mapped (Smith et al. 2021). Several studies have effectively examined shoreline changes in many lakes using the modified normalized difference water index (MNDWI; Xu 2006) based on Landsat data. For example, Tao et al. (2015) used multiyear Landsat imagery from 1987 to 2010 on the Mongolian Plateau and reported rapid losses in these lakes resulting from variations in precipitation, mining and agricultural practices. So, for the preservation and sustainability of wetlands, estimating shoreline change rates utilizing RS technology has emerged as a crucial area of study (Bouchahma and Yan 2014; Bacino et al. 2020; Valderrama-Landeros et al. 2020). Therefore, to measure shoreline changes using RS images, several methods are available, including a cell-to-cell comparison of binary images and the Digital Shoreline Analysis System (DSAS) extension in ArcGIS software (Bouchahma and Yan 2012; Rezaee et al. 2019).
In this article, we aim to analyze the historical shoreline changes in Lake Sibaya between 1986 and 2020 with the Landsat series and DSAS geospatial tool to identify vulnerability based on two statistical variables, namely, Net Shoreline Movement (NSM) and the End Point Rate (EPR). Additionally, the DSAS was utilized to predict future shoreline changes for the next ten years (2030). Our novel contribution to this study is to determine the extent of shoreline displacement and identify vulnerable edges of Lake Sibaya, as there is still no research tracking the evolution of these shores.