Topotecan is a semi-synthetic, water-soluble analogue of camptothecin (CPT), as well as the first FDA-approved oral TOP1B inhibitor for the treatment of several types of cancer. CPT derivatives have been repeatedly suggested as a good source of repurposed drugs for the treatment of a variety of infectious diseases caused by protozoan parasites [1, 13, 46]. With the alarming decrease in effectiveness of first-line drugs in areas where L. infantum is endemic, repurposed drugs could represent a faster solution at lower cost [47]. However, the predisposition of Leishmania to develop drug resistance should be addressed when repurposing a drug [1, 25, 27]. In this study, we used a combination of stepwise drug-resistance selection, whole-genome sequencing and theoretical approaches to explore the propensity of and potential mechanisms deployed by three independent clones of L. infantum to resist the activity of the TOP1B-inhibitor TPT. One of the major strengths of this approach is that both the parent cell line and three directly derived drug-resistant lines are studied together, and thus, any confounding factor derived from strain-related heterogeneity is excluded from the analysis [23, 48].
Firstly, we demonstrated that L. infantum is able to become resistant to high concentrations of TPT. While the mechanisms involved in TPT resistance have not been fully elucidated in tumor cells, several studies have shown the implication of different drug transporters, such as multidrug resistance-associated protein 1 (ABCC1/MRP1) or the ABCG2 transporter [49, 50]. Likewise, Leishmania parasites rely on the amplification of ABC transporter MRPA (ABCC) and inactivation of the aquaglyceroporin 1 (AQP1) gene to counter the action of antimonial drugs [21, 23, 51]. As gene expression in Leishmania is regulated predominantly by gene dosage [20, 21], we proceeded to search for large-scale copy number variations (deletions and duplications) in chromosomes of the three selected clones for comparison with the unselected parental line. In the past, different ABCG and ABCC efflux-pump gene clusters were identified in L. infantum as part of chromosomes 6, 23 and 31 [52]. In addition, overexpression of the ABCG6 transporter is known to be involved in CPT resistance in Leishmania parasites [53]. Of note, none of these regions was found amplified in any of the three TPT-resistant clones in our whole-genome comparative analysis, thus indicating a different mechanism of drug resistance when compared with CPT.
The absence of significant amplifications, coupled with the very unusual fact that no prominent changes in ploidy were observed for any of the studied clones [54], led us to suspect the potential implication of SNPs and small nucleotide insertions or deletions (indels) in the TPT-resistant phenotypes. Several SNPs have been shown to contribute to drug resistance (e.g. miltefosine, antimonial drugs, etc.) in Leishmania parasites by altering the activity of specific transporters or modifying different detoxification pathways [22, 23, 29, 55, 56]. Here we focused on SNPs and indels present in the three TPT-resistant clones and, at the same time, occurring in the same ORF but at different positions. Among the 8 genes fulfilling these criteria, we identified the ORF coding for the large subunit of the DNA topoisomerase IB, which is the main target of CPT-derivatives once bound to the DNA during cell replication [10, 11]. Clones TPT700.1 and TPT700.3 displayed homozygous mutations in the top1B gene, while the SNP identified in TPT700.2 was heterozygous. Although previously observed in diploid Leishmania parasites, homozygous mutations are rare because of their ‘non-reversible’ nature. The homozygous mutations in clones TPT700.1 and TPT700.3 may have originated from loss of heterozygosity, a well described phenomenon in Leishmania [57, 58]. Importantly, these results reinforce previous works demonstrating the possibility that, although rare, Leishmania can generate SNPs associated with drug resistance without the need for alteration of its genomic architecture and gene expression [59].
Due to the impossibility of generating a null mutant, our preferred way for studying the role of mutated variants of top1B consisted of episomal transfection of the mutated forms into a wild-type strain [23]. As expected, since transfected parasites still carry the top1BWT, we were able to only partly recreate the resistance observed in the TPT700 mutants. However, the relative strength of each mutation followed the same drug-resistance trend in both the original mutants (TPT700.1 > TPT700.3 > TPT700.2) and the episomal transfectants (top1BF187Y > top1BW232R > top1BG191A).
To better understand the potential contribution of these three SNPs to TPT resistance in the mutants, we performed several MD simulations. All three residues identified in the TPT700 mutants (F187, G191 and W232) were conserved between the human and parasitic enzyme and can be structurally aligned (Fig. 4). They were located in proximity of the TPT binding site, in close proximity to residues found to be crucial in the human enzyme for the interaction and stabilization of TPT with residues R364 and N722 once intercalated between DNA bases [60], corresponding to leishmanial residues R190 and N221. Thus, we can hypothesize that a change in one of the residues of this cluster may influence the arrangement of the TPT binding site. Although these residues are in proximity of the catalytic pentad [11, 14, 61], the mutations identified in this study are likely affecting the ability of binding of TPT to the DNA-TOP1B complex without altering the global catalytic function of the enzyme, but potentially accelerating the re-ligation step. Indeed, it has been very well established that a malfunction of cleavage/re-ligation reactions will be reflected through altered protein drug sensitivity [11, 60]. Of note, two of the three SNPs identified in the TPT700 mutants (F187Y and G191A) were located within the conserved region corresponding to amino acids 361–365 in the hTOP1B enzyme. These results confirm the findings of Rubin et al. (1993) showing that a substitution of residue F361 can induce high levels of resistance against a CPT derivate (e.g. 9-nitro-20(S)camptothecin) in human U-937 myeloid leukemia cells [62]. Likewise, Li et al. (1997) showed that certain substitutions in the 361–364 region affect DNA cleavage/ligation by the enzyme, as well as contribute to resistance against CPT since they may be included in the CPT-binding domain [63]. These results suggest that these mutations are able to modify the architecture of the binding site, decreasing the persistence of TPT in the binding pocket, as well indicate that CPT and TPT may share binding sites in the LiTOP1B–DNA complex.
Furthermore, in the covalent complexes, K352 and R410 demonstrate a changed profile of interaction in all three TPT700 mutants. In particular, the hydrogen bond between K352 and D353 is lost. This interaction is crucial for the correct position of K352 (known to be a key player in the re-ligation reaction), and when incorrectly positioned affects the re-ligation rate and thus TPT sensitivity [15, 64]. Moreover, D353 is itself involved in the network of residues and TPT interaction. As such, the lack of the K352-D353 hydrogen bond and side chains orientation may be a main cause for rearrangement of the TPT binding site and lowered stabilization of the drug in the binding pocket, further explaining the observed resistance.
Importantly, the three TPT700 mutants became resistant to TPT without impairing their ability to proliferate in vitro. The process of becoming drug resistant can lead to different evolutionary disadvantages (‘fitness cost’), such as reduced survival [65]. However, this concept remains controversial in Leishmania and is highly dependent on the parasite’s genetic and environmental context [48]. Likewise, drug-resistant cancer cell lines exhibit different fitness-cost profiles, including subpopulations with increased fitness when compared to their sensitive counterparts [66]. The absence of fitness cost in vitro in the TPT700 mutants could be due in part to the fact that these cells do not use ATP-dependent drug efflux pumps to resist treatment (e.g. MRPA in antimony resistance), for which they would have to divert energy away from proliferation towards running of the pumps. Moreover, the absence of a cost in terms of growth would also explain why the TPT700 mutants did not return to sensitivity once the TPT was withdrawn. Mutants of this type have the potential to become a major risk for the spread of drug resistance into an environment devoid of antileishmanial drugs. However, at this point, whether this phenomenon would be stable in vivo or in the vector remains to be evaluated.